Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

So, let me get this straight. Your bike tires take 60 psi, so the WTC didn't collapse ?


Things like this make me sympathise with the mice at the end of Hitchhikers.

ARTHUR: You can't have my brain.
MOUSE: Why not.
ARTHUR: I'm using it!
MOUSE: Hardly!

-Gumboot
 
Things like this make me sympathise with the mice at the end of Hitchhikers.

ARTHUR: You can't have my brain.
MOUSE: Why not.
ARTHUR: I'm using it!
MOUSE: Hardly!

-Gumboot
Actually, I hearken to the old saw:
"Never argue with an idiot. He'll drag you down to his level and beat you with experience"
 
I would argue they're not "regular" car tyres. 30-34 is standard for normal car tyres, but there always are different types that have variations.

What kind of Saturn do you drive, and what sort of VW does your daughter have?
Not that this is any more than an anecdote, but in my experience "regular" tires have a wider range of operation than they used to.

I own a light truck and a sports car. The sports car wears Y-rated rubber that will take up to 46 PSI, and I adjust it between 32 and about 38 to dial in handling characteristics. This is somewhat unusual rubber.

The light truck wears very basic mud 'n snows. The tires will take 44 PSI, recommend 40 in a typical application, but the truck manufacturer suggests 28 PSI, and that's what it gets. I was surprised at this apparent mismatch but it is real, and I've verified that the truck is happiest there.

I believe tire pressures have increased over the last decade due to a push for higher fuel efficiency, but that's pure speculation on my part.
 
I believe tire pressures have increased over the last decade due to a push for higher fuel efficiency, but that's pure speculation on my part.

That's what the the Air lobby wants you to think. Glad to see you're resisting their pressure.
 
Not that this is any more than an anecdote, but in my experience "regular" tires have a wider range of operation than they used to.

I own a light truck and a sports car. The sports car wears Y-rated rubber that will take up to 46 PSI, and I adjust it between 32 and about 38 to dial in handling characteristics. This is somewhat unusual rubber.

The light truck wears very basic mud 'n snows. The tires will take 44 PSI, recommend 40 in a typical application, but the truck manufacturer suggests 28 PSI, and that's what it gets. I was surprised at this apparent mismatch but it is real, and I've verified that the truck is happiest there.

I believe tire pressures have increased over the last decade due to a push for higher fuel efficiency, but that's pure speculation on my part.
You can increase the pressure with the lower-profile tires--less shear load on the rim. My experience has been that rim failure is more disasterous than tire failure, since rim failure spews out a lot of sharp, pointy, hard shrapnel.
The automakers are tuning the tire/suspension system to handle higher pressures for better mileage. Obviously, lower rolling friction means better efficiency.
The tire and suspension are 2 springs in series, with the top spring having a dashpot in parallel with it--the shock absorber. In that system, like capacitors in series, total stiffness is less than the lowest spring rate, so the suspension has to soften up to bring the total down--the tire used to be the most compliant--and probably still is, but the stiffness of the tire is much higher nowdays--especially with those really low profile tires...
Tire damping is inherent in the material--typically about 20-30% of critical, but that changes with the stiffer material--generally decreasing?I gueess we could make a rolling damper, but I Don't want to think about that one.
 
Truthseeker1234 said:
And how about the structural drawings for the twin towers? If those were made public, some other folks could have a crack at creating a computer model on Ansys software. Perhaps this time we could let it run past the point of "collapse initiation", you know, just to see what happens.

R.Mackey said:
I honestly don't know what you expect. You're upset because you didn't get a personal copy of a grid file, one that you couldn't comprehend and certainly couldn't use if you got it, is that it?

If you want to invalidate the NIST model, you don't do it by getting their files and rerunning them. You'll just get the same answers without understanding a thing. What you do is either look at the results (something you haven't done) or you build your own model and see how it compares. Purdue and two different insurance companies performed the latter step independently and all got consistent results. I've run some extremely simplified calculations, and they check too.

What have you done?

CTers like to pretend that NIST is the only model, and if they only had the data that is being kept from them by the evil conspiracy, they could produce a model that would refute the whole collapse "story".

The pictures below are taken from a paper presented at the Proceedings of the International Conference on the Protection of Structures in Nov 2002 by Lu XinZheng of the Department of Civil Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing.

The argument that NIST is the only model or that there have been no independent models is pure charade.
 

Attachments

  • image027.gif
    image027.gif
    40.6 KB · Views: 2
  • image036.JPG
    image036.JPG
    21 KB · Views: 4
CTers like to pretend that NIST is the only model, and if they only had the data that is being kept from them by the evil conspiracy, they could produce a model that would refute the whole collapse "story".

<giggle>, they couldn't even model the collapse of a pile of china dishes.
 
I would argue they're not "regular" car tyres. 30-34 is standard for normal car tyres, but there always are different types that have variations.

What kind of Saturn do you drive, and what sort of VW does your daughter have?

-Gumboot
My wife's minivan has tire pressure 38 psi. My next door neighbor has a Toyota Avalon: tire pressure 36 psi.

You lowballed it, gumboot. No big deal, it was a nitpick. ;)

DR
 
Iraq had a Navy?
Did, and does (albeit rather small, mostly patrol boats) but since I was in the US Navy, your question is irrelevant.

Then again, you are only relevant insofar as how much good people's air you are using up, oxygen thief.

DR
 
What have you done? [to attempt to validate NIST's work]

I have written letters to the NY/NJ port authority, and to NIST, requesting copies of the structural drawings of the twin towers, and asking how much it would cost. I've recieved no reply at all.

Sorry, Mackey, NIST's shell game does not cut it for science. It would be as if Einstein announced, "I have derived a formula that shows an equivalence between mass and energy". When asked what the formula was, Einstein replied, "I'm not going to tell you. I've shown it to some guys at Dewey, Cheetum and Howe, and they say it's cool. They won't show you the formula either, but trust us, it's cool."

No.

NIST ignored crucial evidence, assumed the conclusion, and does has not allowed independent verification.

You're right, the idea is for independent researchers to build a correct model of a twin tower with AnSys. I think NIST should just release their model to the public, since:

A] The law says that what they produce is public domain and
B] It is in the interest of science and
C] We paid for it

But really, the structural docs for the twin towers should be released.

The reason this has not happened is clear. Once someone builds a model, it will not explode into dust, no matter how much damage, sagging, creep, and anything else is applied. You know it. And I know it.
 
scooby, truthseeker...

How much of the NIST report have you read?

Oh, I slogged through almost all of it for two weeks, a year ago. Huge amounts on the plane crash, which is irrelevant, because something broke perimeter columns, and something started fires. It doesn't make much difference what.


Huge amounts on the fires. Their computer model totally disagrees with any of their actual real world temperature data.

But it doesn't matter.

Assume the hottest fires. Assume fires that melt steel. Assume thermite. Assume as many core columns servered as you want.

It doesn't matter.

Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.
 
Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.
Why do you think that only you can see these things, and no one else can?
 
Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.


So what did TS ?

Even your fellow twoofers don't agree with you.
 
Assume the hottest fires. Assume fires that melt steel. Assume thermite. Assume as many core columns servered as you want.

It doesn't matter.

Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.

So of what use would the entire set of WTC blueprints be to you? You hope to find a discrepancy in a bar joist dampener connection perhaps? A problem with the verticle bolt connections between perimeter column connections? You do not even have the professional credentials to interpret them. Of course they are ignoring you. You are clearly a nutter!
 
Why do you think that only you can see these things, and no one else can?

This confuses me too. The strangely burned cars, the round holes, all that other stuff are things that ONLY TROOTHYDUDE CAN SEE.

He is basing his entire theory on these things as if the whole world is with him, as if these strange and exotic anomalies are so clear and so obvious that anybody with eyes can see them, except for us evil debunkers and a world full of corrupt experts.

Troothydude you're a crackpot, nothing more, nothing less. You are the internet equal of some wild-eyed bearded homeless guy ranting on a street corner.
 
Last edited:
I have written letters to the NY/NJ port authority, and to NIST, requesting copies of the structural drawings of the twin towers, and asking how much it would cost. I've recieved no reply at all.

And THAT's the whole of your research ? Amazing. What boldness.

Sorry, Mackey, NIST's shell game does not cut it for science. It would be as if Einstein announced, "I have derived a formula that shows an equivalence between mass and energy". When asked what the formula was, Einstein replied, "I'm not going to tell you. I've shown it to some guys at Dewey, Cheetum and Howe, and they say it's cool. They won't show you the formula either, but trust us, it's cool."

You're assuming, here, that no independent body of scientists and experts replicated their results. I do believe Mack corrected you on this.

NIST ignored crucial evidence, assumed the conclusion, and does has not allowed independent verification.

1) Which crucial evidence are we talking about, here ? The type of evidence that only YOU can see in PICTURES ?

2) Assumed their conclusion ? About the collapse ? Then why make a 10,000 page report.

But really, the structural docs for the twin towers should be released.

I agree, if only to shut Christophera up.

The reason this has not happened is clear.

Now, who's assuming his conclusion ?

Once someone builds a model, it will not explode into dust.

Of course not, since we showed that's not what happened.

Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.

All of which didn't happen except in your twisted mind. You've been schooled on all these points before. Do you have a memory disorder ?
 
Assume the hottest fires. Assume fires that melt steel. Assume thermite. Assume as many core columns servered as you want.

It doesn't matter.

Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.



The fizzies? Dude, WTF have you been smoking?

-Gumboot
 
Oh, I slogged through almost all of it for two weeks, a year ago. Huge amounts on the plane crash, which is irrelevant, because something broke perimeter columns, and something started fires. It doesn't make much difference what.


Huge amounts on the fires. Their computer model totally disagrees with any of their actual real world temperature data.

But it doesn't matter.

Assume the hottest fires. Assume fires that melt steel. Assume thermite. Assume as many core columns servered as you want.

It doesn't matter.

Assume all 287 columns disappeard at the 96th floor instantly, allowing the top to just drop. There is no way that even this absurd situation could produce the disintegration, the strangely toasted cars, the round holes, the disappearance of WTC4 south wing, the hollowing out of WTC6, the fizzies, etc. Just no way.

I stopped reading after this TS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom