[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, at least you made up an answer for my question, although the photo shows no indication that it was "touched in".

I've looked at your points, but i find nothing "consistent with someone rolling a trolley from the real path onto the grass and letting a missile go as the flyover takes place." Just a path well worn by use, more than a "trolley" used once would make. It has also been shown here on other posts why the path is the length it is and how it is used, and that evidence is more credible to me, a lowly lurker.

Even if you thought by some silly chance someone were to alter the photo, it would be signifcantly easier just to change the path than to mask damage to the building (yes, I do know about "touching in"). The date/name on the file could easily be changed (it wasn't), but metadata doesn't get altered. Can you please show me where the changes were made? Or other evidence, maybe like the original photo?

The rest of you post is a non-answer to my question, and even has nothing to do with your OP. Please stay focused.
What's so special about meta data?
Also, how can it be a path when it goes from a wall to nowhere.
Who would tread such a 'path' and why do you fail to address that point?
 
Ah, I see.

So, on September 7, 2001, a missile-laden trolley was positioned on the real path and its weaponry fired at the Pentagon. Then, using special camouflage wrapping paper and duct tape, the gaping hole was concealed for 4 days until the great "unveiling" on September 11.

Is that what you are saying?

Ah! Thats really more credible to me than having a large portion of a photo "touched in" and changing the date! I'll stick with jsfisher here, unless you can come up with some evidence to support your contention.

And really, saying "It's a lot easier to change a date and insert an undamaged Pentagon, than it is to fool around with a lawn."? What about the debris on and around the building? That would have had to been "touched in" too. Making changes to the vast majority of a picture is not "a lot easier".

Its not. Really.
 
Well, at least you made up an answer for my question, although the photo shows no indication that it was "touched in".

I've looked at your points, but i find nothing "consistent with someone rolling a trolley from the real path onto the grass and letting a missile go as the flyover takes place." Just a path well worn by use, more than a "trolley" used once would make. It has also been shown here on other posts why the path is the length it is and how it is used, and that evidence is more credible to me, a lowly lurker.

Even if you thought by some silly chance someone were to alter the photo, it would be signifcantly easier just to change the path than to mask damage to the building (yes, I do know about "touching in"). The date/name on the file could easily be changed (it wasn't), but metadata doesn't get altered. Can you please show me where the changes were made? Or other evidence, maybe like the original photo?

The rest of you post is a non-answer to my question, and even has nothing to do with your OP. Please stay focused.
Why do you slip that I suggested that the scar was caused by a trolley used once? When I specifically explained the scar was caused by the missiles exhaust?
Is this deliberate obfuscation?
 
What's so special about meta data?
Also, how can it be a path when it goes from a wall to nowhere.
Who would tread such a 'path' and why do you fail to address that point?

Your point is to use this photo as evidence to support your assertions, and you claim that it has been altered. I have mearly pointed out to you that the photo has not been altered as you suggest, the date has not been changed and so it does not support your claims as such. Addressing your other points about the path is moot, as you have no foundation left nor any supporting evidence.

As to how the paths have come to be there, you have had ample evidence given to you by other posters up-thread, which you seem to have chosen to ignore.

If you are sincerely interested about the importance of metadata included in this photo, or its use (generally) in digital photography, I invite you to ask. Here you seem dismissive, or just not interested.
 
Last edited:
Why do you slip that I suggested that the scar was caused by a trolley used once? When I specifically explained the scar was caused by the missiles exhaust?
Is this deliberate obfuscation?

I have "slipped" no such suggestion in. If you wish to claim "deliberate obfuscation", it is only due to the fact that your posts often make no sense. Please be clear and consise, focus on the issue and you will be better understood and addressed as such.

It was you who indicated the mark was due to the trolley, maybe adding something in about a scorch mark after the fact.

<snip>
All this is consistent with someone rolling a trolley from the real path onto the grass and letting a missile go as the flyover takes place,
That explains the 'path' not reaching the real path, because that's where the trolley was stood.

If you were to attribute to the well worn pathway shown damage done by "the missiles exhaust", then where is all the black scorching damage, as well as the debris from the impact? Where is the trolley? Burning damage of that sort would not be "white". I think you would find that evidence would be very helpful here.

You can't show what is not there in this unretouched photo we are addressing.
 
Last edited:
Ah! Thats really more credible to me than having a large portion of a photo "touched in" and changing the date! I'll stick with jsfisher here, unless you can come up with some evidence to support your contention.


Well, based on the new information Malcolm Kir...er Somerled has provided, it is obvious now, isn't it? Afterall, we have a photo showing no damage to the Pentagon, no sign of a trolley-based rocket launcher, and the wrong date. Isn't the proof positive of Somerled's allegations?
 
Dude. First off, who took the photos is irrelevant; Jack White is 'analyzing' them, and that cries out from the farthest rooftops 'criticism'.

Second, you are dismissing photographic evidence on the basis of "well, they could have been faked, and here's how they maybe could have been faked. That means every image that supports the official story is suspect".

You obviously want us to think you are some brilliant, intrepid truth seeker.
Don't forget the boy scout with the plastic badge. The one who would have no difficulty working this out.
 
What part of the path do I not get?
The part that goes through a wall for a start.
This is the genuine photo,
http://www.geoeye.com/gallery/9-11/P...gon_9_7_01.jpg
I remind you of the seven questions I left you with, not one of which you have answered.


Um, Malcolm, I answered your seven questions. I even provided a link to learn more about "slug lines" and a picture of the Capitol Building showing a similar "scorch mark." I admit it got burried in a lot of posts about your real identity, but I worked hard on it.


I would ask you to concentrate on the last few yards of the 'path' before it reaches the real path. Here you will see that the grass is not worn. Therefore it couldn't be a path, otherwise it would br worn.


What is the source of your path-wear knowledge? What information do you have about how the Pentagon grounds were kept?

I believe I remember someone posting pictures showing that sewr lines were installed in the middle of the Pentagon lawn on that side of the building. If that were the case, people walking on the freshly dug up and then refilled earth would impede grass regrowth. The part of the lawn that was not dug up would just have people trodding on grass as it grows.

I admit that I haven't the first clue as to whether this actually happened. But you must admit that my explanation for why the path would be more bare in some spots than in others is at least as good as your reasoning as to why the path would be uniformly worn.


If you look at the genuine path, it is whiter there than at any other place. You have to really look, but you can see the difference.
Also there is a worn patch beyond the real path.
All this is consistent with someone rolling a trolley from the real path onto the grass and letting a missile go as the flyover takes place,
That explains the 'path' not reaching the real path, because that's where the trolley was stood. It also explains the bleached area of the real path and the scorched bit beyond.


Great. Just to be sociable, I'll agree that based on physical evidence your theory is as likely as mine. Do you have any eyewitnesses that saw the cart with the missiles on it? It was close to rush hour right next to a busy highway. The cart had to have been there for at least a little while. Please list the individuals who saw it.

Now my theory that a damn plane hit the Pentagon is supported by witnesses. Here's a whole page of them.

Actually, there is one piece of physical evidence you keep forgetting. To the left of your "scorch mark," starting from the edge of the parking lot and extending across the grass of one of the clover leaves is another "scorch mark." How do you explain it? I think it's a foot path people took to get to the onramp for cars going the other way on the highway. What do you think it is?


It is not a path, because it goes from a motorway barrier, to a wall.


No, it doesn't. It goes from some outbuildings and a helipad to an on ramp. I think there were one-way exits from the Pentagon located near the helipad. Did you write the DoD to ask?



What's so special about meta data?
Also, how can it be a path when it goes from a wall to nowhere.
Who would tread such a 'path' and why do you fail to address that point?


I addressed the point several times. The path goes from the helipad and some outbuildings to an on ramp. The people who would tread such a path are people who have finished work for the day and want to catch a ride with a Pentagon worker going right (Or maybe East. I have no idea which direction the photo was taken from.) .


Why do you slip that I suggested that the scar was caused by a trolley used once? When I specifically explained the scar was caused by the missiles exhaust?
Is this deliberate obfuscation?


Are you deliberately ignoring my posts?
 

I guess that means I'm on your ignore list.

That's ok. Your outrageous claims will continue unabated whether or not you see my posts, here. You have made quite a few claims, you know, and with the greatest passion. But can you guess how many have actually rung true? We all know the answer.

Now, as stock brokers are fond of saying, the past is no guarantee of future performance, but in your case, I predict with confidence your eschewing of fact will continue. Your fantasy world is ever-expanding.
 
I have "slipped" no such suggestion in. If you wish to claim "deliberate obfuscation", it is only due to the fact that your posts often make no sense. Please be clear and consise, focus on the issue and you will be better understood and addressed as such.

It was you who indicated the mark was due to the trolley, maybe adding something in about a scorch mark after the fact.



If you were to attribute to the well worn pathway shown damage done by "the missiles exhaust", then where is all the black scorching damage, as well as the debris from the impact? Where is the trolley? Burning damage of that sort would not be "white".

You can't show what is not there in this unretouched photo we are addressing.
Where is the trolley? That's a hard one. Seeing as it was wheeled there, might it not have been wheeled away after the event.
How did this path get worn?
People walked through a wall and then jumped the last ten or so feet?
You keep insisting that the scar is a path. How did this ridiculous 'path' get there and to what purpose?
 
Your point is to use this photo as evidence to support your assertions, and you claim that it has been altered. I have mearly pointed out to you that the photo has not been altered as you suggest, the date has not been changed and so it does not support your claims as such. Addressing your other points about the path is moot (without supporting evidence), as you have no foundation left.

As to how the paths have come to be there, you have had ample evidence given to you by other posters up-thread, which you seem to have chosen to ignore.

If you are sincerely interested about the importance of metadata included in this photo, or its use (generally) in digital photography, I invite you to ask. Here you seem dismissive, or just not interested.
I just did ask.
"What's so special about meta data? Looks like a question to me.
 
Interesting.

SOMERLED, I do look forward to seeing any evidence you have to support this. When it comes to any argument, but especially such a tragic event as 9/11, I am always Frank and Earnest in my discussions. I will try to follow along as best I can, but I'm a bit busy with school and all, and these threads tend to move fast.

I don't suppose you could provide a brief outline of the supporting evidence you have collected could you? I know it's probably be posted ad infinitum, but this thread is really long. :(

My pleasure,
Allow me to start by attempting to gain your agreement, that Bob Pugh, the freelance who made this video. Describes the hole in the Pentagon as 16 ft x 16 ft, 20 ft wide max. He also uses the term 'garage door'.
Do you agree,
9 mins 45 secs to close.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
 
Except that it isn't. It's a portable diesel generator.

[qimg]http://photos.state.gov/galleries/usinfo-photo/39/Sept_11_Pentagon/009-Pentagon.jpg[/qimg]

similar to this one:

[qimg]http://www.rigplanet.com/console/upload/listings/p1155499471.jpg[/qimg]
source: http://www.rigplanet.com/webfront/listings/details.php?listingid=173
Kindly stop this video at 7mins 35 secs and you will see an open topped dumpster immediately to the left of a trailer.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYWIT9TSJPE
 
I just did ask.
"What's so special about meta data? Looks like a question to me.


Thank you for asking. As I noted, you seem dismissive, or just not interested, and your phrasing this time is just plain rude. But I'll go ahead and give you this to start with:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metadata

See, that wasn't so hard, could have done that yourself I think. ;)
Most people forget its there, and it may contain valuable info as support. Please peruse that link and feel free to ask for help if any of that doesn't make sense.

You have claimed this photo has been edited, made bold statments of what the edited photo is supposed to be hiding, and at no time substantiated those statements with evidence. Any points you pose about what this photo is supposed to show are really moot until you show some evidence backing your initial statment that this photo has been edited.

You have also ignored posters which have replied to answer your points, especially those who do have supporting evidence.

The evidence in this particular case seems against you. You may want to focus your efforts on those issues which you think you can better support.
 
Last edited:
Um, Gravy, I hate to disagree with you but I think you linked to the September 7, 2001 photo. I think the website misdated it. I've been looking at them pretty closely and I think they're the same.

I could well be wrong.

I think Loss Leader has it right about the date. The copyright of the photo says:

Copyright AirPhotoUSA 2001 All Rights Reserved

No exact date, and they seem to be from different sources, or the second is a derivative of the first.
 
Last edited:
Um, Gravy, I hate to disagree with you but I think you linked to the September 7, 2001 photo. I think the website misdated it. I've been looking at them pretty closely and I think they're the same.

I could well be wrong.
They are different photos. The Sept 7 is a satellite photo, and mine is by aircraft (the stray boat in the harbor is a giveaway in mine). However the date is wrong. It's labeled November, 2000, but the text on the page says it was taken July, 2001.
http://www.directionsmag.com/gisresponse/maps-dc.php
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom