[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

Himmler’s first interview with an American journalist.
http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v18/v18n5p50_Stoddard.html
You ideas are pathetic, so the Jews area was the crematoria! . You are just a NAZI with idiot ideas like most NAZIs. You pass on NAZI junk without understanding anything. Pathetic NAZIs like you are too busy labeling everyone else a subhuman, and you missed you are the only ones who qualify.
 
As a second generation Japanese-American, I just want to note that the Japanese Internment camps in the Western US were not the same as the Nazi concentration camps.

Yes, they were terrible, but there is no good comparison between the two.

That is only so because we are told that Jews were gassed in gas chambers and shoved into ovens which is what is being disputed.

Well I like to know then what really happened in the the US. Were they not forced into labor and such as was the case in Germany?
 
The Holocaust is debated precisely because of the weight of the subject and it's massive consequences.

The Holocaust is "debated" becasue certain people know that if they admit it happened it would be an admission that Jews were victims.
 
Yet another display of your ignorance. Those captured by the allies faired much better than those cpatured by the aixs. To try and imply otherwise is dishonest to the extreme.

Well maybe some sources and critical analysis might shed some light. You don't hear much about this growing up in the States.
 
That is only so because we are told that Jews were gassed in gas chambers and shoved into ovens which is what is being disputed.


Not just told, there was a great deal of physical evidence as well (personal jewelery, etc.)

Well I like to know then what really happened in the the US. Were they not forced into labor and such as was the case in Germany?


No, they most certainly weren't forced into labor. The worst punishment they faced was the loss of US citizenship (which is actually highly unconstitutional and was the basis for the reparation trials). You seem to be confusing the Japanese internment camps in the USA with the Japanese labor camps set up by the Japanese soldiers in Korea, China, and the Phillipines. I am having very strong doubts that you are Japanese as you claim.
 
Well maybe some sources and critical analysis might shed some light. You don't hear much about this growing up in the States.

If that is the case then I guess whatever school district you were in failed you.

If you really need "sources" it tells me that you would not believe those sources anyway.
 
I thought British servicemen were treated fairly well in the POW camps. At least they were not keep out in the open as Eisenhower did with the German prisoners he held at the end of the war.

See Other Losses by James Bacque.

Other Losses

Central claims

Americans killed over 1,000,000 POWs (false)
Americans treated POWs poorly (true)
Americans treated POWs worse than the Germans (false)
Food shortages were faked to justify underfeeding prisoners (false)
Eisenhower led the campaign to mistreat POWs (false)

Another book by a non-historian. His premise was interesting enough to invoke an all out study. The stir was brief when his research turned out to be incredibly bad. The one point about American treatment of POWs is largely valid, if hideously exagerated in combination with the rest of his claims.
 
I thought British servicemen were treated fairly well in the POW camps. At least they were not keep out in the open as Eisenhower did with the German prisoners he held at the end of the war.

See Other Losses by James Bacque.

Could you please back that last statement up.
 
The Holocaust is "debated" becasue certain people know that if they admit it happened it would be an admission that Jews were victims.

I admit that the holocaust happened.

I admit Jews were a major if not the major victim.

I debate the total number hideously murdered.

What does that make me?
 
Other Losses

Central claims

Americans killed over 1,000,000 POWs (false)
Americans treated POWs poorly (true)
Americans treated POWs worse than the Germans (false)
Food shortages were faked to justify underfeeding prisoners (false)
Eisenhower led the campaign to mistreat POWs (false)

Another book by a non-historian. His premise was interesting enough to invoke an all out study. The stir was brief when his research turned out to be incredibly bad. The one point about American treatment of POWs is largely valid, if hideously exagerated in combination with the rest of his claims.

Sources please.
 
You seem to be confusing the Japanese internment camps in the USA with the Japanese labor camps set up by the Japanese soldiers in Korea, China, and the Phillipines. I am having very strong doubts that you are Japanese as you claim.

His thinking here would be consistent with Japanese propaganda. It is typical for any tribe to accentuate the malice committed against the tribe and to downplay the crime the tribe has committed.
 
Gravy, when you say the Germans were systematically killing the civilian population what exactly do you mean and why would they do this? Are the Germans killing Poles on sight? Why would they do this? What would be accomplished by killing Polish civilians?

Just asking questions.


The one these questions should have been addressed to is the Fuhrer. What answers did he give when these questions were raised at his war trial?

Oh, there was no trial, because he was already dead.

Well, then, what did the soldier who killed him report? Did he have any last words?

Oh, wait, no soldier killed him. Because he shot himself in the mouth.

Which, it appears, left his Thousand Year Reich rather in the lurch. No defiant statement to inspire his future admirers. No recommendations for how to do it right the next time. When you shoot yourself in the mouth it demonstrates rather graphically that you have nothing to say.

But, cowards do tend to disappoint. Sorry, fans.

(Somewere, in some munitions factory in early 1945, some starving shivering slave laborer inspected the bullets he'd helped to make, coming off the line, and saw, among uncounted thousands of others, the one that would tear Hitler's brain to shreds. I like to think, and I know this is pure wishful whimsy, that the slave took special note of that bullet, somehow recognized where it was bound, perhaps touched it, and that a little bit of a feeling of relief, a hint of a long-forgotten peace of mind, lightened his despair and anger over the mindless waste and futility.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
I admit that the holocaust happened.

I admit Jews were a major if not the major victim.

I debate the total number hideously murdered.

What does that make me?

A different thing, depending if you're trying to debate it down from 6 million to 5 million, or from 6 million to "hardly any, really".
 
His thinking here would be consistent with Japanese propaganda. It is typical for any tribe to accentuate the malice committed against the tribe and to downplay the crime the tribe has committed.


Japanese propaganda in the '40's? Yes. In 2007? No. They fully realize the atrocities committed by the Japanese forces overseas. Visit the museum in Hiroshima for a good example of Japan admitting to their war-time crimes. Although there is a group of pro-military/war-crime denial types in Japanese politics, their standard school curriculum does not gloss over what happened in the three countries I mentioned.

Have you ever been to Japan?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom