Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

Here's an interesting article that relates to the issues discussed in this thread.

http://www.slate.com/id/2140188/

The case of the rare Ferrari Enzo sports car that crashed and split in two on the Pacific Coast Highway moved into the courts on Monday. Prosecutors charged the man who seems to have been at the wheel with embezzlement, grand theft, drunk driving, and weapons possession. According to the Los Angeles County sheriff's office, the car was traveling at 162 mph at the time of the accident. How do investigators figure out the speed of an auto collision?
They look at where the car and all its pieces end up. (Bits of the Ferrari were scattered over 1,200 feet of highway.) If investigators can figure out the direction and distance each piece traveled from the site of the impact, they can infer the speed at which the car was going when it crashed.
In order to perform this kind of analysis, you first need to figure out where exactly the impact occurred. Marks and debris on the highway—like gouged pavement, broken glass, or oil stains—can give you a good idea of where the accident began and what happened to the car in its aftermath. Then, you need to find out the "coefficient of friction" of the surface on which the accident took place. This tells you how quickly a car (or a piece of car) would skid to a stop on that surface—whether it's pavement, dirt, or grass.
Given these data, you can figure out the velocity of the car as it came out of the collision—which can then help you to figure out its velocity going in. In general, you know that both momentum and energy will be conserved over the course of the accident. For example, the momentum of the speeding Ferrari before the crash would translate into a momentum for each of its two halves, and for the utility pole that it crashed into (and knocked upside down). The same goes for energy: If you know the amount of energy it takes to snap a utility pole in two, or the amount it takes to break a Ferrari in half, you can work backward to figure out how much energy the Ferrari must have had just before the impact.
You can also figure out how fast a car was going by looking at how much of it got crushed on impact. Manufacturers and insurance companies run tests to see what happens to a car when it hits a barrier at various speeds. This gives crash investigators a frame of reference for evaluating crush damage at the scene of an accident.
Most cars now have something like a black box that records its speed during the few seconds before an accident. (The "event data recorder" uses this information to deploy airbags when necessary.) Some manufacturers, like GM and Ford, make it easy for investigators to download the information from these boxes after an accident. Foreign car manufacturers are more likely to keep the event data to themselves. But you can't just go with the number from the recorder, since some of them only keep track of the car's speed along its length, as opposed to its speed going sideways. Collision analysts generally look at the momentum, energy, and crush damage, and then compare their speed estimates to the number coming out of the black box.
 
I originally thought "no plane" theories were nuts. If someone will explain how Reynolds and Rajter are wrong, I will go back to thinking that. Until then, I am open minded. The evidence is that the plane on the videos doesn't slow down much, if at all. This is troubling. If the plane spent so little energy entering the building, why doesn't it exit?

Are their numbers wrong? Please, nothing would make me more comfy than going back to being a plane-hugger. Please convince me. With logic and reasoning, not insults and ad-hominems.
Their numbers show exactly what one should expect--immeasurable deceleration of the tail of the plane even as the nose decelerates rapidly.

Remember that video I showed you?

As soon as the impact begins, the front of the plane decelerates rapidly, but the violence of it decouples it from the rear of the plane, which has not yet measurably experienced the impact.

All but the smallest fraction of the deceleration of the tail happens not from compression against the front portions of the plane, but from impacting stationary objects (i.e., the building).

The animations here ( http://www.cs.purdue.edu/homes/cmh/simulation/phase3/ ) give a good insight into the dynamics involved.
 
Last edited:
Reynolds talks about a plane that does not decelerate but I think that is not really relevant, I'm no plane/crash specialist but if you look at the plane hitting the absorbing wall it doesn't look like the plane that is still intact loses speed at all, the opposite case in which it flies through a piece of paper also doesn't lead to a decrease in speed. For a general wall or structure then you cannot conclude that it should decelerate imo. For low speed this will be different I think. It's too easy to conclude that it should be fly out the other side completely (a part does you can see from the videos) and once it explodes other forces are involved, at that moment all parts go in all directories and will be absorbed easily by the building, there will however be a component that goes straight through.
 
Actually, there is. The end-state is, of course, destruction of the building and the aircraft. Energy from the two distinct phases, namely impact and collapse, can both work towards the end-state.

The building was damaged on impact, and that damage lessened the amount of energy needed to level it later. No "storage" is necessary.
The impacts also triggered the unleashing of stored heat energy within the available fuels in the buildings.
 
The only thing that I remember was that Inplane site, they analyzed those flashes at impact from 4 angles and I remember there was something with an anomaly under the plane.

Even Dr. Greening has raised questions to NIST about the flashes...
Dave von Kliest thinks flight 175 fired a missile as it struck the south tower. Frank Greening does not think that. Do you? Why did you bring it up?
 
I think UFOs struck the North and South towers. Those UFO's oddly looked like commercial aircraft that had been abducted earlier that morning. Strange:hypnotize
 
I think not only did no planes hit the WTC, but that 911 never happened at all, and in fact the WTC were never built at all, and were not built with a huge steel core.

I demand a return to the original and true skyline of NY.
 
Trigood, there are some faulty assumptions in that paper. The weight of the aircraft is far overstated: 450,000 lbs is the max. takeoff weight. The actual weights were about 280,000 lbs, according to NIST (I'm rounding off these numbers). The fuel loads, at about 9,000 gallons, were less than half the maximum. The impact speed on the north tower is about the same as stated at 440 mph, but much higher on the south tower, at over 550 mph.

There is no indication that the steel in the standing towers melted, as the paper states. The steel, especially in the lightweight floor trusses, only had to weaken, not melt, to precipitate the collapses.
Oops, thanks Gravy. I did say "I'm going to look at it more carefully," but I should've done that before I recommended it!

However, neither of those two numbers affect the main point of my paper, which was that the Reynolds paper is full of crap!

Those two numbers only affect two side-calculations I did, namely:

(1) The PE of the plane would go down by a factor of 280/450 or 0.62, so instead of being 0.6 gigajoules, it would be about 0.37 gigajoules. This is minuscule compared to the PE of the upper portion of the towers, above the impact zone. I've previously calculated the PE of, for example, the upper portion of the north tower to be about 200 gigajoules. Hence, the PE of the plane turns out to be not all that significant, and the exact number doesn't really matter.

(2) Energy in the jet fuel would go down by a factor of 9/20 or 0.45, so instead of being 2600 gigajoules, it would be 1200 gigajoules. This, of course, would not change the fact that the jet fuel energy dwarfs the KE of impact energy, at 4 gigajoules. (This is a point that Mackin does correctly make, by the way: "One can see that the impact energy of the jet is negligible compared to the energy content of the fuel.")

But the slight adjustments required here do not change the main point of my post, which was that both the energy of (1) the planes' impact on the towers (KE) and (2) the jet fuel in those planes was, as stated in the First Law of Thermodynamics, conserved in the plane/building system following impact. Namely: (1) the planes' impact caused major damage (in the form of "work" as a physics concept) to the beams, structural members, and fireproofing, and (2) the jet fuel energy (which even with correcton above, dwarfed the impact KE) created fires which did considerably more damage.

The corrections above, therefore, have no impact on my shredding of Reynolds' basic premise, which is that the only thing that caused the planes to lose KE was the initial impact with the towers as reflected in the deceleration visible upon initial impact.

Clearly, Reynolds ignores the entire interior of the towers in making that faulty assumption. As someone here previously said, Reynolds would only have a chance of being correct if the towers constituted an entirely empty shell.

And even then, he would be wrong, as he makes another basic error. The deceleration of the remainder of the plane, as the nose dives into the building, is no indication of the final state of the plane once it penetrates that outer shell. (In actuality, of course, it would no longer be a plane.) The soft aluminum shell of the plane would not transfer impact forces immediately back to the tail of the plane. Think of the steel beams (of the outer shell of the tower) as knives impacting the butter of the aluminum; the tensile strength of the aluminum is not strong enough to convey the force of the plane to the other side of its structure, just as the bottom part of the butter stick doesn't "know" that a knife is cutting the upper part of the stick. Same basic concept.

So, on (at least) two counts, in the case of his KE/deceleration argument, Reynolds is wrong.
 
Last edited:
einsteen said:
The only thing that I remember was that Inplane site, they analyzed those flashes at impact from 4 angles and I remember there was something with an anomaly under the plane.

Even Dr. Greening has raised questions to NIST about the flashes...

9-11 Conspiracy Fact & Fiction

"It's the Flash, Stupid!" In the video 911 In Plane Site, Dave vonKleist claims to have found the smoking gun: a bright flash that can be seen in a slow-motion viewing of video footage at the very moment that the noses of the jetliners crashed into the buildings, or a split-second before impact. In his website essay, "It's the Flash, Stupid!," vonKleist asks, "What caused the flash?" He answers: "There are four possibilities that come to mind: a) a reflection; b) sparks from the fuselage striking the building; c) static discharge; d) some type of incendiary (bomb or missile)." VonKleist quickly disposes of a, b, and c and settles on a missile as the only logical explanation.

General Partin says vonKleist omits the most obvious explanation. "It's very simple," he told The New American, "When the noses of the aircraft hit the buildings, you have a bright aluminum flash, the same as we saw at the Pentagon. That's obvious to anyone familiar with physics, chemistry, and what happens when aluminum hits a structure at a high rate of speed." And the proof of that analysis, the general points out, is in vonKleist's own video. "If you watch just a few frames after the nose flash, you'll see two smaller aluminum flashes as each engine strikes the building. That's all it is."

There's another major problem with the "missile flash." According to vonKleist, the missiles were fired from a pod on the belly of each of the jumbo jets. But, if that is the case, where is the flash from the ignition of the missile; why is there no missile exhaust flare seen on the video? Where is that flash?
 
I think that the reason so many engineers lied about kerosene melting steel is that, in the beginning, a lot of witnesses were reporting "molten metal" and "molten steel" and "molten steel dripping off the ends of beams" and so on. They had to come up with an explanation fast.

It was the truth movement that began pointing out that this is impossible, which led to the abandonment of the "fire melts steel" theory.
I totally shred Reynolds's main argument on KE and deceleration, which you've been asking someone to do, and you totally ignore it and focus on some other area of the Mackin paper, irrelevant to the impact KE discussion. Hmm.

See my above post where I shred a second aspect of Reynolds's argument, namely that the deceleration of the back of the plane has anything whatsoever to do with the KE lost on impact.

Yes, I recommended Mackin's paper without totally reading it; my bad because some of his numbers were off and he talks about "melting" steel. Obviously, no one believes that happened, or needed to, for collapse to ensue. I'm not sure why he mentions it, but that one error and his slightly off values for the plane's weight and fuel load do not change the basic correctness of most of his science (as far as I can tell; I don't understand the impact force calculations, so I can't comment on those).

Look at the diagrams in this paper. They perfectly match what so many JREF's imagine. The top part of the building falls down on the intact lower structure, which acts like a sledgehammer and powers down through the lower floors. The problem, of course, is that this bears no resemblance to observation.
This, from someone who can't even be sure he saw planes going into the towers.
 
More proof that you're full of [rule 8]: [For stating the bin Laden is not wanted for 9/11]


How does it feel to be so consistently wrong?
​

from the FBI site:

Usama Bin Laden is wanted in connection with the August 7, 1998, bombings of the United States Embassies in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi, Kenya. These attacks killed over 200 people. In addition, Bin Laden is a suspect in other terrorist attacks throughout the world.
 
I totally shred Reynolds's main argument on KE and deceleration, which you've been asking someone to do, and you totally ignore it and focus on some other area of the Mackin paper, irrelevant to the impact KE discussion. Hmm.

See my above post where I shred a second aspect of Reynolds's argument, namely that the deceleration of the back of the plane has anything whatsoever to do with the KE lost on impact.

Yes, I recommended Mackin's paper without totally reading it; my bad because some of his numbers were off and he talks about "melting" steel. Obviously, no one believes that happened, or needed to, for collapse to ensue. I'm not sure why he mentions it, but that one error and his slightly off values for the plane's weight and fuel load do not change the basic correctness of most of his science (as far as I can tell; I don't understand the impact force calculations, so I can't comment on those).


This, from someone who can't even be sure he saw planes going into the towers.

Perhaps I can help us communicate a little more effectively. You misunderstand the importance of looking at decelration. Energy is not "spent" causing deceleration. Rather, deceleration is a symptom of energy being spent. A moving object which transfers energy must lose speed, in proportion to the energy transferred.

Thus, it is not appropriate for you to consider the energy sinks, and add them to the deceleration. Looking at the deceleration, by itself, is a way of totalling the energy sinks. The amount of energy spent will be directly reflected in the amount of deceleration.

Now, on "seeing" planes. Yes, we all saw the plane hitting the south tower. I also saw real live dinosaurs at Jurrassic park. I also, just today, saw a magical changing label on the football field that said "3rd and 7" with an arrow and lines.

The question is whether it was faked in real time. I admit this would be very difficult and risky. I am not at all convinced that the no-planers are right. Not at all. I'm just be a skeptic. In the tradition of James Randi.
 
Last edited:
Now, on "seeing" planes. Yes, we all saw the plane hitting the south tower. I also saw real live dinosaurs at Jurrassic park. I also, just today, saw a magical changing label on the football field that said "3rd and 7" with an arrow and lines.
yes, you and i saw them on tv, some there are some people, who for some reason, live in new york, many of them were in manhattan, and they saw the planes with their won eyes

how was that faked?

I'm just be a skeptic. In the tradition of James Randi
ha
 
TS has now made three of the top four dumbest posts I've ever seen.

By the way, TS, do we really need to remind you that James Randi rejected your delusion that you are a skeptic in his tradition?

Are you proud of your stupidity? You seem to be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom