[Moderated]the new 9/11 investigation

DC, I didn't ask for you to describe how a perfect investigation would be, like how your ideal wedding would be, I'm asking what will it be like? Understand the difference?

This is your cause, this is the important thing that must be done, right? Then do the work, think it through, you have to do the intellectual leg work, not us.

who : experts that have no conflict of interest. hard to say names. that would have to be worked out.

Then work it out here, that's what this thread is about.

would be honest when they would find out something else than the official story supports.

What if they don't and come to the same conclusion?

what: everything, from putoptions to collapse of WTC7 and Hijackers - CIA/FBI connections etc.

I know that. Some other twoofers would like to know about the phone calls, the thermite, the plane a the Pentagon.

Get your theories together. Is this going to be a total re-do? Because if you're going to have to remake the entire investigation, you'll probably end up having to deal with the same people who took part in the first one, the same forensic experts, the same engineers, the same agents, and the same witnesses.

Take for example the NIST, what other organisation of engineers is more qualified? If you find one and they find a conspiracy, are you going to have to prosecute the NIST?

when : ASAP

Then what are you waiting for? Who have you asked so far? What steps have you done and what are the steps that you are going to have to do, starting from now?

How : Honest, detailed, transparent, with full acces to everything they need, testemonys under oath and public.

That's a nice day dream, but what does that mean in reality? What are the implications of this?

Who are you going to have to approach to do that? Who has that authority. Who will preside over the investigations, what body? Where? Under what authority? How are they going to be able to prosecute people?

Gee, I'm starting to like that "asking questions" thing.
 
You can offer the best scientific proof in the world to the truthers and they will not accept it. They are political fanatics (from both sides of the spectrum) who hold as a article of faith that the US government is "Behind" 9/11. It's motivitated purely by politics.They don't give a damn about "the truth".
That is why a new investigation will never satisfy them. They do not want a new investigation, they want a lynch mob.

Exactly, it's been two years since I first heard of this movement and I've never seen them do anything about the new investigation, nothing constructive that would help put it together that is.

All I've seen is them putting signs and giving pamphlets at Ground Zero, shouting accusations disguised in "questions", post their "proof" on message boards, spam websites with their comments and post Youtube videos, rally for a lost cause (Ron Paul), heckle and stalk political and public figures of all denominations at public events, annoying the heck at everyone...

Not one paper proposed to the scientific community, they didn't approach any major news outlet (the Howard Stern Show doesn't count) or official public authorities, or their government...

I mean, what the hell is that? What the heck do they think they are doing? Take a step back twoofers and look at what you've been doing so far, does this look serious to you?
 
Here's a question: how would testifying under oath prevent a person from invoking their fifth amendment right and refusing to answer a question which might incriminate themselves?
 
Here's a question: how would testifying under oath prevent a person from invoking their fifth amendment right and refusing to answer a question which might incriminate themselves?

How would testifying under oath prevent a person from just lying anyway? I mean, we're talking the most evil people of all time, here!
 
Okay, let me see if I've got it so far:

We know from previous investigations how the building collapses began. However, we don't know what happened AFTER that.

So, we need a new investigation to see if there was some nefarious plot to cause the building collapse to progress differently than it would have if it had just collapsed without intervention. You never know, there might have been; that's why we have to investigate!

If so, we need to find those dirty bastards who interfered with the collapses for some reason, destroying their timing and natural symmetry, and drag them away in chains.

Hopefully, it will be Bush and Cheney. That would be cool.

(Of course, this all depends on our ability to find a law against interfering with a building collapse once it has begun. I think it may be in there with the anti-suicide statutes.)

Do I have it straight?
 
I think it's come down to three things:

Truthers don't understand how the real world works and expect the new investigation to just happen by itself.

They expect others to work it out and put it together, so it's become a chain-reaction of inaction.

They really don't want an investigation, they just want to keep accusing the US government without actually having to prove it. So the 'new-investigation-that-will-never-happen' is just a pretext.

Maybe it's all three of them combined.
 
I spoke to JFK and asked him why the truth movement hasn't created a concise narrative of the inside job scenario.

His response? He assumes that to get a new investigation you only need to have a lot of people think it was an inside job. Or something.
 
A follow-up on these unanswered threads about the main 9/11 truth issue. OK twoofers, cut the BS. The new investigation, who, what, when and how?

Investigative journalist Peter Lance, who agrees with the broad outlines of the "official" story, favors a new investigation. He wrote this,

"One positive step- one crack of light in that "darkened room"- would be the creation of a truly independent panel, a new investigative body made up of journalists, scholars, victims' family members, and concerned citizens. The goal would be the creation of a populist blue ribbon commission, charged with two goals: filling in the gaps left by the Joint Inquiry and the 9/11 Commission reports..."

I would consider this a start. Would the debunkers even favor this?

I once heard a twoofer claim that demolition charges actually suck the building down. I'm serious.

That's what happens when you grow up not understanding what gravity does.

I also once heard a similar claim. Here it is,

"As the top fell straight down, the debris was sucked down with negative pressure behind the falling mass. Like ship passengers getting sucked down over a sinking ship, the debris directly above the falling mass was sucked down."

Wait! This is from the Journal of Debunking 911 Conspiracy Theories, by "Debunking 9/11". I thought that journal was suppose to be peer-reviewed. That sounds like something that could be nominated for a Stundie. Or maybe would can create a new competition and call it a "Debunkie."
 
OK, keep going, Tanabear.

Other truthers are welcome to jump in the discussion anytime.

First, all of the relevant classified information regarding 9/11 would need to be de-classified. This would include the 9/11 Congressional Inquiry report. Secondly, all important lingering questions need to be resolved. The 9/11 Commission Report states, "To date, the U.S. government has not been able to determine the origin of the money used for the 9/11 attacks. Ultimately the question is of little practical significance." This is not an acceptable answer.

Peter Lance, a five-time Emmy-winning investigative reporter, lists a series of questions in his book, "Cover Up" that all concerned citizens should demand answers to. Here's a selection,

Pre-9/11

- "KSM has the same price on his head[as Ramzi Yousef] but for more than 18 months the Feds kept the hunt for him secret. Why?...and in preparing my March 2004 testimony before the 9/11 Commission, I cited it as one that needed to be addressed by the panel."

- "KSM was a key co-conspirator in the Bojinka plot, his name was missing from the 6,000-page transcript of the trial. Why?"

- "Why was the evidence that Ramzi Yousef conceived the 9/11 plot as far back as 1994 in the Philippines seemingly ignored by the FBI?"

It was Dietrich Snell who prosecuted Ramzi Yousef during the Bojinka trial. Ironically, it was Dietrich Snell who took Peter Lance's testimony to the 9/11 Commission. Lance asked Snell, "Why did you limit the Bojinka evidence at the trial?"... "Did you know about Col. Mendoza's revelations?"...

Snell always responded, "That's classified." Or "I can't discuss that."

Once again, those aren't acceptable answers.

Day of 9/11:

- "...at least two workers of Odigo, as Israeli-owned instant messaging company...received warnings about the impending attack two hours before the first plane hits the North Tower...Who gave these employees prior warnings of the attacks and how did they know what was about to transpire?"

- "How is it that the FAA was able to track AA 11 all the way into the WTC, but NEADS, with its sophisticated radar, couldn't locate the plane?"

- "Why does the Secretary of Defense apparently remain so far out of the loop during he worst attack against the US homeland in history? How could the acting chairman of the Joint Chiefs remain behind closed doors on Capitol Hill...?

- "Why is there a discrepancy of three minutes and five seconds in the flight's [Flight 93] official crash time and the army's seismic records?"

etc..etc...etc...

Going beyond Peter Lance, I would require NIST to test their hypothesis in regards to the destruction of WTC1 and 2. Is the "crush-down" and "crush-up" hypothesis really valid? Can the inward bowing of the perimeter columns lead to the effects we observed on 9/11? The believers in NIST science can use their methods to demolish a steel-frame high-rise with impact damage and fire. The 9/11 Truth members are allowed to hire the top demolition experts to attempt to destroy a steel-frame high-rise from the top down. The result that comes the closest to mirroring the destruction on 9/11 would be accepted as the most reliable hypothesis. If the hypothesis of the 9/11 Truth Movement comes out on top, then a criminal investigation would need to begin into who destroyed the towers.

The neo-con conspiracy theories regarding Iraq have ended up costing us about 2 billion dollars a week. As well, it has lead to the deaths of ten of thousands of people and millions of refugees. I can assert that a new 9/11 investigation will be less expensive and less deadly.
 
truthers are more then welcome to reinvestigate 9-11. using their own money, their own experts, their own labs, their own resources.

..that will be the day.
 
Originally Posted by bill smith
It's time for somebody to start a new thread on the composition of a new 9/11 enquiry. That will be a very difficult task and he debate should start now.

Yes, it is time indeed. Let's have it Bill.

Better late than never.
 
Here is my guess as to whom the truthers would want on such a commission/committee.

Chair - Ron Paul
Vice Chair - Cythia McKinney
Members:
David Ray Griffin
Steven Jones
Morgan Reynolds
Robert Bowman
Guy Razer
Chief Waka Waka Woo
That Goth Guy at the Gap

TAM;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom