Miracle of the Shroud IV - The Phantom Image

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jabba, you have not yet corrected the attribution of the 'yak vomit' comment. I pointed out your mistake to you three hours after you posted the link to your 'map', and Craig4 has confirmed to you that he made the comment, not me.

It is now two days later, and with the greatest possible respect I really must insist that you remove my name from that comment on your website. Please change the map page on your site as soon as possible.
 
Your argument changes words more than a racing car changes tires. It conveys the impression that you don't want the nature of your argument pinned down in any way.


Remember all the different words (and formatting) he used to mean "soul" in the immortality threads? While trying to avoid calling them "souls", of course.
 
Last edited:
Jabba, you have not yet corrected the attribution of the 'yak vomit' comment. I pointed out your mistake to you three hours after you posted the link to your 'map', and Craig4 has confirmed to you that he made the comment, not me.

It is now two days later, and with the greatest possible respect I really must insist that you remove my name from that comment on your website. Please change the map page on your site as soon as possible.

Maybe he'll put an invisible patch over it.
 
Evidence/Circumstantial

Slowvehicle,
- That is not what I admit.
- I admit that I have no significant direct evidence.
- You seem to be saying that circumstantial evidence is not real evidence. Is that what you're saying?

Jay,
- One argument I'm having with Slowvehicle and others is that while my 'evidence' is not "direct," and may be weak, it is still "evidence" -- circumstantial evidence. Wouldn't you agree?

Do not attempt to equivocate. I explained exactly why your evidence was not convincing. Address that.

Jay,
- I don't think that word means what you think it means.
- You don't think that I'm equivocating. You think that I'm prevaricating.
- From
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/equivocate
to use ambiguous or unclear expressions, usually to avoid commitmentor in order to mislead; prevaricate or hedge:
 
Jay,
- I don't think that word means what you think it means.
- You don't think that I'm equivocating. You think that I'm prevaricating.
- From
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/equivocate
to use ambiguous or unclear expressions, usually to avoid commitmentor in order to mislead; prevaricate or hedge:

So you've found to nitpick over this but not to:

- Fix the Yak vomit comment incorrectly attributed to Agatha
- Present any actual evidence

:rolleyes:

btw, IMO you both equivocate (invisible, nearly invisible, partially invisible etc. etc.) and prevaricate. You often use the former to achieve the latter
 
Jabba: why do you ignore the people who took the time to analyze, point by point, the article you're trying to insist is "evidence"? And why do you refuse to address the issues on your blog?
 
And Jabba, where do you get off telling someone what they think? As carefully worded as JayUtah's posts always are, I would bet that he said just exactly what he meant to say and thinks just exactly what he said he thinks.
 
Jay,
- I don't think that word means what you think it means.
- You don't think that I'm equivocating. You think that I'm prevaricating.
- From
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/equivocate
to use ambiguous or unclear expressions, usually to avoid commitmentor in order to mislead; prevaricate or hedge:

In the sense that equivocation is a way to prevaricate, you're doing both. And now you're stalling.

On the subject of consilience...something to keep in mind is that "independent" is a key element of it. The lines of evidence need to be independent not only of each other, but must lead to the conclusion, not be drawn from it- which is to say, the evidence can't be just things that, with no other support, are necessary for the conclusion to be true. So your "invisible/near invisible/quantum patch" is right out, I'm afraid- that is pretty much, I think, anti-consilience.
 
It is indeed a test to see whether Jabba has any interest or ability to have a serious discussion about the evidentiary strength, if any, of his argument. In a world where so many claimants go out into the "wilderness" to pretend to have weathered the storm of criticism, it is important to be able to distinguish a natural reluctance on the part of a conscientious claimant to discard his belief from that of an unscrupulous claimant looking only to play the game long enough to satisfy some shred of intellectual need. Claimants rarely understand how easy it is to see the difference between a well-joined debate and rhetorical gaming.
 
Jabba: why do you ignore the people who took the time to analyze, point by point, the article you're trying to insist is "evidence"?

Because he can only focus on one point at a time, and it's not fair that the big ole meenies have brought up 30 different topics that he needs to address.

Of course, he can just throw them out there in a link, and pretend they are evidence, and that's not a problem or anything. But you expect him to respond to criticism on all those points?
 
So your "invisible/near invisible/quantum patch" is right out, I'm afraid- that is pretty much, I think, anti-consilience.

Worse. Anti-consilience is where avenues of evidence are interpreted, as you say, using the desired conclusion as a guide to resolving ambiguity in the evidence. The "near-invisible" patch is just conjecture. It's not even evidence. The findings regarding the cloth didn't come out as desired, so now advocates are imagining what "must" be true in order for the findings to be accurate, yet contradict their desired belief.
 
Because he can only focus on one point at a time, and it's not fair that the big ole meenies have brought up 30 different topics that he needs to address.

Of course, he can just throw them out there in a link, and pretend they are evidence, and that's not a problem or anything. But you expect him to respond to criticism on all those points?

Yeah, there's that.
 
But you expect him to respond to criticism on all those points?

Of course I do, but I'm prepared to be disappointed. Jabba has ignored the qualitative needs in an argument by consilience and focused entirely on the quantity. That's what separates a consilient argument from a Gish gallop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom