Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

But there is plenty of real evidence that I have used to base my conclusions on. That you have come to different conclusions - is fine by me. You have every right to your opinion. Just stay out of tall buildings.
No you have no facts or evidence to support the idiot ideas that you share with 9/11 truth.

The fact you can not present even one fact proves you to be a fact less drone for the 9/11 truth movement. Unable to think for yourself you just talk using the conclusions of idiots in the truth movement of lies.

You are the one talking about lies who is the most disrespectful to those victim of 9/11 because you are tell lies. Lies are your conclusions not based on facts.

You are the problem and you are too challenged in knowledge, experience and research to realize you do not have a single fact to back your conclusions of lies. You are not an expert and you have no expert who have a clue of the reality of 9/11, just nuts and dolts.
 
Last edited:
LOL - I clicked on your 'blog' - my interest lasted less than the collapse of WTC7 - I won't do it again. But I had one laugh, some skeptic you are ...

Politically Correct and Proud of It
March 10th, 2007


"Hello, my name is Dave, I'm politically correct and proud of it...."

So Mr Politically correct and proud of it, which side of the fence would you have been on when the flat earthers were persecuting people like Galileo? And you flounce round on here claiming to be a skeptic - while bragging about your blind obedience to convention on your blog. Hilarious.

Once again Scooby, the flat earthers who persecuted Galileo were the hard core (Catholic) church people who rejected....science. They rejected facts, formulae, empirical observations et al in favour of the Bible (and had their few "scientists" who would write supporting documents). The scientific community largely supported Galileo, continued his work, and arranged to have his writings smuggled out and published.
Now applying this tempate to the current situation (I am loathe to do this as I am a strong believer in looking a historical event its own merits, but your desperation keeps bringing you back to this bad comparison).
Who most closely resembles the Church authorities?
How large was the segment of the church that wanted to prosecute Galileo?
Who had/has the weight of the scientific community on its side?
Who relied/relies on a few unqualified voices to back their views?
Who had/has an actual and fully expanded theory/explanation?
Which sides claim a conspiracy is at work(as in work of the devil or a cabal of unnamed power mongers)?

The trick with these questions is that they are not simple factoids on the net, you would actually have to do some serious reading to understand the history.

The only real comparison of the two events is in the advance of the power of science in society. In the 17th century the loons had a far greater chance at getting their conspiracy theories accepted. Science now exists as a buffer between the halls of power and the loons, be they intelligent designers or 9/11 conspiracists.

I must admit that, in my view at least, it is very clear where the the general JREF community would be, the same place they are today, going where the real evidence (no youtube videos allowed) takes them.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes:
Obviously not an engineer....
For your edification, should you actually elect to take advantage of it, most floors are designed for less than 1 psi. PSI is a unit of pressure, PSF is how floor loads are expressed. Typical office floor load is 100 PSF (which is not code-required, but more a function of leasability). Warehouse space may be 250 psf, heavy warehouse 300 psf, or slightly around 2 PSI.

See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them, I find the process boring and strangely repetitive. But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle


... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf

This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started with with. Stick to bending spoons.
 
...I'm asking people to think for themselves and make their own minds up?

Actually, I think you're doing nothing of the sort. You're trying to promote a CT, and arguing and insulting anyone who doesn't agree with you -- which, in this forum anyway, is pretty much everyone. Most insulting of all is that you somehow presume to lecture us on how we need to think for ourselves, and make up our own minds, as if we have failed to do so. Ironic too, since it comes from someone who seems to simply parrot statements and claims made by others, statements that have been thoroughly discredited many times on every single point. Doesn't sound much like "thinking for yourself" to me.
 
See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them, I find the process boring and strangely repetitive. But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle

... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf

This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started with with. Stick to bending spoons.
Anybody else hear that loud "Whoosh" as another idea went right over the head?
very gently, I'll tell you this one last time.
Do not confuse the strength of steel to the design load factor.
The floors were (are) normally designed for 125-150 PSF. that is dead load per square feet--includes desks, people, chairs, file cabinets, etc.
Steel Yields (begins to bend) when the force applied to it, multiplied by the length of the piece, times the distance from the shear center to the edge, all divided by the area moment of inertia equals or exceeds the strength in PSI.
The formula for that is [latex]sigma=M*C/I[/latex]
any further questions? Go get a basic statics textbook. Welcome to "Ignore"
 
See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them,
The fact that you believe you have to educate experts in their field of expertise is very telling. Your ego heavily clouds your judgment.
I find the process boring and strangely repetitive.
Imagine how it is for skeptics.
But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle


... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf
Thank you very much for proving, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that you have no earthly idea what you're talking about. What Augustine said is absolutely correct, the design load for a floor is 100~150 pounds per square foot. The compressive strength of the steel that supports said floor is 36+ thousand pounds per square inch.

But why does this make sense to every single engineer here, and not to you?

Because we took classes in how to design buildings. We know that a rectangular beam that is 20 feet long and 1 foot wide with a load of 150 pounds per square foot has a total weight of 3000 pounds bearing on it. If the beam is simply supported, that load produces a bending moment of 0.5*20*3000 = 30 foot*kips. If that beam is 0.1 feet thick, the maximum stress on the beam is given by (30 ft*k)*(0.1/2 ft)/(1*(0.1)^3/12) = 18,000 ksf or 125 ksi or 125,000 psi!!!! That load would break that beam.

The point, in case you missed it, is that Augustine was telling you about design loads that take into account the tensile and compressive strength of steel. NCSTAR 1-3 is talking exclusively about steel strengths, not design loads.
This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started with with. Stick to bending spoons.
I'm glad this post is quote captured so that I can continue to point to it when discussing 9/11 with you. Beyond anything, this single post shows your ego, and your complete ignorance on matters of structural engineering. Congratulations.
 
Really, Mr. Big Picture, what hurdles have we put in their place? Do they have to go through us to get to their government representatives? Cool! Didn't know I had that power.
And mocking them? The only one being mocked here is you, so unless you're one of the bereaved, you're full of it.
As usual, you need to do better. You totally missed the point you were so feebly trying to make.

I don't see you or anyone else on here criticising the gaggle of fools who call such people 'twoofers', as if to imply that they have some kind of mental incapacity. Quite the opposite in fact, all I see is grand pontifications and gleeful "Prove its!'" - something only the guilty and their supporters usually take so much pleasure in saying, safe in the knowledge that nobody knows where the body is buried. But I sense from your tone that my point is well taken - you're a louse and you know it.

These are some of the people that are systematically and fastidiously ridiculed by the majority of posters on here, including your good self ...

Family Members
Joanne Barbara, wife of FDNY Asst. Chief of Dept. Gerard Barbara
Gayle Barker, sister of William A. Karnes, WTC
Michele Bergsohn, wife of Alvin Bergsohn, Cantor Fitzgerald
Derrill Bodley, father of Deora Bodley, passenger on Flight 93
Kathryn C. Bowden, sister of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. WTC1, 104th floor
Janet Calia, wife of Dominick Calia, Cantor Fitzgerald, WTC1
Maggie Cashman, wife of William Joseph Cashman, United Flight 93
Lynne Castrianno Galante, sister of Leonard Castrianno, 1WTC, 105th floor
Elza Chapa-McGowan, daughter of Rosemary Chapa, Pentagon
Bruce De Cell, father-in-law of Mark Petrocelli North Tower, 92nd floor
Ralph D'Esposito, father of Michael D'Esposito, WTC, 96th floor
Loisanne Diehl, Surviving Spouse, Michael D. Diehl, WTC2, 90th floor
Adina D. Eisenberg, sister of Eric Eisenberg, WTC
Jonathan M. Fisher, son of Dr. Gerald Paul "Geep" Fisher, Pentagon
Michael J. Fox, brother of Jeffrey L. Fox, Tower 2, 89th floor
Laurel A. Gay, sister of Peter A. Gay, AA Flight 11
Irene Golinsky, wife of Col. Ronald F. Golinski USA RET, Pentagon
Lori, Jerry, and Beatrice Guadagno, sister and parents of Richard Guadagno, Flight 93
Kristen Hall, daughter of fallen firefighter Thomas Kuveikis 9/11
Kurt D. Horning, father of Matthew D. Horning, WTC Tower One, 95th floor
Jennifer W. Hunt, wife of William C. Hunt, Euro Brokers
John Keating, son of Barbara Keating, passenger on AA Flight 11
L. Russell Keene II, father of Russ Keene III, WTC2, 89th floor, KBW
Peter Kousoulis, sister died in WTC
Paul & Barbara Kirwin, parents of Glenn Davis Kirwin, Cantor Fitzgerald 105th floor
Barbara Krukowski-Rastelli, mother of William E. Krukowski, NYC firefighter
Laura and Ira Lassman, parents of Nicholas C. Lassman, died in WTC, Tower One
Johnny Lee, husband of Lorraine Greene
Alicia LeGuillow, mother of Nestor A. Cintron III
Francine Levine, sister of Adam K. Ruhalter, who died on 9/11
Bob McIlvaine, father of Robert McIlvaine, WTC, Merrill Lynch
Mary McWilliams, mother of FF Martin E. McWilliams- Engine 22
Daryl J. Meehan, brother of Colleen Ann Barkow, WTC 1, 105th floor
Elvira P. Murphy, wife of Patrick Murphy, WTC 1
Natalee Pecorelli, sister of Thomas Pecorelli of Flight 11
James L Perry, M.D and Patricia J. Perry, parents of John W. Perry, Esq., NYPD Officer 9/11
David Potorti, brother of James Potorti, North Tower, WTC, Marsh & McLennan
Terry Kay Rockefeller, sister of Laura Rockefeller, North Tower, WTC
Grissel Rodriguez-Valentin, wife of Benito Valentin, WTC1, 94th floor
Alissa Rosenberg-Torres, widow of Luis Eduardo Torres, post-9/11 mother, writer
Elaine Saber, mother of Scott Saber
Julie Scarpitta, mother of Michelle Scarpitta, WTC Building 2, 84th floor
Paula Shapiro, mother of Eric Eisenberg, WTC2
Elizabeth Turner, wife of Simon Turner, lost on 11th September 2001
Adele Welty, mother of Firefighter Timothy Welty, FDNY, Squad 288
Joan W. Winton, mother of David Winton, WTC, South Tower, 89th floor
David Yancey, husband of Vicki Yancey, American Airlines Flight 77
Nissa Youngren, daughter of Robert G. LeBlanc, flight 175

http://www.911truth.org/article.php?story=20041026093059633

I'd say you owe them an explanation and an apology. And that's before we get to the troops, the people of Afghanistan, the people of Iraq, Islam and whats left of the free world. But we won't hold our breaths though eh?
 
Beat 'cha to it by 2 minutes!
Now that he's had the same thing said 2 different ways, think he'll hatch on?
I don't
My magic 8 ball and Ouiji board are telling me something about a snowball's chance in hell, but the reply is hazy.

And to whit, I actually did the math. Doesn't that give me bonus points or something?
 
No you have no facts or evidence to support the idiot ideas that you share with 9/11 truth.

See what I mean, idiots he calls them, tut tut tut ...

Family Members
Joanne Barbara, wife of FDNY Asst. Chief of Dept. Gerard Barbara
Gayle Barker, sister of William A. Karnes, WTC
Michele Bergsohn, wife of Alvin Bergsohn, Cantor Fitzgerald
Derrill Bodley, father of Deora Bodley, passenger on Flight 93
Kathryn C. Bowden, sister of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. WTC1, 104th floor
Janet Calia, wife of Dominick Calia, Cantor Fitzgerald, WTC1
Maggie Cashman, wife of William Joseph Cashman, United Flight 93
Lynne Castrianno Galante, sister of Leonard Castrianno, 1WTC, 105th floor
Elza Chapa-McGowan, daughter of Rosemary Chapa, Pentagon
Bruce De Cell, father-in-law of Mark Petrocelli North Tower, 92nd floor
Ralph D'Esposito, father of Michael D'Esposito, WTC, 96th floor
Loisanne Diehl, Surviving Spouse, Michael D. Diehl, WTC2, 90th floor
Adina D. Eisenberg, sister of Eric Eisenberg, WTC
Jonathan M. Fisher, son of Dr. Gerald Paul "Geep" Fisher, Pentagon
Michael J. Fox, brother of Jeffrey L. Fox, Tower 2, 89th floor
Laurel A. Gay, sister of Peter A. Gay, AA Flight 11
Irene Golinsky, wife of Col. Ronald F. Golinski USA RET, Pentagon
Lori, Jerry, and Beatrice Guadagno, sister and parents of Richard Guadagno, Flight 93
Kristen Hall, daughter of fallen firefighter Thomas Kuveikis 9/11
Kurt D. Horning, father of Matthew D. Horning, WTC Tower One, 95th floor
Jennifer W. Hunt, wife of William C. Hunt, Euro Brokers
John Keating, son of Barbara Keating, passenger on AA Flight 11
L. Russell Keene II, father of Russ Keene III, WTC2, 89th floor, KBW
Peter Kousoulis, sister died in WTC
Paul & Barbara Kirwin, parents of Glenn Davis Kirwin, Cantor Fitzgerald 105th floor
Barbara Krukowski-Rastelli, mother of William E. Krukowski, NYC firefighter
Laura and Ira Lassman, parents of Nicholas C. Lassman, died in WTC, Tower One
Johnny Lee, husband of Lorraine Greene
Alicia LeGuillow, mother of Nestor A. Cintron III
Francine Levine, sister of Adam K. Ruhalter, who died on 9/11
Bob McIlvaine, father of Robert McIlvaine, WTC, Merrill Lynch
Mary McWilliams, mother of FF Martin E. McWilliams- Engine 22
Daryl J. Meehan, brother of Colleen Ann Barkow, WTC 1, 105th floor
Elvira P. Murphy, wife of Patrick Murphy, WTC 1
Natalee Pecorelli, sister of Thomas Pecorelli of Flight 11
James L Perry, M.D and Patricia J. Perry, parents of John W. Perry, Esq., NYPD Officer 9/11
David Potorti, brother of James Potorti, North Tower, WTC, Marsh & McLennan
Terry Kay Rockefeller, sister of Laura Rockefeller, North Tower, WTC
Grissel Rodriguez-Valentin, wife of Benito Valentin, WTC1, 94th floor
Alissa Rosenberg-Torres, widow of Luis Eduardo Torres, post-9/11 mother, writer
Elaine Saber, mother of Scott Saber
Julie Scarpitta, mother of Michelle Scarpitta, WTC Building 2, 84th floor
Paula Shapiro, mother of Eric Eisenberg, WTC2
Elizabeth Turner, wife of Simon Turner, lost on 11th September 2001
Adele Welty, mother of Firefighter Timothy Welty, FDNY, Squad 288
Joan W. Winton, mother of David Winton, WTC, South Tower, 89th floor
David Yancey, husband of Vicki Yancey, American Airlines Flight 77
Nissa Youngren, daughter of Robert G. LeBlanc, flight 175
 
I don't see you or anyone else on here criticising the gaggle of fools who call such people 'twoofers', as if to imply that they have some kind of mental incapacity. Quite the opposite in fact, all I see is grand pontifications and gleeful "Prove its!'" - something only the guilty and their supporters usually take so much pleasure in saying, safe in the knowledge that nobody knows where the body is buried. But I sense from your tone that my point is well taken - you're a louse and you know it.

These are some of the people that are systematically and fastidiously ridiculed by the majority of posters on here, including your good self ...

Family Members
Joanne Barbara, wife of FDNY Asst. Chief of Dept. Gerard Barbara
Gayle Barker, sister of William A. Karnes, WTC
Michele Bergsohn, wife of Alvin Bergsohn, Cantor Fitzgerald
Derrill Bodley, father of Deora Bodley, passenger on Flight 93
Kathryn C. Bowden, sister of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. WTC1, 104th floor
Janet Calia, wife of Dominick Calia, Cantor Fitzgerald, WTC1
Maggie Cashman, wife of William Joseph Cashman, United Flight 93
Lynne Castrianno Galante, sister of Leonard Castrianno, 1WTC, 105th floor
Elza Chapa-McGowan, daughter of Rosemary Chapa, Pentagon
Bruce De Cell, father-in-law of Mark Petrocelli North Tower, 92nd floor
Ralph D'Esposito, father of Michael D'Esposito, WTC, 96th floor
Loisanne Diehl, Surviving Spouse, Michael D. Diehl, WTC2, 90th floor
Adina D. Eisenberg, sister of Eric Eisenberg, WTC
Jonathan M. Fisher, son of Dr. Gerald Paul "Geep" Fisher, Pentagon
Michael J. Fox, brother of Jeffrey L. Fox, Tower 2, 89th floor
Laurel A. Gay, sister of Peter A. Gay, AA Flight 11
Irene Golinsky, wife of Col. Ronald F. Golinski USA RET, Pentagon
Lori, Jerry, and Beatrice Guadagno, sister and parents of Richard Guadagno, Flight 93
Kristen Hall, daughter of fallen firefighter Thomas Kuveikis 9/11
Kurt D. Horning, father of Matthew D. Horning, WTC Tower One, 95th floor
Jennifer W. Hunt, wife of William C. Hunt, Euro Brokers
John Keating, son of Barbara Keating, passenger on AA Flight 11
L. Russell Keene II, father of Russ Keene III, WTC2, 89th floor, KBW
Peter Kousoulis, sister died in WTC
Paul & Barbara Kirwin, parents of Glenn Davis Kirwin, Cantor Fitzgerald 105th floor
Barbara Krukowski-Rastelli, mother of William E. Krukowski, NYC firefighter
Laura and Ira Lassman, parents of Nicholas C. Lassman, died in WTC, Tower One
Johnny Lee, husband of Lorraine Greene
Alicia LeGuillow, mother of Nestor A. Cintron III
Francine Levine, sister of Adam K. Ruhalter, who died on 9/11
Bob McIlvaine, father of Robert McIlvaine, WTC, Merrill Lynch
Mary McWilliams, mother of FF Martin E. McWilliams- Engine 22
Daryl J. Meehan, brother of Colleen Ann Barkow, WTC 1, 105th floor
Elvira P. Murphy, wife of Patrick Murphy, WTC 1
Natalee Pecorelli, sister of Thomas Pecorelli of Flight 11
James L Perry, M.D and Patricia J. Perry, parents of John W. Perry, Esq., NYPD Officer 9/11
David Potorti, brother of James Potorti, North Tower, WTC, Marsh & McLennan
Terry Kay Rockefeller, sister of Laura Rockefeller, North Tower, WTC
Grissel Rodriguez-Valentin, wife of Benito Valentin, WTC1, 94th floor
Alissa Rosenberg-Torres, widow of Luis Eduardo Torres, post-9/11 mother, writer
Elaine Saber, mother of Scott Saber
Julie Scarpitta, mother of Michelle Scarpitta, WTC Building 2, 84th floor
Paula Shapiro, mother of Eric Eisenberg, WTC2
Elizabeth Turner, wife of Simon Turner, lost on 11th September 2001
Adele Welty, mother of Firefighter Timothy Welty, FDNY, Squad 288
Joan W. Winton, mother of David Winton, WTC, South Tower, 89th floor
David Yancey, husband of Vicki Yancey, American Airlines Flight 77
Nissa Youngren, daughter of Robert G. LeBlanc, flight 175

http://www.911truth.org/article.php?story=20041026093059633

I'd say you owe them an explanation and an apology. And that's before we get to the troops, the people of Afghanistan, the people of Iraq, Islam and whats left of the free world. But we won't hold our breaths though eh?
Did you hear the "whoosh"? That was what I actually said going right over your pointy little head. If any of those people want to petition their government representatives to do something, how in the world is my posting on this forum keeping them from doing so? This is a representative democracy, they are free to do so. That list of names is quite impressive. Want to show me where any one of them appears in any of my posts?
The only one I'm mocking is you, loser. YOU. Nobody else. You are not a proxy for them.

And you want to get to the troops? Let's go, small fry. Let's see how much you think you know about military service. Bring it, dude, I love to take down Keyboard Warriors who played some video game and think they know about serving. Wanna compare DD-214's?
 
My magic 8 ball and Ouiji board are telling me something about a snowball's chance in hell, but the reply is hazy.

And to whit, I actually did the math. Doesn't that give me bonus points or something?
[ct-mensa mode]Sure, you did some math--but where did you get the numbers from? Huh? where did they come from? pulled 'em outta yer hat, huh? whattareya trying to hide, using numbers like that?[/ct mensa mode]:covereyes
I give full points for the math--but whoinheck would build a beam 12 X 1.2 20 feet long? Deduction of 1/2 point for excessive skinnyness in your cross sectian.
 
See this is why I don't get into technical discussions with 'experts' on the web, it's not my job to educate them, I find the process boring and strangely repetitive. But to illustrate the ugly nature of the hog that you are washing for us, I'll be brutal ...

Contemporaneous Structural Steel Specifications
William E. Luecke
Thomas A. Siewert
Frank W.Gayle

... Pittsburgh-Des Moines (PDM) fabricated the perimeter bifurcation columns from the 4th to the 9th floors, 6,800 tons (Feld 1971). The bifurcation columns are also referred to as the "tuning forks" or the trees. Civil Engineering (1970) reported that Lukens Steel "supplied seven basic grades of carbon and alloy plate steels for use in the welded trees... steels meet yield strength requirements from 36,000 to 65,000 min psi"

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-3A.pdf

This is the problem with anonymous internet posters in forums, you have all manner of people claiming to be experts, who talk the talk - somebody reading your posts might have been mistaken in thinking that they have learned something from you, when in fact they would emerge from your post knowing less than what they started with with. Stick to bending spoons.

Where is the laughing dog when you need him? Oh, I laughed and laughed over this bullheaded response...from someone who apparently does not understand the difference between pressure, uniform load, and stress...and proudly flaunts his ignorance for all to see...

Do tell, are you a member of the American Institute of Steel Construction? What is your member number? Did you enjoy the latest issue of Modern Steel Construction? Perhaps you are a Chartered Engineer? A member of the Institution of Structural Engineers? Steel Construction Institute? What is the British Standard for the design of structural steel using UBs?
 
Scooby said:
I don't see you or anyone else on here criticising the gaggle of fools who call such people 'twoofers', as if to imply that they have some kind of mental incapacity. Quite the opposite in fact, all I see is grand pontifications and gleeful "Prove its!'" - something only the guilty and their supporters usually take so much pleasure in saying, safe in the knowledge that nobody knows where the body is buried. But I sense from your tone that my point is well taken - you're a louse and you know it.

I may be new (may?) but... it seems that Scooby's accusing everyone else of being ill-mannered ... while he insults everyone else. Regardless..

As you are the one attempting to disprove the NIST report, the burden of proof is on you. It's part of how we consider proof - that the petitioner must prove it happened, first.

Innocent, until proven guilty.

Scooby said:

That's cool. So why dont' they just sign a petition, form a group or something? Do we have some hidden psychic power that would grant us the million dollar prize? I'm not going to stop them if they want to - also, we aren't mocking them.

We're mocking you for your apparent inability to absorb the point - that you are misunderstanding how loads are handled.
 
Last edited:
Where is the laughing dog when you need him? Oh, I laughed and laughed over this bullheaded response...from someone who apparently does not understand the difference between pressure, uniform load, and stress...and proudly flaunts his ignorance for all to see...
colon dl colon
:dl:
 
[ct-mensa mode]Sure, you did some math--but where did you get the numbers from? Huh? where did they come from? pulled 'em outta yer hat, huh? whattareya trying to hide, using numbers like that?[/ct mensa mode]:covereyes
I give full points for the math--but whoinheck would build a beam 12 X 1.2 20 feet long? Deduction of 1/2 point for excessive skinnyness in your cross sectian.

I chose a skinny beam to show how 150 psf can turn into [some big number] psi. So sue me for trying to save a little hypothetical steel! For Pete's sake, I'm a concrete guy! 0.1 inches of steel sounds like a lot to me!
 
I chose a skinny beam to show how 150 psf can turn into [some big number] psi. So sue me for trying to save a little hypothetical steel! For Pete's sake, I'm a concrete guy! 0.1 inches of steel sounds like a lot to me!
'S ok-I have worked in area where 2" thick is considered "Sheet metal", and now am trying to reduce from .060" thick to .050" to save weight in a 2 square inch bracket. Both ends of the spectrum, indeed...
All I know about concrete is that yod'd best be ready when the truck shows up, have plenty of wheel barrows and helpers, and it will dry your hands out so fast they crack.
 
Anybody else hear that loud "Whoosh" as another idea went right over the head?
very gently, I'll tell you this one last time.
Do not confuse the strength of steel to the design load factor.
The floors were (are) normally designed for 125-150 PSF. that is dead load per square feet--includes desks, people, chairs, file cabinets, etc.
Steel Yields (begins to bend) when the force applied to it, multiplied by the length of the piece, times the distance from the shear center to the edge, all divided by the area moment of inertia equals or exceeds the strength in PSI.
The formula for that is
latex.php

any further questions? Go get a basic statics textbook. Welcome to "Ignore"

But who was talking about floors?
Are you an idiot?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom