[Moderated]the new 9/11 investigation

As stated numerous times throughout this thread, not all of the evidence is available to the general public, so any sort of civilian-sponsored investigation is out of the question until that changes.

So you want the taxpayer to pay for this, correct?

You want funding that is currently being used to educate our children, provide our citizens with health care, develop technologies to protect the environment, etc. to instead be used to fund an investigation into why tiny tufts of air appeared in a few of the windows of a collapsing building.
 
Ahh.. because scientists haven't spoken up about it, that must mean that they aren't "too surprised"? Sorry, but your fallacious argument isn't fooling anyone.

Pssst. Deep44. The scientific community is laughing at you. They are laughing at your precious petition of 384 out of millions of architects and engineers in the United States.
 
As stated numerous times throughout this thread, not all of the evidence is available to the general public, so any sort of civilian-sponsored investigation is out of the question until that changes.

Then I'll reiterate part of the OP again.

WHERE will this funding come from?
 
So you are telling me that all the thousands (millions?) of scientists and engineers in the world find these things surprising, but they won't talk about it?

If NIST published a load of rubbish do you really truly believe that no one would have spotted it except for the loons in the Truth Movement?


NIST didn't investigate beyond collapse initiation.

How many times do I have to say this before it will sink in?

Hundreds of architects and engineers have noticed this problem, and are pushing for a new investigation as a result.

So considering the fact that the actual collapse hasn't been officially investigated, exactly what position are all of these imaginary scientists and engineers taking? There's nothing to agree with NIST on - they chose not to investigate the collapse itself.
 
The towers fell essentially in freefall. Why do dumbunkers still deny this?

OMFG! More than six and a half years after the fact and you're still claiming freefall speed? How do you explain the fact that beams which are falling away from the tower (and which really are in freefall) are falling dramatically faster than the collapsing part of the towers?

Steve S.
 
NIST didn't investigate beyond collapse initiation.

How many times do I have to say this before it will sink in?

Hundreds of architects and engineers have noticed this problem, and are pushing for a new investigation as a result.

So considering the fact that the actual collapse hasn't been officially investigated, exactly what position are all of these imaginary scientists and engineers taking? There's nothing to agree with NIST on - they chose not to investigate the collapse itself.

Actually I think you'll find that architects and engineers understand very well the fact that once started, the collapse could not be stopped. Again, you could educate yourself and find out why this is.

Please stop pretending that the Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth are anything of the sort. They are a great big fraud and you know it.
 
Actually I think you'll find that architects and engineers understand very well the fact that once started, the collapse could not be stopped. Again, you could educate yourself and find out why this is.


That's not what needs to be investigated. It's how the towers collapsed - the speed, the dust, the lateral ejections, etc. How much longer before this sinks in?

Please stop pretending that the Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth are anything of the sort. They are a great big fraud and you know it.


You only believe they are a "big fraud" because you don't agree with what they have to say. Considering the fact that you're obviously not an architect or engineer, I find that to be quite humorous.
 
A congressional appropriation.
Okay, great. Taxpayer money.

Now, for the rest of the questions.
WHO would be the independent party?
WHERE would this funding come from?
WHO would have the subpoena power to make "anyone testify under oath?"
WHO would be subpoenaed, for that matter?

See also:
I'd also like to know WHAT they would be "investigating".

Here is my question. What happens if an independent investigation doesn't find anything, and in fact backs up the Commission Report?

Or is this new investigation going to be free of all Constitutional restrictions, and merely be a repeat of the Salem Witch trails?
 
NIST didn't investigate beyond collapse initiation.

explain why a study that CANT be modeled with today's computers, has any significance to the investigation?

What possible answer are you looking for, in the collapse after initiation?



Hundreds of architects and engineers have noticed this problem, and are pushing for a new investigation as a result.
OUT of millions world-wide. You know MILLIONS of engineers and architects have HAD ACCESS to the 10,000 page report done by NISt and NONE has come forward to challenge their findings, and post htem to RESPECTABLE journals. Howeve,r WE DO HAVE independent engineers and architiects that have posted ARTICLES to RESPECTABLE journals, that agree, and GO BEYOND the study that NIST did.

care to explain why in 7 years, that NONE of your truthers can be bothered to READ THE damn report (its apparent that NONE of them have, INCLUDING Richard Gage), but wish to spend millions of tax payer money to fund a new investigation, without knowing what is in the first one?
 
That's not what needs to be investigated. It's how the towers collapsed - the speed, the dust, the lateral ejections, etc. How much longer before this sinks in?

Well given that there isn't actually anything mysterious about those things either, I'm not sure why you'd want to investigate them more than has already been done. They are all straightforward consequences of the big building collapsing.


You only believe they are a "big fraud" because you don't agree with what they have to say. Considering the fact that you're obviously not an architect or engineer, I find that to be quite humorous.

No, I think that they are big fraud because they aren't architects or structural engineers either. Unlike them, I don't pretend to be.

See the AETruth watch thread for more info...
 
That's not what needs to be investigated. It's how the towers collapsed - the speed, the dust, the lateral ejections, etc. How much longer before this sinks in?

How long till it sinks into your skull that there was no freefall speed? And the dust? Tests of the dust showed most of it was from the thousands of tons of drywall. I can crumble that stuff in my own hands. The collapse of a skyscraper could certainly turn it to dust.
And I would expect something as chaotic as the collapse of a 1400 foot tall building to result in some of it ejected.



You only believe they are a "big fraud" because you don't agree with what they have to say.

No, they're a fraud because Anyone and Everyone can sign up.

Steve S.
 
Last edited:
Pssst. Deep44. The scientific community is laughing at you. They are laughing at your precious petition of 384 out of millions of architects and engineers in the United States.


As new architects and engineers find out about ae911truth, they are joining. That's clear as day if you look at the steady stream of new members.

On the other hand, what evidence do you have that the millions of other architects and engineers have been presented with an opportunity to join, but instead chose to "laugh at them" instead?

You don't seem to understand that there is no rational justification for why you vehemently oppose a new investigation. If they got it right the first time, then a new investigation changes nothing, except this issue is finally put to rest forever.
 
If they got it right the first time, then a new investigation changes nothing, except this issue is finally put to rest forever.

That's where you are so, so wrong. If a new investigation returns the same results, the truth movement will find some new minutiae to complain about. True believers are never wrong.

If you honestly believe a new investigation would "put it to rest forever", you are being incredibly naive.
 
Deep44> There is a rational justification, and it is simply that the troofers don't want to investigate anything. You want money, you want independent organization with Constitutional powers; but you don't want an investigation. You want to walk into a Kangaroo Court and execute those "guilty" parties based on an opinion. An opinion not based in the available science.

You can't even tell us the structure and scope of such an investigation. What you are talking about would take decades to complete, and would have to take into account every hair brained theory that can drum up support from a few hundred people. It would cover everything from the Reptile alien overloads, to the deathstar energy beams; and troofers would never buy into its legitimacy. Why? Because it would have to be sponsored by the same government you blame for the conspiracy.

So a new investigation does change one thing, it goes on for decades and costs the American people an untold sum or money, based on a hunch; and would still never answer the "questions" the troofers bring up.
 
Last edited:
NIST didn't investigate beyond collapse initiation.

How many times do I have to say this before it will sink in?

Hundreds of architects and engineers have noticed this problem, and are pushing for a new investigation as a result.

So considering the fact that the actual collapse hasn't been officially investigated, exactly what position are all of these imaginary scientists and engineers taking? There's nothing to agree with NIST on - they chose not to investigate the collapse itself.

There's NOTHING to agree with NIST on??????

If I read your post correctly, it would appear that you AGREE with NIST up to the point of collapse initiation.

What you claim you want a SCIENTIFIC STUDY on (not an investigation) is the mechanics behind the GLOBAL COLLAPSE.

If (and only if) a SCIENTIFIC STUDY found that a Global Collapse was not possible would an INVESTIGATION into alternative explanations for the collapse be justified.
 
If (and only if) a SCIENTIFIC STUDY found that a Global Collapse was not possible would an INVESTIGATION into alternative explanations for the collapse be justified.


No, because there isn't just some one-size-fits-all "GLOBAL COLLAPSE" scenario. I don't necessarily disagree that the buildings would have collapsed - it's how they collapsed.

If NIST determines that the conditions for a global collapse were met, then they need to keep going. What should happen next? Should the vast majority of the concrete in the building turn to dust and small debris? Should the entire building collapse in about 10 seconds? So on and so forth.
 
How long till it sinks into your skull that there was no freefall speed? And the dust? Tests of the dust showed most of it was from the thousands of tons of drywall. I can crumble that stuff in my own hands. The collapse of a skyscraper could certainly turn it to dust.
And I would expect something as chaotic as the collapse of a 1400 foot tall building to result in some of it ejected.


Again, thanks for your unprofessional and unproven theory, but this is really something that needs to be officially investigated.
 
Again, thanks for your unprofessional and unproven theory, but this is really something that needs to be officially investigated.

The principles behind all the phenomena witnessed that day are well understood (apparently not by you though). You would know this if you weren't just parroting a load of rubbish that some conmen have sold you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom