[Moderated]The Holocaust never happened!

As to your earlier point.... I figured someone (and Tirdun did the job) would come up with the list of current owners of the "major studios". I've had a week of 13 and 14 hour days at work, and I can't link to MaGZie's sites from work. (A modern Germany company that won't let you view neo-nazi garbage... Go figure!)

Even that concept is outmoded. The "majors" act as distribution arms for the most part. In the 20s to 40s, they controlled the product, the talent, the theaters and the distribution. When I was working for Warner Brothers, I looked through some of the historical stuff (I was taking courses in film history and appreciation), and the big studios used to releast over a hundred films a year. If you look at the works of Bogie, Bette Davis, Gable, etc..., it's not uncommon to see them in 2 or 3 films a year. Nowadays, the distribution companies do 25 to 30 releases a year, and more than half of those are distribution deals that they've picked up some of the financing on, but which were produced by one or more other companies. (Thus the annoying four different production/distribution company names that you see in the opening credits now for all films.)

To MaGZ. No, you're not really imagining things! You're just reading hopelessly outdated material. The majors were definitely controlled by Jewish owners and producers through the years that they* were allowed, by law, to control the industry. It's not a secret, though. There have been many good books written on the subject by Jews and non-Jews. (Very few of the ones that made my library were dedicated to the Jews' desire to take over the world, though!)

In fact, here's an actual conspiracy for you..... And it's fairly provable by merely watching a few hundred movies. Find the "bad Jew" in a Hollywood movie from the 30s or 40s. There are close to none. By "bad Jew", I refer to characters who are identified as Jewish, not as someone you might assume to be Jewish by the actor in the role or by traits of the character. If a person is identified as Jewish as part of the plot, he or she is either "good", or merely incidental to the plot. Documented? No. It was never a written policy, and the people who promulgated it probably didn't realize they were doing so. But very real, nevertheless.

I plan to start a thread on the topic of Jews and Hollywood. I will title it "Jewish control of Hollywood?" I have been doing some research on the subject and sorry to say Gumboot did not do an honest review of those who call the shots in Hollywood.
 
Magz,

Could you give us some idea of when and how it was that you discovered that the Holocaust hadn't happened and that Jews were the root of everything bad in the world?

I'm curious to know if this is something you was brought up to believe in, whether it was taught to you or whether you discovered it for yourself.

If you discovered it for yourself, how old were you at the time and what were the circumstances of your discovery?

(apologies if this has been asked before)
 
Nick, check PM. I think our discussion has somewhat abandoned the purpose of this thread, and is probably exhausting the others.

I for one disagree. I have found the exchange very interesting...especially as you two address fact and how those facts are interpreted.

MaGZ never addresses facts or directly answers questions...as is the MO of his ilk.
 
I plan to start a thread on the topic of Jews and Hollywood. I will title it "Jewish control of Hollywood?" I have been doing some research on the subject and sorry to say Gumboot did not do an honest review of those who call the shots in Hollywood.

Funny that you say this in response to a post that proves you wrong.
 
I plan to start a thread on the topic of Jews and Hollywood. I will title it "Jewish control of Hollywood?" I have been doing some research on the subject and sorry to say Gumboot did not do an honest review of those who call the shots in Hollywood.
Way to not use Stormfront as reference material Gumboot.
colbert.gif
 
What are some of the common "evidence" for this conspiracy-theory. And are there ANY of them that makes any sense?
Yes, some of the evidence makes sense, but you have to understand there are different flavors of Holocaust deniers.

* Some of them say that "the Nazis were kind loving brilliant progressive people, and that only due to dirty Jew propaganda was this myth invented that they were really heartless killers. They were very humane in their treatment of the Jews, moreso than the Jews deserved since they were actually responsible for much of Germany's woes." This is typical tripe of modern neo-nazi groups.

* Others say, "The Nazis were bad people but didn't kill anywhere close to 6 million Jews, the real figure might be 60,000 or less." Quite a historical revision, but OK, at least it's not filled with frothing-at-the-mouth hatred.

* Others say "It's true the the holocaust happened, but the 6 million figure is a bit of an exaggeration, the true number being mostly lost to history but perhaps half that, or even less."

* Still others say, "The holocaust happened, but it wasn't an order from the top levels of the Nazi government, it just was a byproduct of working people to death in forced-labor camps. A minimum of the deaths happened in gas chambers, while most people died of typhoid, undernourishment, bullets, and natural causes."

The single most compelling piece of argument that makes me doubt that the holocaust story is 100% true is that it simply is not easy to kill people with poison gas. Gas chambers are devilishly hard to make work right, especially if the safety of the non-victims (e.g. the nazi guards) is any kind of priority. What we see in Germany today does not appear to me to be a valid design for gas chamber. I'm no expert in gas chambers, but the few experts who have reviewed the Nazi setup are at a loss to how it could actually have worked as claimed.

Combine this with the fact that there are such easier ways to kill people than by gas chamber. If you really wanted to kill a million people, gas chambers would be one of the stupidest ways to do it. Why not just lead them into a deep mine, then close it off? Or just good old fashioned bullets. Or inject each one individually with a poison via hypodermic needle? The list goes on and on.

I've heard it said that there is a profound lack of documentation for the gas chamber story, which--if true--I would find odd since the Nazis had no qualms in documenting all sorts of horrific things they were doing at the time. I've never researched it deep enough to hear both sides of the story sufficiently to draw a conclusion there.

Before somebody labels me as some kind of Jew hater, let me say first that I am part Jewish. Second, that Hitler's Germany was arguably the worst and most murderous nation of the 20th century, next to Stalin's Russia. I have nothing good to say about the Nazis and nothing bad to say about Jews as a race/culture. However I do approach wartime propaganda with a healthy level of skepticism, like we all should.
 
Last edited:
Yes, some of the evidence makes sense . . .


:faint:

No, it doesn't.

but you have to understand there are different flavors of Holocaust deniers.


The difference is mostly a matter of degree.

* Some of them say that "the Nazis were kind loving brilliant progressive people, and that only due to dirty Jew propaganda was this myth invented that they were really heartless killers. They were very humane in their treatment of the Jews, moreso than the Jews deserved since they were actually responsible for much of Germany's woes." This is typical tripe of modern neo-nazi groups.


This is somewhat of an oversimplification, and is more like a caricature of Holocaust denial.


* Others say, "The Nazis were bad people but didn't kill anywhere close to 6 million Jews, the real figure might be 60,000 or less." Quite a historical revision, but OK, at least it's not filled with frothing-at-the-mouth hatred.


Not really. Such a huge downward revision perforce implies that Jews everywhere are complicit in an exaggeration of two orders of magnitude.

* Others say "It's true the the holocaust happened, but the 6 million figure is a bit of an exaggeration, the true number being mostly lost to history but perhaps half that, or even less."


This isn't Holocaust denial, and the only serious debate I've ever seen among responsible historians is whether the number of Jews killed is closer to 5 or 6 million.

* Still others say, "The holocaust happened, but it wasn't an order from the top levels of the Nazi government, it just was a byproduct of working people to death in forced-labor camps. A minimum of the deaths happened in gas chambers, while most people died of typhoid, undernourishment, bullets, and natural causes."


This makes no sense; why would anyone think the gas chambers had even been built if they didn't believe in the Holocaust?

* The single most compelling piece of argument that makes me doubt that the holocaust story is 100% true is that it simply is not easy to kill people with poison gas. Gas chambers are devilishly hard to make work right, especially if the safety of the non-victims (e.g. the nazi guards) is any kind of priority.


The gas chambers were generally cleared out by work details of prisoners who were allowed to live (at least for a while) in return for performing the service, and they wore gas masks.

* What we see in Germany today does not appear to me to be a valid design for gas chamber. I'm no expert in gas chambers, but the few experts who have reviewed the Nazi setup are at a loss to how it could actually have worked as claimed.


I sincerely hope you aren't referring to Fred LeuchterWP.

* Combine this with the fact that there are such easier ways to kill people than by gas chamber. If you really wanted to kill a million people, gas chambers would be one of the stupidest ways to do it. Why not just lead them into a deep mine, then close it off?


First, you have to have an abandoned mine handy. Even if you have a thousand abandoned mines handy, you still have to transport about 6000 people to each mine, all at once, and then you have to have enough explosives in place to seal it. Second, you have to figure out how to keep the prisoners from getting suspicious and rushing the guards.

Or just good old fashioned bullets.


The Nazis used bullets at first, but they determined that gas was far more efficient.

Or inject each one individually with a poison via hypodermic needle?


How are you going to keep the ones at the end of the line from figuring out what's happening?

The list goes on and on.


No, it doesn't.

I've heard it said that there is a profound lack of documentation for the gas chamber story, which--if true--I would find odd since the Nazis had no qualms in documenting all sorts of horrific things they were doing at the time.


The Nazis destroyed some records; however, much documentation survives. See nizkor.org

I've never researched it deep enough to hear both sides of the story sufficiently to draw a conclusion there.


Frankly, it's quite clear that you haven't researched any aspects of The Holocaust in any depth. Fortunately, I have.

Before somebody labels me as some kind of Jew hater, let me say first that I am part Jewish. Second, that Hitler's Germany was arguably the worst and most murderous nation of the 20th century, next to Stalin's Russia. I have nothing good to say about the Nazis and nothing bad to say about Jews as a race/culture. However I do approach wartime propaganda with a healthy level of skepticism, like we all should.


Your comments fall more along the lines of pseudo-skepticism. Much of what you've written frankly makes you look ignorant and foolish. I highly recommend you read some of the articles on nizkor.org in order to educate yourself.
 
Last edited:
* Still others say, "The holocaust happened, but it wasn't an order from the top levels of the Nazi government, it just was a byproduct of working people to death in forced-labor camps. A minimum of the deaths happened in gas chambers, while most people died of typhoid, undernourishment, bullets, and natural causes."

Spitfire dealt quite ably with the rest of the post but I just thought I'd interject on this point. The amount of resources needed to move and house your working people required clearances and priorities from the highest level. There is simply no way to absolve the Nazi hierarchy of complicity in the Holocaust. One of the prevailing theories in German political history is called "working towards the fuhrer", made popular by Dr. Ian Kershaw. It is impossible to go into detail here but it connects the dots in the chain of command within the mess that was the German government.
 
I was going to reply to Unalienable,but SpitfireIX did my job for me.
I hope Unalienable is just going through a "question all conventional wisdom" stage that a lot of us go through.
The Holocaust happened. It is an established historical fact,and only a few..very few nutcases challenge it.
 
Last edited:
Unalienable, I'd also recommend that you read Jean-Claude Pressac's Auschwitz: Technique and Operation of the Gas Chambers.

Pressac spent months of research at Auschwitz poring over primary documents relating to the gassing/crematoria complexes- architectural drawings, invoices for euipment and fittings, work orders, workmen's time sheets etc. while also exploring the Birkenau complex and the ruins of the Kremas to determine as much as possible about the as-built configuration of the rooms believed to have been built as gas chambers.

Despite his having started out very sympathetic to the "revisionist" view and having expected that his research would debunk the use of homicidal gas chambers at Auschwitz, the mass of evidence he accumulated by his own work led him ultimately to conclude that homicidal gas chambers at Auschwitz were real.

You can read the book online starting here.

The Holocaust History Project site is a very useful resource. If you explore the home page a bit you'll find links to a number of essays, including examinations of the claims of such "experts" as Fred Leuchter and also information about the Aktion Reinhard camps, where the Nazis first mechanized mass murder with carbon monoxide gas from internal combustion engines.
 
:faint:






The Nazis used bullets at first, but they determined that gas was far more efficient.

There was also the psychological factor. It was much easier to throw a canister of Zyklon B into a room full of people you did not see. Much different than putting bullets into peoples heads all day long.
 
I'd actually recommend Christopher Browning's Ordinary Men in regards to what it was like to shoot masses of people.

Also Hitler's Willing Executioners - Goldhardt

We had to read both books in a German history class, had to contrast and compare the books in an essay.

My eyes are opened now,

Susan
 
That's Goldhagen, sfq8.

Another book that examins the history of the Einsatzgruppen and how the men who murdered ca. 1,000,000 people by shooting them into ditches adapted psychologically is Masters Of Death: The SS-Einsatzgruppen and the Invention of the Holocaust by Richard Rhodes.

Rhodes expands the theory of "violent socialization" from his book Why They Kill: The Discoveries of a Maverick Criminologist to the process by which ordinary, "normal" men from a variety of socioeconomic backgrounds were transformed into willing mass murderers. If he's correct, the implications of what authoritarian childrearing might have prepared for us are downright scary.
 
Hitler's Scientists by John Cornwell covers the developement of the gases and the creation, mechanics and operation of the gas chambers.
 
I have to ask, Magz - is that you Jay? You sound just like the guy who runs the jam rooms my bands practice at. He thinks you cant do anything (and I mean anything) in the world on your own terms because he thinks everything is run by jewish people.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom