Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

You completely misunderstand and have it backwards. Reynolds/Rajter are wondering why the plane did not exit the building, given that it spent so little energy entering the building. They are wondering how the aluminum wing tips can slice through steel and leave a "cartoon cutout" shape. They are wondering why there is no observed damage to the plane at all.

What Reynolds/Rajter/Wood et al are saying is that some of the evidence is inconsistent with how an aircraft would behave striking a twin tower at 500 mph. The videos show the plane entering effortlessly, without much (or any) deceleration. From that the loss of KE can be calculated. They say that from the original 4 billion joules, about 3.8 billion joules would remain. Where does this energy go? If 5% of the energy can get the plane into the building, why can't 95% get it through and out the other side? Why is there no plane wreckage below the impact point?

Yes, there is evidence in support of planes. Videos, eyewitnesses and a few plane parts. And a hijacker passport.

If some of these questions can be answered, I'll go back to thinking there were planes. Until then, color me skeptical. I could argue either side.
I give up. Ignorance of this depth and breadth cannot be countered.
 
You're probebly referring to the engine that wound up three blocks north at Church & Murray Streets. Obviously the nose cone would have been destroyed on impact. Thousands of pieces of plane and its contents were scattered over a wide area. I'm sure you've seen some photographs of these things. What is difficlut to understand? Can an airliner flying at 4-500 knots break a window? Think about it.

Pieces. Get it? Many of the hundereds of remains found on top of 130 Liberty were less than an inch in size. Larger body parts of passengers and building occupants were strewn everywhere.

Please think before you post crap like this. It is ignorant and undignified.

I've seen a landing gear, and a piece of fuselage with windows. Perhaps you can link us to pictures of the thousands of plane parts. Did they ever match up serial numbers on any of those parts? No, I wasn't aware that larger body parts of passengers and building occupants were strewn everywhere. Links?
 
You completely misunderstand and have it backwards. Reynolds/Rajter are wondering why the plane did not exit the building, given that it spent so little energy entering the building. They are wondering how the aluminum wing tips can slice through steel and leave a "cartoon cutout" shape. They are wondering why there is no observed damage to the plane at all.

What Reynolds/Rajter/Wood et al are saying is that some of the evidence is inconsistent with how an aircraft would behave striking a twin tower at 500 mph. The videos show the plane entering effortlessly, without much (or any) deceleration. From that the loss of KE can be calculated. They say that from the original 4 billion joules, about 3.8 billion joules would remain. Where does this energy go? If 5% of the energy can get the plane into the building, why can't 95% get it through and out the other side? Why is there no plane wreckage below the impact point?

Yes, there is evidence in support of planes. Videos, eyewitnesses and a few plane parts. And a hijacker passport.

If some of these questions can be answered, I'll go back to thinking there were planes. Until then, color me skeptical. I could argue either side.

Hmmm. Would the central building concrete core, which consisted of the elevator, mechanical, electrical, plumbing shafts, not to mention stairwell, have anything to do with it? I'd also venture to guess that the plane(s) came in contact with the floor slabs.
 
This is so typical. I can't remember who said it (probably Matt Taibbi), but the observation was that I can't throw an icecube through the door of my Oldsmobile, so therefore an iceberg could not possibly have sunk the Titanic.

You're missing the point. WHat the no-planers are saying is that you're trying to have it both ways. You're trying to say the plane is so strong that it cuts cleanly though the perimeter of the tower, wihout slowing down, and without showing any damage to itself at all. Then, it suddenly loses its energy and comes to a stop inside the building. Why would it do that?
 
If some of these questions can be answered, I'll go back to thinking there were planes. Until then, color me skeptical. I could argue either side.

You have no idea what "skeptical" means.

You have also phrased your sentence in passive voice. Recast it actively, and go from there.

Finally, you assume anyone really gives a crap if you think or not.
 
You're missing the point. WHat the no-planers are saying is that you're trying to have it both ways. You're trying to say the plane is so strong that it cuts cleanly though the perimeter of the tower, wihout slowing down, and without showing any damage to itself at all. Then, it suddenly loses its energy and comes to a stop inside the building. Why would it do that?

Nice assumption! You have absolutely no evidence to support that loopy claim. What internal tower security video are you referring to, that shows the plane inside the tower?!
 
It is a strange world truthseeker is living in.

Maybe he should try to imagine the plane stationary and the building moving towards it at 500mph.

Would the plane still be recognisable?
Would the building sustain damage?
 

The reason why the CTs will never get anywhere with their misinformation and lies is because their "research" never goes beyond Google. Why don't they all chip in a dollar, hire one of the less loony ones to come to NYC and do some real legwork.

Here's your first mission: Find and interview the mysterious "fire commander" who had the conversation with Larry Silverstein about WTC 7. Since these CTs rarely leave their parent's basements I'll even give them a hint. Firefighters drive around in big red trucks. Good luck.
 
Offhand, I would say that he was part of the general cleaning of house that the Bush Administration went through around the first midterm elections. Bush fired just about every economist on his staff after a disasterous downturn in the economy and strong belief by the electorate that his economic policies were, well, insane.

I'm sorry, I can't find any independent support for the above.

1. The "disasterous" downturn in the economy was in fact the mildest recession in postwar history and would have been milder still without the shock of the 9-11 attacks. The downturn was inevitable due to an inverted yield curve and indeed was predicted by Bush and Cheney during the 2000 campaign.

2. If there was a strong belief by the electorate that his economic policies were insane, it was certainly not evident in the first midterm elections, where the Republicans picked up eight seats in the House and two seats in the Senate. It was one of only four midterm elections since 1900 that the party in power in the White House had gained seats in the House.

3. I suspect (but don't know) that Reynolds may have left due to his personal disenchantment with the war.
 
Especially aluminium filled with liquid. Here's a test for TS take a full soda can and throw it at your car window, then throw an empty one at the unbroken window.

I just tried that. Thank you very much :mad:
 
And "...there is no observed damage to the plane...." excuse me?

I observe a plane effortlessly entering the side of a building. I observe no twisting, no breaking, no slowing, nothing. No damage.

If you observe damageto the plane as it is entering the building, please point it out to me.
 
I observe a plane effortlessly entering the side of a building. I observe no twisting, no breaking, no slowing, nothing. No damage.

If you observe damageto the plane as it is entering the building, please point it out to me.

What about the flash as UA 175 (and AA 11) hits the tower? (fears TS1234 brings up pods and missiles next)

ua175impact.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom