Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

I hear Habeas Corpus is about to die a death btw, it's all hanging on one Judge. 800 years of progress erased just like that. And you claim to be a skeptic and a man of honour who swore an oath. Wow.

Or "Quick! Change the subject! Maybe everyone will forget I know nothing about structural engineering!"
 
Are you talking about this asshat?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2428136&postcount=55
...the one who converted a vertical uniform floor loading into PSI, compared it to tire pressure, and then claimed it was column compressive stress? That asshat?

No this one, who's response to the question ...

"What was the loading on the steel supports at the floors that collapsed in PSI? What was the loading that they were designed to support?"

... was this irrelevance, it seems he can't answer the question ...

:rolleyes:
Obviously not an engineer....
For your edification, should you actually elect to take advantage of it, most floors are designed for less than 1 psi. PSI is a unit of pressure, PSF is how floor loads are expressed. Typical office floor load is 100 PSF (which is not code-required, but more a function of leasability). Warehouse space may be 250 psf, heavy warehouse 300 psf, or slightly around 2 PSI.

Is it your contention, that the weight of the world trade center, rested on its floors?

Is it also your contention that PSF (pounds per square foot) is not a unit of pressure as implied in your post?

And any luck with NIST's explanation of how the buildings collapsed yet?

I'm really interested in what happened during the collapse - why the steel failed on the lower floors. I think it is important to understand this mechanism, as so many buildings around the world are now suddenly at risk due to a flawed design concept and unsafe to work in - so much for engineering eh? I'd ask for my money back. If I lost a relative in the attack, I'd certainly be hauling UL in court for falsifying the WTC steel testing. They claimed the floor truss assemblies would stand for 2 hours in an inferno without failing didn't they? It was certainly something like that - so much for american engineering and the people who certify it.
You an engineer?

If so could you post your CV or something so we know who we're talking to - and your current employment or any other references you may have. Do you build skyscrapers for instance?

If it's up to scratch, you might want to join these guys ... www.ae911truth.org

They've got about a dozen or so architects and a couple of engineers so far but they're recruiting. If you have any engineering questions that you'd like an engineer to answer - I'll be happy to pass them on, or you could ask them and post the response?

I'm sure their numbers can only grow, as any engineer is faced with a simple choice really - either they assert the official story is true, and that the collapse was a catastrophic engineering disaster, thus demonstrating that their assertions are worthless - or they defend their discipline.
 
Last edited:
So on what scientific basis does this theory of a fire induced total collapse rest exactly? Is there anything published in academia that describes the mechanism by which it occurred,
"Progressive collapse is a failure mode of great concern for tall buildings, and is also typical of building demolitions. The most infamous paradigm is the collapse of World Trade Center towers. After reviewing the mechanics of their collapse, the motion during the crushing of one floor (or group of floors) and its energetics are analyzed, and a dynamic one-dimensional continuum model of progressive collapse is developed. Rather than using classical homogenization, it is found more effective to characterize the continuum by an energetically equivalent snap-through. The collapse, in which two phases-crush-down followed by crush-up-must be distinguished, is described in each phase by a nonlinear second-order differential equation for the propagation of the crushing front of a compacted block of accreting mass. Expressions for consistent energy potentials are formulated and an exact analytical solution of a special case is given. It is shown that progressive collapse will be triggered if the total (internal) energy loss during the crushing of one story (equal to the energy dissipated by the complete crushing and compaction of one story, minus the loss of gravity potential during the crushing of that story) exceeds the kinetic energy impacted to that story. Regardless of the load capacity of the columns, there is no way to deny the inevitability of progressive collapse driven by gravity alone if this criterion is satisfied (for the World Trade Center it is, with an order-of-magnitude margin). The parameters are the compaction ratio of a crushed story, the fracture of mass ejected outside the tower perimeter, and the energy dissipation per unit height. The last is the most important, yet the hardest to predict theoretically. Using inverse analysis, one could identify these parameters from a precise record of the motion of floors of a collapsing building. Due to a shroud of dust and smoke, the videos of WTC are useless here. It is proposed to obtain such records by monitoring the precise time history of displacements in different modes of building demolitions. The monitoring could be accomplished by real-time telemetry from sacrifcial accelerometers, or by high-speed optical camera. The resulting information on energy absorption capability would be valuable for the rating of various structural systems and for inferring their collapse mode under extreme fire, internal explosion, external blast, impact or other kinds of terrorist attack, as well as earthquake and foundation movements."
http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:bNYC5tInFHoJ:www.civil.northwe...ProgressiveCollapseWTC-6-23-2006.pdf

other than the work of the Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice?
They haven't published anything.
 
"Progressive collapse is a failure mode of great concern for tall buildings, and is also typical of building demolitions. The most infamous paradigm is the collapse of World Trade Center towers. After reviewing the mechanics of their collapse, the motion during the crushing of one floor (or group of floors) and its energetics are analyzed, and a dynamic one-dimensional continuum model of progressive collapse is developed. Rather than using classical homogenization, it is found more effective to characterize the continuum by an energetically equivalent snap-through. The collapse, in which two phases-crush-down followed by crush-up-must be distinguished, is described in each phase by a nonlinear second-order differential equation for the propagation of the crushing front of a compacted block of accreting mass. Expressions for consistent energy potentials are formulated and an exact analytical solution of a special case is given. It is shown that progressive collapse will be triggered if the total (internal) energy loss during the crushing of one story (equal to the energy dissipated by the complete crushing and compaction of one story, minus the loss of gravity potential during the crushing of that story) exceeds the kinetic energy impacted to that story. Regardless of the load capacity of the columns, there is no way to deny the inevitability of progressive collapse driven by gravity alone if this criterion is satisfied (for the World Trade Center it is, with an order-of-magnitude margin). The parameters are the compaction ratio of a crushed story, the fracture of mass ejected outside the tower perimeter, and the energy dissipation per unit height. The last is the most important, yet the hardest to predict theoretically. Using inverse analysis, one could identify these parameters from a precise record of the motion of floors of a collapsing building. Due to a shroud of dust and smoke, the videos of WTC are useless here. It is proposed to obtain such records by monitoring the precise time history of displacements in different modes of building demolitions. The monitoring could be accomplished by real-time telemetry from sacrifcial accelerometers, or by high-speed optical camera. The resulting information on energy absorption capability would be valuable for the rating of various structural systems and for inferring their collapse mode under extreme fire, internal explosion, external blast, impact or other kinds of terrorist attack, as well as earthquake and foundation movements."
http://66.102.9.104/search?q=cache:bNYC5tInFHoJ:www.civil.northwe...ProgressiveCollapseWTC-6-23-2006.pdf


They haven't published anything.

They produce PDF's just like this guy.

Who is he anyway - is this an official explanation?
I'll give it a read anyway, it looks interesting.
Is it from FEMA or NIST - the people asked to produce an explanation?
 
Time for Perry to show up and have the vapors about somebody accusing the Democrats of covering up a terrorist attack on American soil. And in this case I certainly agree with him; the idea that OKC was organized by the government is nutty.
Perry has been banned for being a spamming fool. A pity he could not keep his focus, some of his CT posts have been fun.

DR
 
"The controlled demolition hypothesis has been unambiguously rejected by manistream investigators and by structural engineers.[9] Zdeněk P. Bažant, who was among the first to offer an explanation of the collapses, mentioned the controlled demolition hypothesis in passing in a 2006 paper, co-authored with Mathieu Verdure. Affirming the mainstream consensus as presented in the NIST report, Bažant and Verdure note "a few outsiders claiming a conspiracy with planted explosives" as an exception. They trace "strange ideas" about, among other things, controlled demolition, to a "mistaken impression" that safety margins in design would make the collapses impossible. While strictly speaking superfluous, one of the effects of a more detailed modeling of the progressive collapse, they say, could be to "dispel the myth of planted explosives".[9] To date, however, no such detailed model has been put forward."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contro...is_for_the_collapse_of_the_World_Trade_Center

Thats interesting, even they agree that there has been no detailed model of the collapse and that this is needed to "dispel the myth of planted explosives"

This implies that their PDF does not dispel any myths, and in their own words too. They're probably being professional and referring to the fact that they weren't involved in the investigation into what happened and wouldn't have had access to the data required to produce an accurate model, or access to any steel samples for testing etc.

I'll still give it a thorough read though, I'm interested in exactly how they have failed to dispel any 'myths of planted explosives'.
 
:dl: oh, scooby, I feel sorry for the village that has lost you...ok, point by point...

Is it your contention, that the weight of the world trade center, rested on its floors?
No

Is it also your contention that PSF (pounds per square foot) is not a unit of pressure as implied in your post?
As implied in my post? Reading comprehension, my good man, work on it. No.

And any luck with NIST's explanation of how the buildings collapsed yet?
Yes, NIST did a rather fine job. The report is very impressive, and a great effort. Have you had any luck reading it and understanding it?

I'm really interested in what happened during the collapse - why the steel failed on the lower floors. I think it is important to understand this mechanism, as so many buildings around the world are now suddenly at risk due to a flawed design concept and unsafe to work in - so much for engineering eh? I'd ask for my money back. If I lost a relative in the attack, I'd certainly be hauling UL in court for falsifying the WTC steel testing. They claimed the floor truss assemblies would stand for 2 hours in an inferno without failing didn't they? It was certainly something like that - so much for american engineering and the people who certify it.

Sigh...buildings around the world are only at risk IF there is an airplane flown into them which spills burning fuel throughout the floors...which they were ALWAYS at risk IF that happened. I imagine that would be a flawed design concept if your belief is that every building should be designed to withstand the deliberate impact and extensive fire from terrorists flying planes into them, as uncommon as that is. In that sense, yes, every skyscraper in the world is "unsafe" because NONE of them have been designed for that.
Sigh...UL did not falsify the WTC steel testing. UL certifies "assemblies" - STANDARD assemblies, not SPECIFIC ones. In other words, they specify that if you apply this much fireproofing to this much steel deck, you have such and such fire rating (which, by the way, does not equate to "standing 2 hours in an inferno", but we can leave that for later, don't want to tax your brain too much). They DO NOT say we went to this building and certified its exact assembly for so many hours. AND they most definitely do not certify ANY ASSEMBLY as being able to withstand the impact of a passenger airplane flying into the floor!!:rolleyes:

You an engineer?

If so could you post your CV or something so we know who we're talking to - and your current employment or any other references you may have. Do you build skyscrapers for instance?
Structural engineer. Licensed PE and SE. Member, ASCE, ACI, AISC, SAME. Blast experience. Have advised States Attorney in construction litigation cases. Nothing in the height range of "skyscrapers", more in the realm of mid- to high-rise.

If it's up to scratch, you might want to join these guys ... www.ae911truth.org

They've got about a dozen or so architects and a couple of engineers so far but they're recruiting. If you have any engineering questions that you'd like an engineer to answer - I'll be happy to pass them on, or you could ask them and post the response?
:dl: oh, I practically cried laughing...
Oh, I am absolutely confident that that group will ONLY attract the best and brightest, the CAPTAINS of the industry, with professional affiliations and publications out the wazoo...highly successful, accomplished, and celebrated engineers and architects...:dl:

Thanks for the laughs, scooby!!
 
They produce PDF's just like this guy.
No, they get their papers published in scientific journals.
Who is he anyway - is this an official explanation?
I'll give it a read anyway, it looks interesting.
Is it from FEMA or NIST - the people asked to produce an explanation?
No.

Bazant is a civil engineer at Northwestern University.[1]
 
Last edited:
No this one, who's response to the question ...

"What was the loading on the steel supports at the floors that collapsed in PSI? What was the loading that they were designed to support?"

... was this irrelevance, it seems he can't answer the question ...
It's unfortunate that the way you view yourself and the way the world views you are such disparate quantities. You're trying to save face here by claiming that the argument centered around something it didn't. We're not stupid, and we can see through the BS. If you want to continue making an issue of this, be my guest, but you're only going to appear weaker because of it.
Is it your contention, that the weight of the world trade center, rested on its floors?
And the floors rested upon trusses, which linked to columns, which carried the load to the ground. Congratulations, you've just learned about load paths. But live with your strawmen if you like.
Is it also your contention that PSF (pounds per square foot) is not a unit of pressure as implied in your post?
Is it your contention that a load of 40 psi is insignificant, like in a bicycle tire?
And any luck with NIST's explanation of how the buildings collapsed yet?
I love it when you repost things that have already been debunked. It makes you look worse, and it makes my job easier. How's that reading of the National Construction Safety Team Act coming along? Did you find the section where the Congress directed NIST to study the collapse past the initiation point?
I'm really interested in what happened during the collapse - why the steel failed on the lower floors.
The steel failed at the lower floors because the upper floors fell on them.
I think it is important to understand this mechanism, as so many buildings around the world are now suddenly at risk due to a flawed design concept and unsafe to work in - so much for engineering eh?
Wow! So, as an uneducated, ignorant layman, you've decided there is an engineering flaw in modern buildings? That's an awful lot like you deciding that you have to educate Augustine about steel design. Ego makes a fool of you, my friend.
I'd ask for my money back. If I lost a relative in the attack, I'd certainly be hauling UL in court for falsifying the WTC steel testing. They claimed the floor truss assemblies would stand for 2 hours in an inferno without failing didn't they?
Only if the fireproofing remained in tact. When the fireproofing was stripped, all bets were off.
It was certainly something like that - so much for american engineering and the people who certify it.
You an engineer?
Yep. So is Augustine, an R. Mackey, and Anti-Sophist, and Lurker, and The Grunion.
If so could you post your CV or something so we know who we're talking to - and your current employment or any other references you may have. Do you build skyscrapers for instance?
So, you need someone's license and certification to believe that they're an engineer, but you don't need any qualifications for the wildly moronic statements you routinely make? Absurd.
I'm sure their numbers can only grow, as any engineer is faced with a simple choice really - either they assert the official story is true, and that the collapse was a catastrophic engineering disaster, thus demonstrating that their assertions are worthless - or they defend their discipline.
How about this: Engineers look at the relevant data, read the publications and determine what's true? Oh wait, you've already decided for them what's true! I'm so glad we have you around so that we don't have to bother with all that pesky math.
 
Thats interesting, even they agree that there has been no detailed model of the collapse and that this is needed to "dispel the myth of planted explosives"

No, they say that a detailed model is superfluous, but could dispel the myth of planted explosives.

This implies that their PDF does not dispel any myths, and in their own words too. They're probably being professional and referring to the fact that they weren't involved in the investigation into what happened and wouldn't have had access to the data required to produce an accurate model, or access to any steel samples for testing etc.

You think? I think you've just made up a random opinion to bolster your own beliefs. No change there then.
 
Quote from Dr. Bazant (von Karman medal winner, scoob) in his "PDF" (gotten to this part yet, scoob?):

"As generally accepted by the community of specialists in structural mechanics and structural engineering (though not by a few outsiders claiming a conspiracy with planted explosives), the failure
scenario was as follows:..."
 
I was talking about the Iraqi troops, a conscripted army.
If you're dumb enough to join up and surrender independent thought to the Pentagon, and then wave your dishonourable discharge around on here claiming to be a skeptic and proud, well, I'm not impressed.

And before you get excited I know a DD-214 is not a dishonourable discharge - artistic licence, and frankly boredom with armchair warriors from an Army that hasn't fought in a real war since 1945, that just beats up on weaker countries and brags about it. Bullies basically, and cowards many of them.
I dare you to share those words with Mary Tillman, coward.

JBA was in the Navy, as was I. My bretheren in arms in the Army, some of whom are close personal friends, are people who you just personally insulted, and whose boot soles you are not worthy of licking.

You would be well served to hide behind your net pseudonym, coward.

DD 214: look it up, and find out what it actually is.

DR
 
Amen!

Navy, Cambodia, 1971-72, 73-74.

Good post, Shame on such hominids.

Robert A.M. Stephens, LLC ®
NASA Fine Art Documentation Program
Vision Motion Dynamic-FX-FX
behold the rage dot com
________________________________
Have Jeep, Have Heart, Will Travel
 
"While strictly speaking superfluous, one of the effects of a more detailed modeling of the progressive collapse, they say, could be to "dispel the myth of planted explosives".[9] To date, however, no such detailed model has been put forward."

Thats interesting, even they agree that there has been no detailed model of the collapse and that this is needed to "dispel the myth of planted explosives"

I've seen some quite bizarre behaviour on the part of the 911 truth movement, but by far the most bizarre is exemplified by Scooby here. He posts a quote for everyone to read, then quite openly asserts it says something different to what it actually says. It's so weird I can't even think of a name for it - it puts mere self-debunking to shame. I mean, just look at it. He posts a quote saying that a detailed model of the collapse is superfluous, then openly says that the quote says it is needed. I just fail to comprehend the state of mind that could lead someone to say such a thing.

Snoopy, have you the faintest idea what the word "superfluous" means?

Dave
 
It's unfortunate that the way you view yourself and the way the world views you are such disparate quantities. You're trying to save face here by claiming that the argument centered around something it didn't. We're not stupid, and we can see through the BS. If you want to continue making an issue of this, be my guest, but you're only going to appear weaker because of it.
And the floors rested upon trusses, which linked to columns, which carried the load to the ground. Congratulations, you've just learned about load paths. But live with your strawmen if you like.
Naw--The floors are independent structures, using sky hooks and unobtanium
Is it your contention that a load of 40 psi is insignificant, like in a bicycle tire?
It's only a square inch. The fact that each floor was 480,000 square inches seems to have escaped him. Also the fact that Pressure times area is a force, and that at 40 psi, the structure was capable of carrying 19,200,000 lb, or 9600 TONS, not counting structure.
I love it when you repost things that have already been debunked. It makes you look worse, and it makes my job easier. How's that reading of the National Construction Safety Team Act coming along? Did you find the section where the Congress directed NIST to study the collapse past the initiation point?
The steel failed at the lower floors because the upper floors fell on them.
Wow! So, as an uneducated, ignorant layman, you've decided there is an engineering flaw in modern buildings? That's an awful lot like you deciding that you have to educate Augustine about steel design. Ego makes a fool of you, my friend.
Only if the fireproofing remained in tact. When the fireproofing was stripped, all bets were off.
Yep. So is Augustine, an R. Mackey, and Anti-Sophist, and Lurker, and The Grunion.
As am I--PE, Mechanical engineering, specializing in Structural analysis, stress and dynamic loading.
So, you need someone's license and certification to believe that they're an engineer, but you don't need any qualifications for the wildly moronic statements you routinely make? Absurd.
While hiding anonymously himself--unless he truly is a talking dog*
How about this: Engineers look at the relevant data, read the publications and determine what's true? Oh wait, you've already decided for them what's true! I'm so glad we have you around so that we don't have to bother with all that pesky math.


*-nah--that Great dane is too smart to be THIS Scooby.

and, BTW:
GO AGGIES__WHUP UP on those T-Sippers tonight!
 
I was talking about the Iraqi troops, a conscripted army.
If you're dumb enough to join up and surrender independent thought to the Pentagon, and then wave your dishonourable discharge around on here claiming to be a skeptic and proud, well, I'm not impressed.

And before you get excited I know a DD-214 is not a dishonourable discharge - artistic licence, and frankly boredom with armchair warriors from an Army that hasn't fought in a real war since 1945, that just beats up on weaker countries and brags about it. Bullies basically, and cowards many of them.

Wow. You don't really know much of anything about... anything, do you?

Hell, even I'm offended by that, and I'm neither a veteran nor do I have much of a family history of military service, save for my grandmother's brother who served in the Pacific during WWII. I know a guy whose MOS is 18D and that's about it. Yet I somehow find this personally insulting. Good job.
 
Is it your contention that a load of 40 psi is insignificant, like in a bicycle tire?

By the by, Scooby, before you answer this, you might want to realize that a 40 PSI load on a floor, if you were to place an object on 1 square foot of a building's floor to generate that load, the object would weigh almost 6,000 pounds. That's about 50x what we normally use as a rule of thumb for what is an "acceptable" loading condition. Anything over about .6x usually means I'm calling my structural engineer to doublecheck my figures; this, I don't think I would bother him on.
 
Amen!

Navy, Cambodia, 1971-72, 73-74.

Good post, Shame on such hominids.

Robert A.M. Stephens, LLC ®
NASA Fine Art Documentation Program
Vision Motion Dynamic-FX-FX
behold the rage dot com
________________________________
Have Jeep, Have Heart, Will Travel

Welcome to the fourm RAMS. Look around and you'll find alot of info on the REAL Truth about 9/11, not the crapload the 9/11 truth movement dishes out.

TAM:)
 
Naw--The floors are independent structures, using sky hooks and unobtanium
My statics professor told us that all of those weightless, infinitely rigid beams were made of unobtanium, and that you had to wake up really early to go to the physics lab to get them.
As am I--PE, Mechanical engineering, specializing in Structural analysis, stress and dynamic loading.
Sorry about forgetting you there. Is 40 lashes with a wooden slide rule still standard punishment these days?
 
My statics professor told us that all of those weightless, infinitely rigid beams were made of unobtanium, and that you had to wake up really early to go to the physics lab to get them.

Sorry about forgetting you there. Is 40 lashes with a wooden slide rule still standard punishment these days?

Either that, or explain MC/I to an idiot.
Both are equally painful.

No-I retract that. Even 40 lashes with an Alminum slide rule would be less painful.
Therefore, you have paid your debt.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom