[Moderated]the new 9/11 investigation

No, because there isn't just some one-size-fits-all "GLOBAL COLLAPSE" scenario. I don't necessarily disagree that the buildings would have collapsed - it's how they collapsed.

If NIST determines that the conditions for a global collapse were met, then they need to keep going. What should happen next? Should the vast majority of the concrete in the building turn to dust and small debris? Should the entire building collapse in about 10 seconds? So on and so forth.
You lack of knowledge and have no expertise to understand what NIST did. After the collapse starts there is nothing to stop the destruction of the building. Your lack of knowledge and comprehension of the NIST report is total on this topic. Why? Have you had physics yet?

If you take a physics course you could model the collapse and it was longer than 10 seconds; but you have not done the physics yet.
If you had a basic understanding of physics and gravity, you would understand NIST.

If I did not understand NIST, I would gain the knowledge to understand NIST. Why do 9/11 truth members not try to gain knowledge to understand these things? Why is 9/11 truth the anti-intellectual movement that spews false conclusions?
 
Last edited:
care to explain why in 7 years, that NONE of your truthers can be bothered to READ THE damn report (its apparent that NONE of them have, INCLUDING Richard Gage), but wish to spend millions of tax payer money to fund a new investigation, without knowing what is in the first one?


I'm not a member of the truth movement.

Also, as I've said at least five times now, the new investigation would have very little overlap with the work NIST originally did, because they only investigated up until the point of collapse initiation.
 
The principles behind all the phenomena witnessed that day are well understood (apparently not by you though). You would know this if you weren't just parroting a load of rubbish that some conmen have sold you.


You have yet to provide proof for any of the extraordinary claims you've made in this thread.

Additionally, what "rubbish" am I parroting, exactly? All I've done is explain (over and over again) what happened during the collapse of WTC1/2 that is currently unexplainable, for one reason or another. I'm not pointing my finger at anyone, nor am I suggesting "what really happened".

Either come back with evidence to support your claims, or go pollute some other thread with all of that anger and rage.
 
This has been explained, over and over and over again..

Just to name a few of the reasons - they didn't explain how WTC1/2 could fall at free-fall speed, they didn't explain how steel beams could be laterally ejected 100+ yards with enough force to lodge themselves into the sides of nearby buildings, and they didn't explain the source of those "squibs" that were visible during the collapse.QUOTE]

Why don't you submit a letter to your local congressmen and Senator explaining why you believe that another investigation is warranted, instead of whining about wanting one on internet message boards?
 
You have yet to provide proof for any of the extraordinary claims you've made in this thread.

Additionally, what "rubbish" am I parroting, exactly? All I've done is explain (over and over again) what happened during the collapse of WTC1/2 that is currently unexplainable, for one reason or another. I'm not pointing my finger at anyone, nor am I suggesting "what really happened".

None of it is unexplainable. Why do you think it is unexplainable? The physics of the collapse, the timing, the dust, the "squibs" etc all are fairly basic stuff that even a layman like myself has no problem understanding. Have you noticed anyone with actual physics or structural engineering credentials being puzzled by this stuff? (and no, AETruth don't count).

Either come back with evidence to support your claims, or go pollute some other thread with all of that anger and rage.

Anger and rage? No. A sickening sense of deja vu? Maybe. A despair at the credulity of some people? Definitely. A vain hope that people like you may one day listen to reason? Yep. No anger, no rage.
 
You know what's funny? Not once have I ever seen a debunker say, "Fine - go ahead and do another investigation. Consider all of the new evidence, everything you've mentioned -- they will still arrive at the same conclusion."

Fine - go ahead and do another investigation. Consider all of the new evidence, everything you've mentioned -- they will still arrive at the same conclusion. I'm not American, so I won't be paying for it through my taxes; I'll just sit and watch from the other side of the Atlantic, and laugh myself silly when your fantasies are discarded.

It's never going to happen, but from a personal point of view I don't care a toss if it does. After all, we had the Diana inquest, which had a similar result, and there shouldn't be a monopoly on stupidity.

Dave
 
You know what's funny? Not once have I ever seen a debunker say, "Fine - go ahead and do another investigation. Consider all of the new evidence, everything you've mentioned -- they will still arrive at the same conclusion."

What "all new evidence" anyway? A hurricane as a power source for whatever laser beam you can think of perhaps?
 
1. According to my timing of the collapse, they collapsed at free-fall speed. If it makes you feel better, let's say they collapsed at free-fall speed (+/- 1 sec).

This is a classic example of a deliberate and dishonest attempt to cloud a perfectly simple issue. The question you are desperately trying to avoid prompting anyone to ask here, with your meaningless "free-fall speed" canard, is this one:

Were the collapse times of the Twin Towers consistent with what would be expected from a gravity-driven top-down collapse?

You're trying to avoid this question being asked because you're well aware that the answer is a clear and simple "yes". It hasn't been calculated by NIST, but this is irrelevant; the result of a calculation doesn't depend on the affiliation of the person carrying it out. GregoryUrich, a poster on JREF who is strongly suspicious that there was US Government complicity in 9-11 (Gregory, please correct me if I'm wrong on this) has carried out the most thorough and comprehensive calculation I've seen so far, and found that the collapse times are not suspicious; as far as I know he's submitted a paper to this effect to the Journal of 9-11 Studies. The fact that you're still clinging to your "free-fall speed" mantra suggests to me that you're trying to avoid doing any actual calculations, but simply trying to spread the lie that no such calculations have been done and their results would arouse suspicion if they were.

The follow-on question, which you're trying to jump straight to, is:

If the collapse times of the Twin Towers were inconsistent with what would be expected from a gravity-driven top-down collapse, what additional agent was involved, and who was responsible for its placing?

But that question is of course meaningless, as it is predicated on an untrue condition.

If you want to continue pointing to the Twin Tower collapse times as a cause for suspicion, look up GregoryUrich's work on this forum and refute it. If you fail to do so, yet still claim that the collapse times are in some way suspicious, then I will have no hesitation in accusing you of deliberately lying.

Dave
 
This is a classic example of a deliberate and dishonest attempt to cloud a perfectly simple issue. The question you are desperately trying to avoid prompting anyone to ask here, with your meaningless "free-fall speed" canard, is this one:

Were the collapse times of the Twin Towers consistent with what would be expected from a gravity-driven top-down collapse?

You're trying to avoid this question being asked because you're well aware that the answer is a clear and simple "yes". It hasn't been calculated by NIST, but this is irrelevant; the result of a calculation doesn't depend on the affiliation of the person carrying it out. GregoryUrich, a poster on JREF who is strongly suspicious that there was US Government complicity in 9-11 (Gregory, please correct me if I'm wrong on this) has carried out the most thorough and comprehensive calculation I've seen so far, and found that the collapse times are not suspicious; as far as I know he's submitted a paper to this effect to the Journal of 9-11 Studies. The fact that you're still clinging to your "free-fall speed" mantra suggests to me that you're trying to avoid doing any actual calculations, but simply trying to spread the lie that no such calculations have been done and their results would arouse suspicion if they were.

The follow-on question, which you're trying to jump straight to, is:

If the collapse times of the Twin Towers were inconsistent with what would be expected from a gravity-driven top-down collapse, what additional agent was involved, and who was responsible for its placing?

But that question is of course meaningless, as it is predicated on an untrue condition.

If you want to continue pointing to the Twin Tower collapse times as a cause for suspicion, look up GregoryUrich's work on this forum and refute it. If you fail to do so, yet still claim that the collapse times are in some way suspicious, then I will have no hesitation in accusing you of deliberately lying.

Dave

Yeah, what he said.
 
If NIST determines that the conditions for a global collapse were met, then they need to keep going. What should happen next? Should the vast majority of the concrete in the building turn to dust and small debris? Should the entire building collapse in about 10 seconds? So on and so forth.

Surely you must be joking?

Maybe they should test for magic pixie dust, too.
 
OK. The derail in this thread was not reported early enough, and as there are many other threads about the events of 911 and the various collapses, I am not splitting it out. However, I am re-quoting the OP here. The topic is very specific, and is not about examining the events of that day. Please keep to the topic from this point on, or the posts will be removed, and the thread may be closed or placed on Moderated Status.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero

 
deep44 said:
1. According to my timing of the collapse, they collapsed at free-fall speed. If it makes you feel better, let's say they collapsed at free-fall speed (+/- 1 sec).

Barring the derail, I have noticed that the bolded above is a claim for faster than freefall? I thought that went out with Rubiks cubes?

As regards the OP, I think there should be another investigation as I am not an American taxpayer so it will not affect me. Why should us brits have to put up with the shame of the Diana inquest, which cost millions, and let the Americans get away scot free:rolleyes:

The outcome would be the same, a total waste of money, and the truth movements true colours would be on display shortly afterwards. Especially the scumbags who make money from it.

The basement dwellers will never accept the truth.
 
Barring the derail, I have noticed that the bolded above is a claim for faster than freefall? I thought that went out with Rubiks cubes?

As regards the OP, I think there should be another investigation as I am not an American taxpayer so it will not affect me. Why should us brits have to put up with the shame of the Diana inquest, which cost millions, and let the Americans get away scot free:rolleyes:

The outcome would be the same, a total waste of money, and the truth movements true colours would be on display shortly afterwards. Especially the scumbags who make money from it.

The basement dwellers will never accept the truth.

So you want a new investigation that looks into the claim that GWB killed Princess Diana?

Makes as much sense as anything else in this thread...
 
None of it is unexplainable. Why do you think it is unexplainable? The physics of the collapse, the timing, the dust, the "squibs" etc all are fairly basic stuff that even a layman like myself has no problem understanding. Have you noticed anyone with actual physics or structural engineering credentials being puzzled by this stuff? (and no, AETruth don't count).



Anger and rage? No. A sickening sense of deja vu? Maybe. A despair at the credulity of some people? Definitely. A vain hope that people like you may one day listen to reason? Yep. No anger, no rage.

no problem understanding or falling for very weak attempt of an explenation?
 
You have yet to provide proof for any of the extraordinary claims you've made in this thread.

Additionally, what "rubbish" am I parroting, exactly? All I've done is explain (over and over again) what happened during the collapse of WTC1/2 that is currently unexplainable, for one reason or another. I'm not pointing my finger at anyone, nor am I suggesting "what really happened".

Either come back with evidence to support your claims, or go pollute some other thread with all of that anger and rage.

No, it is not unexplainable, it is just that you do not understand (though it has been axplained over and over to you).

Here's an idea (someone may have already suggested this) for the TM. Instead of going for a full blown investigation, why not gather the donations and hire a few different structural engineering firms in a few different countries. Now, they have access to all of the relevant data to determine if collapse progression would be arrested or if global collapse was inevitable. Now, if these firms come back with hard data showing that the collapse would be arrested, then the TM can work on getting this information published and peer reviewed. Instead of clamoring for a full blown new investigation, why not try taking it one step at a time?
 
The new investigation, who, what, when and how?
who : experts that have no conflict of interest. hard to say names. that would have to be worked out. one i would like to see on that list would be Dr. Frank Greening and Hugo Bachman for examples. (i know Greenings is not a CDer, but he is still openminded and would be honest when they would find out something else than the official story supports.

what: everything, from putoptions to collapse of WTC7 and Hijackers - CIA/FBI connections etc.
Also Mossad / Israel arests and such.
when : ASAP

How : Honest, detailed, transparent, with full acces to everything they need, testemonys under oath and public. including Mike the EMP and William Rodriguez and all the fireman etc.
 
Last edited:
If it was such a weak explanation, why have all the engineers and physicists from all over the world also fallen for it Dick? What do you know that they don't?

ALL engineers???

and it was more about details, like the squibs. the dust/elevator shaft explenation is extremly weak when you take a look into it detailed. the same goes for the fireball / elevator shaft explenation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom