Mass shooting in small town Texas

I suspect you would not need many new laws if the existing ones were enforced.

I suspect that's true. I also think we could better assess what new laws might be needed if we enforced the current ones better.
 
I suspect that's true. I also think we could better assess what new laws might be needed if we enforced the current ones better.

In this area some new laws are needed to make it easier to enforce existing laws.

For example, the government is currently prohibited from using computers to track firearms purchases. This combined with the lack of registration for private sales makes it absurdly difficult to detect straw buyers and diversion of firearms to criminals.

When a gun is found at a crime scene, the current process works like this. BATF contacts the manufacturer to determine the gun shop that first sold the gun. BATF sends agents to that dealer to search the paper records by hand and find the first sale. BATF then attempts to contact that person. If that first owner sold the gun to a licensed dealer, the process repeats with another hand search of records.

The trail often goes cold at the first private sale because there are no record keeping requirements. Even if the firearm is later sold to a licensed dealer, there is no way for investigators to find that sale.
 
In this area some new laws are needed to make it easier to enforce existing laws.

For example, the government is currently prohibited from using computers to track firearms purchases. This combined with the lack of registration for private sales makes it absurdly difficult to detect straw buyers and diversion of firearms to criminals.

When a gun is found at a crime scene, the current process works like this. BATF contacts the manufacturer to determine the gun shop that first sold the gun. BATF sends agents to that dealer to search the paper records by hand and find the first sale. BATF then attempts to contact that person. If that first owner sold the gun to a licensed dealer, the process repeats with another hand search of records.

The trail often goes cold at the first private sale because there are no record keeping requirements. Even if the firearm is later sold to a licensed dealer, there is no way for investigators to find that sale.

Indeed.
 
If nobody can tell they have a gun then they're not making anyone uncomfortable.

Safety is a separate issue. For safety from guns, you need a lot more.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk

I would feel uncomfortable anywhere, where I can't carry gun and where there is no armed guards to offset that.
 
I knew there were accuracy problems, but I didn't know that it was as bad as all that. The more I learn about this the more I'm inclined to think that improving the NICS record check system accuracy might be one of the few things worth doing about the problem that might be able to avoid a knee-jerk partisan roadblock.

I'm not certain that I would accept Kestrel's account of the situation.
 
I am gobsmacked to hear that from you! :D

I have said it before after I was shown just how many gun control laws there are in the USA. There are thousands, I was gobsmacked!

I often comment on the Texan CCW permit law, because after reading them, it was clear there were not to dissimilar to UK legislation. Add in all the other laws and clearly if they were enforced, there would be less of a problem.
 
....
A lot of gun legislation is "feel good" while really only creating a false sense of security.

I think that the problem is that the laws only cover some people in some states and they leave huge gaps for exploitation. The UK has one prime law to cover the whole country, with some amendments that also cover the whole country. So the crack that is gun problems is completely covered. The USA has different laws by each state and some states cover some of the crack and others cover other bits and some parts are not covered at all.
 
I'm not certain that I would accept Kestrel's account of the situation.

You don't have to take my word for it.

Fed data: Colorado gun background check system among tightest in U.S.

Colorado is one of 13 so-called point-of-contact states where purchasers of handguns and long guns apply through local law enforcement, rather than directly to the FBI’s National Instant Criminal Background Check System. The Colorado Bureau of Investigation handles background checks for Federal Firearm Licensees, running applications through a combination of state and NICS records during the review.

But the system — federal or local — is only as good as the data placed in it. About 58.8 percent of denials that were appealed in Colorado were overturned. Between 2000 and 2009, 31.9 percent of 17,355 denials were appealed.

Point-of-contact states during the period denied 2.1 percent of applicants. Of those who appealed, 43.8 percent were reversed. Among states that use only the FBI’s NICS, 1.4 percent of applications were denied and 30.1 percent of appeals were overturned, according to Justice Department statistics.
 
I would feel uncomfortable anywhere, where I can't carry gun and where there is no armed guards to offset that.
You make me feel uncomfortable saying that because it suggests the exact kind of paranoia that makes me think you shouldn't have a gun.

You being in my proximity with a gun makes me far more uncomfortable than any reassurance that you could make a difference if a shtf event happened.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 
You make me feel uncomfortable saying that because it suggests the exact kind of paranoia that makes me think you shouldn't have a gun.

You being in my proximity with a gun makes me far more uncomfortable than any reassurance that you could make a difference if a shtf event happened.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk

I have a few friends who are armed everywhere they go. I don't feel safer. There are other friends that I would certainly trust with firearms, but oddly, those people don't carry them.

If you think you need them, I really don't want you to have them.
 
Harking back to Kelley, and the inclusion of his in-laws as some of the victims of the shooting:

Gun safety campaign group Every Town For Gun Safety found that in 54% of the 156 mass shootings between 2009 and 2016, the victims were current or former intimate partners or other family members.
More than 50 women in the US every month are killed by former partners, according to data compiled by Everytown, and the presence of a gun in a domestic violence situation makes it five times more likely that a woman will be killed.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41952426
 
I have a few friends who are armed everywhere they go. I don't feel safer. There are other friends that I would certainly trust with firearms, but oddly, those people don't carry them.

If you think you need them, I really don't want you to have them.

A few weeks ago four people in my town were shot. A college girl was celebrating her birthday with a double date. Her "good guy with a gun" boyfriend shot and killed her and the other guy and seriously wounded the other girl before killing himself.

A week earlier the big news was about a murder conviction. A young lady had been shot by her boyfriend when she attempted to break up with him. Another "good guy with a gun" gone wrong.
 
BBC: Fatally flawed: The loopholes that let domestic abusers keep their guns

A domestic violence conviction or restraining order will turn up on a federal background check and prevent a gun sale, but there are no federal laws requiring convicts to surrender guns they already own. Only 30 states authorise or require confiscation in the event of a protection order, according to a recent report by the Educational Fund to Stop Gun Violence, and application of the law varies wildly.

An Everytown study of cases in Rhode Island between 2012 and 2014 showed that only 5% of people issued with a protection order were ordered to surrender their guns. In cases where there was a written record of a firearm threat, that figure rose to just 13%.

I really don't think it is unreasonable to require people with restraining orders against them to surrender their firearms. It also is utterly insane to allow private transfers of firearms without proper record keeping - and to prohibit the ATF from computerising their records.

Admittedly "only" 40% of mass shootings involved shooters with either substance abuse, or threats of violence that had previously been recorded, but even so, that would be a significant dent in the problem.

https://everytownresearch.org/reports/mass-shootings-analysis/

Enforcing current bans would have impacted about a third of mass shootings

But there’s a loophole in the federal system. Federal law only requires background checks for gun sales at licensed dealers—a gap referred to as the unlicensed sale loophole. Nineteen states and Washington, DC have acted to close this dangerous loophole by requiring background checks on all handgun sales.13 There is strong evidence that closing this loophole saves lives. In states that have done so, 47 percent fewer women are shot to death by their intimate partners, 53 percent fewer law enforcement officers are killed with guns, and there is 48 percent less gun trafficking in cities.14
 
There is strong evidence that closing this loophole saves lives. In states that have done so, 47 percent fewer women are shot to death by their intimate partners, 53 percent fewer law enforcement officers are killed with guns, and there is 48 percent less gun trafficking in cities.

I'm in favor of requiring background checks myself, but this factoid might be a little misleading. Do we have data on how those states compared before they ended the private sale exception?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom