Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
This article is not without its problems as evidence that the C14 sample area was not a patch.
1. The biases of the author - He is promoting his own theory of why the C14 dating was in error so he has a bias to prove that Rogers' theory is wrong.
2. He references images but unfortunately the images in his report don't seem to be in the on-line version.
3. His claims about the similarity of the patch area to the rest of the shroud seem to rest on x-ray fluorescence reported by Rogers and Schwalbe in PHYSICS AND CHEMISTRY OF THE SHROUD OF TURIN A Summary of the 1978 Investigation. It is difficult to find exactly where in that report there is a detailed chemical analysis of every area of the shroud so that it is possible to compare the chemistry of the sample area with other areas of the shroud. Thibault Heimburger, a shroud authenticity supporter writing a response to Antonacci that appears at the back of the on-line version Antonacci's report:
As I read that Heimburger questions whether Antonacci's claim that similar concentrations of calcium, iron and strontium is fully supported by his evidence and he says even if it is, is that proof that the patch areas and the rest of the shroud were manufactured at roughly the same time and place.

I thought Antonacci's best argument (beyond the chemical similarity argument which seems very good to me) might have been his argument that banding visible with transmitted light through the shroud is similar and continuous through the sample area from surrounding areas. Unfortunately the photograph that he offered as evidence of that was missing from the on-line report. However I did find a radiograph of the sample area that shows banding also. The radiograph is on page 42 of a paper by Schwable and Rogers http://ac.els-cdn.com/S000326700185...t=1342108692_bde95a56874f5a398909f87420fe3777

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/5664fff134e0afb3.jpg[/qimg]
Notes on the above image: I made it by clipping a section of the radiograph in the Scwalbe/Rogers paper and placing it next to a diagram from the Benford/Marino paper. I resized the diagram a bit so it was in the same scale as the clipped portion of the radiograph.


The fact that the banding that passes through the sample area is continuous through the sample area and there is not signs of anything resembling a patch in the area of the sample looks like extremely strong evidence that the sample was taken from an area that had not been patched. My only quibble with what looks like what might be categorical evidence to me is that the backing cloth was on the shroud when the image was made and perhaps the banding we are seeing was affected by banding on the backing cloth.
- Did anyone ever answer Davefoc's question?
 
I'm not sure I understand what you're seeing. Is it this?

z0BvhaQ.png


If so, remember that the bottom section of the photo is actually three layers of cloth, the shroud, its backing, and a bit more of its backing folded up underneath. The lower 'lighter area' is not part of the shroud at all.
 
- Note the lighter area about 3/4 of an inch to the right of the seam that parallels the seam and crosses bands.


Posting five images at once and asking people to note something that's an absolute distance (as though everyone is using the same size/resolution monitor that you are) from some line that may or may not appear as you describe it on any one of them is how evidence is presented in the world of Jabba's Truly Effective Debate™, is it?



That's what I was asking about. Since it paralleled the seam, which also crosses bands, I was thinking that it must be some sort of artefact (or repair)...



Are you truly incapable of understanding that whatever it is that you think you can see, if the banding of the weave is still visible and unbroken then no patching or reweaving can have occurred?



Whatever, it didn't seem to be the result of banding.



You appear, even after all the explanations, to have no idea whatsoever of what is meant by banding or what causes it.

None.
 
Last edited:
- Did anyone ever answer Davefoc's question?


What question?

And in any case, why are you incapable of reading the thread forward from the quoted post and answering your own question, just as anyone else would need/have needed to do?


Does it occur to you on any level that you are now 13 months behind the point at which everyone else now finds him/herself and still running at full speed astern?
 
Last edited:
I missed your last post while composing mine. Yes, the shroud and its backing were X-rayed together, so we're seeing two sets of threads. However, looking at the backing on its own (the dark bit in the top left hand side) it does not seem to contribute much to the banding. There do seem to be two white threads which follow through onto the shroud, but that's about it.
 
- Note the lighter area about 3/4 of an inch to the right of the seam that parallels the seam and crosses bands. That's what I was asking about. Since it paralleled the seam, which also crosses bands, I was thinking that it must be some sort of artefact (or repair)... Whatever, it didn't seem to be the result of banding.

For anyone reading this thread on a phone, that's likely to be in mid air, Jabba.
 
I'm not sure I understand what you're seeing. Is it this?

[qimg]http://i.imgur.com/z0BvhaQ.png[/qimg]

If so, remember that the bottom section of the photo is actually three layers of cloth, the shroud, its backing, and a bit more of its backing folded up underneath. The lower 'lighter area' is not part of the shroud at all.
Hugh,
- Note that the two sections you circled seem to actually join each other -- the joining part just being less obvious.
- I don't understand your last sentence -- i.e., the banding is continuous all around the lower lighter area and must be part of the shroud. Do you accept that the lower area -- except for the lighter area within it -- is part of the shroud?
 
Last edited:
Jabba, I'm having a lot of trouble understanding your argument.
Could you please post up photos with the circled areas you're talking about?
 
Hugh,
- Note that the two sections you circled seem to actually join each other

<gibbersnip>


Except that they don't. At all.

You're blatantly trying to describe things to us that are completely at odds with what is right in front of our noses.

Really. It's as though you're pointing at a Peruvian mountain shrimp and telling us all about the elephant that we're supposed to see.
 
Maybe this will help. Use number and letter as reference on grid.
For example, the white rectangle is at 5D.


ETA: Click on picture to enlarge. For some reason, I can't post it bigger.
 
Last edited:
- I haven't had a chance to pursue the suggestions of how to do that -- especially, since at least some of them wouldn't work with Windows 8, and something that supposedly would work with Windows 8 didn't seem to work with me and my Windows 8...
Which bit didn't work for you?

- I don't understand your last sentence -- i.e., the banding is continuous all around the lower lighter area and must be part of the shroud. Do you accept that the lower area -- except for the lighter area within it -- is part of the shroud?
You referred to davefoc's comment that banding visible on the x-ray may have been affected by the backing cloth. But in Hugh Farey's image (version below cropped by me to show just the center image), you can see that the top left part that shows just the backing cloth is dark. There's not much banding visible there at all. It follows, therefore, that even in the areas where the image is of the shroud + backing cloth, the backing cloth won't have much affect on the banding of the shroud. This is the answer to davefoc's question (which wasn't really a question) that you asked about above.

9p7Oa55-middlesection.png
 
Carbon Dating/Banding

Which bit didn't work for you?


You referred to davefoc's comment that banding visible on the x-ray may have been affected by the backing cloth. But in Hugh Farey's image (version below cropped by me to show just the center image), you can see that the top left part that shows just the backing cloth is dark. There's not much banding visible there at all. It follows, therefore, that even in the areas where the image is of the shroud + backing cloth, the backing cloth won't have much affect on the banding of the shroud. This is the answer to davefoc's question (which wasn't really a question) that you asked about above.

[qimg]http://i254.photobucket.com/albums/hh91/AlwaysTomboy/9p7Oa55-middlesection.png[/qimg]
Tomboy,
- Yeah. I had come to that conclusion myself -- figuring that there should be no way that banding on the backing cloth would show up better when covered by the shroud... Didn’t get a chance to mention it cause I was still struggling with the parallel lighter areas – note that there’s also a lighter area bordering the left side of the seam…
- It wasn’t an explicit question. But it was an implicit question in that he was telling us something he had a question about. Seemed like the easiest way to describe his issue.
 
Jabba, do you think that the hand-spun threads of which the shroud is woven will have a constant thickness and density?

Do you think that the hand-woven cloth will have a constant tightness and thread density?

Do you think that the threads will lie perfectly straight and parallel?

Do you think that after 700 years they will still all be straight and uniform with constant density and thickness?

Do you think that some of these factors may result in lighter and darker areas on the cloth, as might be seen in an X-ray image?
 
Last edited:
- Note the lighter area about 3/4 of an inch to the right of the seam that parallels the seam and crosses bands. That's what I was asking about. Since it paralleled the seam, which also crosses bands, I was thinking that it must be some sort of artefact (or repair)... Whatever, it didn't seem to be the result of banding.
I am sorry, I cannot work out which area you mean. What grid reference would you give this area on Olokow's picture where s/he's added coordinates?
 
Hugh,
- Note that the two sections you circled seem to actually join each other -- the joining part just being less obvious.
- I don't understand your last sentence -- i.e., the banding is continuous all around the lower lighter area and must be part of the shroud. Do you accept that the lower area -- except for the lighter area within it -- is part of the shroud?
You've lost me here. Any apparent joining of the two more-or-less vertical areas I put rings round is illusion, I think. The upper one is a feature of the shroud and the lower one is a feature of the backing cloth. As for "the lower area," well Tomboy has kindly reposted my earlier picture. You can see what layers there are on my labels. The only other thing which might be confusing is the prominent white band running approximately horizontally between J1 and K5, which is the hem of the backing cloth of the shroud. Would a diagram showing a section through the picture help, do you think?
 
Carbon Dating/Banding/xray?

xray.jpg

Maurice,
- Here's hoping...
- Cool!

Everybody,
- My drawing isn't very good, but it should get us started.
- I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.
- If you notice -- the not so obvious middle section also parallels the seam. To me, that pretty much assures that the middle section is not my imagination.
- Also note that the overall lighter area begins just opposite the beginning of the lighter area to the immediate left of the seam.
- Also, note the light band that continues from the beginning of the lighter area -- on both sides of the seam.
 
Last edited:
View attachment 28832

Everybody,
- My drawing isn't very good, but it should get us started.
- I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.
- If you notice -- the not so obvious middle section also parallels the seam. To me, that pretty much assures that the middle section is not my imagination.
- Also note that the overall lighter area begins just opposite the beginning of the lighter area to the immediate left of the seam.
- Also, note the light band that continues from the beginning of the lighter area -- on both sides of the seam.

So exactly the area highlighted by hughfarey in post #9538.

You could have saved yourself a lot of heartache and just agreed that this is the area you were thinking had an anomaly. Then again, you've acquired a skill so maybe it was worthwhile after all.



edited to add......

As hughfarey pointed out, the lower part isn't part of the shroud or rather not solely the shoud.

As somone (sorry i forget who) points out, it is a 700 year old hand-woven piece of linen. It's not surprising that the threads aren't perfectly parallel.
 
Last edited:
So exactly the area highlighted by hughfarey in post #9538.

You could have saved yourself a lot of heartache and just agreed that this is the area you were thinking had an anomaly. Then again, you've acquired a skill so maybe it was worthwhile after all.



edited to add......

As hughfarey pointed out, the lower part isn't part of the shroud or rather not solely the shoud.

As somone (sorry i forget who) points out, it is a 700 year old hand-woven piece of linen. It's not surprising that the threads aren't perfectly parallel.
Don,
- But Hugh left out that middle section.
 
View attachment 28832

Maurice,
- Here's hoping...
- Cool!

Everybody,
- My drawing isn't very good, but it should get us started.
1. I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.
2. If you notice -- the not so obvious middle section also parallels the seam. To me, that pretty much assures that the middle section is not my imagination.
3. Also note that the overall lighter area begins just opposite the beginning of the lighter area to the immediate left of the seam.
4. Also, note the light band that continues from the beginning of the lighter area -- on both sides of the seam.

1. The middle section of your outline is darker than the rest of the cloth enclosed in your outline, and almost the same colour as the main piece of cloth.

2. The linen is woven from warp and weft threads; the warp threads parallel the side seams, the weft threads run perpendicular to the warp and so parallel the top and bottom seams. Any areas of lighter or darker shading (caused by the inherent variability of 13th/14th century hand spun thread being hand woven into cloth) will lie either parallel or perpendicular to the selvedges or the top/bottom of the cloth. If the item is seamed straight along the sides or the top and bottom, the lighter/darker shading cannot help but lie parallel to a seam.

3. What does this imply to you?

4. What does this imply to you?

All the areas of lighter and darker shading can be explained by hand spun thread made from a naturally grown plant, which will vary in thickness, density and colour, which is then hand woven into a piece of cloth.

I don't know if this next bit will help you understand how thread which varies slightly in colour, thickness etc will produce lighter and darker areas on the cloth, but I'll try anyway.

One can purchase wool (yarn) for knitting which varies in colour through the skein; the colours are much more contrasting than the tiny variations we see in the linen of the shroud, but they illustrate the principle nicely. For example, this yarn: http://www.adriafil.com/uk/scheda-filato.html?id_cat=13&id_gr=3&id_filato=ZA will knit up into a garment with self-stripes such as the pink/white pullover pictured below it. The yarn varies randomly in colour, but the cloth produced from it forms patches and stripes of lighter and darker shade.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom