Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

Why would I bother doing that when all I have to do is ask you for the NIST reports explanation of what happened during the collapse of the WTC and WTC7.

Care to provide it?

I'd love to read what they say happened during the collapses - it was all so quick after all. I believe it's online, and you sound like an expert - so please, point out the relevant section.
(Bolding mine)

That's the trouble with you truthers - you're willing to spend countless hours scrutinizing YouTube videos, but you won't spend the time to aquire the necessary knowledge to understand the relevant areas of the NIST report. I know this sounds crazy, but you either have to have some prior knowledge of the subject or you need to read the body of the report and the appendices in order to understand the NIST's explanation of the collapses. Expecting someone to spell it out for you without a corresponding effort on your part just sounds childish.
 
If Ryan believes Partin is credible on OKC, is Partin also credible on the WTC collapses?

“The claims that the explosions and fires would not have generated enough heat to cause the building to collapse are nonsense,” Partin told The New American. “Steel doesn’t have to ‘melt’ as some of these people claim. The yield strength of steel drops very dramatically under heat, and the impact of the airliners would have severely impacted the support columns. When they could no longer support the upper stories and the top started coming down, the dynamic loading caused a very rapid collapse, or ‘pancaking,’ that would have very nearly approached free-fall rate. No demolition charges were needed to accomplish this.”
 
If Ryan believes Partin is credible on OKC, is Partin also credible on the WTC collapses?

Now silly, you know the answer to that. If his opinion isnt in keeping with "da twoofer dogma" he could be an archangel, and it wouldnt matter...they would consider him worthless on the matter...or a shill.

TAM:)
 
Remember, folks... If you're the best-of-the-best, the most qualified in your chosen field and, therefore, the one a large percentage of organizations turn to when they need something done right... that only proves you actually work for the NWO.

Incompetent fools are the only truly free people. :rolleyes:
 
(Bolding mine)

That's the trouble with you truthers - you're willing to spend countless hours scrutinizing YouTube videos, but you won't spend the time to aquire the necessary knowledge to understand the relevant areas of the NIST report. I know this sounds crazy, but you either have to have some prior knowledge of the subject or you need to read the body of the report and the appendices in order to understand the NIST's explanation of the collapses. Expecting someone to spell it out for you without a corresponding effort on your part just sounds childish.

Indeed. This is a common troofer trait. They are perfectly willing to JAQ off all over the internet, but are sadly unwilling to invest any effort in educating themselves. Rather, they expect others to do their work for them while they revel in their own ignorance.
 
Why would I bother doing that when all I have to do is ask you for the NIST reports explanation of what happened during the collapse of the WTC and WTC7.

Care to provide it?

I'd love to read what they say happened during the collapses - it was all so quick after all. I believe it's online, and you sound like an expert - so please, point out the relevant section.

Ah yes, this argument again.

In other words you can't point out where NIST is wrong per se - you can only complain that they didn't model the collapses!

That's a bit like saying: "OK, so you solved the question of why the plane crashed. But you didn't model what happened when it hit the ground! You don't explain how each piece ended up where it did!"

Cuz there's no point, scooby!

Do you want a report that says: "the 79th floor gave way under the collapsing weight, then the 78th floor gave way...and then the 77th, and the 76th...."?
 
Indeed. This is a common troofer trait. They are perfectly willing to JAQ off all over the internet, but are sadly unwilling to invest any effort in educating themselves. Rather, they expect others to do their work for them while they revel in their own ignorance.

Maybe this is a problem we have caused. There are quite a few knowledgeable individuals working as "debunkers" of the 9/11 conspiracy theories, and they have proved ready and able to provide rational explanations or analysis of anything the "truthers" have thrown their way. Perhaps a dependency has grown from this and the "truthers" recognize they don't actually have to learn anything - if they post it at one of the various "debunking" sites they'll quickly get all the learned analysis they need.

Just a thought...
 
Last edited:
Ah yes, this argument again.

In other words you can't point out where NIST is wrong per se - you can only complain that they didn't model the collapses!

So they have no explanation then?
Hmmm.

So on what scientific basis does this theory of a fire induced total collapse rest exactly? Is there anything published in academia that describes the mechanism by which it occurred, other than the work of the Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice?
 
... The only supposedly independent corroboration that the Bush scientists at NIST could produce for their appalling pack of lies was from that old respected scientific institution, Popular Mechanics.
A quick search of Google Scholars later and I'm going to have to point out that I hear lying is immoral. Just checking the NCSTAR bibliography or MIT website debunks this claim.
 
So they have no explanation then?
Hmmm.

So on what scientific basis does this theory of a fire induced total collapse rest exactly? Is there anything published in academia that describes the mechanism by which it occurred, other than the work of the Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice?

NIST did indeed explain what triggered the collapse as you well know. Stop playing stupid.

As for the actual collapses, they saw 40,000 and 120,000 ton masses smash through structures that were 95% hollow.

Only a twoofer asks "but how is that possible?"
 
By the way scooby, I'm still waiting for you to post some videos that capture the charges going off on 9/11.

You remember....those explosives that we all agree are really loud.
 
NIST did indeed explain what triggered the collapse as you well know. Stop playing stupid.

As for the actual collapses, they saw 40,000 and 120,000 ton masses smash through structures that were 95% hollow.

Only a twoofer asks "but how is that possible?"

95% hollow eh?
Like the NIST Report, and the '40,000 and 120,000 ton masses'?

As for the actual collapses - what do NIST say?
What is their explanation for what happened, I'm not interested in gossip - where's the explanation in the report?
 
Last edited:
So they have no explanation then?
Hmmm.

So on what scientific basis does this theory of a fire induced total collapse rest exactly? Is there anything published in academia that describes the mechanism by which it occurred, other than the work of the Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice?

On what scientific basis does your theory that only fire caused the collapse rest?
 
95% hollow eh?
Like the NIST Report, and the '40,000 and 120,000 ton masses'?

What do your calculations peg the weight at?

As for the actual collapses - what do NIST say?
What is their explanation for what happened, I'm not interested in gossip - where's the explanation in the report?

“… the structure below the level of collapse initiation offered minimal resistance to the falling building mass at and above the impact zone. The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that energy through energy of deformation.
Since the stories below the level of collapse initiation provided little resistance to the tremendous energy released by the falling building mass, the building section above came down essentially in free fall, as seen in videos. As the stories below sequentially failed, the falling mass increased, further increasing the demand on the floors below, which were unable to arrest the moving mass.”

Understand?

No of course you don't.
 
What do your calculations peg the weight at?



“… the structure below the level of collapse initiation offered minimal resistance to the falling building mass at and above the impact zone. The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that energy through energy of deformation.
Since the stories below the level of collapse initiation provided little resistance to the tremendous energy released by the falling building mass, the building section above came down essentially in free fall, as seen in videos. As the stories below sequentially failed, the falling mass increased, further increasing the demand on the floors below, which were unable to arrest the moving mass.”

Understand?

No of course you don't.

No I don't and no scientist would - that's not science, that's 2 paragraphs.

Where are the figures that demonstrate that this explanation is valid?
Where's the science?

Where is the scientific explanation of this new principle, whereby a mass can collapse through itself due to gravity alone?

And where is the link to this statement in the report?
 
Doc: "Hey Scooby it's raining outside"

Scooby: "That's not science... that's one sentence. Where are the figures that demonstrate this explanation is valid? What's the science?"

Seriously dude...
 
Doc: "Hey Scooby it's raining outside"

Scooby: "That's not science... that's one sentence. Where are the figures that demonstrate this explanation is valid? What's the science?"

Seriously dude...

It is claimed by theology professor Dr David Ray Griffin and physics professor Dr Steven Jones that the NIST report does not explain how the World Trade Center towers or WTC7 collapsed, and this is a tall one to deny, when it is common knowledge that the report into WTC7 does not exist and the ability to read is a common skill available to anyone.

But go for it anyway - where is the explanation doc?
 
Maybe this is a problem we have caused. There are quite a few knowledgeable individuals working as "debunkers" of the 9/11 conspiracy theories, and they have proved ready and able to provide rational explanations or analysis of anything the "truthers" have thrown their way. Perhaps a dependency has grown from this and the "truthers" recognize they don't actually have to learn anything - if they post it at one of the various "debunking" sites they'll quickly get all the learned analysis they need.

Just a thought...

Yes, that is probably very accurate, AZCat. Good examples of this have been shown here in recent months when troofers have brought their ludicrous stories here for "pre-bunking" in order to try to fix up the holes in their stories before they publish them.

The pentacon fiasco is a good example, as is the ongoing saga of JDX perpetually relying upon members here to point out the holes in his nonsense so that he can try to patch them before publicizing his "work".

The fact that troofers know that knowledgeable people here will step up to the plate and point out their errors and fallacies has probably contributed to their dependency. That said, they rarely show any tendency to actually educate themselves in the first place, as their skills rarely rise above investigoogling and they seem utterly incapable of making proper use of the learned analysis that they find here. Instead, they use it only to come up with new ways of dodging the facts and evidence, and new ways of pretending that the facts and evidence do not exist.

Sad, really.
 
What do your calculations peg the weight at?



“… the structure below the level of collapse initiation offered minimal resistance to the falling building mass at and above the impact zone. The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that energy through energy of deformation.
Since the stories below the level of collapse initiation provided little resistance to the tremendous energy released by the falling building mass, the building section above came down essentially in free fall, as seen in videos. As the stories below sequentially failed, the falling mass increased, further increasing the demand on the floors below, which were unable to arrest the moving mass.”

Understand?

No of course you don't.

Posted by Scooby:

No I don't and no scientist would - that's not science, that's 2 paragraphs.

The NIST report is pretty dry reading. I appreciate your leaving out the other 9,999 1/2 pages.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom