[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

No one denies there were camps-- just as America had camps containing Japanese, German-Americans, and Italian-Americans-- but they weren't "death camps." Many people died in the camps from typhus and malnutrition, especially as Germany collapsed at the end of the war. But most of those who died were not Jews, and they were not intentionally killed.

Many of the accounts of the camps are true. But the accounts of people being sent to gas chambers are lies.

There were mass burials, and cadaverous prisoners. But no exterminations of Jews or anyone else.

No doubt there were atrocities, but not exterminations. As we have seen, the atrocities were committed by all sides of the conflict.
You are full of crap on this topic. Half right does not hack it. Too bad my father was there to see the camps. Darn, you are wrong about this and 9/11. You are just another neoNAZI who can not get the Holocaust correct. Too bad for you.
 
You have been given several major works and the names of some of the finest war historians and you fight back with Wikipedia? Ok, this kid is a lost cause, I'm moving on.
 
I've changed it to "Germans," which is what I meant to say.

No you didn't. You said what you meant.

You know what galls me particularly? Your apparent belief that no one here will have heard of Katyn. Maybe many or most, here, have not; I couldn't say; but I sure was not going to raise this issue without knowing a lot about it.

Again, I say: go to Poland. Or for that matter, go to a Polish-American group here in the States or Canada. Propound your viewpoint. I await the results with eager anticipation. (Is that redundant?)

And I'm still waiting for some Polish or other Slavic-language sources from you. Any sources. Or time's up.
 
Last edited:
Millions of Jews were deported by the nazi's. Men, women and children.
They weren't there at the end of the war.

All the sophistry in the world can't change that fact.

Like many Jews I heard testimonies of survivors in my family about the extermination camps. Did my grandmother lie to me? Did my great-aunt lie to me? Did they invent a story just for me? A story confirmed by almost ALL HISTORIANS?

Some people are so filled with prejudice that they can't accept reality. They can't even accept the reality of the death of one Israeli in flight 11. Let alone the death of millions of innocent Jews, killed by the nazi cowards.

Sad ...
 
Swingie

Would you take this mans word for it?

Oskar Groening?

bigots and racists are the most ignorant trash on this planet
 
I got it from reading just a few books on the subject. How many have you read? The entire myth is comprehensively demolished by an engineering professor who still teaches at Northwestern University named Arthur Butz, in his 1974 book, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century: The Case Against the Presumed Extermination of European Jewry.

Another book I read was The Giant With Feet of Clay, by Jurgen Graf.

Why don't you challenge yourself? Go to the Amazon Books link to Butz's book I provided above. I realize not everyone has the time to purchase and read through a 400 page book; but just scroll down and read through the "Customer Reviews" at the bottom of the page. The majority are on your side of the argument, but compare the quality of those who support Butz, as opposed to those who attack him.

If nothing else, you'll realize that MAGZ and I are not the only ones who have learned the truth regarding this Gigantic Lie.

So you read two books written by two Holocaust deniers and that's all the evidence you need? Seems to me you didn't need to read those books at all. Your mind was already twisted by hate.
 
Many people died in the camps from typhus and malnutrition, especially as Germany collapsed at the end of the war. But most of those who died were not Jews, and they were not intentionally killed.

QUOTE]

Why were they in those camps to begin with?
 
A Train. I tend to keep out of the details of Holocaust denial, because to do otherwise is to lend them space they do not merit. However are you aware that David Irving went to court, and lost, on this very subject? He was (if I recall correctly) bankrupted. His evidence to the courts was set at naught by the jury.

Incidentally I share the ire of previous correspondents regarding your apparent belief that we would be unfamiliar with Katyn.
 
A Train. I tend to keep out of the details of Holocaust denial, because to do otherwise is to lend them space they do not merit. However are you aware that David Irving went to court, and lost, on this very subject? He was (if I recall correctly) bankrupted. His evidence to the courts was set at naught by the jury.

Nope. No jury, just a judge. See:

The Case for Auschwitz by Robert Jan van Pelt

History on Trial by Deborah Lipstadt

Lying About Hitler by Richard J. Evans

Or, if you want the academic versions go to:

h t t p : / / w w w . h d o t . o r g / t r i a l / d e f e n s e # e x p e r t

after removing spaces, that is.
 
I think that the world-view of the deniers is like an inverted story by Lovecraft:

Lovecraft: The protagonists doesn't know very much about the elders. Only bits and pieces, hints and glimpses.
Deniers: The protagonists know everything about the jews and their lies.

Lovecraft: The elders are just collections of atoms that beacuse of some cosmic coincidence has powers far beyond that of a human.
Deniers: The jews are just ordinary humans whose powers stems from slyness, organization, elbow grease and money, money, money.

Lovecraft: The elders doesn't really care about humans.
Deniers: The jews target #1 is the deniers.

Lovecraft: If a human is goes insane, it's beacuse human minds are to limited to fathom the powers of the elders. If a human is killed, it's beacuse the human annoyed the elders like a fly annoys a human.
Deniers: The jews might have the power to pull of a hoax like this, but then will only harass me. That's beacuse I'm more dangerous to them dead than alive.
 
Last edited:
A-Train, you may think that the Holocaust did not occur, but what about the expulsion of jews from germany? did that happen? do you think it was justified?

I thought the National Socialists let the Jews leave Germany in the 1930's. Why would they let the Jews leave if they wanted to kill all of them?
 
When I was 5-6, I was flying out to LA with Dad and the was a guy sitting next to us. I noticed that he had an odd tattoo. I asked him why he just had a number for a tattoo. After Dad cuffed me on the head and the man said it was ok, they explained what that number meant. (Short version.) I could wrap my head around how someone could do what they claimed happened. I got older and smarter. I see some haven't.

Why would those who ran the camps bother to tattoo the inmates if the plan was to kill them?
 
I thought the National Socialists let the Jews leave Germany in the 1930's. Why would they let the Jews leave if they wanted to kill all of them?
The nazis wanted a final solution, right? But final solution-1936 differs from final solution-1942. The murdering started for real *after* Stalingrad. The war was practically lost, and they wasted precios resources on murdering totally harmless people. Irrational? Of course it's irrational!
Why would those who ran the camps bother to tattoo the inmates if the plan was to kill them?
Didn't murder everyone at once.

Smartypants are smart.
 
Yoo hoo, Atrain and Magz. Could you please respond to my questions? They were not meant rhetorically. I have always been puzzled by the failure of the deniers/ apologists to use sources in Polish, Russian, and other languages outside of German and English. (And, occasionally, French.) Note that I am not asking necessarily about sources in Yiddish or Hebrew or Ladino, or necessarily sources by Jews.

If you say "no one knows Polish, Russian, etc., so it doesn't matter," I am going to get surly. There are nowadays approx 40 mln native speakers of Polish, 150 mln native speakers of Russian, 50 mln native speakers of Ukrainian... Oh, I could go on.

What exactly are you asking me? If non-Jews were gassed?

I do not believe anyone was ever killed in any so called "gas chambers" The "gas chambers" were used for delousing prisoners and clothing. When the prisoners arrived at the camps they were told to disrobe and go into the gas chambers to kill the lice.

The only book worth reading on the "Holocaust" is The Hoax of the Twentieth Century by Butz.
 
I do not believe anyone was ever killed in any so called "gas chambers" The "gas chambers" were used for delousing prisoners and clothing. When the prisoners arrived at the camps they were told to disrobe and go into the gas chambers to kill the lice.

:eye-poppi
 
The only book worth reading on the "Holocaust" is The Hoax of the Twentieth Century by Butz.

The amount of evidence that the holocaust was real is ASTOUNDING. If you think that little joke of a book somehow trumps this evidence then you are delusional.

Delusional people don't know they're delusional, so I'm sure you can rationalize ignoring the evidence. Rational people, however, are flabbergasted at your beliefs.

Trust me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom