Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
I got a new toy this week. It's a portable scanner. It is a bar about a foot long with a scanning light that you roll across a piece of paper. The rolling activates the "capture".

So being a guy, I had to screw around with it. I thought, "What would the Shroud of Turin look like if it really did capture the face that it was laid (or even rolled) over?"

So here it is: Tricky Jesus. This is what the face of the shroud would look like if it really did capture the image of the face it was wrapped around.*

*Assuming, of course, Jesus looked like me. A safe assumption I think.
picture.php
 
Stalkers/Reweaving/Multi-quote function/HTH HAND

Let me see if I have this straight. Jabba talked to this guy last summer abut the same topic, and seems to have no recollection of it? And his website has been recommended to Jabba several times by people on this thread, and Jabba thinks he just now discovered it?

Is this correct, or am I misinterpreting what 'the best man in this fight' is saying?

:rolleyes:

That's not my recollection. He mentioned the guy in the context of him replying to a couple of shroud folks, but did not claim here to have contacted him personally. I feel bad for this Mr. Ehrlich though; they have apparently been bugging him for years now, if Jabba's entry below is correct.

Ward,
- Just followed your suggestion. I.E.,

- I think that I asked about this previously (somewhere on Dan’s blog) — but, if I did, I can’t find it…
- According to Michael Ehrlich — the head of “Without a Trace,” the company to which Joe Marino refers when claiming that a really invisible patch is possible — the process for producing a really invisible patch requires the exclusive use of undamaged threads from the original cloth. In other words, even if this process were used on the carbon dating sample from the Shroud, the patch should show the same age as the rest of the cloth…
- Do we have a counter claim?
- (I have a possibility, but don’t know that it really makes sense.)


- I do have a possibility in mind -- which makes it difficult for me to dump (accept the refutation of) the patch theory altogether, but won't mention it till I get some word back (or, fail to get any word back) from my friends.

--- Jabba




Dinwar & Pixel,
- You seem to be accepting that there is reason to doubt at least some of F-L's testimony.
- I assume that you must believe that the doubt refers only, or essentially, to the carbon dating -- that her assessment re the weaving is above repute.
- However, given the quote from http://shroud.com/pdfs/chronology.pdf

Entry: #39
Date: 2005
Data Category: Possibility or direct evidence of invisible reweaving
Evidence: In response to a claim by textile expert, Mechthild Flury-Lemberg, who claimed in a
personal communication to Benford and Marino in November 2000 that an ―invisible reweave‖
was technically impossible, they contacted the president and owner of Without A Trace, Inc.
(www.withoutatrace.com) in Chicago, IL, Mr. Michael Ehrlich. Mr. Ehrlich‘s response to Flury-
Lemberg‘s statement was that the modern-day, time-saving technique for large repairs, called
―Inweaving,‖ would indeed be invisible from the surface but easily recognizable from the back
as she claimed. However, the technique used in 16th Century Europe, called ―French Weaving,‖
is an altogether different technique from Inweaving. French Weaving, now only done on small
imperfections due to its extensive cost and time, results in both front and back side ―invisibility.‖
Erlich also wrote, ―Today, there is a modern, time-saving technique called ‗inweaving‘ that
would be invisible from the surface, but easily recognizable from the back. However, the
technique used in sixteenth century Europe called ―French weaving‖ is an entirely different
matter. French weaving involves a tedious thread-by-thread restoration that is, indeed, invisible.
Sixteenth century owners of the Shroud certainly had enough material resources and weeks of
time at their disposal to accomplish the task


- we have some reason to doubt her assessment re the weaving.

--- Jabba

It's worth noting (again^8) for Jabba's sake, that "invisible" reweaving is only sort of invisible because it uses material from the same cloth, so it obviously wouldn't change the carbon-dated age of anything. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I got a new toy this week. It's a portable scanner. It is a bar about a foot long with a scanning light that you roll across a piece of paper. The rolling activates the "capture".

So being a guy, I had to screw around with it. I thought, "What would the Shroud of Turin look like if it really did capture the face that it was laid (or even rolled) over?"

So here it is: Tricky Jesus. This is what the face of the shroud would look like if it really did capture the image of the face it was wrapped around.*

*Assuming, of course, Jesus looked like me. A safe assumption I think.
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=1113&pictureid=8109[/qimg]

Reported! wait ... I see what it is now.
 
- Just to keep y'all up to date with my "progress"...


Movement backwards isn't progress.


- Or really, just to let you know that I am working at it.


The only thing that you seem to be working on is avoidance of the task at hand, namely: figuring how to post the as-yet-to-be-identified image which you claim contains anomalies in the banding of the cloth.


- I just spoke to Michael Ehrlich of Without a Trace, and probably didn't get any support.


Which news comes as a complete surprise to exactly one person.


For one thing, it turns out that he was not the expert that referred me to "reversing" -- though, he did say that you could hide the reweave on the back by cutting the thread at the necessary places.


You mean your impeccably kept research notes have let you down?

How can this be?


- He couldn't tell me anything about the banding, though I realize now that I didn't explain it in a way that he would know what I was talking about


Sounds familiar.


-- I started off talking about what the shroud looks like under UV radiation, and even though he's very friendly, I could tell that he was getting impatient with my weird issues.


You should have pointed out that you were the better man and that he was therefore obliged to answer all of your questions.

That always helps.


- Anyway, when I asked him if it were possible to reweave the top threads, or top of the threads, (I didn't actually include that last part in my question to him) in such a way so as to not disturb the bottom threads, he referred me to www.withoutatrace.com to see how reweave is actually accomplished in his shops.


The poor man deserves a medal


- That's my next stop.


I'd suggest making a list first.
 
<snip>

- Anyway, when I asked him if it were possible to reweave the top threads, or top of the threads, (I didn't actually include that last part in my question to him) in such a way so as to not disturb the bottom threads

<snip>


What are these top and bottom threads you're talking about?

The nearest I can get to making any sense of this at all is to assume that you mean 'back' and 'front', but the inference that you believe these to be different threads is making my brain hurt.
 
Maurice,

- Thank you.

- Unfortunately, my operating system crashed a few weeks ago, and I had to install Windows 8. Consequently, I ran into trouble when I was supposed to left-click "Start," and Windows 8 doesn't have such a thing (that I can find). I tried to go "around" that part of your instructions but was immediately mired in the Windows mud!#$%^&*!
- I gotta wonder how many old farts drop dead just trying to do simple stuff on their computers -- or worse, talking to alien technicians on the phone about doing stuff!#$%^&*!...


Jabba, you have so many reasons why you can't provide supporting evidence of your claims, or even keep-up with the rest of us geezers here.

Maybe you should write a book? Get back to us on that.
 
Rats, Raspberries and the Turin Shroud

Let me see if I have this straight. Jabba talked to this guy last summer abut the same topic, and seems to have no recollection of it? And his website has been recommended to Jabba several times by people on this thread, and Jabba thinks he just now discovered it?

Is this correct, or am I misinterpreting what 'the best man in this fight' is saying?

:rolleyes:

That's not my recollection. He mentioned the guy in the context of him replying to a couple of shroud folks, but did not claim here to have contacted him personally. I feel bad for this Mr. Ehrlich though; they have apparently been bugging him for years now, if Jabba's entry below is correct.








It's worth noting (again^8) for Jabba's sake, that "invisible" reweaving is only sort of invisible because it uses material from the same cloth, so it obviously wouldn't change the carbon-dated age of anything. :rolleyes:


My bad, people, sorry for the confusion!
Jabba spoke personally to Mr Ehrlich 18 October 2012, not in the Summer of 2012.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8701159&postcount=3641
- Rats!

- Mr Ehrlich said that the really "invisible" re-weaving, the French Re-weaving, would use only threads from the main cloth...
- "Inweaving," which would not be "invisible," could use new material.

- He was in a hurry, and I didn't specifically ask Pakeha's question, but sure sounds like Ehrlich would say that experts would have recognized the patch if it had used new material.
- He was happy to have me quote him, and I told him that it would be on the Randi forum, but didn't get a chance to give him the Internet address.

- I reserve the right to come back and add new, "exculpatory," evidence if I should find some, but for now at least, I concede this round to you guys, and will drop my invisible re-weave explanation possibility.
- I will, however, tell Joe Marino, and the guys on Dan Porter's blog what Ehrlich said, and see if anyone has an effective comeback.

- Raspberries!!!

--- Jabba

Jabba has also been in contact with the website withoutatrace itself

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8698096&postcount=3608
- I'm currently working on summarizing our disagreement about Flury-Lemberg possibly overlooking a patch, but just sent the following request to http://withoutatrace.com/ regarding our next sub-etc-issue. If they respond, I'll post their response.

- You guys have probably been bombarded with questions about the Shroud of Turin and the potential "invisibility" of a patch using French Weave. Sorry, but I have another question – hopefully, it’s one you’ve already answered.
- Apparently, such a patch requires the use of undamaged threads from the greater cloth except on rare occasions. My question: could such an invisible patch use those undamaged threads from the greater cloth to simply replace the damaged edge of the greater cloth, but use NEW CLOTH for the greater patch? Hope that translates.
- Thanks.
--- Rich Savage


--- Jabba
 
Last edited:
Macaroni, M&Ms and Major Resets.

I feel very sorry for Michael Ehrlich. It sounds as though his politeness and willingness to answer ridiculous questions is being taken advantage of by the shroudies.

Jabba, the linen of the shroud is woven in one piece; there are no "top threads" or "bottom threads". The weft threads go over and under the warp threads. In a simple 1x1 weave, the threads look like this:
 

Attachments

  • tx_warp_weft_selvedge.gif
    tx_warp_weft_selvedge.gif
    8 KB · Views: 6
Jabba, the linen of the shroud is woven in one piece; there are no "top threads" or "bottom threads". The weft threads go over and under the warp threads. In a simple 1x1 weave, the threads look like this:
However, in a 3/1 weave, three-quarters of the appearance of the "top" of the cloth (in this case, the image side) is composed of warp threads, and three-quarters of the appearance of the "bottom" of the cloth is composed of weft. Replacing a weft thread by another in, say, bright green, would only appear as a series of dots on the top, although of course it would be very obvious on the bottom. This is why it is instructive to examine the Schwortz photos of the retained Tucson piece, because they show both sides. I can't find any anomalies on either side, which more clearly suggests no interpolation than just examining one side.
 
Absolutely, we are in agreement. Though my point was that any one thread is simultaneously both a 'top' and a 'bottom' thread - which is the case in a 1x1 weave or a 3x1 herringbone weave or any other pattern. It's not possible to replace a thread on one side of the linen while leaving that same original thread undisturbed on the other side, which is where I think Jabba may be going.

3x1 twill, showing the way the linen is constructed for Jabba:
 

Attachments

  • 220px-31twillsm.png
    220px-31twillsm.png
    19.3 KB · Views: 212
No worries, carlitos.
Still, it's difficult to imagine mr Ehrlich's reaction to being called twice in less than a year by the same person on the same subject.

Jabba, did the website ever answer your e-mail, the one you sent 18 Sept 2012?
 
Carbon Dating/Banding

Pakeha,
- I wasn't asking the same question, just 10 months apart -- and as far as I know, no other Shroudie has called him. He seemed happy to hear from me again until I started saying something about UV radiation.
- I can't remember for sure, but I don't think that they ever answered my question. I'll have to put that on the back burner for now.
 
The poor guy is a tailor, and you're asking him about UV radiation. Next you'll be bringing up quantum physics. Leave him alone, for pete's sake.
 
Pakeha,
- I wasn't asking the same question, just 10 months apart -- and as far as I know, no other Shroudie has called him. He seemed happy to hear from me again until I started saying something about UV radiation.
- I can't remember for sure, but I don't think that they ever answered my question. I'll have to put that on the back burner for now.
You really need to get your UV, your X-rays and your transmitted light sorted out before you get back to Mr Ehrlich. As far as I know there are NO UV photos of the C-14 area of the shroud, and even if there were, there is no reason why they should show banding well. No wonder Mr Ehrlich was confused. The photos which show banding are X-rays, and transmitted light. The X-rays are by far the best, as the transmitted light photos are at a much smaller scale, but both of them are made by radiation passing through the cloth from one side to the other, and so give a direct indication of the thickness of the threads they pass through. The UV photos are from reflectance only, and don't show any more than visible-light ones.
 
Pakeha,
- I wasn't asking the same question, just 10 months apart -- and as far as I know, no other Shroudie has called him. He seemed happy to hear from me again until I started saying something about UV radiation.
- I can't remember for sure, but I don't think that they ever answered my question. I'll have to put that on the back burner for now.

You're quite right, Jabba.
I'm sorry to have misunderstood you.
About your first convo with mr Ehrlich you reported
- Mr Ehrlich said that the really "invisible" re-weaving, the French Re-weaving, would use only threads from the main cloth...
- "Inweaving," which would not be "invisible," could use new material.

- He was in a hurry, and I didn't specifically ask Pakeha's question, but sure sounds like Ehrlich would say that experts would have recognized the patch if it had used new material.
- He was happy to have me quote him, and I told him that it would be on the Randi forum, but didn't get a chance to give him the Internet address.

And in the second

...
- I just spoke to Michael Ehrlich of Without a Trace, and probably didn't get any support. For one thing, it turns out that he was not the expert that referred me to "reversing" -- though, he did say that you could hide the reweave on the back by cutting the thread at the necessary places.
- He couldn't tell me anything about the banding, though I realize now that I didn't explain it in a way that he would know what I was talking about -- I started off talking about what the shroud looks like under UV radiation, and even though he's very friendly, I could tell that he was getting impatient with my weird issues.
- Anyway, when I asked him if it were possible to reweave the top threads, or top of the threads, (I didn't actually include that last part in my question to him) in such a way so as to not disturb the bottom threads, he referred me to www.withoutatrace.com to see how reweave is actually accomplished in his shops.
- That's my next stop.

Thanks for putting me straight!

You really need to get your UV, your X-rays and your transmitted light sorted out before you get back to Mr Ehrlich. As far as I know there are NO UV photos of the C-14 area of the shroud, and even if there were, there is no reason why they should show banding well. No wonder Mr Ehrlich was confused. The photos which show banding are X-rays, and transmitted light. The X-rays are by far the best, as the transmitted light photos are at a much smaller scale, but both of them are made by radiation passing through the cloth from one side to the other, and so give a direct indication of the thickness of the threads they pass through. The UV photos are from reflectance only, and don't show any more than visible-light ones.
my hiliting in that distressingly humdrum yellow

Are you up for putting through a call to the poor fellow and clearing that up, hugh?
 
Are you up for putting through a call to the poor fellow and clearing that up, hugh?
Er... no. If he's interested, he'll Google Turin Shroud and Invisible Mending, and will find out all about it; if not, I don't think we need to bother him by phone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom