[Moderated]175 did NOT hit the South tower.

Status
Not open for further replies.
How about not ? If the people decided everything we wouldn't 'need' courts, but we do, and for good reasons.



You have no evidence. All you have is a handful of witnesses brought to this statement by leading questions. We know, we've seen Lyte Trip around here.



You keep saying that, but again never do you support that statement with evidence. I wonder why.



And yet you live, having put two and two together. Funny people, these NWO neocons.



Why would you expect otherwise if it HAD been a plane ?

I also notice you barely answered the points in my post. Are you just repeating the same debunked claims over and over ?

Here, let me help you:

1) And where would you expect flight 77 to ricochet to ? Would it bounce back in the air ? Into the ground ?

2) It DOES matter, because you use it as the basis of a fallacious argument from popularity.

3) You may not realise this, but you've just admitted to two things: 1) you do not have an open mind on this subject, making your arguments and conclusions suspicious at best and 2) you are working form a pre-determined conclusion, which makes ANYTHING you say on this matter highly doubtful.
Are you calling the testimony of two cops "no evidence"?
 
Sorry, Malcolm, the Pentacon is utter rubbish. Lyte Trip is a silly fraud who was sent packing when we demanded that he take is "irrefutable evidence" to a real reporter and win a Pulitzer Prize for breaking the biggest story of all time. He hasn't stopped running yet.

No planes from Offutt had anything whatever to do with the jihadist attacks of 9/11. You were caught lying about that fantasy and, to date, you have still not apologized.

Show us evidence of the existence of your "military bad boys."
Kindly answer my previous question.
Are you calling all those people who want a new investigation of 9/11 "ignoramuses"?
 
How about not ? If the people decided everything we wouldn't 'need' courts, but we do, and for good reasons.



You have no evidence. All you have is a handful of witnesses brought to this statement by leading questions. We know, we've seen Lyte Trip around here.



You keep saying that, but again never do you support that statement with evidence. I wonder why.



And yet you live, having put two and two together. Funny people, these NWO neocons.



Why would you expect otherwise if it HAD been a plane ?

I also notice you barely answered the points in my post. Are you just repeating the same debunked claims over and over ?

Here, let me help you:

1) And where would you expect flight 77 to ricochet to ? Would it bounce back in the air ? Into the ground ?

2) It DOES matter, because you use it as the basis of a fallacious argument from popularity.

3) You may not realise this, but you've just admitted to two things: 1) you do not have an open mind on this subject, making your arguments and conclusions suspicious at best and 2) you are working form a pre-determined conclusion, which makes ANYTHING you say on this matter highly doubtful.
I quote,
"And yet you live, having put two and two together".
Would you kindly expand on this, why shouldn't I live ?
 
I quote,
"And yet you live, having put two and two together".
Would you kindly expand on this, why shouldn't I live ?

As the moderator who approved both these posts I want to make something clear.

There is no threat here.

Belz was clearly referring to your claim that people who push to uncover the truth are murdered. He is stating that you, and many others who similarly push to uncover the truth are very much alive, and therefore have not been murdered by the same people who wish to hide this truth by murdering those who uncover it.

Belz was not making a threat against you, nor suggesting that you should not be allowed to live.
 
As the moderator who approved both these posts I want to make something clear.

There is no threat here.

Belz was clearly referring to your claim that people who push to uncover the truth are murdered. He is stating that you, and many others who similarly push to uncover the truth are very much alive, and therefore have not been murdered by the same people who wish to hide this truth by murdering those who uncover it.

Belz was not making a threat against you, nor suggesting that you should not be allowed to live.
Would you kindly refresh my memory with regard to where I claimed that
"people who push to uncover the truth are murdered"?
 
My pleasure,
Had I still been working, I would probably be in favour of bombing Iran back into the stone age. That would be because my only source of 'news' would be the MSM (BBC) and I never was one to really listen anyway.
In other words, all these mathematicians etc, in fact most anybody working really, is too busy to find the time.


How many retired mathematics professors and mathematics teachers do you suppose there are in the world?? In the United States alone?? Thousands and thousands, Malcolm. Why haven't any of them noticed this astoundingly improbable coincidence?? (Hint: It's really not an astoundingly improbable coincidence at all.)

I've only just found this out and I've been aware of the truth for a good five months now.
I'm sure most people don't need to go to any great depths, such as poring over passenger lists, to realise the truth. In a backhanded way it's a compliment to you deniers, otherwise this 'smoking gun' would not have surfaced.


But you just said all these mathematicians are too busy to have noticed the "astounding coincidence," yet "most people don't need to go to any great depths." Please explain this apparent contribution

On a related point, I'm still working out how an obviously intelligent person such as yourself, can allow some other consideration to hold sway over the mass murder of innocent office workers.


Begging the question of whether the US government staged the September 11 attacks.

Before I came on this forum. I was advocating that people who are au fait and deniers, should be looked at very closely as accessories after the fact. Having had a look at some other threads on this forum, I'm thinking now of 'somebody Walrus', I read an exchange where the walrus was persuaded into being a denier. At the moment, I'm resigning myself to the possibility that otherwise rational people can be persuaded into becoming deniers. I'm thinking now of scientists who are educated into a world of absolutes, if it's guaranteed to be true every time, then it's a law - in your language.


You are confusing skepticism with dogmatism. Scientists are typically skeptical of claims that challenge established theories, and require strong evidence before accepting changes to those theories. But scientific theories can and do change.

But in the language of the legal profession, things are very different.
Bias for example need only be a possibility. If you are on a 'selection' panel and your brother appears before it, you would have to step down because of the POSSIBILITY of bias and the whole proceedings being scrapped.


Very well, Malcolm, I submit that you need to recuse yourself from any advocacy of theories that the US government staged the September 11 attacks, because you are quite clearly biased against George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, et al. What's that? You won't recuse yourself and cease your advocacy? Please explain why any reasonable person would consider this to be anything other than blatant hypocrisy.

So you see, where I come from, absolute proof is for the lab, not the courtroom.


Again, you misunderstand the nature of science. Science deals in theories that best explain all known observations. The theories are not "guaranteed to be true."

With me, when I have enough pieces, I make a hat and if the hat fits, I'll make somebody wear it.


What if the hat fits you, Malcolm? :tinfoil Will you be intellectually honest and wear it yourself, or will you simply ignore all the evidence you don't like?

In conclusion, maths teachers etc are not up in arms, because the don't know. I'll be doing what I can to alter that directly.


Why don't you try the following experiment, Malcolm. Go to the nearest college and find a couple of mathematics professors. Ask them how "astoundingly implausible" it is that one DCMA and four Raytheon employees would have been aboard the hijacked airliners. Let us know what they say.

I have no difficulty with an aitliner entering one of the twins. The designer himself explains how the buildings were designed to behave a bit like a net curtain. My difficulty is the ease with which the planes just slid in. There is no way on earth a wing would slice into a tower at floor level, none.


Three questions, Malcolm. First, please tell us what you think the impact should have looked like, assuming a "normal" Boeing 767 had hit WTC 2.

Second, you claim that you just became aware of The TruthTM a few months ago. Presumably you'd seen video of the impact many times before then, probably starting the day it happened. How is it that it took you over five years to realize that what you were seeing was impossible??

Finally, you claim that mathematicians aren't up in arms because they just don't know about the "Global Hawk connection." However, thousands of physicists (including those outside the US) have seen the video of the WTC 2 impact. Many (especially in America) witnessed it live on television. If it's physically impossible for the aircraft to have been a "normal" 767, why didn't any of these physicists notice, or why aren't they calling attention to the fact?? Please include physicists in Iran, Cuba, North Korea, China, and Russia in your answer.

It would be no different than a plane hitting a pier front on with a wing and slicing the pier in half.


If it were moving fast enough, the wing would slice the pier in half, though it would sustain considerable damage itself.

I hit on the military bit after realising that a USAF fighter just sliced through cable car cables with a wing and carried on oblivious, while a cable car full of skiers were dropped to their deaths.


This explains where you came up with the "ex-military bad boy" idea. First, let's get the relevant facts of the accident in question straight.

The plane was a US Marine Corps EA-6B ProwlerWP electronic warfare aircraft, a variant of the A-6 Intruder carrier-based attack bomber. From the English translation of the report (pp. 13-14) of the inquiry conducted by the Italian Parliament:

The aircraft [EASY 01] entered Val di Fiemme at an altitude of between 260 and 300 meters AGL, descending to about 110 meters at the point of impact, covering the ground to the cablecar at a speed of about 540 kts. At 14:13 on 3 February 1998, the aircraft hit and severed the loadbearing and drive cables of the Cermis cable array, presumably banking to the left on a downward trajectory. . . .

After the impact the aircraft climbed and continued the flight under emergency conditions. The collision had damaged the right wing and the upper part of the vertical stabilizer as well as the jamming pod. EASY 01 re-established radio contact with the Aviano control tower at 14:18:10 at 10 nautical miles west of the airbase on a heading of 245o, declared an emergency and landed . . . at 14:26:40. The crew shut down the engines and effected an emergency exit from the aircraft. Capt. Raney broke his ankle (30 days recovery time) while abandoning the aircraft. [emphasis added]

Clearly, the pilot was not "oblivious" to the fact that the aircraft had collided with something. Most likely you misconstrued the statement in some news articles that the crew were not initially aware that they had collided with a cable-car cable as meaning they didn't realize they'd been involved in a collision.

From a page on the web site of the company that reconstructed the accident for the defense team:

The EA-6B Prowler struck the gondola support cable (2 inch diameter) and haulage cable (1 inch diameter)with its right wing at the wing fold. Post flight investigation revealed a strike of approximately 40-50 degrees relative to the cable. Damage to the Prowler was severe with both cables cutting the wing to the spar.


Attached is a photo of the damage. The red areas represent destroyed sections of the wing. Obviously, the wing didn't just cut through the cables like a knife through string, which is the impression you might have gotten from some news reports. What most likely happened is that the cables were abraded somewhat by the wing skin, then, when the main spar (the strongest support member in the wing) struck them, they parted due to their being stressed beyond their abrasion-reduced tensile limits.

There was only 12 1/2 feet between the floors. Something had to be done to make sure all the plane went in, including the wings.


The wings simply shattered, and the fragments continued on into the building. However, in shattering, they severed a large number of outside support columns. Frankly, I think you're having trouble with the concept that in a high-speed collision, it is possible for both colliding objects to be severely damaged, even if one is significantly stronger than the other.

Malcolm, a fact that you seem not to grasp is that the skins of military planes are not armored. Such armor would be weight prohibitive in any aircraft. Certain aircraft have critical components (such as the cockpit) armored, but no aircraft has all-over armor. Some military aircraft have thicker or stronger skins and more support structure because they need to withstand the stresses of dogfighting, but this is not the same as having armor, and it doesn't make their skins that much heavier than those of civilian aircraft.


I hope this is a comprehensive enough answer.


At least it's more detailed than some of your other answers.

I will refrain from commenting about Purdue, save to say I am aware of their piece which I believe has since been 'debunked'.


Please point to any "debunking" from any qualified structural engineers. Please also explain why there isn't any from any other universities anywhere.
 

Attachments

  • EA6B5.GIF
    EA6B5.GIF
    29.3 KB · Views: 154
I can't do diagrams with a keyboard, I hope to be putting up photos soon.
It's to do with the angle of approach or impact.
Just draw a horizontal line on a piece of plain paper.
Then take a piece of paper that's around an inch or so wide. If you place the paper edge on to the horizontal line, it will measure say 1 inch.
Now draw a line to the horizontal at around 45 degrees.
Now put your piece of paper at right angles to your 45 degree line and make a mark on either side of that line.
Now run those dots into lines that are parallel to the 45 degree line.
Now mark where those two 'wingtip' lines cross the diagonal.
You will find the width of the lines as they cross the original horizontal as something like 1 and 3/4 the width of the original one inch.

Sorry, Malcolm. Perhaps to put it a little less bluntly than my colleagues, but you have your geometry a little mixed up. What you are suggesting is that the wing tips get further apart depending on the angle of viewing.

My guess is you are thinking of the plane as a rectangle, with the nose touching the "Top" line, each wing touching a side, and the tail at the base, and when viewing it at an angle, you see that the diagonal of the rectangle you made is, in fact, longer than the wingspan.

But physically, the plane is incapable of "Growing", so you know that can't be a perfect geometic model. perhaps think of it as the wings are already aligned on the diagonal - they can't get any larger, but viewed from an angle, they can appear shorter.

Anyway, lets see if (as a forum) we can take it down a notch;even if we agree on nothing else, this geometry problem can at least be rationally explained.
 
Sorry, Malcolm. Perhaps to put it a little less bluntly than my colleagues, but you have your geometry a little mixed up. What you are suggesting is that the wing tips get further apart depending on the angle of viewing.

My guess is you are thinking of the plane as a rectangle, with the nose touching the "Top" line, each wing touching a side, and the tail at the base, and when viewing it at an angle, you see that the diagonal of the rectangle you made is, in fact, longer than the wingspan.

But physically, the plane is incapable of "Growing", so you know that can't be a perfect geometic model. perhaps think of it as the wings are already aligned on the diagonal - they can't get any larger, but viewed from an angle, they can appear shorter.

Anyway, lets see if (as a forum) we can take it down a notch;even if we agree on nothing else, this geometry problem can at least be rationally explained.
You will find the correct distance to be 163 ft.
Now kindly show me a 163 ft scar across the face of the Pentagon.
 
How many retired mathematics professors and mathematics teachers do you suppose there are in the world?? In the United States alone?? Thousands and thousands, Malcolm. Why haven't any of them noticed this astoundingly improbable coincidence?? (Hint: It's really not an astoundingly improbable coincidence at all.)




But you just said all these mathematicians are too busy to have noticed the "astounding coincidence," yet "most people don't need to go to any great depths." Please explain this apparent contribution




Begging the question of whether the US government staged the September 11 attacks.




You are confusing skepticism with dogmatism. Scientists are typically skeptical of claims that challenge established theories, and require strong evidence before accepting changes to those theories. But scientific theories can and do change.




Very well, Malcolm, I submit that you need to recuse yourself from any advocacy of theories that the US government staged the September 11 attacks, because you are quite clearly biased against George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, et al. What's that? You won't recuse yourself and cease your advocacy? Please explain why any reasonable person would consider this to be anything other than blatant hypocrisy.




Again, you misunderstand the nature of science. Science deals in theories that best explain all known observations. The theories are not "guaranteed to be true."




What if the hat fits you, Malcolm? :tinfoil Will you be intellectually honest and wear it yourself, or will you simply ignore all the evidence you don't like?




Why don't you try the following experiment, Malcolm. Go to the nearest college and find a couple of mathematics professors. Ask them how "astoundingly implausible" it is that one DCMA and four Raytheon employees would have been aboard the hijacked airliners. Let us know what they say.




Three questions, Malcolm. First, please tell us what you think the impact should have looked like, assuming a "normal" Boeing 767 had hit WTC 2.

Second, you claim that you just became aware of The TruthTM a few months ago. Presumably you'd seen video of the impact many times before then, probably starting the day it happened. How is it that it took you over five years to realize that what you were seeing was impossible??

Finally, you claim that mathematicians aren't up in arms because they just don't know about the "Global Hawk connection." However, thousands of physicists (including those outside the US) have seen the video of the WTC 2 impact. Many (especially in America) witnessed it live on television. If it's physically impossible for the aircraft to have been a "normal" 767, why didn't any of these physicists notice, or why aren't they calling attention to the fact?? Please include physicists in Iran, Cuba, North Korea, China, and Russia in your answer.




If it were moving fast enough, the wing would slice the pier in half, though it would sustain considerable damage itself.




This explains where you came up with the "ex-military bad boy" idea. First, let's get the relevant facts of the accident in question straight.

The plane was a US Marine Corps EA-6B ProwlerWP electronic warfare aircraft, a variant of the A-6 Intruder carrier-based attack bomber. From the English translation of the report (pp. 13-14) of the inquiry conducted by the Italian Parliament:



Clearly, the pilot was not "oblivious" to the fact that the aircraft had collided with something. Most likely you misconstrued the statement in some news articles that the crew were not initially aware that they had collided with a cable-car cable as meaning they didn't realize they'd been involved in a collision.

From a page on the web site of the company that reconstructed the accident for the defense team:




Attached is a photo of the damage. The red areas represent destroyed sections of the wing. Obviously, the wing didn't just cut through the cables like a knife through string, which is the impression you might have gotten from some news reports. What most likely happened is that the cables were abraded somewhat by the wing skin, then, when the main spar (the strongest support member in the wing) struck them, they parted due to their being stressed beyond their abrasion-reduced tensile limits.




The wings simply shattered, and the fragments continued on into the building. However, in shattering, they severed a large number of outside support columns. Frankly, I think you're having trouble with the concept that in a high-speed collision, it is possible for both colliding objects to be severely damaged, even if one is significantly stronger than the other.

Malcolm, a fact that you seem not to grasp is that the skins of military planes are not armored. Such armor would be weight prohibitive in any aircraft. Certain aircraft have critical components (such as the cockpit) armored, but no aircraft has all-over armor. Some military aircraft have thicker or stronger skins and more support structure because they need to withstand the stresses of dogfighting, but this is not the same as having armor, and it doesn't make their skins that much heavier than those of civilian aircraft.





At least it's more detailed than some of your other answers.




Please point to any "debunking" from any qualified structural engineers. Please also explain why there isn't any from any other universities anywhere.
A most comprehensive response. You must have been busy with this and missed my response to the case of Mr Homer.
I shall respond to this post in due course. In the meantime, can we deal with the case of Mr Homer and then probability theory. That is the order in which the cards fell.
Firstly Mr Homer, kindly answer my post 2596. Which was preceeded by your 2550. Preceeded by 2540 and 2525.
 
Are you calling the testimony of two cops "no evidence"?

As long as all you're doing is claim that the testimony exists, yes.

I quote,
"And yet you live, having put two and two together".
Would you kindly expand on this, why shouldn't I live ?

Because the evil government should have offed you by now.

So why don't they ?

Would you kindly refresh my memory with regard to where I claimed that
"people who push to uncover the truth are murdered"?

My utmost pleasure :

The attack plane flew south from Offutt, nice and slow, lined up on route 66 (if you don't mind), then overflew the Pentagon and nipped up the Potomac to land at Dulles. That's why Mrs Booth was murdered, because she would have put two and two together.
 
. . . But you just said all these mathematicians are too busy to have noticed the "astounding coincidence," yet "most people don't need to go to any great depths." Please explain this apparent contribution . . .


Oops--I was trying to finish this late last night, but had to leave it until this morning. I meant for the last sentence to read, "Please explain this apparent contradiction in your theory." :o
 
The EA-6B Prowler struck the gondola support cable (2 inch diameter) and haulage cable (1 inch diameter)with its right wing at the wing fold. Post flight investigation revealed a strike of approximately 40-50 degrees relative to the cable. Damage to the Prowler was severe with both cables cutting the wing to the spar.
Wait a minute. According to Malcolm, the aircraft should have ricocheted. So, Malcolm, why didn't that happen?
 
You are totally, utterly, absolutely and completely CORRECT. ........

............

Both Purdue and NIST, along with the Official pack of lies are farcical attempts to cover up the mass murder of innocent office workers.
Justice will be served in this matter and the list of accessories after the fact increases. A situation I don't mind, because it means the clean up will be all that much more thorough.

Once again illustrating that what malcolm dearly wants is an opressive dictatorship and do do away with the rule of law.

Shall I list the people in charge of such systems past and present , malcolm?
 
Once again illustrating that what malcolm dearly wants is an opressive dictatorship and do do away with the rule of law.

Shall I list the people in charge of such systems past and present , malcolm?
Feel free, you will of course, be starting with George W Bush.
 
A most comprehensive response. You must have been busy with this and missed my response to the case of Mr Homer.
I shall respond to this post in due course. In the meantime, can we deal with the case of Mr Homer and then probability theory. That is the order in which the cards fell.
Firstly Mr Homer, kindly answer my post 2596. Which was preceeded by your 2550. Preceeded by 2540 and 2525.
During the Korean war, a pilot actually bounced his fighter off the frozen ground. He said he got a right roasting from the chief mechanic. He put the planes survival down to its armour. Any civilian plane would have broken up.
It makes sense to me that if you are going to send planes into harms way,
1. You are going to armour the underside against RPG's etc
2. You are not going to shout about how well armoured the plane is
3. You are going to give it all the power it needs and more.
I would list the above points as common sense, so I must contradict your suggestion that military planes are not especially armoured and powered up to cope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom