[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
At the Pentagon the plane went through exactly ONE blast resistant wall and a few parts punched through one other exterior wall of normal, non-blast resistant, wall.

But then you know that since it has been pointed out many times on many websites and was even pointed out a few posts back in this very thread.
I refer you to my previous post, in particular the meaning of the word RICOCHET.
 
I had to laugh at this one. Especially, Yet the Purdue statement says nothing about damage. So the whole paragraph is bogus. Then they re-iterate your claim.
Please explain this:[qimg]http://learner.org/exhibits/weather/images/pic_capt2.gif[/qimg] So a vinyl record can embed itself into a telephone pole at 300 mph, yet aluminum alloy and titanium can't cut through light steel at 490? Yeah, great logic there.

This is just a re-iteration of the first one, so it's not a valid debunk.
Look at the source. Nick Irving is an audio engineer. Yeah, so much more qualified than the structural engineers of Purdue. So again, no debunking here either. So again, please post links to where the Purdue simulation is actually debunked.
Purdue contradicts NIST, they can''t both be right.
 
---

Hi Malcolm, Everyone:

Max here.

Forgive me for interrupting the flow for just a moment.

I have read zero of Malcolm's work, except for his very first post on this thread.

Readers of this thread my be interested in the JREF thread I started:

The aluminum of Flights 11 & 175 was used to create phreato-thermatic explosions


My research findings are consistent with some of Malcolm's assertions (if I understand him correctly):


- I am virtually certain Flight 175 was flown into WTC2 by remote guidance.


- The "Flight 175" that hit the towers fired at least one (I suspect two) projectiles.

Note that this is consistent with Malcolm's assertion that the "Flight 175" that hit WTC2 was not a commercial jet.


- When Flight 175 hit WTC2, the aluminum from the jet was used to engineer a spectacular phreato-thermatic explosion. (That is the topic of the above link.)

This too is consistent with Flight 175 not being a commercial jet. (Ifi it were a commercial jet, it at least had to be modified.)


I hope this is helpful.

Max

---
I am most grateful to you for your most welcome interuption and I am most interested in your findings.
I mentioned in a recent post that most truthers stop 'investigating' once they find themselves overwhelmed with the evidence of an inside job.
I am confident that deeper investigating will uncover even more truth.
For example, I didn't know when I started this thread, that the engine from the plane that hit tower two, landed in the street and would have serial numbers on it.
Neither did I know that the odds of so many people connected to Raytheon, Boeing and Global Hawk, who were amongst the dead 'pssengers', reached the 'astronomical' level of probability or maybe I should say improbability.
That's what you get when you deal with the truth, it just keeps coming on.
I have my hands full at the moment simply asserting that the plane that hit tower two was NOT flight 175, any further evidence you have towards that end will be most gratefully received.
Once again, thank you for your most timely and welcomed interuption.
 
No, Malcolm, you are incapable of comprehending that ignoramuses making up nonsense aren't debunking anything.




In five years of screaming, conspiracy liars have produced bogus science, shamelessly distorted first-responder quotes, and a blizzard of outright lies.

What are the fantasists "bringing" to the rationalists?

You have persisted through sixty-five pages making absurd, baseless claims and being caught in a huge number of mistakes and falsehoods.

How can blind, fact-free, agenda-driven dishonesty turn the tide against reason and evidence?
Are the 84 % of americans who want a proper investigation of 9/11 'ignoramuses'?
 
How many walls did the plane go through?

Do you include gypsium walls or just brick ones ?

You will not adhere to the doctrine of a pre-emptive strike then, will you?

What's that supposed to mean ?

People are entitled to change their mind without being called a liar.

Perhaps, but when one backs down from one's own challenge, and money was involved, others can quite reasonably suspect that the challenge was never going to be met, one way or another. And that makes it a lie.
 
---

Hi Malcolm, Everyone:

Max here.

Forgive me for interrupting the flow for just a moment.

I have read zero of Malcolm's work, except for his very first post on this thread.

Readers of this thread my be interested in the JREF thread I started:

The aluminum of Flights 11 & 175 was used to create phreato-thermatic explosions


My research findings are consistent with some of Malcolm's assertions (if I understand him correctly):


- I am virtually certain Flight 175 was flown into WTC2 by remote guidance.


- The "Flight 175" that hit the towers fired at least one (I suspect two) projectiles.

Note that this is consistent with Malcolm's assertion that the "Flight 175" that hit WTC2 was not a commercial jet.


- When Flight 175 hit WTC2, the aluminum from the jet was used to engineer a spectacular phreato-thermatic explosion. (That is the topic of the above link.)

This too is consistent with Flight 175 not being a commercial jet. (Ifi it were a commercial jet, it at least had to be modified.)


I hope this is helpful.

Max

---

Yes, very useful. We are now aware of your 'opinion'. Thanks.
 
Finally, do these 'astronomical' odds not raise the slightest question in your mind?

Lots of "astronomical" odds are beaten every day. Can you think of some examples ?

If someone fired a bullet at a wall at an angle of less than 45 degrees. Would you gleefully stand at the receiving end of a 'deflection'?
Before you say yes to that, I suggest you gen up on the word RICOCHET.

Do bullets penetrate stronger materials, yes or no ?

I mentioned in a recent post that most truthers stop 'investigating' once they find themselves overwhelmed with the evidence of an inside job.

No surprise there.

I am confident that deeper investigating will uncover even more truth.

And if it doesn't ? Will you believe the investigation, or scream for more of them ?

I have my hands full at the moment simply asserting that the plane that hit tower two was NOT flight 175

It would be far easier for you if you provided evidence that it didn't instead of asking us to disprove a negative.

Are the 84 % of americans who want a proper investigation of 9/11 'ignoramuses'?

Evidence of that number, please. Otherwise I'll just keep saying "0.84%" instead. My word is just as good as yours.
 
Okay, was going to avoid this cesspoll of a thread, but the bit on a new investigation boggles my mind.
You don't trust the government, believing them to be murderers and liars. Yet, you want a new investigation. Who's going to do it, if not the government that you don't trust? If the government pays for an outside agency to do it, you still have government involvement, and I know you'd still cry foul at that. So I guess that means a private investigation.
If it's going to be a private investigation, what's stopping you from doing one now? If it's funds, hey, get a dollar from everyone that wants a new one. Bet you could collect $50 US in not more than 6 months!
So, either get busy on your investigation, or just shut up about it. Nothing is stopping you except your own laziness.
 
I've said it once, and I'll say it again: I sincerely believe that malcom and most others here who believe 911 was an inside job would NEVER accept any conclusion from ANY investigation that concluded anything other than an inside job.
 
Lots of "astronomical" odds are beaten every day. Can you think of some examples ?



Do bullets penetrate stronger materials, yes or no ?



No surprise there.



And if it doesn't ? Will you believe the investigation, or scream for more of them ?



It would be far easier for you if you provided evidence that it didn't instead of asking us to disprove a negative.



Evidence of that number, please. Otherwise I'll just keep saying "0.84%" instead. My word is just as good as yours.

"Do bullets penetrate stronger materials"?
Not when they hit them at less than 45%. Kindly look up the meaning of the word RICOCHETTE - Ricochet.
This site says 64%, others say different,
http://www.reopen911.org/
Figures vary
http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Zogby_poll_finds_45%_want_new_9/11_investigation
I can't find the site that said 84%, no matter.
Now answer this, if so many millions want a proper investigation and Bush just scraped in, why are the GOP alienating so many voters.
 
Okay, was going to avoid this cesspoll of a thread, but the bit on a new investigation boggles my mind.
You don't trust the government, believing them to be murderers and liars. Yet, you want a new investigation. Who's going to do it, if not the government that you don't trust? If the government pays for an outside agency to do it, you still have government involvement, and I know you'd still cry foul at that. So I guess that means a private investigation.
If it's going to be a private investigation, what's stopping you from doing one now? If it's funds, hey, get a dollar from everyone that wants a new one. Bet you could collect $50 US in not more than 6 months!
So, either get busy on your investigation, or just shut up about it. Nothing is stopping you except your own laziness.
Jim,
I'm so glad to hear from you after all this time. Here in the UK, it's called a 'public inquiry'. All that happens is that one independent lawman or woman chairs a 'public' inquiry. Everything relevant is investigated properly in front of a public audience and nothing is left out. Easy eh.
 
I've said it once, and I'll say it again: I sincerely believe that malcom and most others here who believe 911 was an inside job would NEVER accept any conclusion from ANY investigation that concluded anything other than an inside job.

You are totally, utterly, absolutely and completely CORRECT.
 
So who is right then?
Purdue or NIST.
They can't both be right, because they say different things.
Which do you prefer ?

They're both right because they don't actually contradict each other.

a flash flood of flaming liquid

the fireballs did not explode or create a shock wave that would have resulted in structural damage.

Where's the contradiction? Lots of flames but no explosion. Both the same but in different words.
 
They're both right because they don't actually contradict each other.





Where's the contradiction? Lots of flames but no explosion. Both the same but in different words.
Both Purdue and NIST, along with the Official pack of lies are farcical attempts to cover up the mass murder of innocent office workers.
Justice will be served in this matter and the list of accessories after the fact increases. A situation I don't mind, because it means the clean up will be all that much more thorough.
 
"Do bullets penetrate stronger materials"?
Not when they hit them at less than 45%. Kindly look up the meaning of the word RICOCHETTE - Ricochet.

And where would you expect flight 77 to ricochet to ? Would it bounce back in the air ? Into the ground ?

Show your reasoning.

I can't find the site that said 84%, no matter.

It DOES matter, because you use it as the basis of a fallacious argument from popularity.

Now answer this, if so many millions want a proper investigation and Bush just scraped in, why are the GOP alienating so many voters.

You can't find the source of that number, and yet you decide to accept it as gospel truth ? Sounds risky.

I've said it once, and I'll say it again: I sincerely believe that malcom and most others here who believe 911 was an inside job would NEVER accept any conclusion from ANY investigation that concluded anything other than an inside job.
You are totally, utterly, absolutely and completely CORRECT.

You may not realise this, but you've just admitted to two things: 1) you do not have an open mind on this subject, making your arguments and conclusions suspicious at best and 2) you are working form a pre-determined conclusion, which makes ANYTHING you say on this matter highly doubtful.

Perhaps it's time you start from scratch.
 
And where would you expect flight 77 to ricochet to ? Would it bounce back in the air ? Into the ground ?

Show your reasoning.



It DOES matter, because you use it as the basis of a fallacious argument from popularity.



You can't find the source of that number, and yet you decide to accept it as gospel truth ? Sounds risky.



You may not realise this, but you've just admitted to two things: 1) you do not have an open mind on this subject, making your arguments and conclusions suspicious at best and 2) you are working form a pre-determined conclusion, which makes ANYTHING you say on this matter highly doubtful.

Perhaps it's time you start from scratch.
Here's some reasoning for you.
All of the plane had to go through the wall, for the official conspiracy theory (OCT) to be true.
Coming in at the OCT angle, the plane would present a face about 1 and 3/4
its actual width. The 125 ft wingspan would be well over 200 ft from wingtip mark to wingtip mark along the wall.
So if all the plane went inside, which it had to do for the OCT to be right, then the hole would be over 200 wide.
Can you put up a photo of the hole prior to the collapse of the wall and show me a 200 ft wide gap?
 
So, unless you're just being facetious, a call for a further investigation from you is worthless. Once an ideologue, always an ideologue.
I don't want a 'further' investigation, I just want one 'proper' investigation.
 
I think this thread should be moved to Abandon All Hope. Kirkman has shown he has no qualms about lying to further his delusions and now he's admitted he will never change his mind. This is not a debate, rather it's one person trolling this site for their own pleasure.

Kirkman can rescue the thread by paying the donation he agreed to and agreeing to bring an open mind to the debate (bringing some evidence would help as well).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom