[Moderated][Merged]Real or Fake? Video Challenge

I'm failing to see why people even bother putting effort into responding to Ace with detailed, coherent, and rational evaluation of his loopy efforts and claims. He's definitely not got all his oars in the water, so expecting him to respond rationally is a forlorn hope at best, a waste of time at worst. His track record suggests the latter is far more likely.

The only alternative I can think of is that he has your collective legs and is giving them an almighty pull.
 
Last edited:
I was thinking along similar lines.

He tried to introduce a clip which, presumably, would demonstrate it was possible to "fake" video clips of 9/11 (ignoring live broadcast & eyewitness accounts).

He failed to do so.

Then he seems to act like his efforts have demonstrated something significant.

Just paint me unimpressed.
 
Last edited:
I'm failing to see why people even bother putting effort into responding to Ace with detailed, coherent, and rational evaluation of his loopy efforts and claims.

Yeah!

Kittens'n'cats time Ace - spot the Photoshopping in the following:


 
Ace said:
Real - The one which would still appear had I not edited the video.

Discussion of "real" for the purposes of this challenge.

A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.


EHr, correct.

Mmm congratulations! You have deduced that if somebody pastes in an image of a plane in a video, then that is a fake.

Wow.

Any other interesting information you want to share with us?

Hans
 
I'd like to make two separate videos, as suggested, and have a poll.

1) I have not studied the two videos.
2) I have studied the two videos, and I can't tell which one is real and which one is fake.
3) I have studied the two videos, and I think number one is real and number two is fake.
4) I have studied the two videos, and I think number two is real and number one is fake.


How do I make a poll?

You miss two more options:

5) I have not studied the two videos since I can think of better things to do with my time (like watching paint dry). No matter how, why or when you faked a video, it has zilch do do with the realities of 911.

6) On planet X, the videos are real and we fake the planes.


How do you make a poll? Well, the way everybody else makes a poll. Find out how, like anybody else. Remember, you are supposed to be such a smart guy.

Hans :nope:
 
Real - The one which would still appear had I not edited the video.

Discussion of "real" for the purposes of this challenge.

A real airplane landed at Burbank airport yesterday. Many people saw it with their own eyes, including me. I videotaped it. Nobody saw two airplanes.

Only one airplane is allowed on that flight path at a time, because of wake turbulence. There appear to be two airplanes in the video clip.

Therefore, since we know there was only one airplane on that path at that time, one of them must be real, and one must be fake. They can't both be fake, because I saw a real airplane with my eyes.
Here Ace, just for you. Reassurance of Reality. There really was just ONE plane:


 
What's fake?

PlaneRampage.jpg
 
The fact that Ace took a COPY of the real plane and pasted it into the same video, which is no longer LIVE has debunked his own claims.

Ace- here's YOUR challenge. If what you are saying is true, you should be able to go out into the street, take an amateur video camera, and- while broadcasting live- insert realistic and indistinguishable cars into your live shot.

Can you do that? (and could you do it in 2001)

If you can, then I will consider your theory something more than just pure lunacy.

ETA: Ace even so-much as admits this; the name of the video is "Plane1Doubled"...

*bump*


Ace continues to shoot himself in the foot with his analogy- including the concession in his analogies: ie, people SAW the plane land, it was ONE plane, the video was of ONE plane...

He isn't capable of critically thinking about this- even to the point where he's debunking himself.
 
Uh, similar in quality compared to the Chopper 5 video as found on the internet at YouTube? Because the quality and resolution of a YouTube video is nowhere close to the resolution and quality of the actual recorded live broadcast.

You keep overlooking this point - you cannot do any serious analysis of a video taken from YouTube because it has neither the resolution nor the quality required. It'd be like trying to do digital photo analysis of a photograph which was first printed out, then a copy of that printout made on a colour copier, and lastly the colour copy scanned on a flatbed scanner to produce the digital file you're analyzing. The quality loss at each of these steps of reproduction makes it virtually impossible to do any meaningful analysis.

The copy of Chopper 5 that I use is not from YouTube. It is from Eric Salter, and is a 640 x 480 MPEG. Analysis should be done on the highest quality copies available. If there are any copies of any significant 9/11 events that are of higher quality than readily available, please let me know.

I have now shot a number of videos of planes disappearing behind buildings. The distance and zoom make them comparable to Chopper 5. The "double trouble" clone was exported to quicktime with quality set to "highest", colors on "millions" and compressor on "none". The picture was cropped, but not enlarged.
 
No, it should be done on the minimal resolution allowing reasonable conclusions to be drawn, and for the size of the objects in your video, 640x480 is not sufficient...IMO.

TAM:)
 
The copy of Chopper 5 that I use is not from YouTube. It is from Eric Salter, and is a 640 x 480 MPEG. Analysis should be done on the highest quality copies available. If there are any copies of any significant 9/11 events that are of higher quality than readily available, please let me know.

You should be able to get Beta SX copies of the original from the stations.

I have now shot a number of videos of planes disappearing behind buildings. The distance and zoom make them comparable to Chopper 5. The "double trouble" clone was exported to quicktime with quality set to "highest", colors on "millions" and compressor on "none". The picture was cropped, but not enlarged.

And we were able to prove it was a fake within minutes. Your point?
 
You should be able to get Beta SX copies of the original from the stations.



And we were able to prove it was a fake within minutes. Your point?

The only thing that allowed you prove anything was the fact that I gave you two copies of the same plane in one clip. You can prove they are identical, but you can't prove which one is real, as Shrinker said.

As far as getting broadcast quality copies, surely you jest. I'm all for it, but I ain't holding my breath.
 
The only thing that allowed you prove anything was the fact that I gave you two copies of the same plane in one clip. You can prove they are identical, but you can't prove which one is real, as Shrinker said.

Wow, thats a liberal interpretation.

And did you do it real time, on software available in 2001?

As far as getting broadcast quality copies, surely you jest. I'm all for it, but I ain't holding my breath.

Have you even tried?

I can just dial up the library from my edit suite, and be watching it in five minutes.

Most stations have an archive service, you ring em they charge a fee and courier a tape over.
 
No, it should be done on the minimal resolution allowing reasonable conclusions to be drawn, and for the size of the objects in your video, 640x480 is not sufficient...IMO.

TAM:)

By this standard, one cannot prove the 9/11 videos are real, any more than one could prove they are fake.

Actually, different resolutions can play different roles in piecing this together. For instance, the only legitimate complaint with my velocity study was margin of error. Everyone agreed that my overall premise and approach were exactly correct.

So if I can take videos similar in quality to Chopper 5, and demonstrate that the velocities of these plane are much more stable than the one in Chopper 5, then I will overcome the margin of error complaint.
 
Have you even tried? [to get 9/11 tapes]

I can just dial up the library from my edit suite, and be watching it in five minutes.

Most stations have an archive service, you ring em they charge a fee and courier a tape over.

Oh yes. About 6 months ago I made about 3 hours worth of phone calls. I called FOX, CNN, NBC, ABC, CBS, FOX news, and a couple of affiliate stations in LA> I was asking how to obtain archived video footage. I was asked "who I was with", and I was told that archives were only available for those with proper credentials.

Evidently, 8den, you have the proper credentials.

Please let me know how much I need to pay for broadcast quality copies of :

Chopper 5

ABC live shot

CNN darkplane

Aaron Brown live with the North Tower Spire.

Any other video showing a plane, or a twin tower exploding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom