Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
View attachment 28832

Maurice,
- Here's hoping...
- Cool!

Everybody,
- My drawing isn't very good, but it should get us started.


And finished.

Regardless of the quality of your "drawing" and ignoring the root-canalness of having obtained it - it shows nothing.

Where is the interruption to the banding which would serve as evidence of the area in question having been patched or repaired?


- I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.


Maybe, maybe not. I can almost see it myself. None of us are immune.


So maybe it's a case of shared pareidolia.

Maybe it's an x-ray reflection off the material in the seam.

Maybe it's an artifact of the process(es) that were involved in rendering the image that we now see.

Maybe it's a coffee stain.


Whatever it is, it does not interrupt the banding which was woven into the cloth at the time of its manufacture.



- If you notice -- the not so obvious middle section also parallels the seam. To me, that pretty much assures that the middle section is not my imagination.


No, your imagination only comes into play when you seek to produce miraculous explanations for mundane nothingness.



- Also note that the overall lighter area begins just opposite the beginning of the lighter area to the immediate left of the seam.


So bloody what?



- Also, note the light band that continues from the beginning of the lighter area -- on both sides of the seam.


Are you now claiming that the invisible mending was also carried out on the backing cloth?


That'll end well.
 
Last edited:
My drawing isn't very good, but it should get us started.
It's an excellent first step; well done.
I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.
I have to say that the diagonal strip is not obvious to me. However even if it was, it cannot be an indication of any diagonal threads. The light areas are caused by random variation in thicknesses in adjacent threads, vertical areas by warp threads and horizontal ones by weft threads.They are an emergent property of the arrangement of threads. To achieve a diagonal light area, you would need a stepwise arrangement of thick portions of successive warp or weave threads. That is not impossible, but it is also not evidence of interpolated thread.

the not so obvious middle section also parallels the seam. To me, that pretty much assures that the middle section is not my imagination.
To me it's wholly irrelevant. The seam follows the cutting of the shroud along the line where the side-strip was cut away, which has no connection at all with your diagonal lighter area.

Also note that the overall lighter area begins just opposite the beginning of the lighter area to the immediate left of the seam.
No, you've lost me again. I think all the lower lighter areas are artefacts of the triple cloth thickness.

Also, note the light band that continues from the beginning of the lighter area -- on both sides of the seam.
I think this is the hem of the backing cloth, folded up underneath the shroud on the frame when it was mounted for photographing.
 
Carbon Dating/Banding/Xray

- Apparently, someone has radiographs all along the seam (http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf:).
- Would other areas along the seam show similar characteristics? How about the other end of the shroud? Seems like we could expect other similar areas along the seam (especially the other end)... And, if there aren't any, we have further evidence that the sample area is not representative of the greater shroud.
 
We wouldn't have 'further' evidence, since we haven't yet had any evidence that the sampled area is not representative of the rest of the cloth. Quite the reverse in fact; the banding shows that there is no interpolated material in the sampled area.
 
- Apparently, someone has radiographs all along the seam (http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf:).


Gosh!

Your link doesn't work.



- Would other areas along the seam show similar characteristics?


You're telling this story.

Do they?



How about the other end of the shroud?


Isis knows. Why don't you tell us about it?



Seems like we could expect other similar areas along the seam (especially the other end)...


Probably.

And?


And, if there aren't any, we have further evidence that the sample area is not representative of the greater shroud.


Well then, all you have to do is produce images showing the sample area's uniqueness and we'll have something to discuss.

After breakfast, perhaps?
 
Last edited:
Gosh!

Your link doesn't work...
Akhenaten,
- Sorry about that.
- The following is the second paragraph in their excerpt.

(Figures 1 & 2) The details of the 1978 radiographic study are described in the paper
“Radiological Examination of the Shroud of Turin – A Preliminary Report by Mottern, Landon
and Morris, (Ref.: Mottern et al, 1979) In summary, the purpose of the radiographs, as one of
many non-destructive tests, was to collect data on the body images, on the other markings, and
on the linen itself. A Baltograph 5-50 x-ray unit was operated at 15 kVp with filtration to obtain
maximum contrast for the delineation of the features. The specially designed examination table
to which the Shroud was attached by magnetic strips had removable panels, so that only the
fabric was between the film packets and the x-ray source. Positioned just above the Shroud was
an open frame with wires strung horizontally and vertically to provide orientation and
measurement. The examinations were made by a series of three exposures of the film packets across the width of the cloth, with some overlaps. Two different types of x-ray film were in each
packet to provide good contrast and resolution characteristics. A total of forty-two dual-film
packets were exposed. For the many technical details, the original paper should be consulted.
The resolution of images was felt adequate to visualize the individual linen threads of the Shroud
which are about 0.15 mm in diameter.
 
Hugh,
- But, you can tell what I'm referring to?


Everyone, I'm sure, can tell to what you are referring.


TableclothXray01b.jpg


When are you going to attempt an explanation of how it demonstrates that some kind of repair/patching has been carried out on the area in question?
 
I'm claiming that the middle, diagonal, section of the lighter area within my outline is not my imagination -- it isn't a personal case of pareidolia.


I have to say that the diagonal strip is not obvious to me.


The more I look at it, the more I'm inclined to agree with you.

I think the way Jabba has drawn those lines where he thinks he sees something amounts to what I'm going to refer to as 'induced pareidolia'.
 
The more I look at it, the more I'm inclined to agree with you.

I think the way Jabba has drawn those lines where he thinks he sees something amounts to what I'm going to refer to as 'induced pareidolia'.

I suspect Jabba is at some level aware of the pareidolia aspect since he tried to head that off at the pass at the outset.
 
Yes, I can see exactly the area you're referring to, and on enlarging the photo enormously, can point out two places where a couple of warp threads do appear a bit brighter than their surroundings. I just don't think it means anything.

The Whanger paper you tried to link to is at http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf which is what you put except you had an extra colon at the end. The paper is an attempt to show that a) the side-strip is contiguous with the rest of the cloth and had not been cut off and re-attached b) that the area of the C-14 sample shows 'irregularities in some of the weave pattern' and 'significant variability in the radio density' of the threads. Some of the threads 'angulate' and others have broken continuity. The area is denser and the herring-bone pattern less clear. Perhaps I should add that none of these observations is obvious from the photos they publish with the paper, and that the Whangers were already convinced that the C-14 dating was wrong.

If I can, I will get hold of a copy of Mottern's original paper on the X-rays, but it is not easily available.
 
- Apparently, someone has radiographs all along the seam (http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf:).
- Would other areas along the seam show similar characteristics? How about the other end of the shroud? Seems like we could expect other similar areas along the seam (especially the other end)... And, if there aren't any, we have further evidence that the sample area is not representative of the greater shroud.


Fixed your whanger for you.:D
 
- Apparently, someone has radiographs all along the seam (http://www.shroud.com/pdfs/whanger.pdf:).
- Would other areas along the seam show similar characteristics? How about the other end of the shroud? Seems like we could expect other similar areas along the seam (especially the other end)... And, if there aren't any, we have further evidence that the sample area is not representative of the greater shroud.

So because there isn't evidence of micro-repair then there must be large-scale repair instead.

In fact the whole Shroud (Mediaeval artifact carbon dated to the 14th century) is not representative of the Greater ShroudTM (mythical burial shroud of Christ).
 
So because there isn't evidence of micro-repair then there must be large-scale repair instead.

In fact the whole Shroud (Mediaeval artifact carbon dated to the 14th century) is not representative of the Greater ShroudTM (mythical burial shroud of Christ).


Perhaps someone should carbon date a piece of one of those bloody great visible patches.

Imagine the hilarity if it turned out that they date from the 1st century and it's only the rest of the Greater Shroud™ (with the bogus image, etcetera) that's a 14th century fake.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom