[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will the real Malcolm Kirkman please stand up?

I don't need vetted evidence, I just need to suspect it.


So that means we just need to suspect that you're the real Malcolm Kirkman, right, Malcolm? We don't need vetted evidence, do we?

Well, here's some more evidence anyway.

The World Can't Wait

<snip>

Sandra L. Kirkland, Ohio (Main Street Dems)
Arden N. Kirkman, North Carolina
malcolm kirkman, sober
nathan kirkpatrick
Susan Kirn, PA

<snip>


Justice for 9/11 Solidarity Petition

<snip>

12971. Russell Dubisch, New York, USA
12972. Scott Benne, Missouri, USA
12973. malcolm kirkman, United Kingdom
12974. SUSAN M. PITZL, Arizona, USA
12975. Court Micker, West Virginia, USA

<snip>


There are four possibilities:

  1. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and the real Malcolm Kirkman, by an astounding coincidence, is also a "truther."
  2. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen deliberately by you, in order to impersonate a known "truther" from the UK.
  3. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and you signed these two petitions using a false name.
  4. malcolm kirkman is your real name, and you're just "having us on."
The chance that 1. is true are at least one in a million against. There are about 44 million people on the UK electoral rolls; and 1-2 million eligible adults are not registered (these are easily verified via Google). So we'll say there are about 45 million Britons who could theoretically have "signed" the Justice for 9/11 petition. The petition currently has almost 15,000 "signatures"; checking 10 randomly selected pages shows about 2% of these are British. So about 300 Britons signed the petition. 300 divided by 45 million gives about one in 150,000. However, because "Malcolm Kirkman" doesn't capitalize the initial letters in his name, that makes it even less likely to be a coincidence, as you didn't capitalize the initial letters, either. Checking the same page shows 17 non-capitalizations of names, so we can fairly safely assume that fewer than one in five signers didn't capitalize their names. 150,000 * 5 = 750,000, so we're up to one in 3/4 million. Also, from the position of "malcolm kirkman" in the list, the name appeared about the time you first started posting about 9/11, but the petition's been active since 2004. That makes it even less likely to be the "real Malcolm Kirkman," rather than you. This is difficult to quantify, but it should cut the odds to worse that one million to one against.

Now, Malcolm, if 2. or 3. are true, what does it say about you that you would deliberately impersonate another "truther," or that you would use a pseudonym to sign important (from your perspective) petitions calling for a new investigation?

If 4. is true then, as noted, you've just been "having us on."

So, Malcolm, which is it?
 
Hoist with his own petard

For 'tis the sport to have the engineer
Hoist with his own petard: and 't shall go hard
But I will delve one yard below their mines,
And blow them at the moon: O, 'tis most sweet,


--William Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act III, Scene 4

The following is from Malcolm's OP:

4.
The law requires that the passengers on any flight, have the flight crew present themselves to the passengers, by standing by the entrance door. This is to reassure the passengers, that the crew are not hung over or worse.


When I posted a link to the FAA regulations in effect for airlines prior to September 11, 2001, and asked that Malcolm indicate the section where this is required, he responded to that and other requests to substantiate his highly questionable assertions by claiming that he'd seen the information on web sites, but had neglected to save links, and couldn't be bothered to look for them again.

Today I came across the following on PfT while researching another post. The thread was started by Malcolm on July 10, and entitled "Help, Pilots and booze." Bolding mine:

malcolm kirkman said:
I'm in a scrap with a load of deniers on the govt loyalist site. I've said that aircrew have to present themselves to the passengers as the passengers board a plane. I remember this from 30 years ago, to do with reassuring passengers that the pilots were sober etc.
Now I'm struggling for proof, can anybody help me ?


johndoeX said:
Hi Malcolm,

Unfortunately i cannot help you much because we sat up front getting the aircraft ready during turns. The only time we 'presented ourselves' to the pax was during announcements over the PA. Sometimes we stand at cockpit door to meet/greet or say good bye.. but it wasnt mandatory or policy or regulation.

Matter of fact, i know of quite a few times when pax would make joking comments asking or telling the pilots to not drink too much in flight at which point the policy was we would have to cancel the flight and get a breath test. But only if a pax made a comment as such. . . .

Since the AWA pilots (and a few others getting arrested) which caused an increase in 'comments' and subsequent cancellations, the policy has changed to hand the pax a briefing card that basically says "Are you joking with your comment? If not and you have a genuine concern that we may have been drinking or are going to drink during flight, we will have to cancel this flight and get a breath test".


malcolm kirkman said:
Thanks a lot for that. What about 30 years ago, early 70's. I was told then. Could that rule have been relaxed over the years? I hate to be wrong with these neocons.


Oceans Flow said:
Why do you even waste your time arguing with those people?


johndoeX said:
I hear ya Malcolm.. .but sometimes admitting when you're wrong goes a long way (even though the neocons will never admit when they're wrong and rub it in your face).

I started flying professionally since '96 and airline since 2000. The rule has always been as i described.. cant speak for any other time.


I've talked my way around it.
Why bother with them. I'm taking it to them.
Look at this, surely something can be done with this. The 'passengers' all worked for Boeing, Raytheon, Global Hawh etc.
Even Mrs Booth, who would have fingered the pentagon overflight was murdered.
Surely a pilot knows something about probability?
This is from a mug called 'Spitfire' (a right neocon). . . .


Here's a link to the Google cache of the thread.

It's late--for now I'll simply let the above speak for itself. I'll have some additional comments later.
 
It's difficult when people seem only to read their own posts.
There is a conflict of opinion as to where the nose of the 'plane' hit.
For the last time.
You can pick your spot.
Wherever you pick, you can't make a 757 fit. Not only can you not make it fit.

You can't even get it to break a window.
Put up any photo, name the spot and I'll show you.
I have said I don't mind dragging things out, because more and more 'floaters' or 'lurkers' are seeing the truth, but this is getting ridiculous.
It is important for me to convince the unbiased 'lurker', because once convinced that t9/11 was an inside job, then all the rest falls into line like a row of dominoes.

So MK is now Somerled? Excuse me for not knowing. :o

So is that [the bolded part] your "evidence or proof"? Ok, I find it unconvincing.
 
st
Would you point out an error I have made with regard to 9/11 being an inside job.


Yes, your first error is the absurd notion that the September 11th attacks were an "Inside Job", compounded by your original assertions about flight 175.

Let's just be realistic. Every statement you have made on these forums in regard to the events of that tragic day has provably been in error. Your persistence in maintaining your cozy shell of willful ignorance cannot in any way change the facts.
 
He-who-is-now-"Somerled" (my, he's aiming awful high, it'll be the burger franchise next!) has also acceded on several occasions to the suggestion that he lives in the same general area as his unfortunate former namesake, and although the length of the thread prevents me verifying this easily, I seem to remember some remark suggesting he lives in the Manchester area. (Certainly not in Armadale, whatever he's saying now.) Awful big coincidence, really....


On this forum, ask, and it shall be given unto you, apparently!

I think this may have been the post your had in mind, Rolfe:


Oh, I remember it now. It was while he was busy boasting about how much money he had. It was actually this exchange that started me getting a bit narked with him.

It went like this. I had enquired whether he actually had "loadsa dosh" or "a lorra dosh" (he had used both terms, and then quibbled about one or the other not being correct Northern usage), and, realising this was North of England slang, I was actually trying to verify that, horror of horrors, he was actually located on the same side of the Atlantic as me.

Mmm, how much approximately? (Waiting for the currency....)

And just who were you calling a Yank, exactly?


More than enough to buy your house outright. In a while, thanks to the nosedive of your FED controlled dollar, I'll have enough to buy all your houses from under y'all.

Where are you from?


I declined to answer, not feeling that possibly under 200 miles was quite enough distance, considering that Malcolm had a big fancy car that even adjusted its steering wheel height automatically when he got in (dammit, another post I can't find in the thread, but he did say it). And having just bought the house I'd had my eye on outright for £400,000, see thread in Community discussing the series of wild coincidences which led to me getting it, I was slightly narked by his assumption he could just buy it out from under me.

I don't know how come sleahead hit the target, but he did.

Are you from Manchester, Malcolm?


Manchester is close enough.


OK, we've seen that "Malcolm Kirkman" is certainly a Googlewhack in the UK Electoral Register. Judging by the results of an all-Net Google search, the name may well be a whole-world unique one, at least as regards individuals with an Internet presence. (Yes, I'd have put money on that not being the case, but there you go.)

We only have to check the hypothesis in www.912.com by entering "Malcolm Kirkman" and "Manchester" to discover that (Greater) Manchester is indeed where that genuine Malcolm Kirkman, the poor chap who lost his house to the Skipton Building Society in 1991, actually lives now. And we get his full current address, post code and telephone number.

Then we can check the house prices for the area, and even look at the location on Google maps, and see what it's like. If we feel inclined.

So that means we just need to suspect that you're the real Malcolm Kirkman, right, Malcolm? We don't need vetted evidence, do we?

Well, here's some more evidence anyway....

There are four possibilities:
  1. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and the real Malcolm Kirkman, by an astounding coincidence, is also a "truther."
  2. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen deliberately by you, in order to impersonate a known "truther" from the UK.
  3. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and you signed these two petitions using a false name.
  4. malcolm kirkman is your real name, and you're just "having us on."
.... snip discussion of relative probabilities ....

If 4. is true then, as noted, you've just been "having us on."

So, Malcolm, which is it?


With all due respect, Spitfire, I think it's simpler than that. He-who-is-now-Somerled says that he originally just dreamed up the name almost at random.

I didn't have the imagination to think of an animal or a machine (flying or otherwise). I chose what I thought was a rare name. It would appear not rare enough.


"Somerled" just happens to live in or near Manchester, as he told us back in the thread. He chooses a name at random. It turns out that the only person on the planet (that we can identify, haven't checked the jungles of Borneo) who really bears that name, just happens to live - in Greater Manchester.

Now is that or is that not more improbable than that stuff about the number of employees of a particular company who happened to be flying on certain flights on the morning of 11th September 2001?

Frankly, I wouldn't care. It's the lies that rankle.

Over 50 retired businessman with an honours degree in law, loadsa dosh, .... ce la vie.


And all the stuff about the flash expensive car and being able to buy our houses out from under us and so on. I don't think so, not with that financial history and that address.

There's no shame in being hard up, in having had a rough deal 15 years ago and losing your house and your job, or even in not having had a computer until six months ago. There's a lot of shame in posting a slew of boastful lies though, especially from someone whose entire campaign is so dedicated to the Truth.

Yes, Malcolm, we do know the truth when we read it. (In case he changes it, making that remark senseless, Malcolm's current sig. line is YOU KNOW THE TRUTH WHEN YOU READ IT.)

:id:

Rolfe.
 
Who is the "Mrs Booth" he refers to who "could have fingered the Pentagon overflight" but "was murdered"? I googled around and couldn't find anything that seems to fit. There was a woman named Booth who sadly perished aboard Flight 77 but I can't see how that would fit what he says (even in a truther's mindset).
 
st


Yes, your first error is the absurd notion that the September 11th attacks were an "Inside Job", compounded by your original assertions about flight 175.

Let's just be realistic. Every statement you have made on these forums in regard to the events of that tragic day has provably been in error. Your persistence in maintaining your cozy shell of willful ignorance cannot in any way change the facts.
Are these statements "in error"?
http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/129.html
 
What part of the path had been there for years did you not get? Why are you questioning what a path looks like for heavens sake?

As to the bolded questions above. Look at these photos very carefully. I'll be very upset if I have to point out the obvious...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/990246ab7b149783d.jpg[/qimg]
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/990246ab7b14bc5fa.jpg[/qimg]
What part of the path do I not get?
The part that goes through a wall for a start.
This is the genuine photo,
http://www.geoeye.com/gallery/9-11/P...gon_9_7_01.jpg
I remind you of the seven questions I left you with, not one of which you have answered.
 
So that means we just need to suspect that you're the real Malcolm Kirkman, right, Malcolm? We don't need vetted evidence, do we?

Well, here's some more evidence anyway.

The World Can't Wait




Justice for 9/11 Solidarity Petition




There are four possibilities:

  1. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and the real Malcolm Kirkman, by an astounding coincidence, is also a "truther."
  2. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen deliberately by you, in order to impersonate a known "truther" from the UK.
  3. malcolm kirkman is a pseudonym, chosen randomly by you, and you signed these two petitions using a false name.
  4. malcolm kirkman is your real name, and you're just "having us on."
The chance that 1. is true are at least one in a million against. There are about 44 million people on the UK electoral rolls; and 1-2 million eligible adults are not registered (these are easily verified via Google). So we'll say there are about 45 million Britons who could theoretically have "signed" the Justice for 9/11 petition. The petition currently has almost 15,000 "signatures"; checking 10 randomly selected pages shows about 2% of these are British. So about 300 Britons signed the petition. 300 divided by 45 million gives about one in 150,000. However, because "Malcolm Kirkman" doesn't capitalize the initial letters in his name, that makes it even less likely to be a coincidence, as you didn't capitalize the initial letters, either. Checking the same page shows 17 non-capitalizations of names, so we can fairly safely assume that fewer than one in five signers didn't capitalize their names. 150,000 * 5 = 750,000, so we're up to one in 3/4 million. Also, from the position of "malcolm kirkman" in the list, the name appeared about the time you first started posting about 9/11, but the petition's been active since 2004. That makes it even less likely to be the "real Malcolm Kirkman," rather than you. This is difficult to quantify, but it should cut the odds to worse that one million to one against.

Now, Malcolm, if 2. or 3. are true, what does it say about you that you would deliberately impersonate another "truther," or that you would use a pseudonym to sign important (from your perspective) petitions calling for a new investigation?

If 4. is true then, as noted, you've just been "having us on."

So, Malcolm, which is it?
You're so clever, you tell me.
You can tip up your own real name at the same time.
 
--William Shakespeare, Hamlet, Act III, Scene 4

The following is from Malcolm's OP:




When I posted a link to the FAA regulations in effect for airlines prior to September 11, 2001, and asked that Malcolm indicate the section where this is required, he responded to that and other requests to substantiate his highly questionable assertions by claiming that he'd seen the information on web sites, but had neglected to save links, and couldn't be bothered to look for them again.

Today I came across the following on PfT while researching another post. The thread was started by Malcolm on July 10, and entitled "Help, Pilots and booze." Bolding mine:



















Here's a link to the Google cache of the thread.

It's late--for now I'll simply let the above speak for itself. I'll have some additional comments later.
Talking about PilotsRus how about this,
Impossible to Prove a Falsehood True

by George Nelson
Colonel, USAF (ret.)

The precautionary principle is based on the fact that its impossible to prove a false claim to be true. Failure to prove a false premise true does not automatically make it false but caution is called for, especially in the case of a world-changing event like the alleged terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 . After five long years, our government has provided the public with no physical evidence to support its claim that the attacks were the work of Muslim terrorists, or even that the identity of the aircraft that struck their targets on September 11 was the same as those specified in the 9/11 Commission's report. As explained below, it would be a simple matter to confirm the identity of each of the four aircraft, and until such physical proof of identity is forthcoming, no conclusions can be scientifically drawn to support the official story as being accurate. This is a precaution against rushing to judgment. At this point, it could just as easily be assumed that the 911 hijackings were part of a black operation carried out with full cooperation of elements within our own government.
 
I've come here from the IV thread in SMMT. All I can say is: WTF?
In a nutshell, 9/11 was an inside job. The four 'hijacks' were the cover story.
The real attacks were two unmanned jets from Offutt. The Pentagon was a flyover. At the moment I am showing that no 757 hit the Pentagon.
Welcome, I hope you are here with some objectivity and are not a 'rotten fruit' thrower.
 
Webfairy and Killtown - yeah that's a surefire way to boost your credibility here.................................not.
Malcolm, the line had been there for years prior to 9/11. Russell from Pentagonresearch.com debunked this idiocy months ago....

This is why I love the tw00f movement. AS Perry would say, no two troofers have the same theory.


CTer#1 - That line on the lawn on Sep 7 2001 is a smoking gun that there was some sort of missile guidance system there.

CTer#2 - No, it was a visual cue for the drone flyover pilot.

CTer#3- That picture was actually photoshopped, the date was altered and the Pentagon was airbrushed on there. They want you to think the white line was there for years. It was missile exhaust!

CTer#4 - The line was there for years, the NWO planned this well in advance.

CTer#5 - The line had been there for years, you guys are disinfo.....




BTW - what sort of missile would leave a white mark in the grass? The grass would be burned(black), right? Think. Please.

Webfairy and Killtown are two out of millions.
Here's one more,
http://willienelsonpri.com/peace/46/false-flag-operations-and-fake-terror.html
 
Loose Change actually posited that the worn area was a faint marking to guide the plane to that spot (wait...what plane???), as if the giant "H" or an instruction such as "hit the west side" wouldn't have sufficed if that was what the NWO wanted.
So what?
Are you saying it was a path?
 
[newbie delurk]
At the moment the link seems not to be working, and I believe a comment about the file's name was already noted upthread... (*curses* can't even quote the url at the moment...)
The file name of the photo is a date three days prior to 9/11. If it's not a well-tread path - which it seems clearly to be - then what would account for it being "scorched white"? Any scorching (maybe a lot darker, but not "white") will not have happened for another three days.
[/newbie delurk]
Allow me to refer you to post 3352 and the questions therein.
Here is the photo again,
http://www.geoeye.com/gallery/9-11/Pentagon/Pentagon_9_7_01.jpg
 
I've come here from the IV thread in SMMT. All I can say is: WTF?

In a nutshell, 9/11 was an inside job. The four 'hijacks' were the cover story.
The real attacks were two unmanned jets from Offutt. The Pentagon was a flyover. At the moment I am showing that no 757 hit the Pentagon.
Welcome, I hope you are here with some objectivity and are not a 'rotten fruit' thrower.


He's being modest, Taffer. He has also proven conclusively that gravity does not exist inside a television cathode ray tube, there is no such thing as a transitive verb, IV bags are all pressurized, and flight crews are required by law to greet the passengers so their sobriety can be assessed.

The list goes on and on.
 
The sad thing is, on current form Malcolm will either completely ignore this, or shrug it off as a minor point which doesn't affect his argument. Or maybe he'll say he changed his mind, as he did after he was called on his offer to donate $1,000 to charity if he was wrong about something else. Or perhaps he'll just put it down to poetic license.

There isn't a clue bat big enough or heavy enough to get through to Malcolm. The possibility that since he's been arrogantly wrong about this point (actually about lots of points, this is just one of the ones where he's been blatantly shot down), he might be wrong about a lot of other things he thinks are so, won't even enter his head.

Oh, and he still hasn't explained how it even counts as "poetic license" to declare that all hijackers or potential hijackers weigh only six stones. I still don't follow that one. He doesn't believe there were any hijackers, and one of the reasons there weren't is that all hijackers are only six stones in weight, so of course they can't succeed. And that's why they don't try, so there aren't any. :nope:

Rolfe.

I'm an iggerant Yank, so I had to look up "stone" as a measure of weight. Wiki says 14 pounds. That would make the hijackers the original 98-pound weaklings, no?

(I don't think I've weighed less than 100 since I was maybe, six. And I'm a girl-person).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom