The judgement SpitfireIX found was actually the result of a hearing for leave to appeal an earlier judgement. At the end we discover that leave to appeal was indeed granted, but I for one don't know the outcome of that appeal, or even whether it happened at all.
It's a long and involved story, starting over seven years before the hearing.
February 1991
The plaintiff took out a mortgage with the Skipton Building Society, for £117,000. This seems not to have been for a newly-purchased home, but a remortgage of an existing home, with the plaintiff having been persuaded to switch from his previous building society (the Abbey National) because the Skipton would give him "cheaper and better insurance". There were two snags to this.
First, his house wasn't actually worth as much as £117,000. It's very unusual for a building society to grant a mortgage for an amount higher than the value of the property securing it, but this was only a few years after the great property price crash which started in August 1988, and quite a lot of people had mortgages (taken out before the crash) for more than their houses were then worth. Skipton BS may have felt it was a reasonable risk to take on a remortgage of such a property.
Second, the insurance seems to have turned into a problem.
At this point the plaintiff seems to have been quite a well-to-do chap. We forget now, when houses have soared again in value, but in 1991, £117,000 (or even £83,00, which is what it sold for after repossession) wasn't exactly a starter home, especially in Lancashire. Not only that, but for a single person to take out a mortgage of that amount (there's no mention of its being a joint mortgage with a wife or partner), he was probably earning perhaps £30,000 per annum or more - a very good salary at that time. As I said, it's a sad story.
25th February 1991
The plaintiff paid his first monthly mortgage installment (of £1,452, which was a lot in 1991).
26th February 1991
The plaintiff paid the first premium for the mortgage protection (insurance) policy, which was set up to pay his mortgage repayments for a maximum of a year (but excluding the first two months of any disability) if he became totally disabled and unable to carry on his work because of injury or illness. This was probably part of the £1,452.
21st March 1991
The plaintiff made his second mortgage repayment. This was the last one he ever made.
April 1991 (presumably)
Something happened which led the plaintiff to claim on that insurance. So, he believed he was so sick or injured that he could no longer carry on his work, and so the insurance policy would pay out.
Early May 1991
The plaintiff submitted a claim on the insurance policy, to the Skipton BS. They passed that claim to the underwriters, Guardian Royal Exchange.
14th May 1991
Guardian Royal Exchange informed the plaintiff that he was liable for the repayments relating to the first two months of his disability, and in any case he should keep paying the mortgage until they advised him to the contrary. They said they would make enquiries to verify that his claim was valid.
Of course, any insurance company is going to look very suspiciously at a claim on a total disability mortgage protection policy which has been taken out only two months earlier. There would inevitably be requests for medical records, and medical examinations and that sort of thing. It seems that GRE decided the claim wasn't valid, because it's clear that they never paid out on it, and the judge does make reference to what would have happened "if his claim had been a correct one", implying that in fact it wasn't.
It appears that this was the core of the disagreement between the plaintiff and the Skipton BS - that he had been persuaded to change to them, and remortgage with them, because their insurance was "cheaper and better", but when he made a claim on that insurance it turned out that it didn't cover whatever it was he had believed it did.
In spite of the GRS's instructions, the plaintiff did not keep paying his mortgage, in fact it appears that he didn't pay anything at all after the occurrence which led to his claiming on the insurance.
13th June 1991
Skipton BS informed the plaintiff that his mortgage account was over £4,000 in arrears, and that if he didn't pay this in the next week, they would start repossession proceedings. However, they didn't do anything immediately, and the mortgage installments went on not being paid.
October 1991
Some sort of conversation occurred between the plaintiff and a representative of the building society.
17th October 1991
The plaintiff, following on from this conversation, voluntarily surrendered his property to the building society, sending them the keys to the house in the post.
This is the second part of the plaintiff's case. He seems to have in effect decided to wash his hands of the whole thing, and handed back the keys in a spirit of, "well, take the house then, and we're quits." However, he couldn't prove to the court that the building society had accepted the keys on this basis. It's extremely unlikely that any building society would agree to such a deal, certainly not without the intervention of mediators and financial advisors arguing strenuously on behalf of the defaulting debtor. However, it seems to have been in this plaintiff's character that he thought he could just surrender the house and that would be that, notwithstanding that the house probably could not be sold for the full value of his debt - which would of course have been growing over the past seven months.
This was in fact an extremely unwise course of action. People who get into mortgage difficulties are always advised, above all else, to try to avoid repossession. Properties sold as mortgage repossessions always make substantially less than properties sold in the usual way by an owner-occupier. The sensible course of action would have been to seek assistance from somewhere like the Citizens' Advice Bureau, who can help sort out problems like this by staving off the building society for a while, rescheduling repayments, facilitating the sale of the property without repossession, and at least maximising the debtor's remaining assets in order to minimise the resulting indebtedness. However, it seems the plaintiff didn't do that.
Later (probably that same year or early in 1992)
The building society sold the house for only £83,000. By the time the dust had settled, with fees and interest and so on, this was over £56,000 short of the sum the plaintiff actually owed.
For whatever reason, it took the building society nearly five years to get round to chasing up that money.
Fast forward to....
12 June 1996
Skipton Building Society served the plaintiff with a statutory demand for £56,000. This is the first step towards initiating bankruptcy proceedings, if the debt in question is not paid.
5th July 1996
The plaintiff applied to have that demand set aside (that made him the plaintiff, and is the reason why his name comes first in the court documents).
31st July 1996
The application was dismissed on all grounds. It appears that the plaintiff was representing himself (and we all know what they say about people who do that!), and "lacked the ability to explain the matter so that the judge could understand it."
The plaintiff then appealed to the High Court, which seems to have given rise to considerable procedural difficulties, apparently again due to the fact that he was representing himself and did not have legal advice.
15th September 1996
The plaintiff's appeal was dismissed, and he was refused leave to appeal this decision.
Fast forward again, presumably over quite a lot of legal wrangling, with the plaintiff still representing himself without legal advice.
24th April 1998, Royal Courts of Justice, London
The plaintiff's appeal against the refusal of leave to appeal was heard. This is the hearing which relates to the document SpitfireIX linked to. The plaintiff once again represented himself, and the judgement paints a picture of a judge bending over backwards to give an almost incoherent litigant-in-person a break. In the end he decided that buried in the plaintiff's involved explanations, there was the kernel of a point which was proper to be considered by the court.
This seems to have been that the plaintiff claimed he was only two months in arrears when the house was repossessed, because after the initial two months of his disability (which he agreed he defaulted on) they should have made sure they got paid by the insurance company, because they had represented to him that he would be covered by insurance. And that if he only owed two months mortgage payments, it was very unlikely any court would have granted repossession. (At this point the unseen audience rises as one and yells, so why did you give them back the keys then??)
The question of whether the building society accepted the house in full and final settlement doesn't seem to have come into it at this point, possibly because the plaintiff had no proof of his contention that they did, or possibly because, if the preceding point were to be upheld, then the latter point would become moot.
The judge, "having heard him address this court", strongly advised the plaintiff to get himself a solicitor, otherwise he didn't have a hope in hell of winning the appeal. However, this is all that is vouchsafed to us, and if he did appeal, and if so whether or not it was successful, I have no idea.
If the appeal was sucessful, then the plaintiff may only have had to pay just under £3,000 to the building society (two months mortgage payments). However, if he lost (or if the appeal didn't happen), then it's likely he was made bankrupt.
There's a lot of this story we don't know. Was it just lousy luck that illness or injury struck the plaintiff only two months after he'd changed his mortgage lender? What actually happened and how bad was it? Why was it that the insurance policy didn't in fact cover this eventuality, and what exactly were "the difficulties he encountered" during all this which had not been brought to his notice? Why, if he felt he had a fair case, did he decide to send the keys of his house to the building society six months later? Why did he seek neither financial nor legal advice?
In many ways it seems that the plaintiff was his own worst enemy, failing to obtain advice when repossession proceedings were initiated, throwing his keys at the building society and imagining that would end the matter even though the proceeds of the sale of the house wouldn't cover his debt, and electing to represent himself through at least three court hearings (very badly, by all accounts). From the judgement we've read, it seems that he did have at least the kernel of an arguable case. However, this should have been recognised and properly argued at the first opportunity when the building society first started proceedings, not after a voluntary surrender of the property and further complications.
Nevertheless, wherever the fault lay, this does look like a very sad decline, from being able to afford a fairly nice house and a mortgage many would have regarded as eye-popping for the time and the area, to no house and no job, and possibly a disability as well. And that's even if he won the appeal! I do feel sorry for the plaintiff.