Morgan Reynolds and Rick Rajter Release Their No-Plane Paper

I observe a plane effortlessly entering the side of a building. I observe no twisting, no breaking, no slowing, nothing. No damage.

If you observe damageto the plane as it is entering the building, please point it out to me.

No slowing?! Can you provide data which backs this up, or do you count "one mississippi, two mississippi..."?

No damage?! Yeah, I'm sure the plane landed to a complete halt, and all the passengers (gubmit agents) deboarded, took the lift down and were immediately escorted out of the US where they were summarily executed.
 
No slowing?! Can you provide data which backs this up, or do you count "one mississippi, two mississippi..."?

The calculations are provided in Reynolds/Rajter, the very subject of this thread. Perhaps you should read it prior to posting on this thread.
 
What deformation, where, would your model of an airliner striking a WTC tower wall predict?
 
Correct. I observe no damage of any kind to the plane which entered WTC2. No twisting. No bending. No breaking. No slowing. I'm going to make a still picture of a frame I find very interesting.
Please explain what you expect to see when watching low-resolution handheld video of a plane that's traveling faster than a .45 ACP bullet, when the entire plane enters the building in a fifth of a second.
 
Last edited:
Correct. I observe no damage of any kind to the plane which entered WTC2. No twisting. No bending. No breaking. No slowing. I'm going to make a still picture of a frame I find very interesting.

So are you saying you expected it to be damaged PRIOR to hitting the tower?
 
I'm not sure who is more ridiculous..

In one corner, there is this truthseeker fruitcake..

but, then again, we are the ones wasting our time trying to prove that it was an actual plane that hit the WTC?

C'mon.. this is nothing short of retarded.

Next item up for debate with the CTs are whether our retinas have all been replaced with computer chips which enabled us to see the two towers that whole time they were standing but then we deleted that image from the hard drives and we now actually see the truth, that there were no towers or planes, only a figment of our collective conscious imaginations.

:confused:
 
I'm not sure who is more ridiculous...
I don't know that anyone here is trying to prove that planes hit the buildings. Obviously the burden of proof is on him if he has an alternate hypothesis. I'm trying to understand what makes TS1234 think this way, and to suggest ways for him to think more logically. Honestly, though, I can't tell if this is just a sick game that amuses him. It is very, very hard for me to believe that anyone can be as stupid as he acts.
 
Next item up for debate with the CTs are whether our retinas have all been replaced with computer chips which enabled us to see the two towers that whole time they were standing but then we deleted that image from the hard drives and we now actually see the truth, that there were no towers or planes, only a figment of our collective conscious imaginations.

Yeah but THAT is true! :eek:
 
It is very, very hard for me to believe that anyone can be as stupid as he acts.

I'm a teacher and this week I learned the following from students:
1. Lincoln owned Chinese slaves.
2. Hitler's inner circle called him Elizabeth.

Oh wait....those kids are only 15.
 
Please explain what you expect to see when watching low-resolution handheld video of a plane that's traveling faster than a .45 ACP bullet, when the entire plane enters the building in a fifth of a second.

I would expect the fragile nose to crumple as it hit. I would expect the wings to break. I would expect some parts to bounce off and stay outside the building. In short, I would not expect the entire plane to enter the building. Observe the famous video of the military test where they smashed the plane into the concrete wall. 100% of the plane stayed outside the wall. Complete deceleration was observed. In this case, the exact opposite happened. True, the WTC tower was a grid, not a solid surface. I have no problem seeing how the plane would go through the windows. The parts that impacted vertical columns, and especially those parts that impacted floors edge-on, I would think would slow down.

However, if my expectations are wrong, there is still a problem. Assume the plane is strong enough and going fast enough to bust right through the walls and floors, as is appears. How then does it stop inside the building? If it is strong enough to enter so effortlessly, and spend only 5% of KE, then it could easily sail right on through. The plane at WTC2 mostly missed the core, as evidenced by the huge fireball exiting the east face. Why don't plane parts come out?

I've seen no evidence of any plane parts at WTC, except a landing gear under the scaffolding, and a piece of fuselage with windows. And one unburned passport.
 
I would expect the fragile nose to crumple as it hit. I would expect the wings to break. I would expect some parts to bounce off and stay outside the building. In short, I would not expect the entire plane to enter the building. Observe the famous video of the military test where they smashed the plane into the concrete wall. 100% of the plane stayed outside the wall. Complete deceleration was observed. In this case, the exact opposite happened. True, the WTC tower was a grid, not a solid surface. I have no problem seeing how the plane would go through the windows. The parts that impacted vertical columns, and especially those parts that impacted floors edge-on, I would think would slow down.

However, if my expectations are wrong, there is still a problem. Assume the plane is strong enough and going fast enough to bust right through the walls and floors, as is appears. How then does it stop inside the building? If it is strong enough to enter so effortlessly, and spend only 5% of KE, then it could easily sail right on through. The plane at WTC2 mostly missed the core, as evidenced by the huge fireball exiting the east face. Why don't plane parts come out?

I've seen no evidence of any plane parts at WTC, except a landing gear under the scaffolding, and a piece of fuselage with windows. And one unburned passport.

So in short, you are speculating that what we saw wasn't right because of something that didn't look entirely right to you.
 
I'm a teacher and this week I learned the following from students:
1. Lincoln owned Chinese slaves.
2. Hitler's inner circle called him Elizabeth.

Oh wait....those kids are only 15.
Also, those things are within the realm of possiblilty. Lincoln could have secretly owned slaves who lived in the South, or in China, for that matter. Hitler's inner circle could have used the code name Elizabeth for him. But there is no rational explanation that takes the "no plane" hypothesis out of wacko woo-woo land.
 
I would expect the fragile nose to crumple as it hit. I would expect the wings to break. I would expect some parts to bounce off and stay outside the building. In short, I would not expect the entire plane to enter the building. Observe the famous video of the military test where they smashed the plane into the concrete wall. 100% of the plane stayed outside the wall. Complete deceleration was observed. In this case, the exact opposite happened. True, the WTC tower was a grid, not a solid surface. I have no problem seeing how the plane would go through the windows. The parts that impacted vertical columns, and especially those parts that impacted floors edge-on, I would think would slow down.

However, if my expectations are wrong, there is still a problem. Assume the plane is strong enough and going fast enough to bust right through the walls and floors, as is appears. How then does it stop inside the building? If it is strong enough to enter so effortlessly, and spend only 5% of KE, then it could easily sail right on through. The plane at WTC2 mostly missed the core, as evidenced by the huge fireball exiting the east face. Why don't plane parts come out?

I've seen no evidence of any plane parts at WTC, except a landing gear under the scaffolding, and a piece of fuselage with windows. And one unburned passport.
I am completely baffled as to how you can function in your daily life. :jaw-dropp
 
The calculations are provided in Reynolds/Rajter, the very subject of this thread. Perhaps you should read it prior to posting on this thread.

TruthSeeker1234, this may seem a bit odd, but hear me out...

If possible, I'd like to see a discussion between yourself and ChildlikeEmpress. The two of you have in common some suspicions about Sept. 11th, but you differ wildly on the validity of the Reynolds-Rajter position. She believes this paper to be so laughably false that it is proof of COINTELPRO (that's Counter Intelligence Program in civilian) activities being undertaken by influential figures in the United States. I think she would be interested to discuss with one, such as yourself, who sees from a different perspective.

And for the record, the plane impact video shows precisely what I expected, as one formally trained in Aeronautics.
 
Help me understand this.
WTC2impact4up.jpg


See how the wings are already inside the building, yet I don't see the big gaping holes as we see in the picture at lower right. Why not? If the wings broke the steel and caused this, why do we not see it in the frames I have provided? Is it just the resolution of the video?
 
TruthSeeker1234, this may seem a bit odd, but hear me out...

If possible, I'd like to see a discussion between yourself and ChildlikeEmpress. The two of you have in common some suspicions about Sept. 11th, but you differ wildly on the validity of the Reynolds-Rajter position. She believes this paper to be so laughably false that it is proof of COINTELPRO (that's Counter Intelligence Program in civilian) activities being undertaken by influential figures in the United States. I think she would be interested to discuss with one, such as yourself, who sees from a different perspective.

And for the record, the plane impact video shows precisely what I expected, as one formally trained in Aeronautics.

Just explain where Reynolds/Rajter are wrong. I refer to their argument that if entry required only 5% of KE, then the plane would cut all the way through.
 
He's playing a game. He won't commit to anything and is simply trying to appear smarter than the other posters.
 
Help me understand this.

See how the wings are already inside the building, yet I don't see the big gaping holes as we see in the picture at lower right. Why not?
You must see much more detail than I see.

If the wings broke the steel and caused this, why do we not see it in the frames I have provided? Is it just the resolution of the video?
The resolution is far from great.

Most of the visible damage in the clear, lower right pictures is the facade, and need not indicate damage to columns backing it, although I expect that damage to be considerable.

Remember the wings of a jetliner are built around a huge aluminum beam called the main spar, which is designed to support the aircraft through (typically for passenger planes) up to 4 G's of maneuver, and also handles most of the drag at speeds of up to 0.8 Mach. Yet it's thin-walled and light, meaning it's capable of smacking into an object very hard, but then disintegrates rapidly once its structural integrity is gone.

The wings are also backed by 20,000 pounds of fuel or more in this case (I recall ~5,000 gallons at least in the wing tanks).

So imagine being clocked by a giant aluminum baseball bat, backed by a medium-size swimming pool of flammable liquid moving close to the speed of sound. It's going to leave a mark.

But it's also going to give up its energy quickly. The aluminum aircraft won't stay intact for long, and the rush of liquid will dump nearly all of its energy as it swirls all around the building's internal structure. This is why some of it punched out the other side (as your lower right picture shows), but most of it remains captured in the structure. Pretty simple to understand, really.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom