Medical and Healthcare phishing

You are arguing with an incomplete set of facts.

How many patients come in with laundry lists of diagnoses that are totally off the wall? I don't have a number, do you?

My point is that there is more to medical decision making than the PE, Hx, and blood tests. Some information you get from Radiology studies cannot be obtained any other way.

As far as I know there are no "Nurse Radiologists".

There are some chiropractors that read spine MRIs and own centers, I don't know whether they can interpret non-spine studies.
 
S'girl would like to address the thousands of nurses that are practicing "Therapeutic Touch"? Is 20,000 nurse practitioners number an exaggeration, or an under estimate?
 
No one I know practices therapeutic touch and AFAIK, some initial studies suggested blood counts could be affected by it but later research has confirmed there is no effect.

Why not look this crap up before making such outlandish statements?
 
The numbers mentioned are worse, 40,000 have completed "courses", only 20,000 listed as practitioners.

FYI, there are male nurses.

In the future there may be more female physicians than male, in some schools the females outnumber males. Keep sexism out of the discussion.
 
Updates

There is no cardiovascular disease benefit from the vitamin supplements.

Sam Harris stated in "Beyond Belief" that 60% of US physicians believe in a personal God. I don't know the source, but it is probably too low, in my limited experience with physician forums, probably less than 1% would even consider the term agnostic/atheist applies to them.

I started watching "House" on the Fox network and found some explanations for my experience in this thread. A minority of physicians are addicts, in the show only House is an addict, some contributors to the thread made inflammatory accusations that only reflect a media prejudice. House is a fictional character, and most of the situations presented in the show are only of entertainment value.

The Science Network sponsored a seminar: "Beyond Belief" www.tsntv.org , I would like to recommend the videos, in particular Dr. Richard Sloan's presentation. It was a humbling experience to hear distinguished scientists point out the unscientific assessments of Medical Research and Publications.
 
There is no cardiovascular disease benefit from the vitamin supplements.

Sam Harris stated in "Beyond Belief" that 60% of US physicians believe in a personal God. I don't know the source, but it is probably too low, in my limited experience with physician forums, probably less than 1% would even consider the term agnostic/atheist applies to them.

I started watching "House" on the Fox network and found some explanations for my experience in this thread. A minority of physicians are addicts, in the show only House is an addict, some contributors to the thread made inflammatory accusations that only reflect a media prejudice. House is a fictional character, and most of the situations presented in the show are only of entertainment value.

The Science Network sponsored a seminar: "Beyond Belief" www.tsntv.org , I would like to recommend the videos, in particular Dr. Richard Sloan's presentation. It was a humbling experience to hear distinguished scientists point out the unscientific assessments of Medical Research and Publications.

After my cardiac arrest and subsequent open heart surgery my homocysteine levels, among much other stuff, was checked and found elevated. My cardiologists put me on folic acid l mg daily and B12. Then along came a study saying not only was this worthless it was slightly harmful so I was taken off the folic acid and B12. In fact we briefly discussed this in this thread. Now, a year or so later, the following study reverses the study saying it was worthless ... so here we go again:


The Times (London) November 24, 2006



Taking folic acid can reduce the risk of heart disease and strokes, according to research. British scientists have discovered that raised levels of the amino acid homocysteine in the blood is one of the causes of cardiovascular disease.

They say that increasing intake of folic acid would be a relatively cheap and simple way of reducing heart disease. Previous studies have also suggested that eating plenty of folic acid, a type of vitamin B, could help to prevent strokes and some cancers and could potentially halve the risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease. Since folic acid helps to lower homocysteine, the scientists believe increasing intake of the vitamin could help to reduce the risk of disease. The Department of Health recommends that all women take a daily supplement of 0.4mg of folic acid before they conceive and for the first 12 weeks of pregnancy while the baby’s spine is developing to help prevent spina bifida. Folic acid is already recommended to pregnant women as it is known to help prevent spina bifida in babies. Rich dietary sources of folic acid include fortified breakfast cereals, bread, green leafy vegetables such as Brussels sprouts, broccoli, spinach and green beans, oranges, dried beans, peas and lentils. The study is published today in the British Medical Journal. A team led by David Wald of Barts and the London, Queen Mary’s School of Medicine and Dentistry were attempting to resolve the ongoing debate over whether homocysteine causes heart attacks and strokes. They examined evidence from previous studies and found that tests involving large numbers of people and people genetically prone to higher homocysteine levels yielded similar results — that lower homocysteine levels had a protective effect. Importantly, the tests achieved similar results even though they did not share the same sources of possible errors. Moreover, although studies of the effects of lowering homocysteine levels were too small to be conclusive, the results were still consistent with the protective effect of folic acid. The researchers wrote: “The conclusion that homocysteine is a cause of cardiovascular disease explains the observations from all the different types of study, even if the results from one type of study are, on their own, insufficient to reach that conclusion.” The scientists said that it therefore followed that increasing folic acid consumption would reduce the risk of heart attack and stroke and said that action should be taken to lower homocysteine concentrations.



http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-2468885,00.html


PS: My homocysteine levels did drop precipitously with the folic acid/B12 regimen; now only if everyone can agree these levels are a risk for coronary disease or not.
 
Last edited:
There is no cardiovascular disease benefit from the vitamin supplements.....
And we should take your word for this, why?

According to the researchers at the U of Wa Medical School in the three lectures linked below, vitamin C or E alone are not preventative but combined they consistently have some beneficial effect in research on both Alzheimer's and cardiovascular disease. Anti-inflammatory drugs do as well. All of these findings are preliminary but consistent so far.

Here's the research problem. When you look at people with these diseases compared to people without them, you find those who took E & C vitamins together have less disease. The next step has to be to conduct randomized clinical trials. If you don't, then you cannot say if the vitamins are merely associated with less disease for some as yet unidentified reason or whether the vitamins and anti-inflamatory drugs are actually protective in themselves.

Considering the vitamins have low risk, I continue to take them. Dose did not appear important so far.

The anti-inflammatories carry greater risk so many researchers advocate waiting for more conclusive evidence. But if one had greater risk for either of the two diseases it might be worth consideration. The best dose is unknown so being conservative is prudent.

One interesting finding about Alzheimer's (this is from the Nuns study) is that what mattered was if these Nuns took the vitamins and/or anti-inflammatories at or around the time of menopause and that they took them for several years. Taking them later, when Alzheimer's onset was impending or had begun had no effect.

http://www.uwtv.org/programs/displayevent.aspx?rID=3757&fID=1469
http://www.uwtv.org/programs/displayevent.aspx?rID=3758&fID=1469
http://www.uwtv.org/programs/displayevent.aspx?rID=2389&fID=1469

In any event, I see no evidence for your conclusion, skepticdoc, that the role of these vitamins has been conclusively ruled out.

Here's more on the nuns study.
 
Last edited:

From your source (emphasis mine):

1. Evidence is insufficient to determine if vitamins A, C, or E, multivitamins with folic acid, or antioxidant combinations reduce CVD risk.

Comment: These USPSTF guidelines conclude that there is a lack of compelling data to show that routine vitamin supplementation is effective for primary or secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease. The guidelines are consistent with a recent meta-analysis of studies on vitamin E and beta-carotene, which suggested that these 2 antioxidants do not reduce CVD risk and that beta-carotene may increase risk for all-cause and cardiovascular mortality (Journal Watch Cardiology Aug 22 2003). Note that these USPSTF guidelines do not assess the role of vitamins for uses other than preventing CVD and cancer.

Summary of Recommendations
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) concludes that the evidence is insufficient to recommend for or against the use of supplements of vitamins A, C, or E; multivitamins with folic acid; or antioxidant combinations for the prevention of cancer or cardiovascular disease.
Rating: I Recommendation.
The USPSTF recommends against the use of beta-carotene supplements, either alone or in combination, for the prevention of cancer or cardiovascular disease. Rating: D Recommendation.

With the exception of vitamins for which there is compelling evidence of net harm (eg, beta-carotene supplementation in smokers), there is little reason to discourage people from taking vitamin supplements. Patients should be reminded that taking vitamins does not replace the need to eat a healthy diet. All patients should receive information about the benefits of a diet high in fruit and vegetables, as well as information on other foods and nutrients that should be emphasized or avoided in their diet (see 2002 USPSTF recommendation on counseling to promote a healthy diet, P. 125).

This is not inconsistent with the UW researchers. There was actually a negative outcome in using E or C alone. But your source merely states not enough data exists. Your source doesn't say, "There is no cardiovascular disease benefit from the vitamin supplements," which was your statement.

I suggest you do a bit more research into taking vitamin E and C supplements combined before you count out the vitamin benefit of either of the two alone.

Our data indicate that long-term supplementation of nondepleted men with a reasonable dose of vitamin E alone or in combination with slow release vitamin C reduces lipid peroxidation in vitro and in vivo, whereas a relatively high dose of vitamin C alone does not.

CONCLUSIONS: These data replicate our 3-year findings confirming that the supplementation with combination of vitamin E and slow-release vitamin C slows down atherosclerotic progression in hypercholesterolemic persons.

Full text, pdf file here

Clinical Trial: Vitamin E and C to Slow Progression of Common Carotid Artery Plaque Build-Up

Taking Combined Vitamin E and Vitamin C May Reduce Alzheimer Risk

Influence of vitamin E and C supplementation on lipoprotein oxidation in patients with Alzheimer’s disease...These findings document a superiority of a combined vitamin E + C supplementation over a vitamin E supplementation alone in AD and provide a biochemical basis for its use.

Vitamin E Combined With Selenium Inhibits Atherosclerosis in Hypercholesterolemic Rabbits Independently of Effects on Plasma Cholesterol Concentrations Of course I take selenium as well. Marie Annete Brown the Dean of my NP program did extensive research into PMS and that developed into research which determined a number of factors which can be easily manipulated to improve well being. The result was published in a self help book, When Your Body Gets the Blues: The Clinically Proven Program for Women Who Feel Tired, Stressed, and Eat Too Much!

Vitamin B6, selenium and 30 minutes a day OUTSIDE in daylight, (windows were not enough, clouds were OK) were three factors that had a significant impact for example. They found many other vitamins and therapies had little or no benefit.
 
Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proofs.

I am a N=1, had a subendocardial MI while on vitamins, it would be just anecdotal!

I smell a lot of Woo!
 
I provided the evidence supporting my statements, sdoc. If you go back and read what I said, you will not find inconsistencies. So are you claiming the researchers in the studies I cited are not legit? Really? You're not serious?

You, on the other hand, made a claim that exceeded what the evidence you provided supported. You claimed the evidence ruled out the benefit of vitamins when your cited source merely claimed the evidence was so far insufficient to determine any benefit. Insufficient to determine is not the equivalent of ruled out.

And just what do you define as an extraordinary claim here? Vitamins having a health benefit is hardly equivalent to life after death or alien abductions which are recognized as extraordinary claims.

And where do you read anyone claiming vitamins prevent ALL cardiac disease? Your anecdote is meaningless even if it were N of significant numbers. How do you know if your MI wouldn't have been worse had you not been on the vitamins?
 
Last edited:
I friend advised me that arguing in an Internet Forum can be like pissing in the wind, I listed a respected source and essentially I am repeating what is the current medical knowledge. The individual has to reach his or her own conclusion.
 
im thinking of being a nurse someday. I passed phlebotomy school easily and enjoy drawing blood. I really had fun in school learning about the body but obviously it wasnt very in depth. From what I have heard the best way to go about it is get a 2 year degree in biology and then apply for a nurse program. Is this accurate? I am in the states btw.
 
Depends on what you want to do, nails.

Have you had exposure to the nursing field to see what it's all about? What's great about it is that there are a lot of things that you can do with a nursing degree now, but it's important that you know what you're getting into. It's a challenging field but one with many rewards.

Maybe others can speak to the specific nursing programs around the country. I would think that doing whatever type of program that left you with the great number of options would be best. I don't know if midwifery and nurse practitioner programs require a particular type of nursing degree as prerequisites, for example.

Depending on the type of care that you're interested in providing, you might want to check out physician assistant programs, too.
 
The medical epistle of Daniel

Dr. Dennett of course!

I would like to invite all the participants and lurkers to watch episode 9 on http://beyondbelief2006.org/Watch/ , Dr. Dennett put in words an important message describing his recent medical experience. I cannot find the text to link it but the whole series is a most rewarding experience.

(if you are pressed for time FF to 2:32)
 
im thinking of being a nurse someday. I passed phlebotomy school easily and enjoy drawing blood. I really had fun in school learning about the body but obviously it wasnt very in depth. From what I have heard the best way to go about it is get a 2 year degree in biology and then apply for a nurse program. Is this accurate? I am in the states btw.
I started with a 2 year ADN program. It was a wonderful way to get started. When I went back for my BS degree, I had experience as a nurse already. Compared to how hard it was to learn at first, (learning is nothing but performing is another story), with the second degree, I had all the confidence issues out of the way and learning was much easier. And, it seems most nurses who go to an RNB program (BSN for RNs), also complete their MS degrees later. I took another year between programs, saved a bit more and went back for my MS.

Katana is right, there are many different occupations within nursing so it is a very flexible career. That is a good thing in today's job market. A worker with portable skills is much better off than one who advanced entirely within a single company.

I had the option of working as many or as few hours as I wanted and at good wages. With the shortage of hospital nurses I had a job which let me change my hours every quarter depending on class load.
 
I friend advised me that arguing in an Internet Forum can be like pissing in the wind, I listed a respected source and essentially I am repeating what is the current medical knowledge. The individual has to reach his or her own conclusion.
I think most people get it, sd. :wackycool:

:id:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom