Meters for Panhandlers

Why all the hatred?
Because I don't think a lot of people here have had pleasant experiences with these people. Though the quality of the panhandler does vary a bit to the point where I've seen homeless people that run businesses. Though in that case I wonder if that is even applicable to panhandling.
People who play music or perform other activities on the street for money aren't panhandlers, they're buskers.
And in general they are not homeless and have money.
 
Last edited:
I think the calculation went wrong long before that - when Fnord implied that he'd actually given $5 to some smelly, dirty, probably mad, poor person...let alone that that donation would be matched every 30 seconds for a single hour, let alone the rest of the day.
Fnord was referring to street performers, not smelly dirty poor persons. Do you read for content?
 
There are panhandlers all over where I live and I would never give them anything but my scorn. Why you ask? Because in this country an illegal immigrant who can't speak any english, has no id, can go and get work. I do believe that most panhandlers are just people who don't want to work and/or have a serious drug addiction. Now I said most but not all, there are people with mental handicaps who just don't know any better and that just sucks because I can not tell them apart (and even if I could spare change isn't going to help their situation)
On a side note when i drive by on Saturday or Sunday and I see them out begging for money I just think if they had a real job they would get a day off.
 
Frickin' Santa Cruz. If ever they come up with an idea it will be the absolute wrong way to do it. People 'get elected' to the SC city council not so much to do good for their community, but to make broad political statements about how Bush sux.

I left SC 6 years ago and they were struggling with their excessive homeless issues back then as well. Their solutions were inept: first they tried to let the homeless be where they want 'cause they were poor downtrodden folks not subscribing to our evil capitalist system. The businesses growled and people stopped shopping on Main St. Then they tried to get some of them off the streets but made a poorly worded exception for buskers. This was so badly written that the panhandlers just showed up with kazoos and other cheap instruments and claimed they were buskers. Just before I left the legitimate buskers had gotten themselves organized and had told the city council "why don't you stop screwing things up and let us determine who is a legitimate busker and who is just an aggressive panhandler with a plastic flute." Meanwhile the mayor was in trouble for trespassing and the city council was steadfastly ignoring a growing gang problem in the happy city...

But hey! They managed to declare themselves a 'hate free zone' and condemned George Bush! What more do you want?!
 
Fnord was referring to street performers, not smelly dirty poor persons. Do you read for content?

By the time his mathematical error was highlighted, that original information was lost in quotation - but you're right, he did imagine the $5 he gave to a street performer was matched every 30 seconds for an hour.

I've busked - I was homeless at the time, and coincidentally someone had previously given me a penny whistle, which I had no interest in and did not know how to play. I do now. The need to be treated by strangers as something approximating a human being, rather than as a dirty, smelly, drug- & drink-addled, parasitic, lazy subhuman obstruction, turns out to be a strong motivating factor for learning.

Interestingly, major 'donors' to buskers appear to be those people who have least themselves. I made enough to eat and get a camp site pitch (most days...), and most of that came from little old ladies. My most abiding memory of that period is a businesswoman whose self-important passage collided with the wooden bowl I was collecting in, scattering my takings. For some people, apparantly, even a busker is just a subhuman obstruction. Well, her and the little old lady who gave me a quid on her way to the shops and another on her way back, despite my protests, because she still liked what I was playing.
 
There are panhandlers all over where I live and I would never give them anything but my scorn. Why you ask? Because in this country an illegal immigrant who can't speak any english, has no id, can go and get work. I do believe that most panhandlers are just people who don't want to work and/or have a serious drug addiction. Now I said most but not all, there are people with mental handicaps who just don't know any better and that just sucks because I can not tell them apart (and even if I could spare change isn't going to help their situation)
On a side note when i drive by on Saturday or Sunday and I see them out begging for money I just think if they had a real job they would get a day off.

Ha, ha. Wow, I know people who have homes and have been on the job search for over three months. And you know what one of the most important factors in getting a job is? Having a home. Oh, the irony.

But seriously, you need resources to even begin a job search. And how many places would really hire a dirty guy who walks in and has no address?

And the illegals you refer to are shipped around in an underground economy.
 
By the time his mathematical error was highlighted, that original information was lost in quotation - but you're right, he did imagine the $5 he gave to a street performer was matched every 30 seconds for an hour.
Which was the set up for his joke ...
I've busked - I was homeless at the time, and coincidentally someone had previously given me a penny whistle, which I had no interest in and did not know how to play. I do now.
Neat!
The need to be treated by strangers as something approximating a human being, rather than as a dirty, smelly, drug- & drink-addled, parasitic, lazy subhuman obstruction, turns out to be a strong motivating factor for learning.
Word salad.
Interestingly, major 'donors' to buskers appear to be those people who have least themselves. I made enough to eat and get a camp site pitch (most days...), and most of that came from little old ladies. My most abiding memory of that period is a businesswoman whose self-important passage collided with the wooden bowl I was collecting in, scattering my takings. For some people, apparantly, even a busker is just a subhuman obstruction. Well, her and the little old lady who gave me a quid on her way to the shops and another on her way back, despite my protests, because she still liked what I was playing.
I more often toss a few coins or a buck into the bucket/hat of a street performer who plays something I like, than one who doesn't.

DR
 
I would hope they would be trying to better their situation. We offer a number of education and skill training programs for such people for free as well as counseling on how to apply for government aid and to get into subsidized housing. Most actually try to make use of this because their overriding desire is to get out of their rut but those that go the panhandling route do not. That is the issue.

Well most homeless are mentally ill. I've talked to one or two who were obviously somewhat mentally challenged. Others may not seem that way on first meeting, but do have those types of problems. Some just because they're in a rare rough spot. Some are obnoxious and pushy. Some are dishonest. Some aren't. I met a older middle aged woman with a very physically disabled man (husband) panhandling in the grass by the entrance to a grocery store parking lot once. It was at night and they were actually quite hard to see. I gave her a 20.

Panhandling is not something they do as a one time event because of unique circumstances, it is their lifestyle.

You know this for a fact about all panhandlers? I talked to a homeless guy living in LA who was working part time jobs and legitimately looking for more work, but couldn't afford a room. He was an ex-addict with a masters degree. This is him here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-QaH1FUI1gU&feature=related

They will pick out a favored location, defend it from others vigorously and go to "work" there 6-10 hours a day, every day. The man I told off was in San Francisco and it was only after I had observed that he was on the same corner doing his same routine for seven months! Seven straight months of that at the same location.

Yeah, certainly some do it as a full time job. Maybe mental issues keep them from holding a real job. It's the "smooth" pushy ones I don't care for. Like this guy in Chicago, he shakes our hands and gives his spiel wearing some kind of name tag as if asking for money is some high class business deal. I don't generalize, some of them are okay, some are douches.
 
Last edited:
At least they're trying to earn a living. Some here in the L.A. area are quite good, and deserve the fiver for the 30 seconds I spend listening.

... lesse ... at $5 per 30 seconds ... that's $10 per minute ... comes to $60 per hour ... Hey! Where's my violin? I'm taking the day off!

:D

I hope you're not an accountant.
$10/min = $600/hr.
:D
Argh, somebody beat me to it.

The accountant part is original though, so I won't delete it.
 
Last edited:

You're right, 'most' was too strong.

A few stats here (from http://mentalhealth.samhsa.gov/publications/allpubs/homelessness/):

-Thirty-nine percent report some form of mental health problem, and 20 to 25 percent meet criteria for serious mental illnesses.
-Twenty-six percent report acute health problems other than HIV/AIDS such as tuberculosis, pneumonia, or sexually transmitted diseases.
-Twenty-three percent are veterans (compared to 13 percent of the general population).
-Twenty-five percent were physically or sexually abused as children.
-Twenty-seven percent were in foster care or institutions as children.
-Twenty-one percent were homeless as children.
-Twenty-three percent are children under 18 with a parent, 42 percent of whom are under 5 years of age.
-Forty-six percent report chronic health conditions such as high blood pressure, diabetes, or cancer.
 
Here in LA, we don't have enough beds for the homeless. The beds that are available are scattered, many of them are on skid row downtown. The rest fill up quick. It's warm here, sometimes sleeping on the street is safer than waiting to see if there is a bed downtown.

I don't drive so I've gotten to know my local homeless to some degree. They're mostly harmless, mostly insane. Maybe it's because they don't beg, don't make eye contact and aren't aggressive but I've never found them to be anything other than pitiable. They just wander around until someone throws them off whatever steps they've decided to sit on. They live and act like animals, except that animals seem more alive. These people are nearly zombies.

I don't know how we, as a society, can let people live like this. At the same time I don't know where we would find the resources to help them. It would need to be an intensive multi-step process. Treat the addiction or the insanity, then get them a roof, then try to get them training (if needed) and then a job.

All for a group of people that might slip back out if they forget their meds or take a drink. They do need to take personal responsibility for themselves but right now they need help before they can even consider doing that. Who knows how many times they have been helped before. Do you try and hope that this time it sticks? When there are so many people who need those same resources and can benefit from them immediately? Do you just accept that some people are disposable? It's frustrating.

So maybe these meters are a good idea. If the funds are allocated directly to the homeless, then they have a shot at getting off the street. Money that might have gone to drugs or booze can give someone a chance. Those who are willing to try a little harder will get the help they need.
 
Because, as others have stated, the majority are feeding you a line. They want enough money for another trip to the liquor store, or another trip to the local drug dealer. I'm sure there are exceptions to this, but over a period of about 3 years, I've yet to encounter one (and this occurs about once a month).

Not a large sample size, and geographically small (just my area), but out of curiosity, has anyone else used a similar tactic, and ever been taken up on it?

I think that's telling, myself.

I have given out food, and had real homeless people be grateful for it. I've also seen people spit on for offering food instead of drug money.

Around here, there are three types of beggars on the streets: punk kids, professional beggars, and the truly homeless.

Punk kids are usually out in either the University District or Capitol Hill. They're typically middle- or upper-middle-class kids from the nicer neighborhoods out slumming it on the streets because their parents won't let them hang around the house getting high and screwing their flavour-of-the-week. They're easily recognizable, since they typically wear about $500-$1000 worth of leather jacket, boots, and trendy punk clothes. They ask for money for booze/drugs about as often as they ask for money for food. A friend of mine once had one begging for money, supposedly for food. He offered to buy the guy's studded leather jacket for $300 (this was the middle of summer). The guy just starts screaming profanity at him.

Professional beggars are also often recognizable. They're usually seen in the same places every day, and are clearly settled in for the long haul. They're often in wheelchairs, or use portable chairs; and are the ones most likely to have dogs with them. They also tend to have large, elaborate signs, and many claim to be Vietnam vets (one even had an MIA flag attached to his chair). A local tv station did an investigative report on them a number of years back; and found that the majority of them were doing quite well. Their average take was between $200 and $500 a week (I was making $10 an hour at that time, some of these guys were making more than I was), they were not homeless, but had apartments; and some had cars. One was observed getting out of his wheelchair and walking normally; before loading his chair into the bad of a van. None of them were Vietnam vets. The ones who use stories such as needing money for a bus ticket, for gas, etc. are almost always professional beggars.

Actual homeless people are typically either hardcore alcoholics or junkies, the mentally ill, or both. Most of them are found in and around shelters and soup kitches, or clustering in alleys and parks. They're the least likely to engage in aggressive panhandling; although some still do. They're also far more likely to accept handouts of food and cold-weather clothing; although a few still want mainly alcohol or drug money. A large number are alcoholic Native Americans.
 
Last edited:
Homeless shelters can be very dangerous, especially if they're crowded.

Many areas also do not have sufficient shelter space to accomodate all the homeless. A bit over a decade ago, my city even bulldozed some homeless shelters and low-income housing to make way for more upscale condos and business development. No new low-income housing was developed, and it took the better part of that decade to build a new homeless shelter.

Mentally ill homeless often do not take advantage of shelters due to the issues created by their mental illness; or they're barred from them if they're too disruptive.
 
And yes, many are addicts. But the shelters and programs they could get into usually have a strict anti-drug policy.

Seattle actually took a fairly progressive path when they opened their most recent shelter. They allowed alcohol in the building, but prohibited illegal drugs. They also offered an on-premises health service with alcohol counselling. I and others derided the idea at first, for being there simply to warehouse the homeless so they wouldn't have to look at them (the city has a long history of treating homeless as an eyesore and rousting them rather than helping); and not really doing anything useful for them. But by all reports, it's been very successful at reducing the rate of alcoholism among its residents. Unfortunately, it's just not sufficient to provide shelter for even the majority of the homeless in town.
 
Frickin' Santa Cruz. If ever they come up with an idea it will be the absolute wrong way to do it. People 'get elected' to the SC city council not so much to do good for their community, but to make broad political statements about how Bush sux.

...

But hey! They managed to declare themselves a 'hate free zone' and condemned George Bush! What more do you want?!


They want to be left alone... well at least by the authorities.

Of course with the main industry in Santa Cruz being tourism; I expect the repeal of these laws would end up in a huge loss of tourists.
 
Punk kids are usually out in either the University District or Capitol Hill. They're typically middle- or upper-middle-class kids from the nicer neighborhoods out slumming it on the streets because their parents won't let them hang around the house getting high and screwing their flavour-of-the-week. They're easily recognizable, since they typically wear about $500-$1000 worth of leather jacket, boots, and trendy punk clothes. They ask for money for booze/drugs about as often as they ask for money for food. A friend of mine once had one begging for money, supposedly for food. He offered to buy the guy's studded leather jacket for $300 (this was the middle of summer). The guy just starts screaming profanity at him.

The same group hangs around Pioneer Square in Portland. I was walking down the street one day, and this 15-ish year old girl asked for money or food, I don't recall. I looked right at her as she gave her spiel, didn't respond, and never broke stride. She didn't like being "dissed" like this. So she starts yelling at me as I'm walking away, really, really upset. When I get about halfway down the block, she's still yelling, so, without turning around, I just stick my hand in the air and flip her off. Well, she goes ballistic!!! Her shrieks fill Pioneer Square to the point that everyone is looking. I keep walking, laughing my ass off the whole way. People must have wondered what I found so funny. I planned on walking past her again after I left the store, but alas, she was gone. :(
 
The same group hangs around Pioneer Square in Portland. I was walking down the street one day, and this 15-ish year old girl asked for money or food, I don't recall. I looked right at her as she gave her spiel, didn't respond, and never broke stride. She didn't like being "dissed" like this. So she starts yelling at me as I'm walking away, really, really upset. When I get about halfway down the block, she's still yelling, so, without turning around, I just stick my hand in the air and flip her off. Well, she goes ballistic!!! Her shrieks fill Pioneer Square to the point that everyone is looking. I keep walking, laughing my ass off the whole way. People must have wondered what I found so funny. I planned on walking past her again after I left the store, but alas, she was gone. :(
I know this area pretty well, and recognize the groups you talk about. I suppose I haven't met with such aggression because I never make eye contact.

Do you remember the red-haired lady on 6th & Alder? I would give her my "buy-10-get-one-free" cards from Subway. One time I walked past and she had her sandwich there, loaded up with vegetables. She patted the sandwich and said thank you. When she died, people put flowers on her bench.

There was a guy about a block up from there; his sign said we was a veteran and needed money for medicine. In parenthesis under that - ( C. O. P. D ). He looked the part of a old army guy, but the off-putting thing about him was that he always had a cigarette going. I don't know what the VA does for such medication, but it probably wouldn't do that much good as much as he smoked. I never gave him anything.

When I bring visitors downtown, we always go see the "Silver Guy". He is a decent and unobtrusive busker, unlike the folks who are trying to learn to play trumpet in public.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom