[Moderated][Merged]Real or Fake? Video Challenge

ace, are you just ignoring that:

1) posting a still image of a screenshot from a video is not the same of inserting the same type of sfx into a LIVE FEED footage and have the thousands of eyewitnesses WHO WERE THERE THAT DAY, see a plane hit hte building?

It's obvious from his previous threads that he doesn't understand that one.

If you can fake ANY picture or ANY video, then people didn't see 175 crash into the south tower. Simple as 'dat! :rolleyes:
 
My friend's uncle was injured by debris in those attacks, he saw flight 175 crash with his own eyes, and was then hit by a piece of debris that broke off in the impact; that piece of debris nearly killed him.




Ace has no decency. He is insane and not very bright.





His illness will not permit that.

Do not use insults or accusations of insanity to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: chillzero


Whenever Ace introduces a new twist in his campaign to demonstrate that no planes hit the Twin Towers, there is never a shortage of knowledgeable forum members to dissect his fabrications and expose his incompetent efforts to distort reality. The elephant in the parlor is his mental state. It is less than honest to discuss complete nonsense without mentioning the reason why the person who created the nonsense is incapable of recognizing it for what it is. To describe Ace as ill is not an insult. It is an accurate observation that explains a whole lot.
 
I actually want to discuss this issue but I'm afraid any rational discussion of this issue is gonna get lost in the noise of all you guys jumping down his throat.

Ace, I don't believe what you have created is representative, at all, of the actual challenge required. This is because you made one plane exactly follow the other across a fairly static background. The only reason your second plane is going to be hard to distinguish is because a -real- plane did the exact same thing. This means you can copy pixels. This defeats the whole purpose of "faking" video. If you have -real- video then making a direct copy of it doesn't make it "fake".

If you want to do a proper test you will need to make the plane either in a different video sequence entirely, or even travel a different (parallel) line in the image.

Having the two planes follow one behind the other, against a static background, is not representative, at all, of what you claim happened.

All that being said, I'm still fairly confident I can identify the fake. I'd just prefer you'd do a proper test.
 
Definition of real.

Real - The one which would still appear had I not edited the video.

Discussion of "real" for the purposes of this challenge.

A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.
 
Last edited:
A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it.

Exactly, and on 9/11, hundreds of people saw the second plane hit, and quite a few of them videotaped it.

Nobody saw a cloned plane behind it.
 
A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

What if somebody told you that they had analyzed a video of that plane and declared it to be fake, therefore you and everybody else who saw it is either lying or mistaken.

How would you react to them?
 
Ace, I don't believe what you have created is representative, at all, of the actual challenge required. This is because you made one plane exactly follow the other across a fairly static background. The only reason your second plane is going to be hard to distinguish is because a -real- plane did the exact same thing. This means you can copy pixels. This defeats the whole purpose of "faking" video. If you have -real- video then making a direct copy of it doesn't make it "fake".

Copying pixels defines (not defeats!) the purpose of video fakery. This is exactly what I allege the 9/11 perps did. I think they videotaped a real plane, removed the background, and "copied pixels", later inserting it into a "fairly static background".

The only tricky part is masking off the building in real time. They had the technology in 1998, and it almost worked for them on 9/11. They screwed it up, and let the darn nose of the airplane come out the back side.
 
Ace, what strikes me about this video is that, in order to make it, you had to start with a video of the real plane doing exactly the same thing you wanted the fake plane to do; in other words, on 9/11 you could have faked a video of flight 175 hitting WTC2 only if you already had a video of flight 175 hitting WTC2.

Incidentally, how steady is the apparent velocity of the plane?

Dave

Yes, Dave, I shot a steady plane, a camera shake plane, a helicopter and some birds. They will serve as the control cases for my Chopper 5 study, as per your advice.
 
The only tricky part is masking off the building in real time. They had the technology in 1998, and it almost worked for them on 9/11. They screwed it up, and let the darn nose of the airplane come out the back side.

You can speculate about technology all you want, but how did they fool all the eye witnesses? You keep sidestepping that.

It appears that not only did they edit live video in such a way as to only be possible with your hypothetical extension of limited 1998 technology, but they were able to somehow fool thousands of people watching it happen.

These witnesses are the bane of your theory. You can't just wave them away as being mistaken.
 
Copying pixels defines (not defeats!) the purpose of video fakery. This is exactly what I allege the 9/11 perps did. I think they videotaped a real plane, removed the background, and "copied pixels", later inserting it into a "fairly static background".

The only tricky part is masking off the building in real time. They had the technology in 1998, and it almost worked for them on 9/11. They screwed it up, and let the darn nose of the airplane come out the back side.

No, this is not what you claim they did. You copied a plane onto the -exact same background-, 7 frames later. That is -not- at all what you claim they did. All you've done is overlaid a "delayed" version, which is far simpler then actually moving the plane to a different location.

You have chosen a specially contrived case that is far simpler that what you allege happened.
 
By the way, without any sophisticated analysis at all, it's fairly easy to guess that the first plane is fake because it begins 1 frame later then the second plane (ie, the location of plane #2 in frame 8 has no analogue for plane #1). The "missing" first frame would have been the easiest to detect pixel manipulation so my guess is it was left off intentionally.
 
Real - The one which would still appear had I not edited the video.

Discussion of "real" for the purposes of this challenge.

A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.


How do you react to the fact that I have isolated all your sloppy-brush strokes in the video? Weren't they supposed to be undetectable? Wasn't that the whole point?
 
How do you react to the fact that I have isolated all your sloppy-brush strokes in the video? Weren't they supposed to be undetectable? Wasn't that the whole point?

They are undetectable. You ran difference filtering between pairs of frames 8 frames apart. If you ran difference filtering in the opposite direction, you would end up with a mask around the other plane. You can't tell which one is real.

If I hadn't put both planes in the same clip, you wouldn't be able to run difference filtering at all.
 
They are undetectable. You ran difference filtering between pairs of frames 8 frames apart. If you ran difference filtering in the opposite direction, you would end up with a mask around the other plane. You can't tell which one is real.

If I hadn't put both planes in the same clip, you wouldn't be able to run difference filtering at all.

If you hadn't just delayed the movie 8 frames the way you did, it'd be -easier- to detect the fake, not more difficult.
 
Okay, this is my first shot at a debunking so I may be a little shaky, but here goes -
<snip>A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.
I've analyzed your video and the only conclusion that I can come to is that . . . they're both fake. There was no airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Everyone who thought they saw it (including you) is either brainwashed by the evil gubmint or they're deluded. Your so called 'video' is a complete fake. GOVERNMENT SHILL! SHEEPLE!

How'd I do?
 
I had a friend with a very bad case of OCD once. She spent over 10,000 dollars (A yank) in a few years to check she didn't have bone cancer. Every time she got the all clear she went back.

If we could find someone who has a case of OCD that makes you ask consistently "How do you explain 10,000 people seeing a plane hit the building?" We should use him.

Don't attend to technical questions with Ace anymore, they are simply pointless and he will only divert to those. Wait until he answers how 10,000 people saw a plane if it wasn't there.
 
One of the planes in the video is real, the other one is fake. Can you tell which is which?

Download the video clip here.

Plane1Doubled.jpg
Ace you are a disrespectful person. Zero capability to understand anything about 9/11. Sad you are so lacking the capability to have any feelings for those who died on 9/11 by making up false information about the planes on 9/11. You are such a little person, and unable to think rationally. You are the fake. All your ideas on 9/11 are fake. What a waste, making up lies about 9/11.

Cheating again? The speed is not real time, the compression of the video is really bad. You need to produce an original live fake plane. Just like we saw on 9/11. Now take your disrespectful tripe and stop being a liar. Fake, fake.
 
Last edited:
They are undetectable. You ran difference filtering between pairs of frames 8 frames apart. If you ran difference filtering in the opposite direction, you would end up with a mask around the other plane. You can't tell which one is real.

If I hadn't put both planes in the same clip, you wouldn't be able to run difference filtering at all.

In other words, if you'd done what you said you were going to do it wouldn't be detectable. At least, not the same way.

There were supposed to have been two videos. One fake, one real. Not one video with one fake and one real airplane.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom