[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

In response to my assertion that "Some of the evidence makes sense" Spitfire answered
No, it doesn't.
I think Spit is equating "the evidence is true" and "the evidence makes sense". I interpreted "make sense" to mean "compelling enough to demand a closer look", because otherwise the original question is a little weird. I think that it's not so trivial or stupid that it can be completely dismissed out of hand, without research.

I also think that SpitfireIX was presuming that I've reseached a certain conclusion here, because I was repeating some of the oft-cited arguments. Hence his constant urging me to visit some website to re-educate myself on the matter.

Just because I repeated them, doesn't mean I believe them. I was repeating them because that's exactly what the original poster asked for. If you recall, the question that kicked this thread off was What are some of the common "evidence" for this conspiracy-theory?
 
Last edited:
Combine this with the fact that there are such easier ways to kill people than by gas chamber. If you really wanted to kill a million people, gas chambers would be one of the stupidest ways to do it. Why not just lead them into a deep mine, then close it off? Or just good old fashioned bullets. Or inject each one individually with a poison via hypodermic needle? The list goes on and on.
Easier and more reliable, absolutley. But the chambers for mass gassing didn't fall from the skies. The nazis tried at first to shoot, hang and club jews to death en masse. But took to great a toll on the killers (shooting squads getting all hammered in order to cope with the job was too big a problem.)

One often overlooked thing is the T4-program where "aryan" handicapped was gassed to death. In the end, they could as well been stabbed to death. But since the T4 was run by white collar doctors, not soldiers in muddy BDUs, gassing seems like a "clinical" solution.

The chambers for mass gassing is the solution to the problem of maximum efficiency + minimum psychological stress for the killers. It was such a efficient solution that it was easier to ship jews and other undesirables by rail all over Europe.

And you could theoretically use a dilapidated outhouse as a gas chamber. As long as the influx of gas is big enough to maintain a lethal concentration for long enough time. (If the deniers is right, then you don't have to mind the ventilation when using paint thinner, since it's less lethal than HCN and your home is not hermetically sealed when all doors and windows are closed.)

So the gas chambers for executions of single individuals are just a red herring. You don't really have to use something that looks like a beached submarine in order to gas someone. It's just show and tell in order to numb the pangs of guilt among the people. (We have sentenced one person to death, but at least we kill him in a proper way.)
 
Last edited:
I've said this elsewhere, but again: there are tons of witness testimonies from Poles, Russian, Ukrainians, etc. The deniers ignore this, or more likely are intentionally ignorant because, per Nazi Germany, the Poles (etc.) were barely better than the Jews.

Some decades ago -- I don't recall details, it was in or near Chicago -- American Nazis set up in a Slavic-immigrant-populated neighborhood, because they bought into the idea that Poles (etc.) are automatic anti-Semites. Well, one problem they encountered was that many of the locals and their relations had vivid memories of the Nazi brutality against Slavs as well as Jews. It didn't work out. (I ought to look that up for details... Not Skokie...)
 
. . . I think Spit is equating "the evidence is true" and "the evidence makes sense". I interpreted "make sense" to mean "compelling enough to demand a closer look", because otherwise the original question is a little weird. I think that it's not so trivial or stupid that it can be completely dismissed out of hand, without research.


Most or all of your claimed "evidence" is simply specious denier factoids, and/or consists of argument from incredulity. These in no way constitute real evidence.

I also think that SpitfireIX was presuming that I've reseached a certain conclusion here, because I was repeating some of the oft-cited arguments.


I think you're wrong about what I was presuming, and I think I have reason to know. What I presume is that your description of the so-called "evidence" belies a tremendous ignorance of both the Holocaust and Holocaust denial.


Hence his constant urging me to visit some website to re-educate myself on the matter.


Fixed that for you.

Just because I repeated them, doesn't mean I believe them. I was repeating them because that's exactly what the original poster asked for. If you recall, the question that kicked this thread off was What are some of the common "evidence" for this conspiracy-theory?


The problem is, applying common sense to most of your purported "evidence" should lead one to realize that it's not the least bit compelling--such as the claim that sealing prisoners in abandoned mines is more efficient than gassing them. And, just for the record, I've never seen any deniers claim that gas is particularly inefficient, though I suppose it's possible that some have.

As for "experts" claiming the gas chambers couldn't have worked as advertised, I imagine that someone reading Fred Leuchter's report might be taken in initially, but 10 minutes' research should be enough to discover that Leuchter is a charlatan and a fraud. Again, however, the only way that one could find this "compelling" is if one simply accepted the claim at face value, without bothering to investigate.
 
Gas Chambers

The single most compelling piece of argument that makes me doubt that the holocaust story is 100% true is that it simply is not easy to kill people with poison gas. Gas chambers are devilishly hard to make work right, especially if the safety of the non-victims (e.g. the nazi guards) is any kind of priority. What we see in Germany today does not appear to me to be a valid design for gas chamber. I'm no expert in gas chambers, but the few experts who have reviewed the Nazi setup are at a loss to how it could actually have worked as claimed.

The main, important point is that it doesn't matter exactly how the Jews died, or which element of the Nazi regime killed them.

What is an undeniable, 100% fact is that wherever the German army went, they rounded up Jews. This was the common experience of all the occupied countries. Some countries had more Jews than others, and some had more Jews survive than others.

This operation required huge resources. It was a central part of German administration of those occupied countries. It simply could not have happened without central directives from the Nazi government, and the active cooperation of huge numbers of ordinary Germans. It also required cooperation from civilians in the occupied territories.

Given that, to quibble about the details of how the Jews were disposed of might be an interesting historical detail, but it has no bearing on whether the Nazis were carrying out genocide. It's impossible to look at their actions in any other way.

If the Germans had been running work camps, and if they had been using slave labour, then there would have been far, far more survivors returning after the war. The numbers would have been comparable to, say, the number of French workers in German factories.
 
Will you then agree with me that Hogan's Heros was Jew propaganda?

Obviously any TV program featuring Jewish actors is Jewish propaganda, scripted and directed by the Central Council Of Elders. What else could it be?
 
the house is genuine

the photos and other evidence in the house is genuine

the dutch who hid the jews from the nazis are genuine

have you been to her house?

i have

its fake?, usual slopey shoulder nonsense

Say that the diary was fake, and that no such person ever existed.

So, did Jews in occupied Holland hide from the Nazis? Why did they do that?

Were Jews in occupied Holland rounded up and taken away? Did they come back? What happened to them?
 
Jews in Hollywood have been making holocaust films

Look at how many decades the Jews in Hollywood have been making holocaust films. When will you guys wise up? Hollywood is a propaganda factory run by the Jews.

I've been watching war films for many, many years. How many Hollywood films have shown a death camp? How many war films even have the word "Jew" in them?

There's a good reason for this. The people who make films are trying to make money, and the Holocaust is a bit of a downer. Tanks and planes are fun, even with associated death and mutilation - gas chambers are not.

But in Magz' "mind", Hollywood has been making Holocaust films since the war. He see's the world through Jew-coloured glasses. If Ben Stiller is a star, the only explanation is a massive conspiracy by the Elders of Zion.
 
It is easy however to fetishise technology and see that as a necessary condition; Rwanda almost disabuses us of that illusion, except for the fact that the machetes were mass-manufactured and imported from overseas, i.e. planning was needed.

In Rwanda, radio was the means of coordinating the genocide, IIRC.
 
The main, important point is that it doesn't matter exactly how the Jews died, or which element of the Nazi regime killed them.

What is an undeniable, 100% fact is that wherever the German army went, they rounded up Jews. This was the common experience of all the occupied countries. Some countries had more Jews than others, and some had more Jews survive than others.

This operation required huge resources. It was a central part of German administration of those occupied countries. It simply could not have happened without central directives from the Nazi government, and the active cooperation of huge numbers of ordinary Germans. It also required cooperation from civilians in the occupied territories.

Given that, to quibble about the details of how the Jews were disposed of might be an interesting historical detail, but it has no bearing on whether the Nazis were carrying out genocide. It's impossible to look at their actions in any other way.

The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!
 
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!
Except for all of it that you ignore, distort or deny.
Other than that, there's none.
 
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!


1706046ea08bbc0453.jpg
 
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

No, "some" Jews weren't rounded up, due to their activities. All Jews were rounded up. The reason that one tends to blame the Germans for the fact that after being rounded up, they disappeared, is in the absence of any other possible explanation.

In many French schools, they have plaques listing, by name, the children rounded up by the Nazis. In an exhibition in Prague, I saw drawings done by the children sent to concentration camps. It isn't made clear whether the children were arrested for political or military activities.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!

There's no arguing with that statement.
 
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!

Wannsee Conference.

http://www.ghwk.de/ghwk/engl/kopfengl.htm
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!

This is an honest question. Where did you learn this? Did you get this from home or on your own?
 
First, a caveat of sorts. I am well aware that it is impossible to argue with the likes of A (Train) and M(agz). To them, Jews are the source of evil, and 1/ nothing happened to them in WW2, and 2/ they (Jews) deserved what they got.

But let's shift the focus a moment. Scholars recognize that the mass killings of civilians in the war were by no means directly exclusively against the Jews. The best estimates remain that close to 6 mln Jewish civilians were killed. (Obviously, I leave out battlefield deaths; probably up to 2 mln Jews served in the various armed forces, particularly the Soviet, American, British+Commonwealth, and Polish -- and since these made up the 4 largest Allied contingents [Yes, Poland = 4th, and had many Jewish soldiers, under British leadership as well as in Poland at the start of the war], that pretty well covers it.)

Right. Anyhow, the estimates I've heard for non-Jewish civilian deaths in occupied Europe outside the USSR are 5-6 mln as well, especially heavy in Poland and Yugoslavia. Let's focus on Poland alone; perhaps 2 mln civilian dead Christian Poles. They died by gassing, shooting, other methods of execution, starvation, disease, and so on. About 100,000 were killed in Auschwitz. Very well documented; "books of the dead" have been published in Polish and German. (Oh yeah, how about the huge and monstrous WW2 archives now opening up?)

So let's hear it, A and M: is this side of the holocaust real? And how about the Roma/ Gypsies? Best estimates are about 500,000 killed by the Germans and their allies and subjects. Let's hear it, boys. Well? Is it only Jews whom you accuse of faking it, or are Poles/ other Slavs (and so on and so forth) also faking it?
 
Last edited:
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!


Please, visit Europe. Soon.

Feel free to say this in several countries, preferrably very loudly in public places or perhaps in print.

In some you'll just get arrested, spend a few months in jail, and then be deported. In others you'll get the living daylights kicked out of you by the descendants of the survivors.

Ironically, I bet they'd deny it ever happening and tell you that there is no evidence that they touched you.....
 
A-Train, you may think that the Holocaust did not occur, but what about the expulsion of jews from germany? did that happen? do you think it was justified?
 
Please, visit Europe. Soon.

Feel free to say this in several countries, preferrably very loudly in public places or perhaps in print.

In some you'll just get arrested, spend a few months in jail, and then be deported. In others you'll get the living daylights kicked out of you by the descendants of the survivors.

Ironically, I bet they'd deny it ever happening and tell you that there is no evidence that they touched you.....
Too bad that it's illegal in some countries to be a denier. A trial gives the deniers a stage for their antics (remember Zündels infamous construction workers hard hat?) and jailed gives them a shot at martyrdom. But being ostracized as the idiot whos idiocy is on par with claims that gold and poop is the same or that 1+1=(-513)? No martyrdom at all. Not even in getting your ass kicked, as there always the reasonable doubt that you got your ass kicked beacuse you was a drunk bastard feeling up the women of some local biker gang.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom