Miracle of the Shroud / Blood on the shroud

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carbon Dating/Banding

- Just to keep y'all up to date with my "progress"...
- Or really, just to let you know that I am working at it.

- I just spoke to Michael Ehrlich of Without a Trace, and probably didn't get any support. For one thing, it turns out that he was not the expert that referred me to "reversing" -- though, he did say that you could hide the reweave on the back by cutting the thread at the necessary places.
- He couldn't tell me anything about the banding, though I realize now that I didn't explain it in a way that he would know what I was talking about -- I started off talking about what the shroud looks like under UV radiation, and even though he's very friendly, I could tell that he was getting impatient with my weird issues.
- Anyway, when I asked him if it were possible to reweave the top threads, or top of the threads, (I didn't actually include that last part in my question to him) in such a way so as to not disturb the bottom threads, he referred me to www.withoutatrace.com to see how reweave is actually accomplished in his shops.
- That's my next stop.
What are these top and bottom threads you're talking about?
The nearest I can get to making any sense of this at all is to assume that you mean 'back' and 'front', but the inference that you believe these to be different threads is making my brain hurt.
Anakahen,
- I realized too late that "top threads" and "bottom threads" probably didn't make sense...
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating/Banding

There may be artefacts of the photo which affect some of these observations. The UV source was two lamps, one on either side of the camera, pointing at 45° towards the middle of each photo. The UV light was not evenly spread across the cloth, which is why each photo is lighter in the middle than it is at the edges. However, you are certainly correct that the scorch-marks seriously dampen the fluorescence (as does the 'blood'), and there does seem to be a roughly reversed C-shape in the middle. I suggest this may be due to a slight quenching of the fluorescence to the left of the shape, possibly due to an effect of the big diamond shaped water-stain right in the middle of the photo, of which the right hand edge can be seen clearly.
Hugh,
- For some reason, I can't find the diagram you gave for the UV contraption. Can you give me a hand?
 
Last edited:
Hugh,
- For some reason, I can't find the diagram you gave for the UV contraption. Can you give me a hand?
Yes, indeed. It's on the third page of the Miller/Pellicori paper (actually page 73 of the Journal it's published in), which I understand you can access via the New York Library.
 
- I accept that the banding probably is uninterrupted through the sample area... But, there are some barely visible, strange shaped, lighter areas extending down through the samples and into the reserve -- they start in the first Arizona sample. I'm trying to figure out how to copy the Schwalbe/Rogers radiograph and then draw lines around the interruptions I'm imagining.

Are these different from what's seen in the shroud in other locations? Remember, the banding is related to the amount of thread the shuttle can hold; thus, we would expect to see some variations. Simply pointing out that variations exist is not evidence of patching...
Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?
 
Random newz...
http://www.livescience.com/6912-voice-reason-truth-shroud-turin.html

While science and scholarship have demonstrated that the Shroud of Turin is not the burial cloth of Jesus but instead a fourteenth-century forgery, shroud devotees continue to claim otherwise.

In medieval Europe alone there were more than forty "True Shrouds," although the Turin Cloth uniquely bears the apparent imprints of a man, crucified like Jesus in the gospel narratives. Unfortunately, the alleged "relic" has not fared well in various scientific examinations--except those conducted by Shroud partisans like those of the Shroud of Turin Research Project (STURP), whose leaders served on the executive council of the pro-authenticity Holy Shroud Guild.

The following facts have been established by various distinguished experts and scholars:...
end of copy-paste.
 
Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?

Mr. Savage:

You are grasping at straws. Remember that the banding seen is an artifact of the way the shuttle lays in the weft threads. If weft threads had been replaced, the banding would not be disturbed, or displaced, but destroyed. Threads added into the original weave would not show a different banding, but no banding at all; taken, as it were, at random, from a shuttle spool or from other places on the cloth, there would be no looming artifact.

None of which addresses that fact that the photos of the samples do not show that 60%-80% of the samples are egregious threads.

None of which answers the questions as to who wrought the "patching", and when, and for what reason; or why a "much-handled" insignificant corner of the linen was chosen for such special treatment.

To say nothing of problems with the image itself...
 
Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?

No.

Move along. You're supposed to be refuting the 14C dating. This patching/reweaving/repairing angle is a dead end. Your argument has gotten no traction from beating this into the ground - just the opposite, in fact.
 
Whangers/Clangers/What a moiré!

Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?


What a ridiculous question.

The banding is right there for everyone to see, despite the low quality of the image.

Obviously, nothing "precludes" it.


Speaking of the quality of the image . . .

I assume this is the image you're talking about as it appears in the Whanger paper (you have yet to clarify this, by the way):


TableclothXray02.png

Are you aware that it's overlaid, quite heavily, with the mosaic-like pattern that I've enhanced below?


TableclothXray01a.jpg

I'm pretty sure this is a moiré pattern which has been introduced by reproducing the image using media having different resolutions and is but one of many artefacts contained in the image which a keen evidence discarder could use to imply all sorts of things.

It doesn't, however, disguise the banding of the cloth. Only deepest, darkest denial can do that.
 
What a ridiculous question.

The banding is right there for everyone to see, despite the low quality of the image.

Obviously, nothing "precludes" it.


Speaking of the quality of the image . . .

I assume this is the image you're talking about as it appears in the Whanger paper (you have yet to clarify this, by the way):


[qimg]http://www.yvonneclaireadams.com/HostedStuff/TableclothXray02.png[/qimg]​

Are you aware that it's overlaid, quite heavily, with the mosaic-like pattern that I've enhanced below?


[qimg]http://www.yvonneclaireadams.com/HostedStuff/TableclothXray01a.jpg[/qimg]​

I'm pretty sure this is a moiré pattern which has been introduced by reproducing the image using media having different resolutions and is but one of many artefacts contained in the image which a keen evidence discarder could use to imply all sorts of things.

It doesn't, however, disguise the banding of the cloth. Only deepest, darkest denial can do that.

I would have pegged those as compression artefacts, maybe.
 
I'm happy to agree, although whoever used whatever they used to compress the raw image is a complete amateur.

The x-y alignment sorta has me heading for that. Moire really doesn't care at all. But the bottom line is it is in reality distortion of some kind, and it's obvious, even in the original image.

More to the point is why jabba failed to spot it.

Shroud of turducken is immanent.
 
It's a 700 year old piece of handwoven linen.

Of course the banding isn't perfectly straight.
 
Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?

I hope you've had time to consider this question. It's obviously silly. Even without the image issues, the trivially obvious answer to your question is that the banding must be parallel to the threads of the cloth. If those weren't perfectly straight, the bands wouldn't be either.
 
I hope you've had time to consider this question. It's obviously silly. Even without the image issues, the trivially obvious answer to your question is that the banding must be parallel to the threads of the cloth. If those weren't perfectly straight, the bands wouldn't be either.

Did you grok that answer, Jabba?
 
I got a new toy this week. It's a portable scanner. It is a bar about a foot long with a scanning light that you roll across a piece of paper. The rolling activates the "capture". ...]

Oh, what fun! That's now on my Twelfth Night wish list.

Dinwar,
- These lighter areas aren't straight. Wouldn't that preclude "banding?


It's a 700 year old piece of handwoven linen.

Of course the banding isn't perfectly straight.

Yes.
Jabba, I think all this question would be much easier to understand if you observed weaver at work or even tried that activity for yourself.
Hand weaving's a fascinating thing to watch,


Yes.
Still, seeing is believing
 
Last edited:
Carbon Dating/Banding

Hugh,
- Referring back to the Tomboy pictures, I can at least imagine seeing some significant interruption of the banding in the Schwalbe/Rogers radiograph of the sample area. Is it just my imagination?
--- Jabba

I think it must be, as it is the only available image which shows the banding with any clarity. And you beat me to it, but here is my take on the subject anyway:

[qimg]http://i.imgur.com/9p7Oa55.png[/qimg].
- Note the lighter area about 3/4 of an inch to the right of the seam that parallels the seam and crosses bands. That's what I was asking about. Since it paralleled the seam, which also crosses bands, I was thinking that it must be some sort of artefact (or repair)... Whatever, it didn't seem to be the result of banding.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom