Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

But who was talking about floors?
Are you an idiot?
no, but apparently you do a remarkable impersonation of one.
Here is the post, in its entirety:
Originally Posted by Augustine
:rolleyes:
Obviously not an engineer....
For your edification, should you actually elect to take advantage of it, most floors are designed for less than 1 psi. PSI is a unit of pressure, PSF is how floor loads are expressed. Typical office floor load is 100 PSF (which is not code-required, but more a function of leasability). Warehouse space may be 250 psf, heavy warehouse 300 psf, or slightly around 2 PSI.

See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them, I find the process boring and strangely repetitive. But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle


... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf

This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started
Augustine was discussing floor loading-which you started, with the "bicycle tire" alfalfa--and you tried to pull a spin out of your hat by quoting strength of materials at him.

Either you truly are mentally deficient, or you are looking for hot buttons--or both.
The odds, however, are on the deficiency
 
Where is the laughing dog when you need him? Oh, I laughed and laughed over this bullheaded response...from someone who apparently does not understand the difference between pressure, uniform load, and stress...and proudly flaunts his ignorance for all to see...

Do tell, are you a member of the American Institute of Steel Construction? What is your member number? Did you enjoy the latest issue of Modern Steel Construction? Perhaps you are a Chartered Engineer? A member of the Institution of Structural Engineers? Steel Construction Institute? What is the British Standard for the design of structural steel using UBs?
Wait till someone keys his car with 20,000 psi from a bic pen. He is challenged with number and facts. A kid loose with google and no functioning logical neurons.

If he could answer a question I would ask him what he thinks the loading would be on WTC floor per square inch. I would hate to see the dolt attempt then to figure the total weight outcome for his number.
 
Last edited:
See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them, I find the process boring and strangely repetitive. But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle

... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf

This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started with with. Stick to bending spoons.
Can you explain what this means and why 100 pounds per square foot of office space is not a good number?

Keep it simple I am just a simple pilot from the swamps of Georgia, please.
 
I'm not trying to build an argument

I don't claim that I have evidence

Gee wiz, a twoofer gets cornered and all of a sudden he wasn't really trying to prove anything. He was just asking questions this whole time!

Happens every time. :D
 
I must admit that, in my view at least, it is very clear where the the general JREF community would be, the same place they are today, going where the real evidence (no youtube videos allowed) takes them.

Yeah I find that doesn't really wash when you read what's said here.
Forget the 911 conspiracy theories - where is the JREF forums list of problems with the official story? It is replete with inconsistencies and half truths and this was obvious from day one. Yet it seems that people claim on here, that there are no problems with it. This is nonsense.
 
Yeah I find that doesn't really wash when you read what's said here.
Forget the 911 conspiracy theories - where is the JREF forums list of problems with the official story? It is replete with inconsistencies and half truths and this was obvious from day one. Yet it seems that people claim on here, that there are no problems with it. This is nonsense.

What are these "inconsistencies and half truths"?
 
Can you explain what this means and why 100 pounds per square foot of office space is not a good number?

Keep it simple I am just a simple pilot from the swamps of Georgia, please.
How 'Bout it scooby? Gonna answer, or dodge around some more?
We are waiting for you...
 
I missed this thread because I have scooby on ignore. He's apparently unaware that in addition to the FEMA/ASCE and NIST reports, Silverstein Properties and the WTC insurers, as adversaries, each commissioned engineering analyses of the tower collapses. These were not government-funded investigations. I don't think I need to tell you what their conclusions were.

scooby is welcome to PM me (pun intended) for a list of experts who worked on these issues and whose conclusions refute the conspiracist claims. I'd post it here but it is very, very long, and I think scooby is just a troll.
 
Actually, I think you're doing nothing of the sort. You're trying to promote a CT, and arguing and insulting anyone who doesn't agree with you -- which, in this forum anyway, is pretty much everyone. Most insulting of all is that you somehow presume to lecture us on how we need to think for ourselves, and make up our own minds, as if we have failed to do so. Ironic too, since it comes from someone who seems to simply parrot statements and claims made by others, statements that have been thoroughly discredited many times on every single point. Doesn't sound much like "thinking for yourself" to me.

Firstly the official story is a conspiracy theory - didn't you know?
So all this 'CT' stuff is nonsense - a cheap tactic.

And again, I've already done the thinking, I did the thinking in 2002 and came to my conclusions within a year of the event. It was several years before the likes of Prof Steve Jones and David Ray Griffin came along and documented the issue in a more formal manner. I was pleased when they turned up and have been following their successes over the past 2 years with some interest. It is from this position, that I strongly recommend other people pay serious attention to their work and consider it carefully. However unlike the majority of the content I see posted here, I would stress that the final understanding is for them to form.

As an aside, the earliest recorded interview that I have collected discussing our 911 problem, was back in October 2003, though I would not quote it as an authoritative source as neither participant holds any academic qualifications - and lets face it, even they're not enough for some. To watch this 'big foot' conspiracy theory burgeon and spread, and conquer a reluctant mainstream media, well, back to meme's again - it's sure got legs hasn't it?
 
I missed this thread because I have scooby on ignore. He's apparently unaware that in addition to the FEMA/ASCE and NIST reports, Silverstein Properties and the WTC insurers, as adversaries, each commissioned engineering analyses of the tower collapses. These were not government-funded investigations. I don't think I need to tell you what their conclusions were.

scooby is welcome to PM me (pun intended) for a list of experts who worked on these issues and whose conclusions refute the conspiracist claims. I'd post it here but it is very, very long, and I think scooby is just a troll.

I attended a presentation by Allyn Kilsheimer where he related the story that his office got a call asking for him to come to NY after the WTC got hit but prior to its collapse. He had done some work in relation to the 1993 bombing so he was familiar with the building and its design. On his way back to his office, the Pentagon was hit. He watched the news footage in his office, and decided to go to the Pentagon because he knew the towers were going to collapse, and he could do more good at the Pentagon.

Also, it's worth noting that Dr. Zdenek Bazant submitted his preliminary paper demonstrating that the failure of one floor in the towers led to total collapse within two days of the attack. That is how quickly experienced engineers recognized that this was an inevitable result of two extreme loading events on a high-rise structure.
 
Last edited:
I attended a presentation by Allyn Kilsheimer where he related the story that his office got a call asking for him to come to NY after the WTC got hit but prior to its collapse. He had done some work in relation to the 1993 bombing so he was familiar with the building and its design. On his way back to his office, the Pentagon was hit. He watched the news footage in his office, and decided to go to the Pentagon because he knew the towers were going to collapse, and he could do more good at the Pentagon.
And he did a helluva job at the Pentagon. FEMA and the other rescue/recovery/stabilization experts sing his praises. Here's a PBS NewsHour interview with him and W. Lee Evey that you may appreciate.
 
Scooby seems to be getting dumber. Is he working with the home-trepaning kit between starting threads?
 
Did you hear the "whoosh"? That was what I actually said going right over your pointy little head. If any of those people want to petition their government representatives to do something, how in the world is my posting on this forum keeping them from doing so? This is a representative democracy, they are free to do so. That list of names is quite impressive. Want to show me where any one of them appears in any of my posts?
The only one I'm mocking is you, loser. YOU. Nobody else. You are not a proxy for them.

And you want to get to the troops? Let's go, small fry. Let's see how much you think you know about military service. Bring it, dude, I love to take down Keyboard Warriors who played some video game and think they know about serving. Wanna compare DD-214's?

I was talking about the Iraqi troops, a conscripted army.
If you're dumb enough to join up and surrender independent thought to the Pentagon, and then wave your dishonourable discharge around on here claiming to be a skeptic and proud, well, I'm not impressed.

And before you get excited I know a DD-214 is not a dishonourable discharge - artistic licence, and frankly boredom with armchair warriors from an Army that hasn't fought in a real war since 1945, that just beats up on weaker countries and brags about it. Bullies basically, and cowards many of them.
 
Where is the laughing dog when you need him? Oh, I laughed and laughed over this bullheaded response...from someone who apparently does not understand the difference between pressure, uniform load, and stress...and proudly flaunts his ignorance for all to see...

Do tell, are you a member of the American Institute of Steel Construction? What is your member number? Did you enjoy the latest issue of Modern Steel Construction? Perhaps you are a Chartered Engineer? A member of the Institution of Structural Engineers? Steel Construction Institute? What is the British Standard for the design of structural steel using UBs?

What are you talking about? Some asshat on here started pontificating that steel specs are not quoted in PSI, and I posted a document from NIST itself which plainly demonstrates that this is not true.

Is it your contention, that the term PSI is not used to describe the strength of steel?
 
Wait till someone keys his car with 20,000 psi from a bic pen. He is challenged with number and facts. A kid loose with google and no functioning logical neurons.

If he could answer a question I would ask him what he thinks the loading would be on WTC floor per square inch. I would hate to see the dolt attempt then to figure the total weight outcome for his number.

What was the loading on the steel support columns - the things holding the floor up? Or is it your contention, that the WTC was a stack of floors holding the steel support beams up? I don't believe this is an accurate way to model the design unless constrained by 'walnut brain'.
 
I may be new (may?) but... it seems that Scooby's accusing everyone else of being ill-mannered ... while he insults everyone else. Regardless..

As you are the one attempting to disprove the NIST report, the burden of proof is on you. It's part of how we consider proof - that the petitioner must prove it happened, first./quote]

But I'm not attempting to disprove the NIST report, it will stand or fall on it's own merits. Whooooo, look it at go. Bye bye.
 
And he did a helluva job at the Pentagon. FEMA and the other rescue/recovery/stabilization experts sing his praises. Here's a PBS NewsHour interview with him and W. Lee Evey that you may appreciate.

Prior to 9/11, he was known as something of a character in the engineering community, and he still is a colorful, salty, no-nonsense, tell-it-like-it-is-and-pardon-my-language MF (probably his own chocie of phrase, seeing as how his hardhat read HMFIC), but for what he did at the Pentagon, he is a hero, but he'll argue with you all day if you try to call him that. He's said he's writing a book, and won't pull any punches in it - that I look forward to! (He also told some stories about getting calls from CTers around the world, and his anger and frustration in dealing with them and explaining some detail that they picked out of a photograph...)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom