Medical and Healthcare phishing

When you cannot attack the idea, attack the messenger......
So ignore it and answer a question I (you) posed ages ago....
Originally Posted by skepticdoc :
Saline computation:

1 cup = 8 oz = 240 cc

1 tsp = 5 cc = 11 gm ( assume 2.2 gm/cc for either sodium chloride or bicarbonate, to simplify )

4 cups = 960 cc , 11/960 ~ 0.01145...

each teaspoon makes a 1.1% solution, normal saline is 0.9%

the percentage will range from 2.2 to 5.5 % following my patient's recipe
So, could you answer the question you posed in post #223, "What is the tonicity/osmolarity of my Pt's recipe?"?
 
Please illuminate me, what is the military chain of command?

Isn't it unidirectional?

No, it isn't.

There are three branches, for starters (officer, enlisted, warrant), and rank is not the same as chain-of-command. There's also a difference between rank and authority, which you seem to be unable to distinguish either in the military or in medical care. IN my position as a Sergeant, I have authority over certain areas related to my job. I can give orders to our Commanding General regarding my specialty and area of responsibility, for example. If he breaks those orders, I can go farther up the chain and have action taken (not usually worth it unless it's a serious breech, though).

Not to mention that each unit/section has a chain of command that's different. I don't take orders from a Captain in a different section, for example. If that Captain wants me to do something, he goes through my chain of command.

Even within my immediate section, it isn't clear cut. There's an officer that, technically, leads the section, but I decide how my job gets done. He outranks me, and is at the top of my chain of command (within my section), but even then certain things that I do are outside his area of responsibility.

So it's not a simple matter of "A follows orders from B". A and B have different jobs to do, and it's not just following orders.

Not to mention that you didn't restrict your comments to chain of command issues, but went on to imply brainwashing, something for which there is very little evidence (with the possible exception of Marines). You could have just made your point, but instead you went out of your way to make it insulting and deriding. Just so you know, that is why you're getting a hard time...not because of your views, but because you act like a major *****. No one in the military classifies us as "freedom fighters". Very few members in the military are "brainwashed". Chain-of-command is not a clear case of "more rank means I own you". You've just watched too many cheesy war movies.
 
Last edited:
From Wikipedia:

Chain of command

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search
This article deals with the military concept. For other things see Chain of Command. In a military context, the chain of command is the line of authority and responsibility along which orders are passed.
The line of command will generally go from a higher-ranked soldier who gives the order, i.e. an officer, down to a lower-ranked soldier who is ordered to perform, i.e. a common soldier.
In general, military personnel give orders to only those directly below them in the chain of command and receive orders from only those directly above. For example, a common soldier who has difficulty carrying out an order is likely to be disciplined for not observing the chain of command if he skips the officer who is in direct command of him and directly appeals to a higher-ranked officer in his chain of command.
The concept of chain of command also implies that higher rank alone does not entitle a person to give commands. For example, an officer of a given military unit cannot directly command common soldiers of another unit, because this officer is outside of their chain of command. If the officer needs something from the soldiers of another unit, he is generally expected to approach an officer along their chain of command.
The term is also used in civilian context describing comparable hierarchical structures of authority, for example in management.

Do you have any reliable sources that differ from this?
 
From Wikipedia:

Chain of command

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Jump to: navigation, search
This article deals with the military concept. For other things see Chain of Command. In a military context, the chain of command is the line of authority and responsibility along which orders are passed.
The line of command will generally go from a higher-ranked soldier who gives the order, i.e. an officer, down to a lower-ranked soldier who is ordered to perform, i.e. a common soldier.
In general, military personnel give orders to only those directly below them in the chain of command and receive orders from only those directly above. For example, a common soldier who has difficulty carrying out an order is likely to be disciplined for not observing the chain of command if he skips the officer who is in direct command of him and directly appeals to a higher-ranked officer in his chain of command.
The concept of chain of command also implies that higher rank alone does not entitle a person to give commands. For example, an officer of a given military unit cannot directly command common soldiers of another unit, because this officer is outside of their chain of command. If the officer needs something from the soldiers of another unit, he is generally expected to approach an officer along their chain of command.
The term is also used in civilian context describing comparable hierarchical structures of authority, for example in management.

Do you have any reliable sources that differ from this?

No, but that doesn't disagree with what I stated. I took issue with your condescending tone and your misunderstanding or oversimplification of the issue. It's not just about rank, it's about authority.

An example, a Major can't order the armorer (usually a sergeant/enlisted) to give him weapons from the arms room. The armorer has authority over the arms room, granted by the Commander. Likewise, when I worked as a medic, I could coutermand orders from higher in the chain of command if such orders would endanger a patient (i.e.- a commander ordering a soldier with a severely sprained ankle to do a road march).

The military does not rely on brainwashing and propoganda to maintain order, it relies on rules (just as any society does) which are enforced. It's also not inflexible. I can "skip" my direct superior in my chain of command for certain things (besides authority due to job/position, safety concerns are another example).

What you stated above does not agree with the Wiki article, and your further comments show you have very little understanding of military rank structure. I've been in the service for over 14 years now, both in reserve and active componenets, during both peacetime and in war zones. Your statements were both incomplete and inaccurate.
 
I'm probably wading in pretty deep, but here goes.

Many years ago before I was a doctor, I was an ER nurse. When I realized that what I really wanted was to take the responsibility for the entire patient, I went to medical school because that's the way things work in this country. While a nurse, I never felt any "collegiality" with the doctors — they had their duties, I had mine, and we both worked for the benefit of the patient. If they had things to teach me, great. I was a willing student and learned much.

But familiarity breeds contempt, or at least a "shared equality" which is anything but equal. In the last few weeks I've had nurses tell me, "I knew you should have intubated that patient earlier," "I knew that patient had a dissecting aorta" (when nobody, including the intensivist, cardiologist, or surgeon knew any such thing), and, when a patient last Sunday suddenly dropped his pressure and went into a-fib, "I thought that was a pulmonary embolism when he hit the door" (with a set of vague complaints which matched absolutely nothing).

The retrospectoscope is a marvelously accurate tool. Unfortunately, it's of no help in the present tense, and causes mostly resentment if used in the past tense. I would love nothing more than to be right 100% of the time in the present tense, but that will never happen. That's why I subscribe to Emergency Medical Abstracts, Audio-Digest, Topics in Pediatric Emergency Medicine, Critical Decisions in Emergency Medicine, Medical Letter, Journal Watch, Annals, AEM, JEM, EM News, etc. That's why there are well-thumbed copies of Rosen & Barkin, Tintinalli, Roberts & Hedges, Nelson's Pediatrics, etc. on shelves in my ER (and rarely looked at by the nurses, I might add). That's why our department on-line computer has bookmarks for emedicine, eMedHome, NEJM, BMJ, Pub Med, NCEMI, etc. (if I can get access to it, in which case the comment is "There's Mark...playing on the computer again"). That's why I am active in Emergency Medicine organizations at the local, state, and national levels. That's why I'm on this list . . .

. . . and that's why my malpractice insurance runs about $30,000 / year, because I can never be right 100% of the time.

I've worked with some damn good nurses whose opinions I've learned to respect and trust, but they had to earn that trust. I expect to earn trust and respect from nurses in the same manner. But this malarkey about "Listen to the nurse, because the nurse knows" is hard to swallow.

And yeah I wasn't going to say anything, but this IS a topic which needs to be discussed.

An essay that describes many experiences that I have had. So many people assume that docs don't respect nurses, but do they ever look at how some nurses' behavior might contribute to this? I need to earn your respect, fine, but show the same professional courtesy in permitting me to do so in return.

Essay can be found at:
http://www.erbook.net/another point of view regarding nurses.htm
 
Judging by the most recent posts, I still refuse to believe that this guy is currently a doc. He just displays way too much irrationality and way too little actual medical knowledge. I'm still thinking technician. However, there's another distinct possibility that I am increasingly leaning towards: a former doctor. Someone who probably lost his practice, and possibly his license, for unethical or abusive behaviour. Could be that he did work in a hospital, and was quietly asked to leave, or maybe underwent an investigation; possibly for self-prescribing medication with a higher abuse potential than the ones he posted. It's also a strong probability, judging from the irrationality and inconsistencies in his post, that he's an alcoholic.

Judging by his view of nurses, I'd be willing to consider the possibility that there was some sort of sexual harassment involved, as well.
 
Judging by the most recent posts, I still refuse to believe that this guy is currently a doc.

Judging by his view of nurses, I'd be willing to consider the possibility that there was some sort of sexual harassment involved, as well.

You're certainly doing a lot of judging.

I realize that I'm new to this place, and I know a lot of nasty things have been said, but this is inappropriate. I hope that it doesn't win you any votes from whomever you're trying to impress.
 
Hey luchog ( or is it lunch hog, swine or "puerco" ), are you you willing to make a donation to the JREF or do I have to sue you for libel? I can prove you so wrong, so quickly, that you won't know what happenned until it is too late to apologize! Or do you speak oink more fluently?

Do not threaten other forum members. Oh, and stop the childish taunting, too.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey luchog ( or is it lunch hog, swine or "puerco" ), are you you willing to make a donation to the JREF or do I have to sue you for libel? I can prove you so wrong, so quickly, that you won't know what happenned until it is too late to apologize! Or do you speak oink more fluently?
Threats? Elementary-school style insults? *tsk* Some people never learn.
 
I made a mistake, I assumed the insults were coming from a male, the correction would be puerco or puerca, cochino or cochina, cochin in French is asexual. I have trouble figuring out the avatar, maybe it is a transexual pig, I would find it hard to believe a lady would behave like that!

Pepe LePew, do you want to engage in childish exchanges, are your scent glands excised? or do you enjoy your stinking personal comments? You can't argue with ideas, eh?
 
And supposing it were a transsexual person - would you think less of them for that? Cos you seem to be slinging it about like an insult. Nice going for a medical professional.
 
You know, the only time I ever read someone on this forum threatening a libel suit to another user were threats made by trolls claiming to have won the million dollar prize.

Doc, no one has agreed to your "wager" nor cares to, therefore telling someone to "get out their checkbook" could be construed as a threat of extortion, especially when a threat of lawsuit is included in the same paragraph. Be careful.

Also, I would love to see your libel suit laughed out of court. Your personal information is not known to luchog or meffy or I, so how would you prove we knew anything about you when statements about you were made? Not to mention, as skeptics every one of us would acknowledge proper evidence of your MD status if it were presented, however you don't do that, you just insult us more.

I think you just blew what little credibility you had by threatening libel suits and tossing the petty insults you have.
 
Last edited:
You can't argue with ideas, eh?


What ideas? We've already shredded your manifesto (and explained the delicacies of plagiarism), and shown your inconsistant statements regarding your own beliefs.

What other ideas have you written on here about? Because other than insulting just about everyone, you've had little of substance to post.

Until you straighten out your athiest/agnostic/pantheist/whatever else problem, and address the other inconsistancies brought up in this thread no one is going to take anything you write here seriously, credentials or not.
 
sd, please cut your losses. Really. You're making wrong guesses right and left, trying so hard to deliver stinging insults but failing to score any hits, and generally just making yourself look more and more infantile and desperate. C'mon, why not do the sensible thing: quit the insulting childish prattle, abandon this thread as a bad job, and get on with enjoying life? You can't be getting much satisfaction from having got refuted so thoroughly and handily... can you?
 
Are you in the US or UK?
And what does this have to do with the price of tea in China? Or we're you hoping he'd say UK so you could claim that it's done differently in the US and you know better than he does? Like you did when you dismissed Deetee's input:

Don't you practice in the UK? It is different in my corner of the USA.

I may consult the enterostomal therapy nurse, who writes orders under MY NAME for the floor nurses to follow.
 
You're certainly doing a lot of judging.
And judgement is to be considered a negative exactly why? This is a forum devoted to judgement of the facts and evidence available, and making decisions on the validity of assertions made and to their likelyhood of being true.

s'doc claims to be a physician, and many here have expressed doubt about that based on his behavior and evasions of questions that have been put to him.

luchog wrote:
Judging by the most recent posts, I still refuse to believe that this guy is currently a doc. He just displays way too much irrationality and way too little actual medical knowledge. I'm still thinking technician. However, there's another distinct possibility that I am increasingly leaning towards: a former doctor. Someone who probably lost his practice, and possibly his license, for unethical or abusive behaviour. Could be that he did work in a hospital, and was quietly asked to leave, or maybe underwent an investigation; possibly for self-prescribing medication with a higher abuse potential than the ones he posted. It's also a strong probability, judging from the irrationality and inconsistencies in his post, that he's an alcoholic.

Judging by his view of nurses, I'd be willing to consider the possibility that there was some sort of sexual harassment involved, as well.
Bolding mine.
luchog was obviously taking ownership of those hypotheses, and did not intend them to be taken as GOD's judgement, but as his/hers alone. This if a forum where no one automatically gets final authority.

I realize that I'm new to this place,...
<sniff> Does anyone else smell unwashed used socks?
Funny thing about your timing and choice of articles to reprint, to say nothing of your first post (#494) :
Ooh! Are you cruisin' for a bruisin' (from an outsider/newbie's perspective)!
Which implied that you expected what was coming. THAT makes me wonder...

...and I know a lot of nasty things have been said,...
I believe you will discover, if you bother to read the entire thread, that any nastiness you percieve was initiated and escalated by s'doc himself.

...but this is inappropriate. ...
Sez you? What you appear to be responding to was quite mild by comparison to some of s'doc's tirades/tantrums.

...I hope that it doesn't win you any votes from whomever you're trying to impress.
To whom are you addressing that comment? s'doc? luchog? meffy? fowlsound? The only one here who seems bent on impressing folks is s'doc, and he has lost so many "votes" already that he has doomed himself to a long uphill struggle to gain any (medical) credibility with many of us.

Those other members need impress no one; they have already earned respect here.

---------------------

FYI, compare what luchog wrote with (only one example of many) an earlier post by Flo (#378) :
One who has severely lost his marbles, possibly. I've seen cases like this in my line of work (medical secretary in a university hospital - boss involved in medical professions disciplinary authorities) ... Not too competent but unaware of their limitations, good at hiding it from patients and some colleagues, good at hiding their psychological and personnal problems, and at shifting the blame for their mistakes on subordinates, arrogant, huge chips on their shoulders when it comes to women (especially competent and independent ones) and different cultures, lacking any basic respect for their patients despite discourse about their humanitarian motivations, and the constant shifting of issues when challenged. Usually ends badly.
s'doc has given many of us no reason to believe in his creds, and considerable reason to doubt: His behavior has spoken volumes.

You should really read the entire thread before assuming that s'doc is a hapless victim of these mean ol' skeptics.:D

Cheers,
Dave
 
S'doc, you are still making the same mistake regarding the relationship between nurses and doctors. Why is it so hard for you to get the concepts here? If you can't understand the basic relationship between nurses and doctors it doesn't say much of your ability for abstract thought, something I would think necessary for the kind of information processing a medical provider might need to perform. Not to mention your failure to grasp what the profession of nursing is all about doesn't say much of your ability to take in new information or consider new concepts.


The following is a section from the laws of WA State re nursing and medicine. Show me where in those laws, or any other state law for that matter, where it says nurses follow orders from doctors.
RCW 18.71.011
Definition of practice of medicine — ...

A person is practicing medicine if he does one or more of the following:

(1) Offers or undertakes to diagnose, cure, advise or prescribe for any human disease, ailment, injury, infirmity, deformity, pain or other condition, physical or mental, real or imaginary, by any means or instrumentality;

(2) Administers or prescribes drugs or medicinal preparations to be used by any other person;

(3) Severs or penetrates the tissues of human beings;

(4) Uses on cards, books, papers, signs or other written or printed means of giving information to the public, in the conduct of any occupation or profession pertaining to the diagnosis or treatment of human disease or conditions the designation "doctor of medicine", "physician", "surgeon", "m.d." or any combination thereof unless such designation additionally contains the description of another branch of the healing arts for which a person has a license: PROVIDED HOWEVER, That a person licensed under this chapter shall not engage in the practice of chiropractic as defined in RCW 18.25.005.


RCW 18.79.040
"Registered nursing practice" defined — ...

1) "Registered nursing practice" means the performance of acts requiring substantial specialized knowledge, judgment, and skill based on the principles of the biological, physiological, behavioral, and sociological sciences in either:

(a) The observation, assessment, diagnosis, care or counsel, and health teaching of individuals with illnesses, injuries, or disabilities, or in the maintenance of health or prevention of illness of others;

(b) The performance of such additional acts requiring education and training and that are recognized by the medical and nursing professions as proper and recognized by the commission to be performed by registered nurses licensed under this chapter and that are authorized by the commission through its rules;

(c) The administration, supervision, delegation, and evaluation of nursing practice. However, nothing in this subsection affects the authority of a hospital, hospital district, in-home service agency, community-based care setting, medical clinic, or office, concerning its administration and supervision;

(d) The teaching of nursing;

(e) The executing of medical regimen as prescribed by a licensed physician and surgeon, dentist, osteopathic physician and surgeon, podiatric physician and surgeon, physician assistant, osteopathic physician assistant, or advanced registered nurse practitioner.
In other words as is further spelled out here:
(2) A registered nurse may, at or under the general direction of a licensed physician and surgeon, dentist, osteopathic physician and surgeon, naturopathic physician, podiatric physician and surgeon, physician assistant, osteopathic physician assistant, or advanced registered nurse practitioner acting within the scope of his or her license, administer medications, treatments, tests, and inoculations, whether or not the severing or penetrating of tissues is involved and whether or not a degree of independent judgment and skill is required. Such direction must be for acts which are within the scope of registered nursing practice.
Since when is delegating a responsibility the equivalent of ordering an action?

Doctors and other licensed professionals prescribe medical regimens FOR PATIENTS. Nurses may perform the care indicated by a PATIENT CARE regimen if a physician delegates the responsibility for carrying out that regimen.

D-E-L-E-G-A-T-E
# transfer power to someone
# give an assignment to (a person) to a post, or assign a task to (a person)
# a person designated to act for or represent another or others
# to assign responsibility and authority to the appropriate level.

If the physician is the employer, the physician may be seen as ordering the employee to carry out a task. That is an employer/employee relationship. The physician has a patient/provider relationship. The nurse has a patient/provider relationship. The physician and nurse have a colleaguial relationship.


Further description of the practice of nursing can be seen in this law:
WAC 246-840-700
Standards of nursing conduct or practice.

a) Registered Nurse:
Minimum standards for registered nurses include the following:

(i) Standard I Initiating the Nursing Process:

(A) Assessment and Analysis: The registered nurse initiates data collection and analysis that includes pertinent objective and subjective data regarding the health status of the clients. The registered nurse is responsible for ongoing client assessment, including assimilation of data gathered from licensed practical nurses and other members of the health care team;
(B) Nursing Diagnosis/Problem Identification: The registered nurse uses client data and nursing scientific principles to develop nursing diagnosis and to identify client problems in order to deliver effective nursing care;
(C) Planning: The registered nurse shall plan nursing care which will assist clients and families with maintaining or restoring health and wellness or supporting a dignified death;
(D) Implementation: The registered nurse implements the plan of care by initiating nursing interventions through giving direct care and supervising other members of the care team; and
(E) Evaluation: The registered nurse evaluates the responses of individuals to nursing interventions and is responsible for the analysis and modification of the nursing care plan consistent with intended outcomes;

(ii) Standard II Delegation and Supervision: The registered nurse is accountable for the safety of clients receiving nursing service by:

(A) Delegating selected nursing functions to others in accordance with their education, credentials, and demonstrated competence as defined in WAC 246-840-010(10);
(B) Supervising others to whom he/she has delegated nursing functions as defined in WAC 246-840-010(10);
(C) Evaluating the outcomes of care provided by licensed and other paraprofessional staff;
(D) The registered nurse may delegate certain additional acts to certain individuals in community-based long-term care and in-home settings as provided by WAC 246-840-910 through246-840-970 and WAC 246-841-405; and
(E) In a home health or hospice agency regulated under chapter 70.127 RCW, a registered nurse may delegate the application, instillation, or insertion of medications to a registered or certified nursing assistant under a plan of care pursuant to chapter 246-335 WAC;

(iii) Standard III Health Teaching. The registered nurse assesses learning needs including learning readiness for patients and families, develops plans to meet those learning needs, implements the teaching plan and evaluates the outcome.

(3) The following standards apply to registered nurses and licensed practical nurses:

(a) The registered nurse and licensed practical nurse shall communicate significant changes in the client's status to appropriate members of the health care team. This communication shall take place in a time period consistent with the client's need for care. Communication is defined as a process by which information is exchanged between individuals through a common system of speech, symbols, signs, and written communication or behaviors that serves as both a means of gathering information and of influencing the behavior, actions, attitudes, and feelings of others; and

(b) The registered nurse and licensed practical nurse shall document, on essential client records, the nursing care given and the client's response to that care; and

(c) The registered nurse and licensed practical nurse act as client advocates in health maintenance and clinical care.

(4) Other responsibilities:

(a) The registered nurse and the licensed practical nurse shall have knowledge and understanding of the laws and rules regulating nursing and shall function within the legal scope of nursing practice;

(b) The registered nurse and the licensed practical nurse shall be responsible and accountable for his or her practice based upon and limited to the scope of his/her education, demonstrated competence, and nursing experience consistent with the scope of practice set forth in this document; and

(c) The registered nurse and the licensed practical nurse shall obtain instruction, supervision, and consultation as necessary before implementing new or unfamiliar techniques or procedures which are in his/her scope of practice.

(d) The registered nurse and the licensed practical nurse shall be responsible for maintaining current knowledge in his/her field of practice; and

(e) The registered nurse and the licensed practical nurse shall respect the client's right to privacy by protecting confidential information and shall not use confidential health care information for other than legitimate patient care purposes or as otherwise provided in the Health Care Information Act, chapter 70.02 RCW.
As you can see from the law in WA State governing the practice of nursing, the legislators fully recognize that nursing is a profession, and performing medical care delegated by certain other health care providers is merely one aspect of nursing practice.

Medical care isn't even mentioned in the scope of practice. Following "doctor's orders" isn't mentioned in the scope of nursing practice. That's because it is in the medical scope of practice law, specifically, that a physician may delegate a medical task to a licensed nurse.


I'll be happy to post this information every time you repeat the banal anal statement, "nurses still have to follow the orders written by doctors." No, nurses do not have to follow any such orders. In the course of their employment, nurses may be delegated to provide medical care which physicians order for patients. Nurses, (with the exception of advanced practice nurses), may not provide some medical care unless it is delegated by a physician, usually in the form of a written or verbal order for a patient. The employer may order the nurse to perform a delegated task, the physician, if not the employer, certainly may not order a nurse to do anything!! In addition, without such medical delegated tasks, the scope of nursing care is still quite broad.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom