Medical and Healthcare phishing

Have you heard about a rhetorical comment?

I quoted my friend's response, it was not directed to anybody.
 
It's rather an insult to sum this thread up as a "vomit of beliefs".

You and your friend must both subscribe to the debating tactics found on answersingenesis.

Bingo. See skepticdoc's thread at skeptic.com regarding "practical uses of evolution"--same song; second verse--

Snarky dishonesty pretending to desire "debate" when actual intent is to preach.

Some kinds of thinking never evolve.
 
It's rather an insult to sum this thread up as a "vomit of beliefs".

You and your friend must both subscribe to the debating tactics found on answersingenesis.

"vomit beliefs" is skepticdoc's way of saying "I will never admit you are right no matter how much evidence you have..." Favorite woo tactic to distract from weakness of their claims.

Dishonesty in the name of religion yet again. (good things will happen if only you BELIEVE... oh, and don't let tinkerbell die--say "I do believe in fairies...I do believe in fairies")
 
Last edited:
When do you decide to quit?
[...]
More to come

Your dredging this old thread up instead of letting it continue to molder seems to indicate that the discussion is still fun for you. The "More to come" reinforces that impression. Or did you quote your friend just to put some text on the screen, not implying that you took his advice?

Decide to quit. Or state a claim and defend it. At least tell what you hope to achieve by continuing to post.
 
Your dredging this old thread up instead of letting it continue to molder seems to indicate that the discussion is still fun for you. The "More to come" reinforces that impression. Or did you quote your friend just to put some text on the screen, not implying that you took his advice?

Decide to quit. Or state a claim and defend it. At least tell what you hope to achieve by continuing to post.

Well, he does amuse--and that is worth something isn't it?
 
This thread has been reported.

I find I am at a loss as to what this thread is now meant to be discussing. If it is about discussing individual Members this section is definitely not the appropriate section for such a discussion.

If your posts are not to do with a topic that is appropriate for a section titled "Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology" take them somewhere elsewhere and if they are not in accordance to your Membership Agreement don't post them at all on this Forum.

Also please do not respond to my Admin comments in this thread, there is a section of the forum titled "Forum Management" which is for any discussion of a moderation matter.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Last edited:
I struggled with continuing this thread.

On Friday, I came across a link http://www.pointofinquiry.org/ to a webcast from The Amazing One. I was again inspired to continue to fight for the truth, and after requesting e-mail advice, posted again.

I am encouraged by the Admin. intervention, I kept wondering what did I do to these people to be so hostile to me?

Now, getting back to the topic of Healthcare:

this thread provides some insight on the thought and emotional process that goes on in the mind of humans.

Some posters dismissed me as a Physician who could provide care to them as patients. They reached that decision on the basis of posts in an Internet Forum. Furthermore, they expressed a preference for getting medical care from a non-physician poster, whom they had never met, nor did they have any objective evidence of any posters qualifications.

I became aware of the JREF studying quackery and coming across the book on faith healers written by Mr. Randi.

People go to Quacks, homeopaths, etc. because they believe in them, they have faith that practitioner will "cure", "help" them. Is that any different from the Forum members that dismissed me and embraced another healthcare profesional?

Are YOU skeptic enough to question your own belief system, whatever that may be?

These questions are not rhetorical, anywhere that you live, you and your government are making decisions regarding Healthcare that will affect you, your family, neighbors and other members of your society. How are those decisions made? At the personal level? Government level?

Please consider visiting the thread started by Mr. Grenard, the specific issue pertains to the U.S., but the problem is really Universal to our little planet.
 
I am encouraged by the Admin. intervention, I kept wondering what did I do to these people to be so hostile to me?

I don't feel 'hostile', but I do think you've come across as arrogant and naive.

I've already posted once or twice in this thread from a pathology scientist's point of view, and will endeavour in the future to keep my view objective. However, from a momentarily personal point of view, from the first page your responses are less than professional. That doesn't mean you can't be a physician, but if I encountered your manner in a hospital, I'd be rather dubious about the level of care you are capable of offering.

Some posters dismissed me as a Physician who could provide care to them as patients. They reached that decision on the basis of posts in an Internet Forum.

From what I've read they've reached that decision based on the information within those posts. At least, I did. Therefore, if the nature of the information is accurate, the conclusions formed have some credibility.

Furthermore, they expressed a preference for getting medical care from a non-physician poster, whom they had never met, nor did they have any objective evidence of any posters qualifications.

If a garbage collector said 'try aspirin', and I saw sense in that based on the information I knew about aspirin, I might technically be taking medical advice from a garbage collector.

Skeptics look at the evidence and the information. The authority comes second. You did claim to be a critical thinker, didn't you?

People go to Quacks, homeopaths, etc. because they believe in them, they have faith that practitioner will "cure", "help" them. Is that any different from the Forum members that dismissed me and embraced another healthcare profesional?

See my above statement.

I agree that some folk here have become rather emotional. I can hardly blame them, although it doesn't help. But holding your arms up and claiming innocence is foolish when the entire thread is here for anybody to read.

Athon
 
Where have I claimed innocence?

I stand by my statements regarding Nurses and Physicians, see my last "recapitulation".

There is a BIG difference, between the medical systems in the US and in Europe, maybe we can expand on that. Are there Chiropractors in Europe?
 
Please send me a PM if you are a Physician or are involved in any direct way with human healthcare.

I am a Skeptic Family Physician in the USA and tried to find out if there were other physcians in the Skeptic Forum. It seems that in that Forum there are very few that would acknowledge participation or would want to be identified.

I would like to find out if the situation is different in this Forum.

Thanks

OP for this thread.
 
Firstly, I might suggest you split into a new thread if you wish to have a discussion distanced from the progress of this thread.

Now, on request, you wish to take it from the last 'recapitulation'.

1) If you are a healthcare provider send me a PM

I don't see the need for a PM; for what it's worth, I was a hospital-based medical scientist for a pathology firm in Queensland, Australia, about five years ago, and then became a high school secondary teacher. That's evolved into becoming a science communicator these days.

2) Doctors and Nurses take care of patients, most of the time Doctors write orders that Nurses follow, some Advanced Practice Nurses write orders that subordinate Nurses follow

Perhaps an oversimplified comment based on the variety of situations, however for all intensive purposes it works as a generalisation.

3) boiling water kills pathogens if you wait long enough

I can't find where you retracted this. If you haven't, you should.

It's wrong. Pure and simple. Ask if you need an explanation why.

4) An Armistice Offer:
s'girl, we have proved we can be nasty to each other in a public forum.
I am sure you are a caring and competent healthcare provider. I re-read your posts in this thread, and we probably agree on most healthcare issues. We can fight the Doctor-Nurse Practitioner battle somewhere else, I don't think JREFers care about or understand the issues in our little battle.

Apart from the very condescending nature of the last part, I agree.

As for the remainder of your comments, they are particular to the comments of others and I shan't comment.

I stand by my statements regarding Nurses and Physicians, see my last "recapitulation".

It said little, other than to discuss in another thread. Feel free to open that can of worms.

There is a BIG difference, between the medical systems in the US and in Europe, maybe we can expand on that. Are there Chiropractors in Europe?

After reading most of this thread, I still can't grasp what it is precisely you're after. Insinuative questions don't progress a discussion; why are you asking about chiropractors in Europe? It takes nothing to find that information on the web, so you obviously wish to discuss the issue. Come out and say it.

As for a comparison on US and European medical systems, what comparisons do you wish to make? I can only comment in detail on the Australian one as of over five years ago, personally.

Athon
 
I should have added pressure to my statement on boiling water, I have an autoclave that heats to 270 deg, 30 psi, that will kill most pathogens, I am not sure about prions.

Practically speaking, I believe any significant human pathogens that could be present in the US tap water system, would be killed by boiling ( not a 100% sure about cryptosporidium )
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom