Meters for Panhandlers

SRW

Master Poster
Joined
Jul 25, 2001
Messages
2,903
http://www.thecalifornian.com/article/20100414/NEWS01/100414012/1002/rss

SANTA CRUZ (AP) - New meters to collect money for panhandlers will soon go up in downtown Santa Cruz.

The city council voted unanimously Tuesday to install the meters. The goal is to raise money for bus fare, state identifications and other services for transients while discouraging panhandling.

The meters are expected to collect about $1,700 a year. City officials say the services it's used to purchase will be distributed by a county social worker.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
So this will discourage panhandling how?

Can I collect from the meters because I am not panhandling?
 
Wow, I just did a quick Google search, and they've already got them in other places, such as Cleveland (USA) and Aberdeen (Scotland).

http://blog.cleveland.com/metro/2009/08/yellow_meters_in_downtown_clev.html
But Jeffrey Gaddis, who is homeless, would prefer if people walking around downtown gave him money instead of donating to the meters.

"Why would you give it to the meter and I'm sitting right here?" asked Gaddis, 49, holding an empty coffee cup while seated near one of the meters at West Sixth Street and St. Clair Avenue on Thursday morning. "I'm not trying to get nothing but something to eat right now."

Bekah Lee, an 18-year-old from Maple Heights, said she often encounters panhandlers when she visits the city and would rather give money to them than a meter.

"I would give it directly to the person just because not everybody goes for help," Lee said as she left a Cleveland Indians game. "Some people have too much pride to go and get help."


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/north_east/6575935.stm
"We have never been sure that if the intention of these boxes is to stop people begging, that it will have the desired effect.

"It should be a matter of choice whether an individual wants to give money to someone who is begging on the streets. Often people beg because they feel they have no choice."

The boxes, which cost about £180 each, are being installed at a variety of locations in Aberdeen.

While begging is not illegal in Scotland, it became a recordable offence in England on 1 December 2003 as part of measures to tackle anti-social behaviour.

Collection box schemes already operate in Manchester and Cambridge.
 
I think I understand the principle.
I feel sympathy for panhandlers, and I want to help, but I'm never sure if giving money will help a particular individual get food or bus fare, or hurt them by allowing them to get another fix, deepening the addiction that put them on the street.

With a clear and easy way to donate change that goes to those useful things only, I'd be much less likely to give directly to a panhandler.
 
Homeless guy: Got any change?
Cain: Yeah, lots! [walks right by]
Homeless guy: F-f-f-**** you!
Cain: muahahhahahaha
 
Hmm ... could work ... might cut down on thefts of cardboard and crayons ...
 
Homeless guy: Got any change?
Cain: Yeah, lots! [walks right by]
Homeless guy: F-f-f-**** you!
Cain: muahahhahahaha

I actually did that in San Francisco once. Boy I heard some cuss words I never even knew existed. It was worth it though. I can't stand panhandlers.
 
"Some people have too much pride to go and get help."

They are too proud to seek help from a government program but not too proud to beg in the streets?
 
I actually did that in San Francisco once. Boy I heard some cuss words I never even knew existed. It was worth it though. I can't stand panhandlers.

I know what you mean - if people have a run of real bad luck and perhaps some physical and mental health issues (exacerbated by homelessness) which act as a barrier to a return to a more conventional lifestyle, they ought to at least retain enough dignity to crawl into a ditch and die out of sight of decent people.

If they do have to publically demonstrate how far beneath you they are, of course you're well within your rights to confirm publically just how far above them you are. After all, they deserve everything they have coming to them, eh?

Big Issue seller kicked to death
 
I actually did that in San Francisco once. Boy I heard some cuss words I never even knew existed. It was worth it though. I can't stand panhandlers.

I don't even respond. Of course that doesn't mean I ignore them. I look right at them as they give their speech, then continue on my way. It makes it quite clear to them that they don't deserve even a response from me.
 
They are too proud to seek help from a government program but not too proud to beg in the streets?

It has nothing to do with pride. The "government programs" won't let them have their drugs and alcohol, so they beg on the street instead.

It's also worth remembering that many panhandlers aren't homeless at all.
 
People who play music or perform other activities on the street for money aren't panhandlers, they're buskers.
 
People who play music or perform other activities on the street for money aren't panhandlers, they're buskers.

I'll remember that next time some *********** living statue starts asking for money just because they might have been in the photo you took of that tourist attraction.
 
I know what you mean - if people have a run of real bad luck and perhaps some physical and mental health issues (exacerbated by homelessness) which act as a barrier to a return to a more conventional lifestyle, they ought to at least retain enough dignity to crawl into a ditch and die out of sight of decent people.

From "Overheard in New York":
Guy: I have to say, one nice thing about living here is that the winters are so cold that a lot of the homeless freeze to death. So, you know, there's a lot less of them.
Girl: O my God... it's "fewer," not "less."
 
From "Overheard in New York":
Guy: I have to say, one nice thing about living here is that the winters are so cold that a lot of the homeless freeze to death. So, you know, there's a lot less of them.
Girl: O my God... it's "fewer," not "less."

:D
 
People who play music or perform other activities on the street for money aren't panhandlers, they're buskers.
At least they're trying to earn a living. Some here in the L.A. area are quite good, and deserve the fiver for the 30 seconds I spend listening.

... lesse ... at $5 per 30 seconds ... that's $10 per minute ... comes to $60 per hour ... Hey! Where's my violin? I'm taking the day off!

:D
 
I know what you mean - if people have a run of real bad luck and perhaps some physical and mental health issues (exacerbated by homelessness) which act as a barrier to a return to a more conventional lifestyle, they ought to at least retain enough dignity to crawl into a ditch and die out of sight of decent people.
Sorry you feel that way. (Protip: Your sarcasm is not well directed ... )
If they do have to publically demonstrate how far beneath you they are, of course you're well within your rights to confirm publically just how far above them you are. After all, they deserve everything they have coming to them, eh?
Sorry you feel that way. (Protip: Your sarcasm is not well directed ... )

Thanks for the link.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom