Meters for Panhandlers

I don't pay the panhandlers because it only encourages them and for many of them panhandling is their job. There are already places they can go in the city to eat and get medical care.

Bus fare and state ID? Sounds like they have no idea what goes on...
 
My current building works the same way, except that we have no bench. Last winter (2008-2009), we had a bum start showing up and sitting in there. And he smoked.

So one day, I came home and saw him out there eating a slice of pizza. I went out, took his pizza away and told him if he ever came back, I would kick his ass. In the intervening weeks, I heard people say that he was seen in there a few more times.

One evening, I come home, he's sitting in there again. I go out tell him (in a loud voice) to get the hell out. He looks at me and says "No". Wrong answer. I grab him by the collar, and drag him out and drop him in the middle of the sidewalk. I'm sure the other pedestrians wondered what the hell was going on. So he starts walking across the street, heading for a building with a similar lobby set up as mine. I race past him and stand in the door way. He takes a look at me, then scurries around the corner. I keep standing there. Sure enough, about 2 minutes later, I see him peeking around the corner. I take off running toward him, he runs, but does a face plant on the side walk. Gets up, face is bloody, and takes off again.

We haven't seen him since.

The politically correct in the building told me how terrible I was, but a lot of other residents, mostly women, privately thanked me.
The worst thing is, even after you kick the bum out the smell lingers for at least 12 hours.

I lived on the 5th floor, and one morning I open the door to go to work and a bum was passed out in the hallway. I kicked him awake and told him to get out. He mumbled something and rolled over. I kicked him again, and this time used much more colorful language. He started saying "where are my shoes"? I told him that's his problem (I sure didn't know) and told him he leaves now without shoes (and it was winter) or he can sleep at the police station... he chose to leave barefoot.

I never had to actually touch one of them, and I'm thankful for that.
 
The worst thing is, even after you kick the bum out the smell lingers for at least 12 hours.

I lived on the 5th floor, and one morning I open the door to go to work and a bum was passed out in the hallway. I kicked him awake and told him to get out. He mumbled something and rolled over. I kicked him again, and this time used much more colorful language. He started saying "where are my shoes"? I told him that's his problem (I sure didn't know) and told him he leaves now without shoes (and it was winter) or he can sleep at the police station... he chose to leave barefoot.

I never had to actually touch one of them, and I'm thankful for that.

Both the cigarette and bum smell linger.

Yeah, I washed my hands thoroughly after I grabbed his collar.
 
At least they're trying to earn a living. Some here in the L.A. area are quite good, and deserve the fiver for the 30 seconds I spend listening.

... lesse ... at $5 per 30 seconds ... that's $10 per minute ... comes to $60 per hour .

$10 per minute is $600 per hour
 
$10 per minute is $600 per hour

I think the calculation went wrong long before that - when Fnord implied that he'd actually given $5 to some smelly, dirty, probably mad, poor person...let alone that that donation would be matched every 30 seconds for a single hour, let alone the rest of the day.

Is it a coincidence that a predominantly atheist forum appears to lack any compassion or empathy for people who are a bit smelly, because 'homeless' usually also means 'showerless' and 'cleanclothesless'?
 
I think the calculation went wrong long before that - when Fnord implied that he'd actually given $5 to some smelly, dirty, probably mad, poor person...let alone that that donation would be matched every 30 seconds for a single hour, let alone the rest of the day.

Is it a coincidence that a predominantly atheist forum appears to lack any compassion or empathy for people who are a bit smelly, because 'homeless' usually also means 'showerless' and 'cleanclothesless'?

It's not a lack of compassion. Actual homeless use shelters, food aid, cash benefits, and other government services. I used such services for about 6 months when I was destitute a few years back, and was very grateful for them, the government can be surprisingly generous. If you've lost your job and haven't eaten in a few days go to a Department of Human Services building and you will get lots of help. I was getting $200 a month just as a food budget, one of my friends was eligible for $700 a month rent stipend.

Panhandlers are a different animal, mostly con-men and drug addicts, with a few rare schizophrenics who do need help, but not of the monetary kind. I mentioned this before on JREF at some point I think, but once I was at a Hard Rock Cafe sitting at a table outside, and there was a panhandler there. The waiter mentioned that he often saw people who would leave a $2-3 tip for him after waiting on them for an hour, then as they leave give $5 to the panhandler. He said he saw the panhandler easily make $30-40/hour on busy days, much more than the waiters actually, you know, working, five feet away from him.

ETA: And why is Fnord's $5 so unlikely? I've given $5, $3, $1, etc. to beggars on many occasions. I'm just also aware I'm most likely being taken by a sob story. I gave $2 just yesterday to a man at a gas station who was quite insistent I help him, and I sell my plasma to buy food. 3 or 4 hours and you walk out with $20. Why doesn't he?
 
Last edited:
It's not a lack of compassion. Actual homeless use shelters, food aid, cash benefits, and other government services.

Homeless shelters can be very dangerous, especially if they're crowded.
 
I've given homeless/tramps or whatever they were money, beer, and food on different occasions. In return I've gotten help carrying my groceries, much better directions than I get from other locals and tourists, and on one occasion a custom made dance video (sent via email). Sometimes I also refuse politely, it depends on the situation and whether I actually have any change.
 
Well my anecdote is the mental illness community. Most people don't know where to find services or what is available. "Shelters" are avoided like the plague, in general and especially because of their rules. I know the "NY has enough beds for ten billion homeless" line is popular, but that usually counts beds lining a church basement where personal property (they only things they have) are at extreme risk. And yes, many are addicts. But the shelters and programs they could get into usually have a strict anti-drug policy.

I'm not saying that they and others like them aren't morally responsible quite often, but I think any effective policy needs to meet people where they are at.
 
, but that usually counts beds lining a church basement where personal property (they only things they have) are at extreme risk. And yes, many are addicts. But the shelters and programs they could get into usually have a strict anti-drug policy.

More at risk in a shelter than on the street?

It is good that shelters and progams have a strict anti-drug policy, especially if many clients are addicts.
 
And you're certain they're not the same people? What do you suppose your virtuous soup kitchen homeless do outside meal times?

I would hope they would be trying to better their situation. We offer a number of education and skill training programs for such people for free as well as counseling on how to apply for government aid and to get into subsidized housing. Most actually try to make use of this because their overriding desire is to get out of their rut but those that go the panhandling route do not. That is the issue. Panhandling is not something they do as a one time event because of unique circumstances, it is their lifestyle. They will pick out a favored location, defend it from others vigorously and go to "work" there 6-10 hours a day, every day. The man I told off was in San Francisco and it was only after I had observed that he was on the same corner doing his same routine for seven months! Seven straight months of that at the same location.

Do people imagine that anyone who has lost their home should realise that they are not entitled to want anything now? Grudgingly ladled bowls of soup (for the good homeless) is enough, what more could they need that would justify asking a stranger for help?

I don't begrudge someone who just wants to eat and get some help. But help only works if they want to help themselves. Otherwise you are merely subsidizing unproductive activities.

Certainly, some beggars will spend what they 'earn' on drink and/or drugs - sleeping on cold, damp pavements ('sidewalks'), being shunned (if not roundly abused) by your fellow humans, and fearing being kicked or burnt to death while you sleep in a doorway quite often leads to substance use and dependence.

Personally I don't care what they spend their money on, that's not the point. The point is that they are not helping themselves with their actions. The 6+ hours they spent begging could have been spent doing way more constructive things that would have genuinely helped them out of their situation if that is what they actually want. They don't though they certainly want you to think that they do. I help people that have genuinely had the whole world just up and take a steaming dump on them. People who've lost everything, are emotionally broken and are at wits end. But, damnit, they are willing to do anything to claw their way back. Some sucked at basic math, and were ashamed to admit it. Some were functionally illiterate and had hidden it their whole lives. Some were on drugs and admitted so. Some had runaway from sexual abuse. But, regardless of that, they were willing to try and work with others to escape the traps of poverty and homelessness. So when I see panhandlers who give no effort to move on and escape but pretend they are victims in the same vein as those that I have seen actually work themselves out of some really horrid circumstances it just angers me. They are pretenders.

Certainly, some panhandlers spin tales which essentially aim to defraud you. The same thing every advertiser, every business and every form of government does. But it's safe and easy to spit at panhandlers and ward off the bad luck they might infect you with...

Whoa there. Who said anything about spitting?
 
Last edited:
One of the wholly unacceptable aspects of UK immigration is that all of our native beggars have been put out of a job by cheap Romanian Gypsy beggars!
I feel it's time The government stood up for British panhandling!

- Col. Vivian de Cere Cholmondley-Sawcutt, Bucks.
 
I would hope they would be trying to better their situation. We offer a number of education and skill training programs for such people for free as well as counseling on how to apply for government aid and to get into subsidized housing. Most actually try to make use of this because their overriding desire is to get out of their rut but those that go the panhandling route do not. That is the issue. Panhandling is not something they do as a one time event because of unique circumstances, it is their lifestyle. They will pick out a favored location, defend it from others vigorously and go to "work" there 6-10 hours a day, every day. The man I told off was in San Francisco and it was only after I had observed that he was on the same corner doing his same routine for seven months! Seven straight months of that at the same location.

There was a guy in Portland about 5-6 years ago, stood on the same corner every morning for as long as anyone could remember. Of course, I never gave him anything, but others did.

The local "alternative" paper did a story on him, after he won a settlement in a lawsuit against the city (for some ridiculous claim). He got around $30K, but it also came out that he wasn't homeless at all - he had an apartment. They did a follow up story a few months later, and it turned out he was angry because all his donations had dried up.
 
Because we don't want you drinking it instead? :confused:


I dunno. We always used to give money to this guy who had a sign saying "I won't lie, I want money for beer." Candor goes a long way sometimes. :)

The late, great Robin Harris: What exactly is "spare change?" Go get yourself a "spare job," then you'll have some "spare change."
 
I love buskers - most of the time they're damned good at whatever it is they do and if I have money I will give some for being entertained. If I don't have money, then I don't stand and watch or listen; I'd consider it rude. I know that a lot of buskers aren't homeless, either, but just people who like to play or do whatever it is they do. Sure I'll give them money.

About ten years ago, my vehicle's engine quit somewhere close to downtown and I rolled off onto a small gravel lot beneath a large, spacious overpass; there were a number of (presumably) homeless there milling around; a block or two away there was one of those work-a-day places, and many homeless like to stick close to those, naturally.

After fixing the problem (it was electrical) and finding out my starter wasn't working anymore, I asked some nearby guys for a push-start. Three of them helped, and once the car was running I gladly split between them every spare dollar and cent I had in the van - close to 10 dollars all told. I wished I could give them more. As I was handing the money out, a number of other people started crowding around, and one man in particular came up, shouldering his way in, and started forcing his hand on top of whoever's hand I was trying to put money in at the time.

When I was all changed out, I was getting ready to leave, and the man objected that he didn't get any money (I had pointedly made sure not to put any in his hands). I told him I didn't have anymore. "You've got that watch," he said as he came close to the window, looking into my van at a watch I had sitting on the center console. I'd taken it off before handing out the money so it wouldn't disappear off my wrist. "Come on, you don't need it," he told me, and looked as if he was going to reach into the vehicle. I drove away, quickly - and I'll be honest here: I wouldn't have felt too guilty about taking his arm with me if he actually had been reaching into my window at the time, either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom