Mass shooting in small town Texas

I knew there were accuracy problems, but I didn't know that it was as bad as all that. The more I learn about this the more I'm inclined to think that improving the NICS record check system accuracy might be one of the few things worth doing about the problem that might be able to avoid a knee-jerk partisan roadblock.

More about those background checks:
The FBI’s background-check system is missing millions of records of criminal convictions, mental illness diagnoses and other flags that would keep guns out of potentially dangerous hands, a gap that contributed to the shooting deaths of 26 people in a Texas church this week.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/nati...87ff8c-c4c4-11e7-aae0-cb18a8c29c65_story.html

One obvious, if imperfect, solution would be to eliminate the "instant" part of the background check and impose a waiting period that would allow sufficient time to search multiple databases, as some states do now. If somebody tells the gun shop clerk "I need a gun right now!," that by itself should raise a red flag.
 
Last edited:
You make me feel uncomfortable saying that because it suggests the exact kind of paranoia that makes me think you shouldn't have a gun.

You being in my proximity with a gun makes me far more uncomfortable than any reassurance that you could make a difference if a shtf event happened.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk

Paranoia ? You've seen the numbers ? You feel safe ? You think it can't happen anywhere near you ? Check the map.
And don't worry, I don't plan to get anywhere near US. It might be the safest third world country, but it is still is third world country, safety wise.
 
More about those background checks:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nati...87ff8c-c4c4-11e7-aae0-cb18a8c29c65_story.html

One obvious, if imperfect, solution would be to eliminate the "instant" part of the background check and impose a waiting period that would allow sufficient time to search multiple databases, as some states do now. If somebody tells the gun shop clerk "I need a gun right now!," that by itself should raise a red flag.

FBI can take up to three days to do the check if they see fit. Sale can go through by default if they don't provide an answer at the end of that time. I'd have thought that a sufficient time, but I'd underestimated how broken the system is.
 
I would feel uncomfortable anywhere, where I can't carry gun and where there is no armed guards to offset that.

You have my sympathy. It must be terrifying to live in a place where you feel so unsafe. I would suggest moving. I am sure there are lots of places similar to my area where it has never even occurred to me, or anyone I know, to carry a weapon.
 
I have a few friends who are armed everywhere they go. I don't feel safer. There are other friends that I would certainly trust with firearms, but oddly, those people don't carry them.

If you think you need them, I really don't want you to have them.

A few weeks ago four people in my town were shot. A college girl was celebrating her birthday with a double date. Her "good guy with a gun" boyfriend shot and killed her and the other guy and seriously wounded the other girl before killing himself.

A week earlier the big news was about a murder conviction. A young lady had been shot by her boyfriend when she attempted to break up with him. Another "good guy with a gun" gone wrong.

Exactly.

The first clue that you should be trusted with a gun is you have a realistic idea of when a gun may be needed. An expectation that isn't "at any time anywhere."
 
Exactly.

The first clue that you should be trusted with a gun is you have a realistic idea of when a gun may be needed. An expectation that isn't "at any time anywhere."

I support tough restrictions. But recent tragic history has proven that a gun might well be needed "any time anywhere." A prudent person could just stay away from places where he might predict a gun would be needed: dark alleys, biker bars, crack houses. But a Sunday church service? An elementary school? A college classroom? If you're going to carry, and you go to the trouble of getting a CCP, you may as well carry everywhere.
 
Can't keep up with the thread but in case no one has yet posted it, townspeople are kindly cleaning up the overgrown yard of the good guy with a gun while he and his daughter are lying low out of town to avoid all the publicity. I thought that was great.
 
I support tough restrictions. But recent tragic history has proven that a gun might well be needed "any time anywhere." A prudent person could just stay away from places where he might predict a gun would be needed: dark alleys, biker bars, crack houses. But a Sunday church service? An elementary school? A college classroom? If you're going to carry, and you go to the trouble of getting a CCP, you may as well carry everywhere.
Statistically your odds of dying from a gunshot in any given year is about one in ten thousand, and that includes suicides and accidents.

If you honestly feel unsafe with those odds, then you probably don't drive either as that's about 40 times more likely to kill you.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
But it needs to fail so often, that gives people the ability to claim they just need to enforce the existing laws and we don't need new ones.

Those are good words, wrongly arranged.

But it needs to fail so often, that gives people the ability to claim they just need new laws and we don't need to enforce the existing ones.
 
Do you think they would be reduced? Seems like they could be increased instead.
Why would they increase? Because the carrier would shoot him or herself? Or someone might see their gun and shoot them?
 
Why would they increase? Because the carrier would shoot him or herself? Or someone might see their gun and shoot them?

I don't know that it would increase, but the reasons you mention are possibilities. Also, sometimes police shoot people after mistaking a wallet or cell phone for a gun, so it stands to reason your odds of being shot by the police go up if you carry an actual gun. It's also possible that if someone gets pissed off at you they might feel they need their own gun if they know you have a gun. Also, if you happen to be in an active shooter situation, that shooter has more incentive to shoot you first.

Which is all very unlikely, but remember you're comparing it to a very unlikely possibility that you might be the good-guy with a gun at a time and place where a bad-guy with a gun decides to start shooting people. Compared to that the very low possibility that you might accidently shoot yourself or get shot by someone who thinks you're a threat is statistically significant.
 
Looking over some statistics on gun deaths, it turns out that almost two-thirds of gun deaths are suicides, so if you exclude those then the odds of being killed by someone else with a gun drop to one in 30,000.

https://everytownresearch.org/gun-violence-by-the-numbers/#YearlyGunMurders

Which suggests to me that even in the United States, you just don't need to carry a gun to be safe from a potential shooter.

I want to be clear, I'm not against guns. I have no problem with people who like to hunt, target shoot, or even people who feel they need them for self defense.

What I don't get is this extreme opposition to any regulation at all. Why not background checks? Why not close gun-show loopholes? Why not prohibit people convicted of domestic violence from owning guns?

It seems like there are measures that can be taken that would reduce tragedy yet still have very little impact on the responsible gun owners, but they're blocked or undermined by a small number of people who are opposed on ideological grounds to doing anything at all.
 
Which suggests to me that even in the United States, you just don't need to carry a gun to be safe from a potential shooter.

You don't until you do.

I want to be clear, I'm not against guns. I have no problem with people who like to hunt, target shoot, or even people who feel they need them for self defense.

Facts not in evidence.

What I don't get is this extreme opposition to any regulation at all. Why not background checks? Why not close gun-show loopholes? Why not prohibit people convicted of domestic violence from owning guns?

A Domestic Violence conviction already is suppose to put the individual on the prohibited list. See the catch phrase "gun show loophole" addressed below.

It seems like there are measures that can be taken that would reduce tragedy yet still have very little impact on the responsible gun owners, but they're blocked or undermined by a small number of people who are opposed on ideological grounds to doing anything at all.

The numbers are not as small as you seem to think they are. Everything proposed is mostly oriented toward the responsible gun owner law abiding citizen because they are by definition the ONLY ones who obey laws. Criminals don't, no matter how many laws are on the books.

You obviously haven't read the thread. Many proposals have been discussed at length throughout the thread. These haven't been addressed quite as much as our leftist friends from across the ocean telling us how stupid we are and how much superior they are to the Colonials.

The so called "gun show loophole" meme is misnamed. In reality it's private sales. Only FFL's have access the the NICS for background checks. Individuals don't. So, even tho' according to polls Universal Background checks are supported nation wide, I suspect most voters don't really know what that means. It's tantamount to the Govt interfering in private commerce between citizens because private sales likely would be prohibited with everything bought and sold through an FFL Dealer. There is an alternative with a License to show an individual has passed an NICS background check, but no legislation has been proposed AFAIK. Instead we get such things as Finestein's ban on AR-15's. It's tantamount to the "black rifle" bans that have been proposed and defeated in the past. As has been pointed out many voters vote based on single issues. One of the largest is gun rights. So, these voters are fed up with the nonsense and will vote any legislator out of office in the pro gun areas of the Country if they perceive them as anti-gun rights. This is mostly in the Heartland, the South and Southwest. Note, anyone who brings up proposed legislation is generally from the left or right coast in liberal districts and it's usually a stupid proposal that won't sell to the voters not in their districts. Consequently, nothing ever gets done.
 
Because I could be shot like a chicken ?

Is Czech society that violent?
Do you carry a gun when you nip to the shop for a pint of milk or go to work?

Couldn't you be 'shot like a chicken' anyway? How would a potential shooter know you were carrying a concealed weapon?
 
Statistically your odds of dying from a gunshot in any given year is about one in ten thousand, and that includes suicides and accidents.

If you honestly feel unsafe with those odds, then you probably don't drive either as that's about 40 times more likely to kill you.

Got some evidence to back up the claim that driving is much more dangerous?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year

US motor vehicle deaths 2016 - 37461.

Are you really claiming US gun deaths are less than 1000 pa?
 
Got some evidence to back up the claim that driving is much more dangerous?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year

US motor vehicle deaths 2016 - 37461.

Are you really claiming US gun deaths are less than 1000 pa?

No, you're right. I got my figures by asking my phone and got a global figure of 1.3 million instead of the national figure. Using your figure one is only about 3 1/2 times more likely to die in a car crash in a year.
 
The so called "gun show loophole" meme is misnamed. In reality it's private sales. Only FFL's have access the the NICS for background checks. Individuals don't. So, even tho' according to polls Universal Background checks are supported nation wide, I suspect most voters don't really know what that means. It's tantamount to the Govt interfering in private commerce between citizens because private sales likely would be prohibited with everything bought and sold through an FFL Dealer.

Once again a slippery slope logical fallacy rears it's ugly head.

Colorado implemented universal background checks after the Aurora Theater shootings. It's a minor inconvenience and a minor expense for those buying from a private seller. It's a major barrier for those who can't pass a background check who want to buy a gun anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom