Medical and Healthcare phishing

That is why I keep coming back! I always learn something new.

I believed chiropractic care was a US phenomenon, is it a covered benefit in the European healthcare system?

Not in every country. If you go to the country links in the site I posted it lets you know whether the country's health service covers it and/or if optional private coverage does so.
 
Last edited:
Athon....

I agree with skepticdoc that it's not known what is necessary to effectively kill prions, perhaps nothing. However, barring these and spore formers, are you saying the following statement is incorrect for effective sterilization of water making it safe for either drinking or as a nasal spray?

Boiling is the most certain way of killing all microorganisms. According to the Wilderness Medical Society, water temperatures above 160° F (70° C) kill all pathogens within 30 minutes and above 185° F (85° C) within a few minutes. So in the time it takes for the water to reach the boiling point (212° F or 100° C) from 160° F (70° C), all pathogens will be killed, even at high altitude. To be extra safe, let the water boil rapidly for one minute, especially at higher altitudes since water boils at a lower temperature (see page 68.)

http://www.princeton.edu/~oa/manual/water.shtml

I am not talking about using boiling water to kill organisms on other objects such as instruments but in the water itself.
 
Last edited:
I can't believe this thread is still alive.
We've all just been had by a clever troll.
That's it. Nothing more.
I am now putting this thread on "mental ignore". I encourage you to all do the same.

Skeptidoc, if you have a beef with skepticism's stance, just construct a logical argument against it.
This is just silly.
 
I should have added pressure to my statement on boiling water, I have an autoclave that heats to 270 deg, 30 psi, that will kill most pathogens, I am not sure about prions.

Practically speaking, I believe any significant human pathogens that could be present in the US tap water system, would be killed by boiling ( not a 100% sure about cryptosporidium )

Prions are tricky and standard autoclaving does not ensure decontamination of prions, unfortunately.

Crypto' has been a problem in many of our local water supplies in past years on account of cattle grazing. Boiling water does indeed reduce the effective dose of cryptosporidium to safe levels. I don't know enough about the US water system to be able to state whether boiling is necessary. In Australia, standards are high enough that water from the council regulated system is safe, and there is no need to boil water.


Athon, are there Nurse anesthetists in Australia?

No, there aren't. Proposals were made in recent years on allowing nurse anaesthetists accreditation by ANZCA (Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetics) on the argument that we are underskilled in that field, however I don't think it resolved. I'd need to ask a friend on that one.

Athon
 
Athon....

I agree with skepticdoc that it's not known what is necessary to effectively kill prions, perhaps nothing. However, barring these and spore formers, are you saying the following statement is incorrect for effective sterilization of water making it safe for either drinking or as a nasal spray?



I am not talking about using boiling water to kill organisms on other objects such as instruments but in the water itself.

For a healthy person, I agree with what you quoted. Most organisms that you would find in non-treated water are killed by boiling.

Spores from microbes such as clostridium and some kinds of thermophiles would remain, however for immediate consumption effective doses would be reduced enough that I would not see any cause for concern. In most countries, it's the parasites such as giardia that are of primary concern in water, and these are easily removed through boiling.

Athon
 
I struggled with continuing this thread.

On Friday, I came across a link http://www.pointofinquiry.org/ to a webcast from The Amazing One. I was again inspired to continue to fight for the truth, and after requesting e-mail advice, posted again.
Truth is good. Will you really fight for it or will you continue to pick fights with any who disagree with you? Do you assume you have the sole franchise to truth?

am encouraged by the Admin. intervention, I kept wondering what did I do to these people to be so hostile to me?

How about being stubborn and hostile to them? Can you not see your own contribution?
Read the thread from the start with an open mind and you may see it.

Now, getting back to the topic of Healthcare:

this thread provides some insight on the thought and emotional process that goes on in the mind of humans.

Some posters dismissed me as a Physician who could provide care to them as patients. They reached that decision on the basis of posts in an Internet Forum. Furthermore, they expressed a preference for getting medical care from a non-physician poster, whom they had never met, nor did they have any objective evidence of any posters qualifications.

I became aware of the JREF studying quackery and coming across the book on faith healers written by Mr. Randi.

People go to Quacks, homeopaths, etc. because they believe in them, they have faith that practitioner will "cure", "help" them. Is that any different from the Forum members that dismissed me and embraced another healthcare profesional?

Are YOU skeptic enough to question your own belief system, whatever that may be?

These questions are not rhetorical, anywhere that you live, you and your government are making decisions regarding Healthcare that will affect you, your family, neighbors and other members of your society. How are those decisions made? At the personal level? Government level?

Please consider visiting the thread started by Mr. Grenard, the specific issue pertains to the U.S., but the problem is really Universal to our little planet.
I have read the above three times, and I still have no idea what you are trying to put accross.

I Give Up.

Cheers,
Dave
 
I struggled with continuing this thread.

On Friday, I came across a link http://www.pointofinquiry.org/ to a webcast from The Amazing One. I was again inspired to continue to fight for the truth, and after requesting e-mail advice, posted again.

I am encouraged by the Admin. intervention, I kept wondering what did I do to these people to be so hostile to me?
You demeaned the nursing profession, for one.

Some posters dismissed me as a Physician who could provide care to them as patients. They reached that decision on the basis of posts in an Internet Forum. Furthermore, they expressed a preference for getting medical care from a non-physician poster, whom they had never met, nor did they have any objective evidence of any posters qualifications.
No objective evidence? So what you are claiming is that meeting a person, in person, and hearing their spoken words is objective, but reading what they have to say is less objective? My license to practice and degree are on my office wall. Is that the objective evidence you speak of?

I became aware of the JREF studying quackery and coming across the book on faith healers written by Mr. Randi.

People go to Quacks, homeopaths, etc. because they believe in them, they have faith that practitioner will "cure", "help" them. Is that any different from the Forum members that dismissed me and embraced another healthcare profesional?
Most definitely.

Are YOU skeptic enough to question your own belief system, whatever that may be?

These questions are not rhetorical, anywhere that you live, you and your government are making decisions regarding Healthcare that will affect you, your family, neighbors and other members of your society. How are those decisions made? At the personal level? Government level?

Please consider visiting the thread started by Mr. Grenard, the specific issue pertains to the U.S., but the problem is really Universal to our little planet.
Your posts simply boggle the mind.
 
Last edited:
I should have added pressure to my statement on boiling water, I have an autoclave that heats to 270 deg, 30 psi, that will kill most pathogens, I am not sure about prions.

Practically speaking, I believe any significant human pathogens that could be present in the US tap water system, would be killed by boiling ( not a 100% sure about cryptosporidium )
You should be sure about crypto and boiling. That is a very common instruction which every physician should be giving any patient with HIV-AIDS or other serious immunocompromising condition.

Preventing Cryptosporidiosis: A Guide to Water Filters and Bottled Water

Preventing Cryptosporidiosis: A Guide for People with Compromised Immune Systems
A. Boiling water: Boiling is the best extra measure to ensure that your water is free of Crypto and other germs. Heating water at a rolling boil for 1 minute kills Crypto, according to CDC* and EPA** scientists. After the boiled water cools, put it in a clean bottle or pitcher with a lid and store it in the refrigerator. Use the water for drinking, cooking, or making ice. Water bottles and ice trays should be cleaned with soap and water before use. Do not touch the inside of them after cleaning. If you can, clean water bottles and ice trays yourself.

As for prions, a quick Google search finds they are destroyed by the following means:

WHO infection control guidelines for transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. Report of a WHO consultation, Geneva, Switzerland, 23-26 March 1999
[from the pdf file in the link] Section 6. DECONTAMINATION PROCEDURES

Surfaces contaminated by TSE agents can be disinfected by flooding, for one hour, with NaOH or sodium hypochlorite, followed by water rinses...

Autoclave/chemical methods for heat-resistant instruments:
1. Immerse in sodium hydroxide (NaOH)20 and heat in a gravity displacement autoclave at 121°C for 30 min; clean; rinse in water and subject to routine sterilization.
2. Immerse in NaOH or sodium hypochlorite21 for 1 hr; transfer instruments to water; heat in a gravity displacement autoclave at 121°C for 1 hr; clean and subject to routine sterilization.
3. Immerse in NaOH or sodium hypochlorite for 1 hr.; remove and rinse in water, then transfer to open pan and heat in a gravity displacement (121°C) or porous load (134°C) autoclave for 1 hr.; clean and subject to routine sterilization.
4. Immerse in NaOH and boil for 10 min at atmospheric pressure; clean, rinse in water and subject to routine sterilization.
5. Immerse in sodium hypochlorite (preferred) or NaOH (alternative) at ambient temperature for 1 hr; clean; rinse in water and subject to routine sterilization.
6. Autoclave at 134°C for 18 minutes. (*22)
(*22) In worse-case scenarios (brain tissue bake-dried on to surfaces) infectivity will be largely but not completely removed.
 
In reviewing preface to (section 6) the original document it seems that WHO is still somewhat on the fence regarding the re-use of previously possibly prion infected instruments that have been decontaminated by flooding, bleach and sodium hydroxide and especially so about delicate reusable instruments which cannot be subjected to such harsh chemicals without damaging them. In short, this is why there may not ultimately be (yet) a perfect means of destroying the protein that is a prion ....but denaturing it with these agents seems to be the best one could hope for at present. Prions are not living organisms like bacteria/spores, viruses or parasites.

For a good discussion of prions, see the thesis (page 4, section 2.2) at:

http://www.lfcs.edinburgh.ac.uk/publications/thesis/online/IT030018.pdf.
 
Last edited:
The official guidelines from gastroenterologists is to destroy any scope used in patients with "Mad Cow" disease, as sterilization cannot be guaranteed.
 
The official guidelines from gastroenterologists is to destroy any scope used in patients with "Mad Cow" disease, as sterilization cannot be guaranteed.

Exactly. There is no "guaranteed" way to decontaminate an instrument that may've been doused with prions.
 
Um... no offence folks, but what's the point of this thread now? The questions asked have been pretty simple ones, easily Googled I'm sure, and there's no real discussion happening.

Skeptidoc, either make a point or let's abandon this thread, yeah?

Athon
 
I don't like to leave loose ends.

This thread's development continues to be illuminating of the human experience, ethics and morality.

I have been spending time listening to podcasts from Point of Inquiry and exploring the "other" Forum, Skeptical Community.

Whoever has followed the news, knows about the court martial of the soldier that is refusing to go to Iraq, I hope that clarifies and settles the arguments about discipline and chain of command.

Some were critical of "LOL", in a different forum the following is posted to assist members:

People often use these and other acronyms on message boards.

Code:
AAMOF As a matter of fact

AFAIK As Far as I Know

AFK Away From Keyboard

AKA Also Known As

ASAP As Soon As Possible

ATM At the moment

BRB Be Right Back

BTDT Been There, Done That

BTW By the way

DIY Do it yourself

EOD End of Discussion

FAQ Frequently Asked Questions

FWIW For What It's Worth

FYI For Your Information

GIGO Garbage In, Garbage Out

IMHO In My Humble Opinion

IMLTHO In My Less Than Humble Opinion

IMO In My Opinion

IOW In other words

IIRC If I remember correctly

IRL In Real Life

JK or J/K Just Kidding

LMAO Laughing my arse off

LOL Laughing Out Loud

MYOB Mind Your Own Business

NM Never Mind

NP No problem

OIC Oh, I See

OMG Oh my god.

OT Off Topic

OTOH On The Other Hand

OTT Over The Top

POV Point of View

ROFL Rolling on Floor Laughing

WB Welcome Back

WTG Way To Go

WYSIWYG What You See Is What You Get

More to follow....
 
regarding vitamin supplements:

Supplementation with folic acid and B vitamins is ineffective for adults 55 years and older with known cardiovascular disease (CVD) or diabetes. A second report in the same issue found that similar supplementation in patients with a recent acute myocardial infarction was not helpful and may actually increase the risk of a bad cardiovascular outcome (relative risk = 1.22; 95% CI, 1.0 - 1.5). (LOE = 1b)

Reference
Lonn E, Yusuf S, Arnold MJ, et al, for the Heart Outcomes Prevention Evaluation (HOPE) 2 Investigators. Homocysteine lowering with folic acid and B vitamins in vascular disease. N Engl J Med 2006;354:1567-1577.

I may have to change my list, so far, there may be neurologic benefits with B6, B12, folate
 
Did you read it?

The wife asked about NHL.

Case Scenario
A 48-year-old patient with a family history of early colon cancer came to my office complaining of fatigue. He also said he felt "feverish" and had chest pressure. A physical examination and echocardiogram were normal. He returned to my office several more times complaining of chest pressure. I performed a work-up for cardiac disease and, because a complete blood cell count showed that he was anemic, I referred him for a colonoscopy.
The patient's wife accompanied him to his fourth office visit. She said, "Doctor, could this be NHL?" After thinking for a few minutes, I realized that she meant non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. She said that she found this diagnosis after doing Internet searches on her husband's symptoms.

With a normal PE, labs anything a healthcare provider orders is a "hunch", of course we don't know how many other diagnosis were suggested in the Internet search.

This is just another anecdotal case that justifies thinking outside the box, we cannot order every single test imaginable because a low probability will generate false positives and increased morbidity and mortality that accompany unnecessary tests. Go back to earlier posts to have perspective on this post, I ordered a CT that diagnosed Renal carcinoma and a hepatic lesion on a "hunch".
 
Last edited:
From the link:
Curbside Consultation

Usefulness of Online Medical Information

Case Scenario

A 48-year-old patient with a family history of early colon cancer came to my office complaining of fatigue. He also said he felt "feverish" and had chest pressure. A physical examination and echocardiogram were normal. He returned to my office several more times complaining of chest pressure. I performed a work-up for cardiac disease and, because a complete blood cell count showed that he was anemic, I referred him for a colonoscopy.

The patient's wife accompanied him to his fourth office visit. She said, "Doctor, could this be NHL?" After thinking for a few minutes, I realized that she meant non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. She said that she found this diagnosis after doing Internet searches on her husband's symptoms. Follow-up computed tomography showed mediastinal lymph nodes, confirming that non-Hodgkin's lymphoma indeed was the diagnosis. Are patients becoming better at determining diagnoses than physicians? Should patients be diagnosing themselves? I
What normal PE? The guy was anemic and had symptoms the Dr had failed to determine the cause of. There is no hunch involved in pursuing a differential for chest pressure. It's called an education.
 
So if it isn't education, S-doc, then are you claiming people good at these "hunches" just happen to also go to medical or nursing schools?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom