Meters for Panhandlers

Homeless guy: Got any change?
Cain: Yeah, lots! [walks right by]
Homeless guy: F-f-f-**** you!
Cain: muahahhahahaha
Incidentally Cain I didn't steal your name. Cainkane1 has been my chat name for 12 years. I had it years before i came to this forum. My name is patterned after Kane in Karl Edward Wagners books and I added cain for filler reasons or to make my chat name longer. I added the 1 after I Cainkane got kicked out of Yahoo Christian chat in part for speaking against Christianity, Islam and Judaism. My arguments were too effective and I was upsetting quite a few people. Incidentally my current chat name is Cainkanecane.
 
Last edited:
I know what you mean - if people have a run of real bad luck and perhaps some physical and mental health issues (exacerbated by homelessness) which act as a barrier to a return to a more conventional lifestyle, they ought to at least retain enough dignity to crawl into a ditch and die out of sight of decent people.

If they do have to publically demonstrate how far beneath you they are, of course you're well within your rights to confirm publically just how far above them you are. After all, they deserve everything they have coming to them, eh?

Big Issue seller kicked to death

Don't even try to guilt me. I volunteer my time in a soup kitchen feeding the underprivileged and desperate. Actual underprivileged and desperate people who really do just need something to eat and someplace warm to sleep. Not those that have turned their back on all the charity and services available to them and have decided to turn public walkways and roads into their own little platform to annoy everyone into subsidizing their bit of "Misery Performance Art."
 
Why all the hatred?

It is rather extraordinary.

I mean, apparently it's not good enough to just not pay a panhandler, but you've gotta be really forceful about paying too. Maybe even crack a few jokes about how good it is that the cold weather kills off some of their number.

And if that's a step too far then just simmer with resentment that they have fallen through the cracks in the charity/welfare system and offend thine eyes.
 
Incidentally Cain I didn't steal your name. Cainkane1 has been my chat name for 12 years. I had it years before i came to this forum. My name is patterned after Kane in Karl Edward Wagners books and I added cain for filler reasons or to make my chat name longer. I added the 1 after I Cainkane got kicked out of Yahoo Christian chat in part for speaking against Christianity, Islam and Judaism. My arguments were too effective and I was upsetting quite a few people. Incidentally my current chat name is Cainkanecane.

I know :) It's just one time a friend referred to you as Fake Cain, and it stuck. I don't think I've ever accused you of stealing my name. You did steal my thread though! But I was kidding seriously (no comma).

And unlike Travis, I'm a ********ter. I never said that to a homeless person. Wanted to but didn't.

I remember hearing years ago that Santa Cruz told teachers to correct papers using purple pen rather than red because red is "mean."
 
We have quite a few panhandlers in the area of where I work.

And I'm about to generalize, so let's assume that the "but not all of them!" and "some of them are differnt!" arguments have already happened, and I've agreed, and that I'm talking about my personal experience.

I have, on occassion, given a bit of money if I had any on me. However, I stopped doing that years ago. For those who think the ill will towards panhandling here is extreme, try doing what I do now.

When they come up and give their story, listen to it. Then, don't offer them money, offer to correct whatever they stated was wrong in the story. Examples:

"I need something to eat"--Great, let's go over there to that McDonald's and I'll buy you a value meal!
"I'm on my way to home/new job/whatever and ran out of gas"-That sucks, tell you what, I have a gas can, I'll go buy some gas and we'll take it to your car and get you filled up.

You get the point.

Since I began doing this, I have had not a single person accept my charity. If you need food, I'm offering a choice of meals, so why isn't that good? IF you need gas, I'm offering to fill the tank...why wouldn't you take that?

Because, as others have stated, the majority are feeding you a line. They want enough money for another trip to the liquor store, or another trip to the local drug dealer. I'm sure there are exceptions to this, but over a period of about 3 years, I've yet to encounter one (and this occurs about once a month).

Not a large sample size, and geographically small (just my area), but out of curiosity, has anyone else used a similar tactic, and ever been taken up on it?

I think that's telling, myself.
 
We have quite a few panhandlers in the area of where I work.

And I'm about to generalize, so let's assume that the "but not all of them!" and "some of them are differnt!" arguments have already happened, and I've agreed, and that I'm talking about my personal experience.

I have, on occassion, given a bit of money if I had any on me. However, I stopped doing that years ago. For those who think the ill will towards panhandling here is extreme, try doing what I do now.

When they come up and give their story, listen to it. Then, don't offer them money, offer to correct whatever they stated was wrong in the story. Examples:

"I need something to eat"--Great, let's go over there to that McDonald's and I'll buy you a value meal!
"I'm on my way to home/new job/whatever and ran out of gas"-That sucks, tell you what, I have a gas can, I'll go buy some gas and we'll take it to your car and get you filled up.

You get the point.

Since I began doing this, I have had not a single person accept my charity. If you need food, I'm offering a choice of meals, so why isn't that good? IF you need gas, I'm offering to fill the tank...why wouldn't you take that?

Because, as others have stated, the majority are feeding you a line. They want enough money for another trip to the liquor store, or another trip to the local drug dealer. I'm sure there are exceptions to this, but over a period of about 3 years, I've yet to encounter one (and this occurs about once a month).

Not a large sample size, and geographically small (just my area), but out of curiosity, has anyone else used a similar tactic, and ever been taken up on it?

I think that's telling, myself.
I feel this way. The person may be lying or telling the truth. You can ofter look at a person and tell if he or she is sick or mentally ill or both. A person dressed too well and a bit overweight won't be getting my money. It may be an act but being kind is the decent way to be.
 
Not a large sample size, and geographically small (just my area), but out of curiosity, has anyone else used a similar tactic, and ever been taken up on it?

I think that's telling, myself.

When I was living in downtown Kansas City, I gave away some food coupons and fresh fruit (I tend to have fruit with me for snacks) and never got any attitude about it. Not to the professional types on the plaza, but to some of the exit ramp campers and parking lot beggars.

I did get hassled by one aggressive beggar between me and my car asking for bus fare, and I gave it to him because the nonverbals (of this big guy) was just short of a mugging, then he got into a car and drove off.

eta: when I mean just short of a mugging, I mean he was standing bewteen me and my car, blocking my access with a "go and head and start somethin" smirk.

That's only happened that once though.
 
Last edited:
Not a large sample size, and geographically small (just my area), but out of curiosity, has anyone else used a similar tactic, and ever been taken up on it?

Yes. No.

One bum begged for money so he could get "something to eat". The irony was, he was standing about 50 feet from the front door St. Patrick's Center, who gives free sandwiches to the homeless.

About 6 months ago, I saw a guy with a gas can walking down the sidewalk in my direction. I knew what was coming. I knew I was going to mess with him. Like you, he wasn't interested in my offer to fill his gas can.

About a year or two ago, a girl stopped me ("I'm not a panhandler, but....") and said her car had broken down a few blocks over and she needed money to call a tow truck. I lied and told her I was a mechanic, and would be happy to take a look, and if I couldn't get it running, I would call my garage and give her a free tow. As you might imagine, she strangely wasn't interested.
 
I did get hassled by one aggressive beggar between me and my car asking for bus fare, and I gave it to him because the nonverbals (of this big guy) was just short of a mugging, then he got into a car and drove off.

One time, a guy wouldn't leave me alone (I think I was in Chicago). I pulled out my cell phone, dialed 911, and started describing him to the dispatcher. I never saw a person run so fast.
 
It has nothing to do with pride. The "government programs" won't let them have their drugs and alcohol, so they beg on the street instead.

Exactly why I think this will not reduce panhandlers. They just created a new "government program" to help people who panhandle, because they do not want to receive money from "government programs". Or they are supplementing what they receive from "government programs" by panhandling (now they can triple dip).

Will people, who do not normally give money to panhandlers, contribute to meters? Also will people who currently give to panhandlers shun the meters? Who will measure the results?
 
Years ago, early 90s, I lived in a studio apartment in a large building with a vestibule and lobby. The door to the lobby locked, but the door from the street to the vestibule didn't. There was a bench in the vestibule, and it was heated. Needless to say, in the winter bums were always sleeping in there. Usually with a bottle of cheap booze (Night Train, Mad Dog, typical bum drinks) at their side.

I would always kick them out, telling them I was calling the police (and this was years before I had a cell phone lol). The women in the building would thank me for doing so, as they didn't feel safe coming home late at night to a bum party/sleepover in the vestibule.
 
Exactly why I think this will not reduce panhandlers. They just created a new "government program" to help people who panhandle, because they do not want to receive money from "government programs". Or they are supplementing what they receive from "government programs" by panhandling (now they can triple dip).

Will people, who do not normally give money to panhandlers, contribute to meters? Also will people who currently give to panhandlers shun the meters? Who will measure the results?

I suspect it will be an increase in money for the truly homeless, and a decrease for the panhandlers. Because people who might have normally given to a panhandler, with reservations that he might spend it on crack or booze, will now give to the meter, with the knowledge that whichever social services organization gets it certainly won't use it to buy crack. Of course, you can expect the panhandlers to come up with some story to tell people as to why they shouldn't put money in the meters. And the gullible will believe them.
 
Years ago, early 90s, I lived in a studio apartment in a large building with a vestibule and lobby. The door to the lobby locked, but the door from the street to the vestibule didn't. There was a bench in the vestibule, and it was heated. Needless to say, in the winter bums were always sleeping in there. Usually with a bottle of cheap booze (Night Train, Mad Dog, typical bum drinks) at their side.

I would always kick them out, telling them I was calling the police (and this was years before I had a cell phone lol). The women in the building would thank me for doing so, as they didn't feel safe coming home late at night to a bum party/sleepover in the vestibule.

My current building works the same way, except that we have no bench. Last winter (2008-2009), we had a bum start showing up and sitting in there. And he smoked.

So one day, I came home and saw him out there eating a slice of pizza. I went out, took his pizza away and told him if he ever came back, I would kick his ass. In the intervening weeks, I heard people say that he was seen in there a few more times.

One evening, I come home, he's sitting in there again. I go out tell him (in a loud voice) to get the hell out. He looks at me and says "No". Wrong answer. I grab him by the collar, and drag him out and drop him in the middle of the sidewalk. I'm sure the other pedestrians wondered what the hell was going on. So he starts walking across the street, heading for a building with a similar lobby set up as mine. I race past him and stand in the door way. He takes a look at me, then scurries around the corner. I keep standing there. Sure enough, about 2 minutes later, I see him peeking around the corner. I take off running toward him, he runs, but does a face plant on the side walk. Gets up, face is bloody, and takes off again.

We haven't seen him since.

The politically correct in the building told me how terrible I was, but a lot of other residents, mostly women, privately thanked me.
 
Don't even try to guilt me. I volunteer my time in a soup kitchen feeding the underprivileged and desperate. Actual underprivileged and desperate people who really do just need something to eat and someplace warm to sleep. Not those that have turned their back on all the charity and services available to them and have decided to turn public walkways and roads into their own little platform to annoy everyone into subsidizing their bit of "Misery Performance Art."

And you're certain they're not the same people? What do you suppose your virtuous soup kitchen homeless do outside meal times?

Do people imagine that anyone who has lost their home should realise that they are not entitled to want anything now? Grudgingly ladled bowls of soup (for the good homeless) is enough, what more could they need that would justify asking a stranger for help?

Certainly, some beggars will spend what they 'earn' on drink and/or drugs - sleeping on cold, damp pavements ('sidewalks'), being shunned (if not roundly abused) by your fellow humans, and fearing being kicked or burnt to death while you sleep in a doorway quite often leads to substance use and dependence.

Certainly, some panhandlers spin tales which essentially aim to defraud you. The same thing every advertiser, every business and every form of government does. But it's safe and easy to spit at panhandlers and ward off the bad luck they might infect you with...
 
My current building works the same way, except that we have no bench. Last winter (2008-2009), we had a bum start showing up and sitting in there. And he smoked.

My current building has a similar problem - although nobody's actually seen him yet. But he *****. He may smoke as well. But he evacuates his bowels in the stairwell. We're 100 yards from some fields with hedges and gates and suitable leaves. But he chooses to take his daily dump in our building.

I don't know, by the way, whether he begs. But he does sh...well you get the picture.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom