[Moderated]the new 9/11 investigation

Why would CD make a building fall down faster than say a normal failure of a building's supports?

I once heard a twoofer claim that demolition charges actually suck the building down. I'm serious.

That's what happens when you grow up not understanding what gravity does.
 
Last edited:
Then I implore you to come up with alternative explanations.

I am reading your mind. You are going to complain that "but 1337m4n, I don't have to have an exact explanation! I just want to know THE TRUTH!".

I am not asking you to give a final explanation for what happen on 9/11. What I am asking for is for you to throw out possibilities. Given the alleged "anomalies", what do you think could possibly explain them, aside from the official story?


Ahh, I see what you're getting at now. You want me to answer a question that doesn't have any right answers, so any response I give will be considered "wrong". Then, you'll have a fresh excuse to insult me, belittle me, and claim that I'm insane because of what I just said.

I support a new investigation. That's it.



No, that doesn't answer why it "must" be investigated. "Must" we investigate the color of the toilet seat on Flight 77? "Must" we investigate the provider of office furniture for the WTC? "Must" we investigate why the people who leaped from the 70th floor died upon impact with the ground?


Well, I've been stating these reasons throughout this thread, but it's almost as if you're not able to retain them in your long-term memory for some reason.

To summarize, we need to investigate the characteristics of events for which we have no frame of reference. For example, the collapse speed of a 110 story skyscraper - what's normal, abnormal, etc? Even just estimates are fine - right now we have nothing. How much should be created? Again, now we have nothing.

Please go back and read my previous messages in this thread if you want additional examples. If you ask me the same question yet again, you will be ignored.


I have proof. Watch the videos of the alleged "squibs". You can see that these "squibs" actually INCREASE in force over time. They start out weak and gradually become more forceful. This is characteristic of an air pressure wave.


Where is the write-up on this, describing how you arrived at this conclusion, etc? Where is your proof for the statements I've bolded?

In other words, you haven't proven anything - in fact, your explanation is on the same level with, "the squibs are explosives because they go boom".


Now it's my turn to ask you a question: How exactly is a "new investigation" supposed to discern anything about the "squibs" other than what we already know?


Well, considering we don't know anything about them, I don't think that will be much of a problem.
 
Ahh, I see what you're getting at now. You want me to answer a question that doesn't have any right answers, so any response I give will be considered "wrong". Then, you'll have a fresh excuse to insult me, belittle me, and claim that I'm insane because of what I just said.

I support a new investigation. That's it.






Well, I've been stating these reasons throughout this thread, but it's almost as if you're not able to retain them in your long-term memory for some reason.

To summarize, we need to investigate the characteristics of events for which we have no frame of reference. For example, the collapse speed of a 110 story skyscraper - what's normal, abnormal, etc? Even just estimates are fine - right now we have nothing. How much should be created? Again, now we have nothing.

Please go back and read my previous messages in this thread if you want additional examples. If you ask me the same question yet again, you will be ignored.





Where is the write-up on this, describing how you arrived at this conclusion, etc? Where is your proof for the statements I've bolded?

In other words, you haven't proven anything - in fact, your explanation is on the same level with, "the squibs are explosives because they go boom".





Well, considering we don't know anything about them, I don't think that will be much of a problem.

You know what I'd do if I was you?: I'd study physics and/or engineering to find out why none of those science type eggheads ever agree with me about these things I keep saying we know nothing about...
 
I think we've lost sight of the original question here.
...The new investigation, who, what, when and how?...

"Answers" have been given, such as:

Simple: an independent investigation with no conflicts of interest, that has proper funding and full subpeona power to make anyone testify under oath.
WHO would be the independent party?
WHERE would this funding come from?
WHO would have the subpoena power to make "anyone testify under oath?"
WHO would be subpoenaed, for that matter?

See also:
I'd also like to know WHAT they would be "investigating".

Here is my question. What happens if an independent investigation doesn't find anything, and in fact backs up the Commission Report?

Or is this new investigation going to be free of all Constitutional restrictions, and merely be a repeat of the Salem Witch trails?
 
You're doing it wrong again, deep44.

Your entire purpose for wanting a "new investigation" is because there are things that we supposedly "don't know".

Well? Do we "know" whether or not an NWO exists?


Do we "know" whether aliens from space exist? Should we also include them in this new investigation?

It's obvious that you're purposely trying to waste my time now -- I can assure you that it won't happen again.
 
You know what I'd do if I was you?: I'd study physics and/or engineering to find out why none of those science type eggheads ever agree with me about these things I keep saying we know nothing about...


Please provide proof, or your claim is meaningless.
 
Last edited:
Please provide proof, or your claim is meaningless.

If I were to provide proof, you would just dismiss it like you do with everything else that you don't agree with.

It is your claim that we know nothing about these squibs and the collapse time etc. I'm just pointing out to you that scientists and engineers don't seem to be too surprised by these things. You can either educate yourself in the relevant fields, trust those so educated, or wallow forever in a pit of uncertainty. The choice is yours.
 
Is there some evidence that NIST didn't have that your new investigation would have?


Most importantly, they would be considering the actual collapse of WTC1/2 (instead of stopping at collapse initiation, like NIST did).
 
Deep44,

let's say that I, CHF, gain access to all the relevant info about 9/11 and I then do an investigation that concludes no inside job.

Would you accept it?
 
why do the truthers think that CONTROLLED Demolition accelerates the fall of a building in a collapse? What the hell goes into this kind of thinking?


That's what I want to know.

Why would CD make a building fall down faster than say a normal failure of a building's supports?

Uh...umm...gravity...umm...thermite...uhh...keebler elves...err...ummm...ahh...SHUT UP YOU GOVERNMENT SHILL
 
Last edited:
Maybe the money being raised for the $2000000 infowars moneybomb could be put towards a truther-sponsored investigation?

I know $50,000 isn't much, but it's a start.
 
If I were to provide proof, you would just dismiss it like you do with everything else that you don't agree with.


There is no proof, because there was no official investigation into anything beyond collapse initiation.

It is your claim that we know nothing about these squibs and the collapse time etc. I'm just pointing out to you that scientists and engineers don't seem to be too surprised by these things.


Ahh.. because scientists haven't spoken up about it, that must mean that they aren't "too surprised"? Sorry, but your fallacious argument isn't fooling anyone.
 
Ahh.. because scientists haven't spoken up about it, that must mean that they aren't "too surprised"? Sorry, but your fallacious argument isn't fooling anyone.

By the same token, because they haven't spoken up, they have a problem with it? What's a more likely scenario?
 
Last edited:
Ahh.. because scientists haven't spoken up about it, that must mean that they aren't "too surprised"? Sorry, but your fallacious argument isn't fooling anyone.

Are you claiming that there are no scientists that support the non-truthy explaination or are you trying to claim that scientists are afraid to talk? More specifically structural engineers afraid to talk? I mean would you believe any scientists who didn't back up claims that are extra-truthy?

I tend to think that you really don't want a new investigation, because you won't be happy until they return the results you want. Personally I don't want my tax dollars supporting an infinite number of troofer witch hunts.
 
There is no proof, because there was no official investigation into anything beyond collapse initiation.




Ahh.. because scientists haven't spoken up about it, that must mean that they aren't "too surprised"? Sorry, but your fallacious argument isn't fooling anyone.

So you are telling me that all the thousands (millions?) of scientists and engineers in the world find these things surprising, but they won't talk about it?

If NIST published a load of rubbish do you really truly believe that no one would have spotted it except for the loons in the Truth Movement?
 
Maybe the money being raised for the $2000000 infowars moneybomb could be put towards a truther-sponsored investigation?

I know $50,000 isn't much, but it's a start.


As stated numerous times throughout this thread, not all of the evidence is available to the general public, so any sort of civilian-sponsored investigation is out of the question until that changes.
 
As stated numerous times throughout this thread, not all of the evidence is available to the general public, so any sort of civilian-sponsored investigation is out of the question until that changes.
So basically any private effort won't work. So the only alternative is a government investigation, but you can't trust the government because they may or may not been responsible; so the government cannot investigate itself. The only option is a non-government investigation, but a private effort won't work. So the only alternative is a government investigation, but you can't trust the government...
 
Ahh, I see what you're getting at now. You want me to answer a question that doesn't have any right answers, so any response I give will be considered "wrong". Then, you'll have a fresh excuse to insult me, belittle me, and claim that I'm insane because of what I just said.

I support a new investigation. That's it.

Stop putting words in my mouth liar. All I am asking is that when you make a retarded claim, you back it up.

Well, I've been stating these reasons throughout this thread, but it's almost as if you're not able to retain them in your long-term memory for some reason.

To summarize, we need to investigate the characteristics of events for which we have no frame of reference. For example, the collapse speed of a 110 story skyscraper - what's normal, abnormal, etc? Even just estimates are fine - right now we have nothing. How much should be created? Again, now we have nothing.

Please go back and read my previous messages in this thread if you want additional examples. If you ask me the same question yet again, you will be ignored.

Wrong.

We have 10,000 pages of data that you have obviously not read.

Even if we didn't, the lack of a "frame of reference" still does not justify investigating every single nitpickable detail without a good reason for doing so. If you would simply answer my question above instead of trying to put words in my mouth, I could explain to you the errors in your reasoning.

Lastly, we have plenty of other examples of buildings collapsing from fire. For example, there is the video I gave you in a previous post which exhibits all of the "anomalies" you have mentioned so far.

Where is the write-up on this, describing how you arrived at this conclusion, etc? Where is your proof for the statements I've bolded?

In other words, you haven't proven anything - in fact, your explanation is on the same level with, "the squibs are explosives because they go boom".

Idiot. Watch your Lies Movement's own videos that deal with the "squibs", then tell me I'm wrong.

Why don't YOU provide an example of something else--ANYTHING--that the squibs could even POSSIBLY be? ANYTHING at all.

Well, considering we don't know anything about them, I don't think that will be much of a problem.

Nice dodge.

I'll reword it then for you, liar:

How exactly is a "new investigation" supposed to discern anything about the "squibs", period?

Do we "know" whether aliens from space exist? Should we also include them in this new investigation?

You tell me. You're the one who wants to spend billions of taxpayer dollars trying to discern the origin of tiny tufts of air being blown out the windows of a collapsing building.

Just answer your own question, the one you asked me just now, and you'll soon understand why we're all calling you an idiot.
 
As stated numerous times throughout this thread, not all of the evidence is available to the general public, so any sort of civilian-sponsored investigation is out of the question until that changes.

Yes, but you already think there is something fishy going on. What evidence do you have? Surely if this new investigation had the same evidence as you, they would come to the same conclusion, right? So why not start with that?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom