[Moderated][Merged]Real or Fake? Video Challenge

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.
Yes and thousands upon thousands of people also watched Flight 175 with their own eyes hit the South Tower on 9/11, coincidentally backing up all the video you are trying to say is fake, correct? YES or NO? Reply please!
 
I had a friend with a very bad case of OCD once. She spent over 10,000 dollars (A yank) in a few years to check she didn't have bone cancer. Every time she got the all clear she went back.

If we could find someone who has a case of OCD that makes you ask consistently "How do you explain 10,000 people seeing a plane hit the building?" We should use him.

Don't attend to technical questions with Ace anymore, they are simply pointless and he will only divert to those. Wait until he answers how 10,000 people saw a plane if it wasn't there.


Ace contends that they are liars. They are members of the NWO. They have been paid. There are really only a few of them. They don't exist.

Trust me, he isn't inconvenienced by reality.
 
They are undetectable. You ran difference filtering between pairs of frames 8 frames apart. If you ran difference filtering in the opposite direction, you would end up with a mask around the other plane. You can't tell which one is real.

If I hadn't put both planes in the same clip, you wouldn't be able to run difference filtering at all.

Your strokes are as clear as day. You tried to take the easiest possible route to faking your clip. It's tripped you up because that kind of forgery is easily detectable. Whoops. If you'd tried to do a proper fake instead of this pathetic child's play I would have needed a tougher technique. Tough luck, smartass.

I ran the difference matte both ways, as early contributors to the thread will note. I even specifically said, it showed 2 possibilities. You are correct, it doesn't tell which is which.

So...

One noticeable feature of your fakery is that you have chosen a scene where there is so little structure and movent in the foreground and background that you thought you could get away with some rough strokes. In other words you're cutting your plane out of one background and pasting it into an identical background. Amatuer stuff, seriously.

However on frame 33 you messed up, and painted in something you shouldn't have. A bit of the future pops in for one frame, then pops out again (far left, in the trees - see it?). Specifically, its a bit of frame 41. That shows that the layer you were clumsily painting in (represented by black in my filtered version), was the forward layer.

Therefore the plane in front is the one which is out of sync with the rest of the frame.

Also, am I right in thinking you took the sightly perverse route of putting your normal clip, over your slipped clip, then painted holes in the slipped clip to allow the 'fake' to show through? That's just an educated guess...
 
Last edited:
There is no way Ace is going to back down from this "Chopper 5" fakery nonsense because in effect he'll be admitting to wasting several months of his life researching it.
 
Real - The one which would still appear had I not edited the video.

Discussion of "real" for the purposes of this challenge.

A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.
They could both be fake if you are lying and the airplane was filmed elsewhere and never appeared in that shot, or if the airplane in the original shot was cloned twice, and the original removed completely.
 
Haven't run some of the most simple image processing stuff I can think of, it's becoming increasingly obvious to me that the first plane is the faked one.

I didn't even get to run the fun stuff.
 
Frame 34:


Frame 41:



Notice the reddish "tail" ghosting (from the compression, this is a high-frequency area) on the plane going behind the building. Notice how Ace didn't copy enough. The second plane is legit. The first one is a fraud. This could explained by "naturally" occurring noise via compression, but this pattern of plane #2 having "more" tail wash then plane #1 repeats numerous times.

Anyone who wants to reproduce these results just sharpen and edge-find. I used convert from imagemagick (-sharpen 1 -edge 1.0). If you have gimp, do a sharpen and then a laplacian edge find and it'll explode out on the screen.
 
Last edited:
Notice the reddish "tail" ghosting (from the compression, this is a high-frequency area) on the plane going behind the building. Notice how Ace didn't copy enough. The second plane is legit. The first one is a fraud. This could explained by "naturally" occurring noise via compression, but this pattern of plane #2 having "more" tail wash then plane #1 repeats numerous times.

Nice.

Now we should all get out our analysis tools and attempt to detect what all of this has proved.
 
Last edited:
Frame 34:
http://www.sourimage.comhttp://www.sourimage.com/img/2bf15eb33017b46386cf4cee37784a4c/34.jpg

Frame 41:
http://www.sourimage.comhttp://www.sourimage.com/img/81c7c1760c34e5670fca798f1e1c7d3a/41.jpg


Notice the reddish "tail" ghosting (from the compression, this is a high-frequency area) on the plane going behind the building. Notice how Ace didn't copy enough. The second plane is legit. The first one is a fraud. This could explained by "naturally" occurring noise via compression, but this pattern of plane #2 having "more" tail wash then plane #1 repeats numerous times.

Anyone who wants to reproduce these results just sharpen and edge-find. I used convert from imagemagick (-sharpen 1 -edge 1.0). If you have gimp, do a sharpen and then a laplacian edge find and it'll explode out on the screen.

Excellent work. So you're saying that you apply some filters, and suddenly the plane is trailing anomalies behind it?

Let's apply some filters to Chopper 5, and have a look.
PastedPlane-Contrast.jpg


Notice the left wing is trailing pixels decidedly more pink than the background sky. Seems like these are kept from the original in order to preserve the appearance of wake turbulence. The sky was a bit more pink on the day they shot the plane, than it was on 9/11.
 
http://www.acebaker.com/9-11/PinocchioStudy/PastedPlane-Contrast.jpg

Notice the left wing is trailing pixels decidedly more pink than the background sky. Seems like these are kept from the original in order to preserve the appearance of wake turbulence. The sky was a bit more pink on the day they shot the plane, than it was on 9/11.


Did everything just posted in this thread just fly over your head?

You are taking a heavily compressed video and trying to enlarge it to focus in the tiny pixel coloration to see if there is an anomaly. Do you not see that what you are doing is comparing apples and oranges to the work that anti-sophist just did



And you still side step those PESKY 1000's of witnesses to the plane crash.

When are you going to address this?
 
How do I get a poll?

I'd like to make two separate videos, as suggested, and have a poll.

1) I have not studied the two videos.
2) I have studied the two videos, and I can't tell which one is real and which one is fake.
3) I have studied the two videos, and I think number one is real and number two is fake.
4) I have studied the two videos, and I think number two is real and number one is fake.


How do I make a poll?
 
Excellent work. So you're saying that you apply some filters, and suddenly the plane is trailing anomalies behind it?

Nowhere have I claimed that. First of all, the claim that you can just apply any filters you want and find them is silly.

More importantly, the evidence I provided disproves this conjecture. Please note plane #2 (the real plane) in the first frame... this is the one I did not call your attention to earlier. This is a "real" plane and it has absolutely no trailing anomalies behind it.



Please note the "real plane" in this image. The second one. It has no trailing anomalies.

The trailing anomalies are not omnipresent and only occur in places of high frequency who have received a too-low-bit rate for the compression. Furthermore, they are only noticeable under very specific filters. If you apply the above filter the entire scene, you will see the trailing anomalies several times... but not every time.

Lack of these particular compression anomalies is not proof of fakery, as the above example shows very clearly.
 
Back here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=81890&page=3

I asked Ace the following:

Ace, TS, or whatever you call yourself,

Could you please explain to me how the NWO, Government, or whoever you think made these videos also somehow implanted the images of 2 planes hitting the WTC in to my EYEBALLS!

See, I was there, and I personally witnessed both planes hitting the buildings.

I saw everything, EVERYTHING!

I saw it firsthand, not on video, not by description after the fact. I saw BOTH PLANES HIT THE BUILDINGS!!!

Please explain how I saw what you say didn't happen.

Please, this I gotta hear.

I was a few hundred yards from WTC1 walking towards it when the first plane hit. I looked up when I heard an incredibly loud jet engine sound a second or two before the plane hit. It was so loud that the ground was vibrating and I actually felt the sound. Of course the crash and resulting explosion was even louder, but I'll never forget the sound of the jet. Its what made me look up. Then there it was, an American Airlines jet flying full speed in to the north tower.

So please tell me Ace, how did the big bad NWO not only implant images in to my eyeball, but also have the accompanying sound effects so perfectly staged?

The answer he gave was to run away and completely ignore me. Not at all a surprise, but still very telling.
 
<snip>

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.

"And the truth shall set you free"

Congratualations, Ace! You've just debunked your "no planes at the WTC" theory! Your prize is a juice box. Enjoy.

It's truly amazing how if you just keep a twoofer talking, they'll eventually become their own worst enemy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom