[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

When I was 5-6, I was flying out to LA with Dad and the was a guy sitting next to us. I noticed that he had an odd tattoo. I asked him why he just had a number for a tattoo. After Dad cuffed me on the head and the man said it was ok, they explained what that number meant. (Short version.) I could wrap my head around how someone could do what they claimed happened. I got older and smarter. I see some haven't.
 
Too bad that it's illegal in some countries to be a denier. A trial gives the deniers a stage for their antics (remember Zündels infamous construction workers hard hat?) and jailed gives them a shot at martyrdom. But being ostracized as the idiot whos idiocy is on par with claims that gold and poop is the same or that 1+1=(-513)? No martyrdom at all. Not even in getting your ass kicked, as there always the reasonable doubt that you got your ass kicked beacuse you was a drunk bastard feeling up the women of some local biker gang.

Jail might give them a shot at martyrdom within their little community. However jail is still jail. And it can be especially unpleasant if your cellmate takes a dislike to you. Or a liking to you.;)
 
Jail might give them a shot at martyrdom within their little community. However jail is still jail. And it can be especially unpleasant if your cellmate takes a dislike to you. Or a liking to you.;)
Yes, but social ostracism is a far better punishment. If someone at some academic institution churns out crap like poop=gold or 1+1=(-513), the idiot will be kicked out. Compare with a boycot. If you has been treated badly at a restaurant, not visiting it anymore and spreading a bad rumor will be more swift, harsh and remorseless than any trial. Remember that even if holocaust-denial is not be opinions per se, restricting freedom of thought was exaclty what Hitler did. Of coruse there's a difference between being punished for denying historical facts and punished for denying blatant lies. But we are better than the nazis, eh? (And you can be better than a nazi and still think that people like Faurisson represents the worst of humanity. Give me a honest and proud nazi any day, I'll say!)

And as far as I'm concerned, the only real crime that Germar Rudolf has commited is academic cheating (you know his sock puppet theatre featuring his *nyms.) And I'm not sure that it's a real crime.
 
Last edited:
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!


If you believe this, just try barking at the moon, it would be more convincing than your words.
 
That's what confuses me: the evidence of the holocaust is OVERWHELMING. I find the bias necessary to ignore that evidence fascinating.

No wonder A-Train believes 911 was an inside job perpetrated by the Jews. He's had a longer time to learn how to ignore evidence contrary to his opinion than just 6 years.
 
The fact that Jews may have been "rounded up" does not mean they were ultimately "disposed of." That some Jews may have been executed due to their individual activities as Bolsheviks, partisans, etc., does not mean that "the Jews" were exterminated as a group.

How does six million equals some?

There is no evidence that the Germans ever tried or wanted to exterminate Jews at any point during the Nazi regime!

Evidence that the NAZI's (not Germans!!!) did not want to exterminate the Jews?

A-Train, did you hit your head on your namesake?
 
Last edited:
Yoo hoo, Atrain and Magz

First, a caveat of sorts. I am well aware that it is impossible to argue with the likes of A (Train) and M(agz). To them, Jews are the source of evil, and 1/ nothing happened to them in WW2, and 2/ they (Jews) deserved what they got.

But let's shift the focus a moment. Scholars recognize that the mass killings of civilians in the war were by no means directly exclusively against the Jews. The best estimates remain that close to 6 mln Jewish civilians were killed. (Obviously, I leave out battlefield deaths; probably up to 2 mln Jews served in the various armed forces, particularly the Soviet, American, British+Commonwealth, and Polish -- and since these made up the 4 largest Allied contingents [Yes, Poland = 4th, and had many Jewish soldiers, under British leadership as well as in Poland at the start of the war], that pretty well covers it.)

Right. Anyhow, the estimates I've heard for non-Jewish civilian deaths in occupied Europe outside the USSR are 5-6 mln as well, especially heavy in Poland and Yugoslavia. Let's focus on Poland alone; perhaps 2 mln civilian dead Christian Poles. They died by gassing, shooting, other methods of execution, starvation, disease, and so on. About 100,000 were killed in Auschwitz. Very well documented; "books of the dead" have been published in Polish and German. (Oh yeah, how about the huge and monstrous WW2 archives now opening up?)

So let's hear it, A and M: is this side of the holocaust real? And how about the Roma/ Gypsies? Best estimates are about 500,000 killed by the Germans and their allies and subjects. Let's hear it, boys. Well? Is it only Jews whom you accuse of faking it, or are Poles/ other Slavs (and so on and so forth) also faking it?

Yoo hoo, Atrain and Magz. Could you please respond to my questions? They were not meant rhetorically. I have always been puzzled by the failure of the deniers/ apologists to use sources in Polish, Russian, and other languages outside of German and English. (And, occasionally, French.) Note that I am not asking necessarily about sources in Yiddish or Hebrew or Ladino, or necessarily sources by Jews.

If you say "no one knows Polish, Russian, etc., so it doesn't matter," I am going to get surly. There are nowadays approx 40 mln native speakers of Polish, 150 mln native speakers of Russian, 50 mln native speakers of Ukrainian... Oh, I could go on.
 
Last edited:
please respond to my questions?

Yoo hoo, Atrain and Magz. Could you please respond to my questions? They were not meant rhetorically.

It's been shown quite clearly, on this thread, that neither of them have the resources to carry out any kind of sensible discussion on this matter. Magz thinks that Hollywood keeps churning out Holocaust films. Atrain thinks that the Nazis weren't even anti-semitic. How can there be a discussion on that basis?

That's not to say that the thread is of no value. It's always the casual passer-by who needs to have things explained to them. There's a certain appeal in explaining away the Holocaust as just one of those things that happens when there's a war on, and it needs to be pointed out, without mitigating other horrific things that happened, what was unique about the Nazi racial exterminations.
 
The main, important point is that it doesn't matter exactly how the Jews died, or which element of the Nazi regime killed them.

What is an undeniable, 100% fact is that wherever the German army went, they rounded up Jews. This was the common experience of all the occupied countries. Some countries had more Jews than others, and some had more Jews survive than others.

This operation required huge resources. It was a central part of German administration of those occupied countries. It simply could not have happened without central directives from the Nazi government, and the active cooperation of huge numbers of ordinary Germans. It also required cooperation from civilians in the occupied territories.

Given that, to quibble about the details of how the Jews were disposed of might be an interesting historical detail, but it has no bearing on whether the Nazis were carrying out genocide. It's impossible to look at their actions in any other way.

If the Germans had been running work camps, and if they had been using slave labour, then there would have been far, far more survivors returning after the war. The numbers would have been comparable to, say, the number of French workers in German factories.


Not to mention, if one believes (like the Nazis did and folks like MaGZ do) that the jews are the greatest threat to "good" people that ever existed, and more concretely that they caused Germany to lose the previous war, then organizing and executing the Holocaust (or something very much like it) is the only logical way of action. After all, to virulent anti-semites such as them, history clearly shows that anything less throrough than genocide fails to stop the evil omni-present jewish conspiracy to dominate the world.
 
It's been shown quite clearly, on this thread, that neither of them have the resources to carry out any kind of sensible discussion on this matter. Magz thinks that Hollywood keeps churning out Holocaust films. Atrain thinks that the Nazis weren't even anti-semitic. How can there be a discussion on that basis?

That's not to say that the thread is of no value. It's always the casual passer-by who needs to have things explained to them. There's a certain appeal in explaining away the Holocaust as just one of those things that happens when there's a war on, and it needs to be pointed out, without mitigating other horrific things that happened, what was unique about the Nazi racial exterminations.

Yes, I understand. I just hope against hope to see a Holocaust denier/ revisionist address these sorts of questions. Fundamentally, they can't address them and maintain their illusions, of course. So it goes.

There is a limited amount of Holocaust denial in Polish anti-semitic circles; but I think it's 1/ against the law, and 2/ a fact that much of the killing took place on Polish soil, and too many people saw too much and have said too much since.

(And if anyone asks why most of the killing took place on Polish soil: a/ the Nazis didn't want to do it in Germany, b/ Poland in 1939 had the largest Jewish population in Europe, c/ it was centrally located in Europe + Soviet Union as a whole, with a good train network).
 
Yes, I understand. I just hope against hope to see a Holocaust denier/ revisionist address these sorts of questions. Fundamentally, they can't address them and maintain their illusions, of course. So it goes.

There is a limited amount of Holocaust denial in Polish anti-semitic circles; but I think it's 1/ against the law, and 2/ a fact that much of the killing took place on Polish soil, and too many people saw too much and have said too much since.

(And if anyone asks why most of the killing took place on Polish soil: a/ the Nazis didn't want to do it in Germany, b/ Poland in 1939 had the largest Jewish population in Europe, c/ it was centrally located in Europe + Soviet Union as a whole, with a good train network).


It's also worth noting that the German Jewish population was quite small by beginning of the war. They had been forced out in systematic campaigns by the Nazis, and this is where the shame of some western nations come in. My own beloved Canada had a anti-semetic pinhead in charge of immigration who prevented any influx of Jews in the pre-war period.

Now this can't be true because according to these two, the Germans had no anti-Jewish policy. And my Leafs will win the Stanley cup this year, two delusions are better than one.
 
This is an honest question. Where did you learn this? Did you get this from home or on your own?

I got it from reading just a few books on the subject. How many have you read? The entire myth is comprehensively demolished by an engineering professor who still teaches at Northwestern University named Arthur Butz, in his 1974 book, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century: The Case Against the Presumed Extermination of European Jewry.

Another book I read was The Giant With Feet of Clay, by Jurgen Graf.

Why don't you challenge yourself? Go to the Amazon Books link to Butz's book I provided above. I realize not everyone has the time to purchase and read through a 400 page book; but just scroll down and read through the "Customer Reviews" at the bottom of the page. The majority are on your side of the argument, but compare the quality of those who support Butz, as opposed to those who attack him.

If nothing else, you'll realize that MAGZ and I are not the only ones who have learned the truth regarding this Gigantic Lie.
 
I got it from reading just a few books on the subject. How many have you read? The entire myth is comprehensively demolished by an engineering professor who still teaches at Northwestern University named Arthur Butz, in his 1974 book, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century: The Case Against the Presumed Extermination of European Jewry.

Another book I read was The Giant With Feet of Clay, by Jurgen Graf.

Why don't you challenge yourself? Go to the Amazon Books link to Butz's book I provided above. I realize not everyone has the time to purchase and read through a 400 page book; but just scroll down and read through the "Customer Reviews" at the bottom of the page. The majority are on your side of the argument, but compare the quality of those who support Butz, as opposed to those who attack him.

If nothing else, you'll realize that MAGZ and I are not the only ones who have learned the truth regarding this Gigantic Lie.

Hey Champ! How about addressing my questions, above!
 
... Let's focus on Poland alone; perhaps 2 mln civilian dead Christian Poles. They died by gassing, shooting, other methods of execution, starvation, disease, and so on. About 100,000 were killed in Auschwitz. Very well documented; "books of the dead" have been published in Polish and German. (Oh yeah, how about the huge and monstrous WW2 archives now opening up?)

Yes, let's talk about Poland. I've never studied the subject, but I have no doubt that many Polish Christians were murdered during the war. But are you sure it was the Nazis who did it, and not the Soviet-Bolsheviks, who then passed along the blame on to defenseless Germans after the war?

Let's look at one particular incident involving the mass murder of between 15 and 22 thousand Polish officers. Since I know you don't trust any references from "Anti-semites," let's just refer to a source we all generally trust, Wikipedia.

"Katyn Massacre"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre

To summarize what happened, the Soviets imprisoned thousands of Polish Army officers after invading Poland in 1939. After interrogating them to find which ones were most resistant to Communist rule, thousands of them were shipped to the Katyn forest in the western USSR, where, on orders from Stalin, they were executed en masse with bullets to the head, and their bodies laid in a mass grave. (Anyone who has studied the history of the USSR will recognize this as only an extension of typical Judeo-Bolshevik behavior throughout the USSR.)

When the Germans overran the Soviet Union in 1941, they discovered the bodies, and showed them to the world. (In his book, Butz notes that this episode shows how difficult it is to hide large numbers of corpses. The Soviets couldn't hide 20,000, but the Nazis made 6 million disappear?) Soviet guilt was obvious, but Churchill promised Stalin to block any investigations.

When the Red Army retook the territory, they naturally began an effort to blame the atrocity on the Nazis. Goebbels wrote this in his diary:
"Unfortunately we have had to give up Katyn. The Bolsheviks undoubtedly will soon 'find' that we shot 12,000 Polish officers. That episode is one that is going to cause us quite a little trouble in the future. The Soviets are undoubtedly going to make it their business to discover as many mass graves as possible and then blame it on us."
And of course that's exactly what they did, with American help of course. After the war, ten officers of the German Wehrmacht were tried in Leningrad for the crime; seven of them were hung that day for their "crime." The American President Roosevelt did his part by stifling reports showing Soviet guilt:

"In 1944 Roosevelt assigned Navy Lieutenant Commander George Earle, his special emissary to the Balkans, to compile information on Katyn, which he did using contacts in Bulgaria and Romania. He concluded that the Soviet Union had committed the massacre. After consulting with Elmer Davis, the director of the Office of War Information, Roosevelt rejected that conclusion, saying that he was convinced of Nazi Germany's responsibility, and ordered Earle's report suppressed. When Earle formally requested permission to publish his findings, the President gave him a written order to desist. Earle was reassigned and spent the rest of the war in American Samoa."
The whole episode is shocking, but it is a microcosm of what was going on in Europe after the war, when the Holocaust Legend was being born. When you start to understand that these kinds of things could be happening right under the noses of the American military presence, then you are on the road to understanding how a propaganda hoax of millions of Jews being gassed could have ultimately been rammed down all of our throats. You are also on the path to understanding what really happened on 9/11.

So, to sum up SDC, I have no doubt that thousands of Christian Poles were murdered. But I consider it far more likely they were killed by the same people who did the Katyn Massacre than by the Germans.
 
Last edited:
So according to this concept all the death camp photos are fakes or are misinterpreted. All the accounts given by victims and eyewitnesses are false. Photos of mass burials and cadaverous prisoners on the verge of collapse aren't Jews? The attempted escapes from death camps are fiction? The graphic descriptions of atrocities callously inflicted are imaginary? Why would someone believe this type of thing?

Wait a minute! I just read the post asbove which partially answers my question. There is actually no denial that these things happened. The denial is that the Germans were not the ones doing it. Well, that's an a completely different scenario.
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm glad that A-Train finally opened my eyes to the truth. Auschwitz was just a day spa for the Jews. Bergen-Belsen was a fitness center and halfway-house for wayward teens. All the bodies? Those were Nazis who selflessly gave their lives for the betterment of the Jews. And what thanks do they get? Having to take the blame for the disappearance of 6 million Jews. Hey, they just took off for Samoa after the war, they didn't die! It's true, just read up on it! These books will open your eyes, yessir, no doubt about it!
But only after your self-administered lobotomy. There are helpful instructions on how to do this in chapter 7; "Brain Surgery with Common Kitchen Utensils".
 
So according to this concept all the death camp photos are fakes or are misinterpreted. All the accounts given by victims and eyewitnesses are false. Photos of mass burials and cadaverous prisoners on the verge of collapse aren't Jews? The attempted escapes from death camps are fiction? The graphic descriptions of atrocities callously inflicted are imaginary? Why would someone believe this type of thing?

No one denies there were camps-- just as America had camps containing Japanese, German-Americans, and Italian-Americans-- but they weren't "death camps." Many people died in the camps from typhus and malnutrition, especially as Germany collapsed at the end of the war. But most of those who died were not Jews, and they were not intentionally killed.

Many of the accounts of the camps are true. But the accounts of people being sent to gas chambers are lies.

There were mass burials, and cadaverous prisoners. But no exterminations of Jews or anyone else.

No doubt there were atrocities, but not exterminations. As we have seen, the atrocities were committed by all sides of the conflict.
 
... then you are on the road to understanding how a propaganda hoax of millions of Jews being gassed could have ultimately been rammed down all of our throats. You are also on the path to understanding what really happened on 9/11.
...
NeoNAZIs make up stupid idiotic stuff. Why are NeoNAZIs total idiots, unable to think rationally or make correct conclusions on anything. Insane ideas on 9/11 must be like calling the Holocaust a hoax. Good job A-Train, you sound like a NeoNAZI
 
Yes, let's talk about Poland. I've never studied the subject, but I have no doubt that many Polish Christians were murdered during the war. But are you sure it was the Nazis who did it, and not the Soviet-Bolsheviks, who then passed along the blame on to defenseless Nazis after the war?

Cut down considerably by me.

Hoo hah. He speaks! By the way, I expect you to use sources other than Wikipedia. If you don't I will scoff and scorn your inability to use multiple sources.

Yes, Katyn. By the way, a large share of those particular Polish soldiers were reserve officers, including many professionals (i.e., lawyers, doctors), and guess what! Many were Jews. Yup. Sovs killed them. No doubt about it. And after the war (as during the war) the Sovs were pretty unkind to the Nazis. During the war, the Katyn revelations were a source of considerable strain among Western Allies (Churchill took the lead), Polish gov't-in-exile, and Sovs. Sure were.

So what the hell is your point? Outside of the basic Katyn facts, your statements about the innocent Germans and the uniquely-evil Sovs are lies, and well known in the scholarly world and among anyone else who looks into it. My advice to you is to travel to Poland and make some speeches. I want to read about the responses of the locals. What they think of the "innocent Germans" of WW2.

Lo, the "defenseless Nazis." That is a wonderful phrase, which I really, really doubt they would thank you for.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom