[Merged]Peer-reviewed technical paper to appear in mainstream journal

The second reply, in Mr. Alam's own words, was a suggestion that I should instead be submitting my own paper in response. I have never before seen a scientific journal article whose abstract dealt with the editorial standards of the journal itself. Needless to say, this suggestion is unprofessional, and borderline insane.

Well yeah, he wants the $600!! :D
 
Far be it from me to ascribe a motive to his bizarre and unprofessional behavior, so let's just say that he didn't offer me a discount.
 
And if you get the paper retracted and the 'publication' cleans up it's act........

[truther] Censorship!!! They must be scared of us because they went all out, night and day, no expense spared to pressure the company to stop publishing ALL of the truth movement's papers. I even heard of a NASA government shill who actually went to Dundee in India to personally physically threaten the commander-in-chief of the publication, personally in person. Inside job!!!11eleven!!! etc etc and so forth[/truther]
 
Regardless of whether or not the paper ultimately gets retracted, we can now confidently state that the publishers are incompetent. This matter needs to be resolved independent of any concerns with Dr. Jones or his paper.

I have now informed the Editor in Chief, Dr. Dong-Sheng Jeng of the University of Dundee, of the situation. I remain hopeful that he was previously unaware of these problems and will take steps to rectify them. The alternative is most depressing.

Well, there's our answer. Please let us know what Dr. Jeng's response is.

Yeah, everyone gets burned once in a while. But at least we can all learn from other's mistakes....
 
Progress!

Dr. Jeng responded to my e-mail promptly, and he is looking into it.

I'm not going to reprint his entire e-mail, but there are two interesting points. One is that before he took over the publication, the publishers handled all submissions rather than the editors. He's correctly insisting that all publications must go through the editors. This paper did not.

The other point is that he was alerted to this paper by another respondent a week ago, tried to find out who the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

As expected, Dr. Jeng seems to be handling this professionally, and he has my full support. We'll see how this turns out, but I think we've found the source of the problem.
 
Dr. Jeng responded to my e-mail promptly, and he is looking into it.

I'm not going to reprint his entire e-mail, but there are two interesting points. One is that before he took over the publication, the publishers handled all submissions rather than the editors. He's correctly insisting that all publications must go through the editors. This paper did not.

The other point is that he was alerted to this paper by another respondent a week ago, tried to find out who the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

As expected, Dr. Jeng seems to be handling this professionally, and he has my full support. We'll see how this turns out, but I think we've found the source of the problem.


Nice work!
 
Dr. Jeng responded to my e-mail promptly, and he is looking into it.the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

As expected, Dr. Jeng seems to be handling this professionally, and he has my full support. We'll see how this turns out, but I think we've found the source of the problem.

Thanks for lookign into this for us!

On another note, I just got an "interesting" CFP from another small journal. Details are in a thread I started in Science & Tech. I'd particularly like to hear your comments if you care to make any.
 
I'm not going to reprint his entire e-mail, but there are two interesting points. One is that before he took over the publication, the publishers handled all submissions rather than the editors. He's correctly insisting that all publications must go through the editors. This paper did not.

Ahhhh.....

The other point is that he was alerted to this paper by another respondent a week ago, tried to find out who the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

Shouldn't the publisher have easy access to that information?
 
Dr. Jeng responded to my e-mail promptly, and he is looking into it.

I'm not going to reprint his entire e-mail, but there are two interesting points. One is that before he took over the publication, the publishers handled all submissions rather than the editors. He's correctly insisting that all publications must go through the editors. This paper did not.

The other point is that he was alerted to this paper by another respondent a week ago, tried to find out who the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

As expected, Dr. Jeng seems to be handling this professionally, and he has my full support. We'll see how this turns out, but I think we've found the source of the problem.


Excellent. Thanks for the update, R.Mackey. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
 
Dr. Jeng responded to my e-mail promptly, and he is looking into it.

I'm not going to reprint his entire e-mail, but there are two interesting points. One is that before he took over the publication, the publishers handled all submissions rather than the editors. He's correctly insisting that all publications must go through the editors. This paper did not.

The other point is that he was alerted to this paper by another respondent a week ago, tried to find out who the reviewers were at that time, and still hasn't gotten the answer.

As expected, Dr. Jeng seems to be handling this professionally, and he has my full support. We'll see how this turns out, but I think we've found the source of the problem.

VERY, very interesting. That doesn't sound like how a journal should be run at all. If the editor in chief can't find out who the reviewers of a particular article were, something is very badly wrong.

This whole thing has just permanently soured me to the Bentham open journals. I don't think I'll ever be sending anything there and I'll be advising all my colleagues and collaborators the same. I can't see Thomson ISI putting them in their indexes any time soon, put it that way.

Good work.
 
No, it is not. There is a very real possibility that some people could lose tenure over something like this. The responsible way to deal with it is to bottle it as quickly and professionally as possible, and that is precisely what I am attempting to do.

===

Two replies last night, both of them from Mr. Alam. The first was a forwarded message from Dr. Steven Jones. As you can expect, he disagrees with my assessment. However, as I indicated above, this is an editorial matter, and there is absolutely no reason why a submitter should be responding or even weighing in on the issue. This is clear evidence of a broken peer review process.

The second reply, in Mr. Alam's own words, was a suggestion that I should instead be submitting my own paper in response. I have never before seen a scientific journal article whose abstract dealt with the editorial standards of the journal itself. Needless to say, this suggestion is unprofessional, and borderline insane.

Regardless of whether or not the paper ultimately gets retracted, we can now confidently state that the publishers are incompetent. This matter needs to be resolved independent of any concerns with Dr. Jones or his paper.

I have now informed the Editor in Chief, Dr. Dong-Sheng Jeng of the University of Dundee, of the situation. I remain hopeful that he was previously unaware of these problems and will take steps to rectify them. The alternative is most depressing.

Mackey, would not another approach be to contact one of the heads of Bentham? I know it is unlikely to happen, but a discussion on the ridiculous standards being exhibited might make them review it with Mr. Alam a little more closely.

Just a thought.

TAM:)
 
Mackey, would not another approach be to contact one of the heads of Bentham? I know it is unlikely to happen, but a discussion on the ridiculous standards being exhibited might make them review it with Mr. Alam a little more closely.

Well, I've discussed it with the publisher (Mr. Alam) and the editor in chief. I don't know what their org chart looks like, but presumably these are the two best people to contact.

Also, I went through the contact information on their website. Since it's an open access journal, I can only assume that e-mail is their preferred method of communication. I didn't find any other obvious contacts apart from the rest of the editorial board. If there is someone else who should be informed, I can do that, but I think this is being handled at the right level at present.
 
I think the strong point of the paper, besides the issues it raises with NIST's hypothesis, is that it passed peer review outside of his own journal.
His "own journal" is not a "journal". It raises nothing Jones hasn't been blathering about on his websites for these past years...nothing at all.

Now is this journal just another scam? Although I haven't seen anything that would suggest it is a scam journal, it might very well be.
Let's see...
How many other Engineering Journals can you site that have 163 editorial members (gotta be a record!) with most all last name starting with A-C, charge a $600-$900 fee and SOLICIT via email spam for editorial members to persons with no expertise in the related field?

Does this not raise a rather large red flag as to their credibility at this point?

With that said, I think it is important to once again look at the claims made in his paper. By your own admission you have claimed that his information is correct (in a different post), and I would agree.
What, like thermite? The very same claims he's been making for some time now while refusing to disclose the chain of custody of the material, refusing to show his methods of testing or test data?
The only info on his paper thats correct is when he agrees with the NIST report. Can you site anything else on the paper that is correct?
I can site lies Jones has made on the paper!!

think this is a great start in bridging cooperation between the "truth movement" and NIST. We are all still waiting for WTC7 report to come out after all. This, and other efforts may be what some of the NIST scientists need to look outside of the fire induced collapse hypothesis, if indeed it is proving unfeasible.

Would you be willing to post your letter to the publishers that you mentioned?
How is a argumentative paper with zero data sets, no evidence, and no new information of any kind a "great start"?
NIST scientist and many other scientist have shown a "fire induced collapse hypothesis" to be very much feasible. The only hypothesis (if one can call it that) that is proving unfeasible is that of Dr. Jones. Are you suggesting that we are to investigate claims that have no empirical evidence made by persons going out of their way to bypass all scientific protocol?

If so, explain why.
 
Last edited:
Bump.

(I imagine it's going to be a while before we hear anything if at all, but I don't want this to be forgotten)
 
FWIW, I've contacted one of the people on the editorial advisory board, and he had confirmed that was really him (except for the editor, there are no full names on the list and I initially theorised the board members were simply made up, with names resembling well known experts in the field).

But he also said he had never done any peer reviews for the journal nor is he familiar with their peer review process. The only contacts with the journal were their initial mail, asking him to become editorial board's member, his inauguration process, and multiple further emails asking him to write an article for them. He was never asked to perform any peer reviews for them, as opposed to other journals, where he does, on average, up to 10 peer reviews annually.
 
FWIW, I've contacted one of the people on the editorial advisory board, and he had confirmed that was really him (except for the editor, there are no full names on the list and I initially theorised the board members were simply made up, with names resembling well known experts in the field).

But he also said he had never done any peer reviews for the journal nor is he familiar with their peer review process. The only contacts with the journal were their initial mail, asking him to become editorial board's member, his inauguration process, and multiple further emails asking him to write an article for them. He was never asked to perform any peer reviews for them, as opposed to other journals, where he does, on average, up to 10 peer reviews annually.

What I find very odd, is that almost all members have last names beginning with the letters A, B, or C.
What are the mathematical odds of this happening?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom