[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not possible to know the truth of 9/11 and then deny it, unless you have a greater loyalty to someone or something other than justice for murdered innocent office workers.
The arrogance with which some denials are done on here, tells me all I need to know.


Wow, you could cut the irony with a dull knife. I'm starting to think that Ron is right and that this is one big put-on.
 
First, the linked web page answers none of my questions. Second, why would you expect anyone to take your (extraordinary) claims on faith?? How do we know they aren't just the ravings of some crackpot whose web site you happened upon?? Third, the question about base commanders doesn't require a reference, and I gave you the site you can use to back up your "pilots at the door" claim.

Now, please either a) provide evidence to back up your claims, b) give a reasonable date by which you expect to be able to provide such evidence, or c) withdraw any claims you can't support. If you cannot or will not do this, please explain why anyone should take you or your arguments seriously.
Withdraw my claims ?
My claims are infinitely stronger now that when I started this thread.
Have you for gotten the engine serial numbers from the engine of the plane that hit tower two? If the FBI can identify a rental van from its back axle, as with the Oklahoma City bombing. Then why can't they produce serial numbers from the aero engine and end this dispute?
Also, have you forgotten the 'astronomical' odds on all these murdered passengers being connected to Raytheon, Boeing and Global Hawk?
'Astronomical' is the term that you used.
I cannot help you further in sourcing my original claims, I have no time to trawl the internet for references that I should have kept at the time.
Any spare time I will have, will be spent on homing in on probability and odds in general. I would like to thank you for playing your part in revealing this latest 'smoking gun'.
In definitive reply, I will most certainly NOT be withdrawing my claims, the evidence to support them is stronger than ever.
That's what you get when you deal with the truth.
 
It obviously didn't just "slide in." The huge fuel-air explosion shows that the wings didn't last very long at all. They were going too fast and had too much momentum for the outer wall to stop them, yet the explosion occurred when they were just a few feet into the building. The only part of the wing that would have caused damage to the floor structure is the main spar. Remember, it has to be able to support several times the full weight of the aircraft.
This show that a wing can cut through steel without too much trouble when going fast enough.
See above.
Debunked where?
Can we agree that an engine from the plane that hit tower two landed in the street? If so, where are the serial numbers from it?
 
What? 12 or so such walls? how did you come up with that? are you not aware that in the area and level the plane impacted the first three rings were of an open floor plan and connected with lower roofs between the rings separating them? are you also aware the exit hole wall need not be blast resistant simply because there was no practical way to drive a truck bomb or similar device from within the rings of the pentagon?

And onto the unburned bible on a stool story. did you not see the millions of individual un-scorched papers falling to the streets of Manhattan from the WTC towers when the planes hit?

OK thats two more beatings you got kirkman.
How many walls did the plane go through?
 
If you can perceive a threat or insult that you cannot see, hear, smell, or feel, from someone miles away, you can have a million dollars (aka loadsa dosh) of the Randi Foundation's money. I suggest you apply for it (after testing yourself to make sure you really do have this ability); that way you can fulfill your promise to donate $1000 to charity.

However, if you're talking about perceiving a remote threat, real or otherwise, from miles away that you can see or hear (such as a distant explosion, or an image transmitted by television) -- my dogs can do that.

Imagining something is no challenge for anyone. If I hold out my hand in a certain way, my dogs imagine a dog biscuit that they cannot possibly see, hear, or smell because it's not there. So what?

Respectfully,
Myriad
You will not adhere to the doctrine of a pre-emptive strike then, will you?
 
Physics says otherwise malcolm.

How about you show the physics that shows that "
Any plane hitting such a wall at 45 degrees or less would be deflected along the wall and not go through the wall".
I'm not sure science feels the need to prove common sense. Throw a dart at a plaster wall and see what happens.
 
So says the proven liar.
Where do you get the proven liar bit from?
If this is a reference to the $1,000 then I changed my mind.
People are entitled to change their mind without being called a liar.
I take it that you post the best post you can. Resorting to personal attacks tells me that you cannot argue with the claims I have made.
 
How many do you want? These three should suffice.
http://truthorlies.org/911trutharticle015.html
I had to laugh at this one. Especially,
The following statement was used in the Purdue simulation: "The weight of the aircraft's fuel, when ignited, acted like a flash flood of flaming liquid". This is a direct contradiction of the FEMA report (which can be viewed HERE)which stated: "despite the huge fireballs caused by the two planes crashing into the WTC towers each with 10,000 gallons of jet fuel, the fireballs did not explode or create a shock wave that would have resulted in structural damage.”
Yet the Purdue statement says nothing about damage. So the whole paragraph is bogus. Then they re-iterate your claim.
Further, the Purdue simulation claims “the engines ripped through the central columns and sent the engines bursting through the other side of the towers”, showing that the airliner, made of aluminum, ripped through the steel facing of the north tower like a knife through butter. How is this possible?
Please explain this:
pic_capt2.gif
So a vinyl record can embed itself into a telephone pole at 300 mph, yet aluminum alloy and titanium can't cut through light steel at 490? Yeah, great logic there.
This is just a re-iteration of the first one, so it's not a valid debunk.
Look at the source. Nick Irving is an audio engineer. Yeah, so much more qualified than the structural engineers of Purdue. So again, no debunking here either. So again, please post links to where the Purdue simulation is actually debunked.
 
I'm not sure science feels the need to prove common sense. Throw a dart at a plaster wall and see what happens.


ROFLMAO


"common sense" also would dictate that light is either a wave phenomena or a particle yet science shows us that it is both. Nothing else we commonly experience behaves as both, nor can we detect with our own senses that light is behaving as both. We can only infer it by what light does in various circumstances. Apparently 'common sense' does not always serve one well in predicting things that we do not normally experience. Light is but one example of human 'common sense' not dictating to nature how it should behave.

Such is the case with throwing a dart at a plaster wall. (I assume a straight forward 1/2inch thick plaster over lathe wall) Yes, if I throw a dart at a plaster wall it will make a small dent and bounce off. However if I construct a machine to throw that dart causing it to hit the wall at 700 feet per second, it will pass right through your plaster wall.

Throw the dart at 700 fps at a plaster wall at a 45 degree angle from perpendicular and it will still penetrate through the wall.

Obviously you would agree that a bullet can penetrate a plaster wall. A bullet is made of soft lead, is not as sharply pointed as a dart and has less mass than a dart. A .22 caliber bullet has a muzzle velocity of just under 1100 fps, less than 60% greater than a dart travelling at 700 fps.

If a dart has 1.54 times the mass of a bullet and is travelling at 65% the speed of a bullet the dart the dart and the bullet will have the same momentum. The kinetic energy of the dart will still be 70% that of the bullet. If the bullet would still have 55% of its velocity after having passed through the wall ( a safe bet ) then the dart also would have enough KE to pass through the wall.

Now malcolm, please scale up the math and physics for a large Boeing and a brick and concrete wall.
 
How many walls did the plane go through?

At the Pentagon the plane went through exactly ONE blast resistant wall and a few parts punched through one other exterior wall of normal, non-blast resistant, wall.

But then you know that since it has been pointed out many times on many websites and was even pointed out a few posts back in this very thread.
 
The aluminum from Flights 11 was 175 was used to create phreato-thermatic explosions

---

Hi Malcolm, Everyone:

Max here.

Forgive me for interrupting the flow for just a moment.

I have read zero of Malcolm's work, except for his very first post on this thread.

Readers of this thread my be interested in the JREF thread I started:

The aluminum of Flights 11 & 175 was used to create phreato-thermatic explosions


My research findings are consistent with some of Malcolm's assertions (if I understand him correctly):


- I am virtually certain Flight 175 was flown into WTC2 by remote guidance.


- The "Flight 175" that hit the towers fired at least one (I suspect two) projectiles.

Note that this is consistent with Malcolm's assertion that the "Flight 175" that hit WTC2 was not a commercial jet.


- When Flight 175 hit WTC2, the aluminum from the jet was used to engineer a spectacular phreato-thermatic explosion. (That is the topic of the above link.)

This too is consistent with Flight 175 not being a commercial jet. (Ifi it were a commercial jet, it at least had to be modified.)


I hope this is helpful.

Max

---
 
How many walls did the plane go through?
Two. The entry on the face of the building and the exit hole at AE drive on C ring 310 feet away.
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/build03/PDF/b03017.pdf

I'm not sure science feels the need to prove common sense. Throw a dart at a plaster wall and see what happens.

So your claiming with your "Common sense" that an object weighing 181,520 pounds and traveling 520 MPH when impacting the pentagon wall at an angle will simply deflect off like a billiard ball hitting a bumper cushion? do you have even the foggiest notion of the momentum and forces involved? If I am ever mugged and shot at, it is comforting to know i can just turn my torso at an angle and bullets will just deflect off my chest.
 
As I said, the Department of Defense would have asked all of its offices to list those personnel missing after the attack, and this request would have gone through several levels of bureacracy. Have you ever played "post office," Malcolm, the game where a number of people sit in a circle and take turns whispering a message to each other around the circle? Often, the original message becomes so garbled as to be barely recognizable. Add to this the chaotic and stressful aftermath of the attacks, and such mix-ups become perfectly understandable. The DCMA had around 10,000 employees. The most likely explanation is that someone fairly high up heard that Homer was missing, and, not knowing Homer or his duties, simply assumed that he had been at the Pentagon. Therefore, when the request to list those missing came down, Homer was added to the list. How is this even remotely suspicious??
How many offices does the Department of Defence have and how long would it take to amass and verify information that came in?
How would the DoD phrase the request and how many DoD employees were off work and no one knew where they were?
Skating on thin ice with this one, don't you think?
Finally, do these 'astronomical' odds not raise the slightest question in your mind?
 
Debunked on sites that you don't go to.


No, Malcolm, you are incapable of comprehending that ignoramuses making up nonsense aren't debunking anything.


In other words you are not taking anything to truthers, we are bringing it to you. The tide is turning.

In five years of screaming, conspiracy liars have produced bogus science, shamelessly distorted first-responder quotes, and a blizzard of outright lies.

What are the fantasists "bringing" to the rationalists?

You have persisted through sixty-five pages making absurd, baseless claims and being caught in a huge number of mistakes and falsehoods.

How can blind, fact-free, agenda-driven dishonesty turn the tide against reason and evidence?
 
I had to laugh at this one. Especially, Yet the Purdue statement says nothing about damage. So the whole paragraph is bogus. Then they re-iterate your claim.
Please explain this:[qimg]http://learner.org/exhibits/weather/images/pic_capt2.gif[/qimg] So a vinyl record can embed itself into a telephone pole at 300 mph, yet aluminum alloy and titanium can't cut through light steel at 490? Yeah, great logic there.

This is just a re-iteration of the first one, so it's not a valid debunk.
Look at the source. Nick Irving is an audio engineer. Yeah, so much more qualified than the structural engineers of Purdue. So again, no debunking here either. So again, please post links to where the Purdue simulation is actually debunked.
So who is right then?
Purdue or NIST.
They can't both be right, because they say different things.
Which do you prefer ?
 
ROFLMAO


"common sense" also would dictate that light is either a wave phenomena or a particle yet science shows us that it is both. Nothing else we commonly experience behaves as both, nor can we detect with our own senses that light is behaving as both. We can only infer it by what light does in various circumstances. Apparently 'common sense' does not always serve one well in predicting things that we do not normally experience. Light is but one example of human 'common sense' not dictating to nature how it should behave.

Such is the case with throwing a dart at a plaster wall. (I assume a straight forward 1/2inch thick plaster over lathe wall) Yes, if I throw a dart at a plaster wall it will make a small dent and bounce off. However if I construct a machine to throw that dart causing it to hit the wall at 700 feet per second, it will pass right through your plaster wall.

Throw the dart at 700 fps at a plaster wall at a 45 degree angle from perpendicular and it will still penetrate through the wall.

Obviously you would agree that a bullet can penetrate a plaster wall. A bullet is made of soft lead, is not as sharply pointed as a dart and has less mass than a dart. A .22 caliber bullet has a muzzle velocity of just under 1100 fps, less than 60% greater than a dart travelling at 700 fps.

If a dart has 1.54 times the mass of a bullet and is travelling at 65% the speed of a bullet the dart the dart and the bullet will have the same momentum. The kinetic energy of the dart will still be 70% that of the bullet. If the bullet would still have 55% of its velocity after having passed through the wall ( a safe bet ) then the dart also would have enough KE to pass through the wall.

Now malcolm, please scale up the math and physics for a large Boeing and a brick and concrete wall.

If someone fired a bullet at a wall at an angle of less than 45 degrees. Would you gleefully stand at the receiving end of a 'deflection'?
Before you say yes to that, I suggest you gen up on the word RICOCHET.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom