[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you want to liken your heart and your mind to stony ground, I won't dispute you, but I think you're being unnecessarily hard on yourself. The entire world was once stony ground, and no one is born wise. The fertile soil that nourishes civilized thought does not appear overnight. Give it some time.

In any case, I'm not speaking to you alone. You know only a tiny fraction of the ground my words are falling upon.




Yes, they are innocents. But they are not "the innocents" to the exclusion of everyone else. That is a false choice fallacy. Their innocence doesn't make everyone else guilty.

Whenever someone makes false accusations (even if they believe them to be true), they create new innocent victims and they aid the real perpetrators and their cause.

That's one reason why older wiser people are very cautious making accusations. They know the terrible harm done by false accusations and they do not want such painful consequences to be inflicted on innocent people. This is known as compassion. They also don't want to live with having been responsible for such harm. This is known as conscience. People sometimes develop these characteristics (as with other aspects of wisdom) with age and experience.




I'm not asking you to prove anyone. I'm just reminding you that if you fail to prove it, you do not, and should not, get your wish for retribution.




This list has not convinced older, wiser people of your case. Possibly because some of the items on the list directly contradict people's own personal experience, so they know they're false.

So what, you say? That can only be the case for a few items on the list, leaving plenty of smoking guns remaining?

No. A responsible prosecutor does not get to lie about ANY of the evidence. Making mistakes is inevitable and excusable, but making no effort to correct mistakes is fatal to credibility. Prosecutor caught lying = case dismissed. Truthers lose all credibility when, like the metaphorical monkey with its hand caught in the jar of nuts, they will not let go of any accusation no matter how worthless.




I agree that my loyalty should be (and is) to the Constitution, first and foremost. Funny you should point this out though, considering your subsequent statements.




Yes, this privilege is known as my Constitutional right to free speech. I treasure it highly.




Thank you for warning me that evil people are planning to attempt to revoke my right to free speech. Can you be more specific about who these reprehensible Constitution-hating thugs might be?




Please be more specific regarding the danger you believe he's in. Who is plotting to take away his right to be uncertain about what happened on 9/11? The U.S. government? Or perhaps the same evil bullying wannabe-thought-police who are plotting "moves afoot" to take away my right to free speech?




I cannot answer any question "as a denier" because I do not regard myself as any sort of denier. I accept whatever conclusions the evidence leads to.

Respectfully,
Myriad
Kindly consider this photo, do you see material going UP.
If so, can you kindly explain to me how material goes UP, without being BLOWN UP ?
1%257E4.jpg
 
Edited by Darat: 
Moderated Thread

It's to do with Pythagoras's theorem.
The hypotenuse is 163 ft because the side is 125 and the opposite angle 50 degrees.


What Malcolm is trying to say is that there should be damage along an area of 163 ft of the Pentagon wall because the plane struck at a 50 deg. angle.

impact757-2.gif



However, this is only true if the wings stayed in exactly the same position relative to the fuselage until they struck the wall, and I'm not certain that was the case. They could have folded forward due to their failing after the nose struck the fuselage. I'll see if I can find any more information on that.
 
Edited by Darat: 
Moderated Thread

It's to do with Pythagoras's theorem.
The hypotenuse is 163 ft because the side is 125 and the opposite angle 50 degrees.

Ah, HA! there's your trouble. it's NOT a right triangle. the wingspan is 125 ft, and will never be greater that 125 ft. if you rotate the wing 50 degrees around one end at the wingtip, the other end doesn't move in a straight line, it would move IN AN ARC. part of a circle with a radius of the wingspan.

Think it through. If you had a one foot long ruler, held it by one end, and rotated it 50 degrees, would it suddenly be longer than one foot? it would be the same length as it always would, and the other end would move through a 50 degree arc. rotate it all the way through 360 degrees, and the other end would move trace out a circle, not a square.

I don't know what got edited out by the moderator, but if you owe me an apology I expect you to do the honorable thing.
 
Edited by Darat: 
Moderated Thread

It's to do with Pythagoras's theorem.
The hypotenuse is 163 ft because the side is 125 and the opposite angle 50 degrees.

Know what? Ignore my last post. It took a moment, but I see what you are saying now. the physics is going to be hellishly complicated in the few miliseconds after the initial impact, so it's probably not going to be the 163 ft you calculate, but I understand where you got the number from now.
 
It makes sense to me that military transports are both reinforced and armoured in places other than the cockpit. A designer would be clearly remiss in doing nothing to counteract the ability of an RPG to take down a troop transport about to land.
The purpose of a transport aircraft is to transport, not fight. You don't fly them into places where they might get shot at unless you absolutely have to. You let combat aircraft do the fighting.

Armour is heavy. And aircraft design is all about the interplay between power and weight. The heavier you make the aircraft, the more power you need to get it airborne and the more fuel it's going to consume. Heavier aircraft generally are also less maneuverable.

The Japanese Zero of WWII, for example, sacrificed armour and self-sealing fuel tanks so as to keep weight down and maximize maneuverability. American fighter designs instead emphasized protection and included armour. Note though that that armour was only used in certain places; a large armour plate was used behind the pilot (since most attacks were from the rear quarter), the front window of the cockpit used armoured glass, and some armour was used to protect the engine in some designs; the rest of the fighter though was just a thin aluminum skin.

Ship designs exhibit similar tendancies. Do you think something like an Iowa class battleship had armour everywhere? They didn't. The armour was concentrated into an armour belt running along the waterline, the main gun turrets, and the main deck; the rest of the ship was essentially unarmoured. This was the "all-or-nothing" approach: use maximum armour to protect the most important parts, and nothing anywhere else. The reason for this was the weight involved; armouring all parts of a battleship would require a lot of armour and thus a lot of weight, and more weight meant less space internally for propulsion, crew spaces, fuel storage, magazines, and so forth. Using armour only where deemed absolutely necessary saved weight.

Weight is an even more critical factor for aircraft than for ships.
 
The purpose of a transport aircraft is to transport, not fight. You don't fly them into places where they might get shot at unless you absolutely have to. You let combat aircraft do the fighting.

Armour is heavy. And aircraft design is all about the interplay between power and weight. The heavier you make the aircraft, the more power you need to get it airborne and the more fuel it's going to consume. Heavier aircraft generally are also less maneuverable.

The Japanese Zero of WWII, for example, sacrificed armour and self-sealing fuel tanks so as to keep weight down and maximize maneuverability. American fighter designs instead emphasized protection and included armour. Note though that that armour was only used in certain places; a large armour plate was used behind the pilot (since most attacks were from the rear quarter), the front window of the cockpit used armoured glass, and some armour was used to protect the engine in some designs; the rest of the fighter though was just a thin aluminum skin.

Ship designs exhibit similar tendancies. Do you think something like an Iowa class battleship had armour everywhere? They didn't. The armour was concentrated into an armour belt running along the waterline, the main gun turrets, and the main deck; the rest of the ship was essentially unarmoured. This was the "all-or-nothing" approach: use maximum armour to protect the most important parts, and nothing anywhere else. The reason for this was the weight involved; armouring all parts of a battleship would require a lot of armour and thus a lot of weight, and more weight meant less space internally for propulsion, crew spaces, fuel storage, magazines, and so forth. Using armour only where deemed absolutely necessary saved weight.

Weight is an even more critical factor for aircraft than for ships.
We will have to agree to differ on this.
If, God forbid, the Iraqui's blow all the bridges and roads around Baghdad, how would the garrison there be reinforced?
These lessons have been known for a long time. For example, the Germans lost 1,000 junkers trying to reinforce Stalingrad.
That's just one possible scenario and one real example out of many. You can't possibly say that transports will never find themselves in harms way.
In conclusion, I can do no more than refer you to my previous post.
 
You really think you are "breaking the necocon stranglehold" by posting on an Internet forum? Well if the neocons are reading this, I'm sure they are now popping open another bottle of Dom Perignon.

As for myself, I'm one of a growing number high school teachers who have made it our mission to not brainwash our students regarding 9/11 but to teach them to be critical thinkers in regard to FACTS and SCIENCE.

Over the past 5 years not one of my 800 students has believed that 9/11 was "an inside job" after they themselves conducted research. I've got about 15 more years until I retire, that's about another 2,500 students...multiple that by the hundreds of other educators who are teaching similiar curricula in NYC and across the U.S. and hundreds of thousands of young people will learn the truth behind your lies.

Before you and your ilk get back to your important job of voting on Internet polls, here's an example of the type of lesson I'm talking about:



Linky: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1568480-5,00.html
Does it now follow, that you yourself have done your own research and concluded that the govt version is correct?
 
Your platitudes are falling on stony ground.
The innocents in this matter are the office workers who were allowed to go to work that morning, allowed to go to their deaths, inside a waiting to explode, giant bomb. Then there are the firemen and police who were also allowed to go to their deaths in guaranteed to fail rescue attempts.
The guilty are megalomaniacs on steroids such as Rumsfeld who predicted the attack on the twins before it happened and then predicted the attack on the Pentagon moments before that happened.
He even, the day before 9/11, clearly knowing what was coming off, announced that the Pentagon had lost $2.3 trillion.



Fetzer's hopeless fabrications about the imaginary "missing" 2.3 trillion doillars was laughed at by most conspiracy liars. Is there any nonsense you won't swallow uncritically. I mean, you simply must be able to filter out some of the fantastic idiocy the fantasists invent.



People keep asking me for references. Prove this, prove that.
Here is one page of one website, with all the references and proof you need.
I don't know your motives for constant denial. Being kind, you may be blindly loyal and mistaken in the direction of that loyalty. Your loyalty should be to the Constitution, first and foremost.
At the moment, you have the luxury of constant denial without facing accusations of being an accessory after the fact. You should know that there are moves afoot to alter that state of affairs. This clean up won't necessarily begin at the top. It can equally begin at the bottom.
Only recently a newspaper reporter said to me,
"Does anyone really know what happened on 9/11"? He said it in a bored manner. I couldn't be bothered to tell him, that he was skating on thin ice.
What's it matter to me, whether or not his ice breaks.
Let me ask you quite candidly,
As a denier, do the following 250 facts raise any doubts whatsoever in your mind?
http://killtown.911review.org/911smokingguns.html
Before answering me, will you kindly confirm that you have considered all the points raised on the webpage?

Killtown is an embarrassment even to the conspiracy liars themselves. He has been banned from many fantasist sites. You cite his rubbish on a rationalist forum?!?
 
Know what? Ignore my last post. It took a moment, but I see what you are saying now. the physics is going to be hellishly complicated in the few miliseconds after the initial impact, so it's probably not going to be the 163 ft you calculate, but I understand where you got the number from now.

Now you agree (in part), perhaps you can point out the 163 or so ft scar along the face of the Pentagon?
 
What Malcolm is trying to say is that there should be damage along an area of 163 ft of the Pentagon wall because the plane struck at a 50 deg. angle.

[qimg]http://perso.orange.fr/jpdesm/pentagon/damage/impact757-2.gif[/qimg]


However, this is only true if the wings stayed in exactly the same position relative to the fuselage until they struck the wall, and I'm not certain that was the case. They could have folded forward due to their failing after the nose struck the fuselage. I'll see if I can find any more information on that.
How far forward would they have folded travelling at 500 mph ?
 
Know what? Ignore my last post. It took a moment, but I see what you are saying now. the physics is going to be hellishly complicated in the few miliseconds after the initial impact, so it's probably not going to be the 163 ft you calculate, but I understand where you got the number from now.
Are you going to do the physics ?
 
You raise a number of worthy points. You also imply that you are older and wiser than I.
Would you mind if I establish a few markers as to your wisdom.
Are you aware of the legal term,
"Knew or ought to have known" ?
Also, people are entitled to make mistakes. A prosecutor is allowed to make mistakes, without all his evidence being declared void. It happens all the time. A jury makes it's decision after considering ALL the evidence.
It is therefore without standing that you can dismiss all the 250 points raised by the one webpage.
So, I ask you again, Do any of the 250 points raise any questions in your mind or not ?

You seem determined to change the subject to the reiteration of arguments about evidence that have already been discussed here in hundreds of threads as well as addressed by the numerous resources linked in Gravysites and other links readily available here.

I might be interested in revisiting some of these points, but before doing so, I'd like to resolve your warning about the imminent change in the existing "state of affairs" that currently allows me to voice my opinion about what the 9/11 evidence shows without fear of malicious prosecution on the absurd pretext of "accessory after the fact." Please, tell me who you believe is planning to effect such an attack, and how are they planning to go about it? I will do all I can to oppose them, but I need the information you appear to have about the nature of the threat in order to do so effectively.

Wisdom (unlike intelligence quotient) is neither defined nor measured by tests. Whether or not I am older or wiser than you (I have indeed implied so, but any positive claim i could make would be limited to stating that it is extremely likely as best I can determine from the available evidence) is irrelevant to the points that as long as civilized society holds sway you must convince people who are evidently older and wiser than yourself in order to win retribution, and that vengeance is an unworthy and counterproductive goal in any case. Rather than "markers," I suggest readers rely on the evidence of the posts that we each have contributed to this site to gauge our relative maturity, range of real-world experience, and depth of moral understanding.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Kindly consider this photo, do you see material going UP.
If so, can you kindly explain to me how material goes UP, without being BLOWN UP ?
[qimg]http://www.sharpprintinginc.com/911/Photo%20archives/towers%20falling/1%257E4.jpg[/qimg]


Is this a trick question? Or are you really asking me to measure motion from a still photograph?

In the photo I see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to usually go up. That, of course, is the smoke. I also see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to usually go down. That is, the larger debris. I also see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to hang in the air and move with the air currents or very slowly downward. That is, the dust.

I do see streaks of dust that appear to angle upward from near the center of the image. These could, in theory, be plumes of heavy material ejected upward. But they could also be plumes of lighter material ejected sideways, from a source that was itself moving downward, or even material ejected with horizontal and downward components to its velocity, from a source that was itself moving more rapidly downward. So I must ask myself, "Self, does that image show any large dust-ejecting object that is moving rapidly downward?" And sure enough, right in the center of the image, if you look very closely, there appears to be a collapsing building. Aha!

The second question, of what other than explosions can cause material to move up, must remain purely hypothetical until it's shown that material other than smoke -- or dust entrained in the smoke's convective flow -- is indeed moving up. A time series graph of measured positions of particles of the material would be preferable, but a video might suffice. While we're waiting for that evidence, perhaps you might want to think about the question yourself. Can materials move against the pull of gravity without having been propelled by explosions, and if so, what are some of the mechanisms that can cause it to happen?

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Killtown is an embarrassment even to the conspiracy liars themselves. He has been banned from many fantasist sites. You cite his rubbish on a rationalist forum?!?
I would hardly descibe someone who answers his own posts as 'rational'.
Is calling Killtown names, your way of avoiding answering the questions he raises ?
Kindly answer my previous questions. I'll roll them all into one for you,
Are you calling voters who demand a proper investigation of 9/11,
"Liars". "Ignoramuses","an ignorant lynch mob" and now, talking "rubbish" ?
 
Is this a trick question? Or are you really asking me to measure motion from a still photograph?

In the photo I see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to usually go up. That, of course, is the smoke. I also see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to usually go down. That is, the larger debris. I also see material that, based on previous experience, I would expect to hang in the air and move with the air currents or very slowly downward. That is, the dust.

I do see streaks of dust that appear to angle upward from near the center of the image. These could, in theory, be plumes of heavy material ejected upward. But they could also be plumes of lighter material ejected sideways, from a source that was itself moving downward, or even material ejected with horizontal and downward components to its velocity, from a source that was itself moving more rapidly downward. So I must ask myself, "Self, does that image show any large dust-ejecting object that is moving rapidly downward?" And sure enough, right in the center of the image, if you look very closely, there appears to be a collapsing building. Aha!

The second question, of what other than explosions can cause material to move up, must remain purely hypothetical until it's shown that material other than smoke -- or dust entrained in the smoke's convective flow -- is indeed moving up. A time series graph of measured positions of particles of the material would be preferable, but a video might suffice. While we're waiting for that evidence, perhaps you might want to think about the question yourself. Can materials move against the pull of gravity without having been propelled by explosions, and if so, what are some of the mechanisms that can cause it to happen?

Respectfully,
Myriad
You say a video might suffice. Here's a couple,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-n3XOb3uAQ&mode=related&search=
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xq1gpC7QqeM&mode=related&search=
There's plenty more where where these came from.
 
I would hardly descibe someone who answers his own posts as 'rational'.
Is calling Killtown names, your way of avoiding answering the questions he raises ?
Kindly answer my previous questions. I'll roll them all into one for you,
Are you calling voters who demand a proper investigation of 9/11,
"Liars". "Ignoramuses","an ignorant lynch mob" and now, talking "rubbish" ?


Isn't this just a distraction from your argument? If he is calling them that, will it change your facts, your proof, or your speculations one iota? No? Then why give a crap about it, I wonder?
 
We will have to agree to differ on this.


You can think what you want, but you thinking it won't change reality.



If, God forbid, the Iraqui's blow all the bridges and roads around Baghdad, how would the garrison there be reinforced?

Ha ha. Please tell me you're not serious.



These lessons have been known for a long time. For example, the Germans lost 1,000 junkers trying to reinforce Stalingrad.


According to the Russians about 670 Ju-52s were shot down or destroyed trying to resupply the 6th Army.



That's just one possible scenario and one real example out of many. You can't possibly say that transports will never find themselves in harms way.
In conclusion, I can do no more than refer you to my previous post.


Transports do, rarely, find themselves in harm's way. An RNZAF C-130H Hercules cracked its main wing spar avoiding an Iraqi SAM which was fired at it in the first Gulf War. The reality, nonetheless, is that transport aircraft are not armoured, and indeed, aircraft in general are seldom armoured in this day and age. The only armoured aircraft I know of are the A-10 and numerous variants of helicopter.

The way tactical airlift aircraft deal with hostile landing zones is to perform what's called a Tactical Landing:



and if that fails, there's always counter-measures:



-Gumboot
 
What Malcolm is trying to say is that there should be damage along an area of 163 ft of the Pentagon wall because the plane struck at a 50 deg. angle.

[qimg]http://perso.orange.fr/jpdesm/pentagon/damage/impact757-2.gif[/qimg]


However, this is only true if the wings stayed in exactly the same position relative to the fuselage until they struck the wall, and I'm not certain that was the case. They could have folded forward due to their failing after the nose struck the fuselage. I'll see if I can find any more information on that.
Would you also kindly confirm the following two facts,
Here in this photo, you can clearly see the outline of the wings where they have cut through steel. All the posters on here have spent much time insisting that aluminium wings can go through most anything when travelling at 500mph.
Now show me the scar caused by the wings across the face of the Pentagon in the seventh photo on this webpage.
http://911review.org/Wiki/snopespentagonrumor.html
holescompared500.jpg
 
Isn't this just a distraction from your argument? If he is calling them that, will it change your facts, your proof, or your speculations one iota? No? Then why give a crap about it, I wonder?
He is calling voters all these names, why ?
I am entitled to conclude that he can't answer these points any other way.
Perhaps you can do better, would you like to try ?
Here are the points, kindly answer them,
http://killtown.911review.org/911smokingguns.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom