Lizards Undergo Rapid Evolution After Introduction To A New Home

I know it is one of my hobbyhorses, but I am beginning to think that people sometimes think "evolution" itself has a directing influence, even if they do not agree with ID...


This bothers me as well. It is not that science itself does so, but some of the advocates of this are what I like to call "wooptics"
 
I don't have access to the 1971 Oecologia paper by Nevo describing the beginning of the lizard experiment. I wonder if any head measurements were taken on the ten lizards that were released.
 
I don't have access to the 1971 Oecologia paper by Nevo describing the beginning of the lizard experiment. I wonder if any head measurements were taken on the ten lizards that were released.

I have downloaded it and printed it, and will read it later. It does have a table of measurements. PM me your mail address if you're interested in the article.

A cursory glance at the paper seems to imply that this is one of several experimental introductions of lizards of the same genus in this area. I have hardly slept last night, though, as I was out trying to catch coots, so I may have understood something wrong.
 
The North Ronaldsay sheep breed provides another example of rapid evolutionary development in response to environmental change.
From the mid-19thC, they have been kept exclusively on local beaches, where they eat only seaweed. They are so well adapted to this diet that they tend to get seriously sick and even die when fed on grass; however, when fed supplements, they can readapt back to grass-eating in two generations.
 
Last edited:
The North Ronaldsay sheep breed provides another example of rapid evolutionary development in response to environmental change.
From the mid-19thC, they have been kept exclusively on local beaches, where they eat only seaweed. They are so well adapted to this diet that they tend to get seriously sick and even die when fed on grass; however, when fed supplements, they can readapt back to grass-eating in two generations.

Any idea of the mortality rate for this to occur?
 
There is another possible explaination that could be investigated:

Devil's Advocate: "

As the islands seem very similar,

Maybe this was a random mutation that was highly beneficial, and allowed spread throughout the lizard population on the island where it occured, as it enabled a slight change in lifestyle, and a greater population density.

This could be investigated by placing some of the "new" lizards back onto the original island, and seeing if they spread. If they do, then it can't have be due to the differences in the external environment, but a "benefical" mutation opening up a slightly different niche...


"
 
My cats eat everything in sight. They sure like their normal cat food, but they would live on olives, raisins, sundried tomatoes, dust bunnies, socks and cotton, if they could.
They'd get sick and die very rapidly if that was all they had to eat. Cats need taurine, which (I believe) is only found in meat.
Cats are carnivores.
 
Any idea of the mortality rate for this to occur?
There are a couple of links to science sources on that page, I think. I only skimmed them, but it seems that there was a low(ish) mortality rate.
It may be an adaption, rather than classical evolution.
 
There are a couple of links to science sources on that page, I think. I only skimmed them, but it seems that there was a low(ish) mortality rate.
It may be an adaption, rather than classical evolution.

That's was what I was thinking, as otherwise you would expect both a high motality rate, and a high mutation rate on the genes associated with the adaptation...

BTW: I put my previous post in devils advocate, as that idea sems to be anathema for some people, because such a situation could "never occur"....
 
Dr. Dino's son Eric Hovind has incorporated the lizard story into their argument for rapid diversification of 'kinds' after they left Noah's Ark. It's on the video in the link. These guys get on my nerves every time.

From that link:
There is certainly no reason to believe that the many varieties of dogs in the world (including the fox species, wolves, and coyotes) could not have come from just two of the dog kind.

Oh my!
 
Say again? Are you saying that if we moved the lizards back to their original island, they wouldn't change back to carnivores?
Of course they wouldn't, because they never were carnivores. They were omnivores functioning as non-exclusive opportunistic insectivores. A quick read of the article demonstrates that they already had an omnivorous digestive structure. Without that, they could not have adapted to a predominantly herbivorous diet. The fact that the cecal valve developed so rapidly indicates that it's very likely that it already existed as a genetic holdover from an older population, which lost the expression of the gene due to adapting to a predominantly insectivorous diet. Chances are that the cecal valve is not a novel structure, but merely a re-expression of a pre-existing genetic potential.

By contrast, lions could not adapt to an herbivorous diet in anything even close to a similar time frame, if at all, simply because they are obligate carnivores and lack all of the major digestive structures necessary for processing plant matter. There are no genetically related species capable of an omnivorous diet, all of them are obligate carnivores; so there isn't likely to be sufficient dormant genetic capability to adapt to that level. At least not on a visible time frame.

Really, Claus, this is pretty rudimentary biology. I expected better from you.
 
OMy cats eat everything in sight. They sure like their normal cat food, but they would live on olives, raisins, sundried tomatoes, dust bunnies, socks and cotton, if they could.
Not inherently.

Domestic cats and dogs suffer from sublimated instincts that express themselves in many non-normal behaviours; including eating foods, and consuming non-food objects, which cannot provide adequate nutrition for the animal. Typically, eating non-normal foods and non-food objects indicates abnormal stresses, usually sublimnated hunting instincts, boredom, or illness.

Genetically identical feral cats and dogs which can express their instincts normally do not engage in this sort of abnormal eating behaviour. In the wild, obligate carnivores eat vegetable matter very infrequently, and primarily as a purgative, not a food source.

You really should be able to do better than this, Claus.
 
They'd get sick and die very rapidly if that was all they had to eat. Cats need taurine, which (I believe) is only found in meat.
Cats are carnivores.
Taurine is found in almost no vegetable sources, although there are a few, such as yeast. However, even should it be found in vegetable sources, that wouldn't matter, as it would not be biologically available to cats. Cats lack the necessary digestive structures to adequately process vegetable matter for nutrition. It would require a major restructure of their digestive system.

They are only capable of aquiiring taurine from animal sources; and only animal sources contain biologically significant amounts of taurine.

(The lack of vegetable sources of taurine isn't an issue for humans, since humans normally synthesize taurine from methionine and cysteine.)
 
From that link:
There is certainly no reason to believe that the many varieties of dogs in the world (including the fox species, wolves, and coyotes) could not have come from just two of the dog kind.
Oh my!
Well, technically that's close to correct, since all dog-related species did evolve from a common proto-canid ancestor. :)
 
Well, technically that's close to correct, since all dog-related species did evolve from a common proto-canid ancestor. :)

Indeed, but given the context...^^.

EDIT:
Also, you don't know that you EVILutionistic Jesus-hater.:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom