Mass shooting in small town Texas

Well, it is more fun to agree. One thing I learned on this forum is that there is no-one prosecuting those who file false forms while trying to buy a gun. If that were prosecuted you would have fewer people testing the system who know they should not be able to buy a gun.

It seems just enforcing that alone would cut back on some issues.

That's something I've addressed many times here. I would also support severe penalties for a prohibited person who attempts the same. The form says you will be prosecuted if you lie, but that rarely happens. I guess the ATF doesn't have enough time...
 
If a tragedy were caused by poor road maintenance wouldn't we call for better road maintenance?

The system failed so it should be fixed. It should be better. It should do what it was intended to do: keep guns away from people who have shown us they can't be trusted with them.

I don't see that as ironic.

The problem is that is impossible to do.

1 - there are too many laws and law makers involved in gun control. For example; there is a ban on automatic weapons in the UK which covers the entire country. No one in the UK can get an automatic weapon. A ban on automatic weapons in New York has zero effect on the rest of the country and a New Yorker intend on a massacre can still go and get such a weapon.

2 - the culture and history of the gun, the 2nd and people defending themselves and their property is a huge block to the universal legislation needed to have effective gun control.

3 - there are already far too many guns, particularly in the wrong hands, to be able to get them restricted to only suitable people.

4 - there is very poor enforcement of existing legislation, so people just routinely break the law.

The USA cannot be fixed so as to restrict gun ownership to only suitable people.
 
Well, it is more fun to agree. One thing I learned on this forum is that there is no-one prosecuting those who file false forms while trying to buy a gun. If that were prosecuted you would have fewer people testing the system who know they should not be able to buy a gun.

It seems just enforcing that alone would cut back on some issues.

But then you wouldn't have that as an excuse not to fix the broken laws.
 
The problem is that is impossible to do.

1 - there are too many laws and law makers involved in gun control. For example; there is a ban on automatic weapons in the UK which covers the entire country. No one in the UK can get an automatic weapon. A ban on automatic weapons in New York has zero effect on the rest of the country and a New Yorker intend on a massacre can still go and get such a weapon.

2 - the culture and history of the gun, the 2nd and people defending themselves and their property is a huge block to the universal legislation needed to have effective gun control.

3 - there are already far too many guns, particularly in the wrong hands, to be able to get them restricted to only suitable people.

4 - there is very poor enforcement of existing legislation, so people just routinely break the law.

The USA cannot be fixed so as to restrict gun ownership to only suitable people.

I think it's an interesting case study in language and its effect on thought.

Here in the USA, we have a document, and in it there is a phrase "the right to bear arms". The existence of that phrase becomes a sort of foundational idea for a lot of people. Never mind whether it is logical for such a right to exist. Never mind whether the people who penned those words two centuries ago meant something different, and at any rate could not have foreseen technological developments which have transformed the nature of "arms" which could be borne. None of that really matters. We have a notion that there exists something called a "right to bear arms", and by gum no one is taking it away, or even restricting it.

I think it's one of those things that Dawkins had in mind with the concept of "meme". It has a life of its own. It lives symbiotically, or perhaps parasitically, inside a host. It can mutate and evolve over time as it creates the conditions to ensure its own survival.
 
I think it's an interesting case study in language and its effect on thought.

Here in the USA, we have a document, and in it there is a phrase "the right to bear arms". The existence of that phrase becomes a sort of foundational idea for a lot of people. Never mind whether it is logical for such a right to exist. Never mind whether the people who penned those words two centuries ago meant something different, and at any rate could not have foreseen technological developments which have transformed the nature of "arms" which could be borne. None of that really matters. We have a notion that there exists something called a "right to bear arms", and by gum no one is taking it away, or even restricting it.

I think it's one of those things that Dawkins had in mind with the concept of "meme". It has a life of its own. It lives symbiotically, or perhaps parasitically, inside a host. It can mutate and evolve over time as it creates the conditions to ensure its own survival.

The UK right to bear arms;

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/aep/WillandMarSess2/1/2/introduction

was, like the US right to arms, written in a time when circumstances, attitudes and the arms themselves were significantly different to how they are now;

"Subjects’ Arms.
That the Subjects which are Protestants may have Arms for their Defence suitable to their Conditions and as allowed by Law."

The difference between the UK and USA is that the UK has allowed the right to be amended over the years as circumstances, attitudes and the arms themselves have changed. The USA wants to keep to initial written right and not amend it, which is ironic, since it is an amendment.
 
That's something I've addressed many times here. I would also support severe penalties for a prohibited person who attempts the same. The form says you will be prosecuted if you lie, but that rarely happens. I guess the ATF doesn't have enough time...

Does anyone know if the feds have ever given any sort of official explanation for this? I'd be interested in hearing their rationale.
 
Does anyone know if the feds have ever given any sort of official explanation for this? I'd be interested in hearing their rationale.

The penalty for lying on form 4473 is perjury. It's a serous crime but not high on the list of priorities for the US justice Department. Especially when you consider that the intent of the background check law was to bar prohibited persons from buying firearms. That goal has already been met.

Next you have to consider reality. The databases used for NICS checks are plagued by errors and omissions. Here in Colorado we have an appeals process for disputing a failed background check. About half of those appeals find that the person should not have failed the background check. The cancelation of a restraining order was never properly entered. A conviction overturned on appeal still appears in the database. A crime in the database was actually committed by another person with the same name.

Pro gun people rant about the law not being enforced while fighting to keep the private party sales loophole wide open. They also fight to keep gun purchases secret from law enforcement by invoking a slippery slope logical fallacy.
 
The difference between the UK and USA is that the UK has allowed the right to be amended over the years as circumstances, attitudes and the arms themselves have changed. The USA wants to keep to initial written right and not amend it, which is ironic, since it is an amendment.
Over the years is has been amended in a way. Imagine paying a $200 tax back in 1934 to own a $10 firearm. Or asking the local sheriff for permission to own certain guns which he can deny for any reason. Just because a right is "enshrined" in a written document doesn't mean someone (like Congress or the police) is going respect it.
 
The databases used for NICS checks are plagued by errors and omissions. Here in Colorado we have an appeals process for disputing a failed background check. About half of those appeals find that the person should not have failed the background check.

I knew there were accuracy problems, but I didn't know that it was as bad as all that. The more I learn about this the more I'm inclined to think that improving the NICS record check system accuracy might be one of the few things worth doing about the problem that might be able to avoid a knee-jerk partisan roadblock.
 
I knew there were accuracy problems, but I didn't know that it was as bad as all that. The more I learn about this the more I'm inclined to think that improving the NICS record check system accuracy might be one of the few things worth doing about the problem that might be able to avoid a knee-jerk partisan roadblock.

But it needs to fail so often, that gives people the ability to claim they just need to enforce the existing laws and we don't need new ones.
 
It's rather an issue of better government control, not more.

True. Also easily mixed up by folks approaching this. Better government oversight does not necessarily mean more government, neither does more government intrusion equal better oversight.
 
That's something I've addressed many times here. I would also support severe penalties for a prohibited person who attempts the same. The form says you will be prosecuted if you lie, but that rarely happens. I guess the ATF doesn't have enough time...

I know it gets repeated a lot here, but this is one of those issues where it seems like actual gun enthusiasts and those who would prefer more gun control can actually agree. This is the common ground where the NRA and the Brady folks should be holding hands: enforce the law. They will both wash their hands afterwards, but make this simple stuff work before you move on to tinkering with other laws.
 
Is there anyone who finds the irony that this travesty was the failure of Government regulations, yet we find on this thread the advocacy of more Government regulations?

The travesty of...armed police officers on our schools?

Which government regulation failure resulted in that?
 
Is the consensus that there is no evidence that gun-free zones serve any purpose?

If I ran a business in which the comfort of my customers was important, I would have such a policy in place. Its purpose would be so that people who feel uncomfortable around guns would feel comfortable at my business.
 
I know it gets repeated a lot here, but this is one of those issues where it seems like actual gun enthusiasts and those who would prefer more gun control can actually agree. This is the common ground where the NRA and the Brady folks should be holding hands: enforce the law. They will both wash their hands afterwards, but make this simple stuff work before you move on to tinkering with other laws.

This.

At least try enforcing existing laws before adding new ones.
 
If I ran a business in which the comfort of my customers was important, I would have such a policy in place. Its purpose would be so that people who feel uncomfortable around guns would feel comfortable at my business.

Problem with that is that you wouldn't know if someone in your store was armed or not if they didn't want you to know. So your claim of safety and comfort is actually false. You are making a promise to your customers that you can't keep.

A lot of gun legislation is "feel good" while really only creating a false sense of security.
 
If I ran a business in which the comfort of my customers was important, I would have such a policy in place. Its purpose would be so that people who feel uncomfortable around guns would feel comfortable at my business.

The gun lobby would rather have you pander to those who are uncomfortable being anywhere without a loaded firearm.
 
Last edited:
Problem with that is that you wouldn't know if someone in your store was armed or not if they didn't want you to know. So your claim of safety and comfort is actually false. You are making a promise to your customers that you can't keep.

A lot of gun legislation is "feel good" while really only creating a false sense of security.

If nobody can tell they have a gun then they're not making anyone uncomfortable.

Safety is a separate issue. For safety from guns, you need a lot more.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom