[Moderated][Merged]Real or Fake? Video Challenge

Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
1,756
One of the planes in the video is real, the other one is fake. Can you tell which is which?

Download the video clip here.

Plane1Doubled.jpg
 
Ace, what's your point?

Do you not understand how posting a video of two planes on the internet is different to live broadcasting a plane hitting a building in a packed city with hundreds of thousands of witnesses?
 
The point is to test whether or not we can composite an airplane into video convincingly. A number of JREF members have agreed to take this challenge, and I encourage all.
 
There's alot of things we can do now with video technology.

Real people died on those planes when they crashed into the towers, real people saw it with their own eyes.
 
The point is to test whether or not we can composite an airplane into video convincingly. A number of JREF members have agreed to take this challenge, and I encourage all.

No, you have missed my point.

I doubt anyone here denies that a plane can be composited into video in a convincing manner. That technology has been available for years.

Technology that is not available, though, is making it appear to thousands of eyewitness that a plane has struck a building, and doing so on live TV.
 
The point is to test whether or not we can composite an airplane into video convincingly. A number of JREF members have agreed to take this challenge, and I encourage all.



Don't you mean it tests whether you can clone an object in a video and do it convincingly?

-Gumboot
 
Make sure the videos you post are more close up of the planes.

Those were too small. Make then at least twice the size.

On edit:

I think the first one is the fake one.
 
Last edited:
The distance and quality are quite similar to the Chopper 5 video.

(psssst. I knew it would be impossible to tell the difference, so I left a clue).
 
Ace, please stop.

Flight 175 had innocent people onboard it, it was flown at high speed into the side of a building, killing them instantly.

Please before you go any further show you have an ounce of decency and give this insanity up.
 
The distance and quality are quite similar to the Chopper 5 video.

(psssst. I knew it would be impossible to tell the difference, so I left a clue).


ace, are you just ignoring that:

1) posting a still image of a screenshot from a video is not the same of inserting the same type of sfx into a LIVE FEED footage and have the thousands of eyewitnesses WHO WERE THERE THAT DAY, see a plane hit hte building?



why do you continue to ignore that there were REAL eyewitnesses who were there that DAY

Are you going to ignore (damn what's his name, the chinese guy that was in WTC 2 and ACTUALLY saw the plane coming toward him....he stayed in the building trying to call emergency services within the building).....his claims that he saw the plane approaching the building????


no amoutn of you trying to prove that hte "video" was faked will disprove what those who were there that day saw.
 
I don't run QT so I'm gonna go by the Pic and say the one on the right is fake. Now then Are you using tech that was available in 2001 and can you prove it?
 
It's like the Shoah survivors. One day, sadly, the witnesses will be gone, and the deniers will have free reign to spout their nonsense...

:(
 
Maybe it would be a good idea if we took the approach we did with christophera and (attempt to) stop encouraging him by responding to this nonsense?
 
dont know how it proves what he claims since he has yet to prove that it was able to be done for live video feed and the thousands of witnesses including those in the buildings who saw the planes approaching and crashing
 
This is stupid. He has taken a video of an aircraft, and cloned it to make two aircraft. That's not even remotely related to the subject under discussion in his other thread.

Ace, get help. Please.

-Gumboot
 
The point is to test whether or not we can composite an airplane into video convincingly. A number of JREF members have agreed to take this challenge, and I encourage all.


Ace I agreed to take this challenge, if you posted up high quality quicktimes on an FTP site. I don't consider a 12mb compression to be satisfactory.


You were also going to be given bonus points if you did it real time, using software/hardware available in 2001. Did you do either of these things?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom