Lizards Undergo Rapid Evolution After Introduction To A New Home

Do you ever actually think about what it is you are trying to discredit or is it just a compulsion you cannot control?

Attack the argument, not the arguer.

What dilemma? I gave an example of adaptation vs an example of evolution to illustrate the difference.

But we aren't talking about adaptation. We are talking about evolution. You also used this example:

If it is just diet and not evolution, change the diet back and see what happens.

You think a change in diet can't result in evolution?

Protogynous and Protandrous fish develop new gonads, change color, and change size in response to environmental changes. Where do the new structures come from?

Adding specific proteins to chicken embryos can result in scales instead of feathers, teeth, and limbs instead of wings. Where did the structures come from? No evolution took place in these experiments. Gene expression was changed, but no genetic changes occurred.

I have no idea what you are getting at.
 
Attack the argument, not the arguer.
Then don't make stupid remarks about stuff you don't get that I post. There was no argument to attack. There was only you making some completely off the wall, unrelated comment about a false dilemma.

But we aren't talking about adaptation. We are talking about evolution.
What we, paleface? Some of us were debating whether or not the changes represented evolution or just changes that resulted from a new diet. The fact you didn't know this discussion was going on should have led you to ask what my post was referring to, instead of childishly claiming some irrelevant nonsense about a false dilemma. You essentially criticized my remarks without having a clue about what I had said.


You think a change in diet can't result in evolution?
Is this question even on the table here? Of course it can.

Does that mean a change in diet only results in evolution? Do fat people evolve because of diet changes? Or do they get fat when their food source changes and their genes lag behind?

I have no idea what you are getting at.
Now there's something we actually agree on.

You asked Kotatsu,
Not evolution? Where did the new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts come from? Magic?
I merely offered some examples in nature where large structures developed in fish in response to environmental changes that had nothing to do with genetic changes or magic.
 
Hard to find much on the species' usual diet but here's what I did find:

They feed on insects, vegetable and sometimes, its own newly hatched young.

Sounds like omnivore to me.

Well, the original paper (which you linked to) states that the population on the first island had 4-7% vegetable matter in their guts when examined, which supports this. I have to run away to a course, but I noticed that there's a linked article in J. Evol. Biol. called "Omnivory in lacertid lizards" (reference 13). Maybe that could be worth looking into? I'll try to get it and see what I can find.
 
From the paper (see link in post #60 above)
The evolution of these structures has likely gone hand in hand with a novel association between P. sicula on Pod Mrcˇaru and a set of microorganisms assuring the digestion of cellulose as is suggested by the presence of nematodes in the hindgut of individuals from Pod Mrcˇaru....

Although the presence of cecal valves and large heads in hatchlings and juveniles suggests a genetic basis for these differences, further studies investigating the potential role of phenotypic plasticity and/or maternal effects in the divergence between populations are needed.
If the researchers themselves don't know, anyone here claiming to know would be overstepping the evidence a bit.


I was curious how many generations they were talking about. That is an important variable.
Our data show that in only 36 years (30 generations)......



I never knew they gave Darwin a value.
high phenotypic divergence rates (17) up to 8,593 darwins or 0.049 haldanes
That cracks me up.
 
Last edited:
I don't disagree with that. I thought you were saying undetected genetic changes were more likely to be the mechanism of change here. I think something in the environment, very likely stress of an abruptly changed food source, is more likely to have affected gene expression than some genetic change accounting for the observed physical changes.

Did you mean to quote me here, rather than Lupus?

Oh, come on. They wouldn't check the lizards from the old island?

I assume that they did. That does not imply that the structure was not present, however. It may be that it is only developed when needed, and is otherwise dormant. Thus, if the dietary situation on the first island never changed during the period of monitoring, it may very well be that they simply never saw it, though it is certainly not a novel structure for the species.

Being omnivorous does not mean that you eat equally from all groups. E.g., dogs are omnivorus (even turds! - yuck!), but that doesn't mean they feast on carrots.

But being omnivorous means that you do eat from all (or at least several) groups. This is merely a change in percentages; they didn't change from carnivores to herbivores. The mother population still ate 4-7% vegetable matter on the first island.

I disagree.

I would be surprised if you didn't. Nevertheless, you seek to compare a change in relative amounts of plants present in the diet to a change from exclusively carnivorous habits to exclusively herbivorous. The two are not equal, and thus your comparison fails.

Not evolution? Where did the new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts come from? Magic?

One hypothesis could be that they are coded for in both populations, but expressed only in one, as Skeptigirl is arguing. This happens all the time, and is hardly revolutionary.
 
I assume that they did. That does not imply that the structure was not present, however. It may be that it is only developed when needed, and is otherwise dormant. Thus, if the dietary situation on the first island never changed during the period of monitoring, it may very well be that they simply never saw it, though it is certainly not a novel structure for the species.

One hypothesis could be that they are coded for in both populations, but expressed only in one, as Skeptigirl is arguing. This happens all the time, and is hardly revolutionary.

Mkay.

So, where's the story in this? Why the hubbub?

But being omnivorous means that you do eat from all (or at least several) groups. This is merely a change in percentages; they didn't change from carnivores to herbivores. The mother population still ate 4-7% vegetable matter on the first island.

I have two cats. Are they herbivores?

I would be surprised if you didn't. Nevertheless, you seek to compare a change in relative amounts of plants present in the diet to a change from exclusively carnivorous habits to exclusively herbivorous. The two are not equal, and thus your comparison fails.

Where did I say "exclusively"? Carnivores might eat plants and herbivores might gobble the odd piece of meat.
 
Well, the original paper (which you linked to) states that the population on the first island had 4-7% vegetable matter in their guts when examined, which supports this. I have to run away to a course, but I noticed that there's a linked article in J. Evol. Biol. called "Omnivory in lacertid lizards" (reference 13). Maybe that could be worth looking into? I'll try to get it and see what I can find.
I see, I missed this.
Our data show that P. sicula lizards consume more plant material on Pod Mrcˇaru compared with the ancestral population on Pod Kopisˇte. Analysis of stomach contents shows marked differences in diet between populations in both spring (F1,20422.9, P0.01) and summer (F1,74 103.13, P 0.01) but no differences in diet between sexes in either population (F1,202 1.36, P 0.24). Seasonal differences in diet were significant in lizards from the introduced population (Pod Mrcˇaru, F1,184 30.31, P 0.01) with plants composing between 34% (spring) and 61% (summer) of the total volume of the food eaten (Fig. 2). In contrast, plant consumption was low (7% to 4%) and did not differ seasonally for lizards from the source population (Pod Kopisˇte, F1,94 0.33, P 0.57). Moreover, 50% of the plant matter eaten year round by lizards from Pod Mrcˇaru consists of items with high cellulose content such as leaves and stems (Fig. 3).
Looks like there were still quite a few bugs in the diet in the new environment.
 
Last edited:
Regarding the cats and dogs being omnivores, Claus, that doesn't seem to fit with what wild dogs and cats eat. Those are carnivores. Domestic cats and dogs might eat vegetable matter. My dogs will eat anything I hand them just about but they actually will only chew a number of veges before leaving the remains on the ground.

I think your analogies are again flawed. How are your comments about cats and dogs relevant to whether or not these lizards are omnivores? They seem like omnivores from the paper and from the other link I posted describing the species.
 
Last edited:
Then don't make stupid remarks about stuff you don't get that I post. There was no argument to attack. There was only you making some completely off the wall, unrelated comment about a false dilemma.

Attack the argument, not the arguer.

What we, paleface?

Attack the argument, not the arguer.

Some of us were debating whether or not the changes represented evolution or just changes that resulted from a new diet. The fact you didn't know this discussion was going on should have led you to ask what my post was referring to, instead of childishly claiming some irrelevant nonsense about a false dilemma. You essentially criticized my remarks without having a clue about what I had said.

You were addressing my posts.

Is this question even on the table here? Of course it can.

Does that mean a change in diet only results in evolution? Do fat people evolve because of diet changes? Or do they get fat when their food source changes and their genes lag behind?

Then, why did you present it as a dichotomy?

Now there's something we actually agree on.

You don't know yourself what you are getting at?

You asked Kotatsu, I merely offered some examples in nature where large structures developed in fish in response to environmental changes that had nothing to do with genetic changes or magic.

Gene expression is also evolution.
 
Once again, you've reached the point where your post is no longer following the discussion but has wandered off in your quest to conquer those windmills.
 
Gene expression is also evolution.

Only in the same way that legs are drumsticks ...

It isn't.

In biology, evolution is the process of change in the inherited traits of a population of organisms from one generation to the next.

and

Gene expression is the process by which inheritable information from a gene, such as the DNA sequence, is made into a functional gene product, such as protein or RNA.

So, how do you suggest that gene expression influences the genetic structure between several generations of a species? As far as I understand this, gene expression has no influence at all on the genetic make-up of an individual or its offspring. But without any such changes you do not have evolution.
 
So, where's the story in this? Why the hubbub?

I have no idea. You posted the OP. This suggests that of the two of us, you are the one who would think there is a remarkable story in this.

I will agree that some parts of this story are indeed very interesting, especially when it comes to the implications for plasticity in morphology and physiology even among "higher" vertebrates. The whole experiment as such seems very interesting as well. But the conclusions are not extremely extraordinary. However, as suggested by skeptigirl and others, we all seem to lack sufficient background knowledge on the group to be able to say anything more definite than that. I have downloaded some of their references, and will read them during the afternoon.

I have two cats. Are they herbivores?

Unless you have trained your cats to a vegetarian diet, in which case they are herbivores in the practical sense, my answer would be no. Cats are carnivores or, at best, omnivores.

Where did I say "exclusively"? Carnivores might eat plants and herbivores might gobble the odd piece of meat.

So? A cow that eats a cricket doesn't become an omnivore, let alone a carnivore. It remains a herbivore.

Gene expression is also evolution.

In one sense, yes. Suppression and expression of various genes are also aspects of evolution, and may steer the course of evolutionary history in certain ways. However, that is not the sense of the word that skeptigirl seems to be using. While her examples were a bit off, in that those --- as I understand it (1) --- are changes within an individual when exposed to different environmental conditions, they suggest that there may be cases where this can happen across generations as well.

I could offer you other examples, such as certain clitellates, which switch between an asexual stage and a sexual stage. In these, asexual reproduction continues until changes in the environment causes one generation to develop sexual organs and then reproduce sexually for a while. When conditions change back, they revert to asexual reproduction. The important change is usually temperature, with sexual reproduction occurring in late summer or early autumn.

In these cases, several generations of clitellates would have no sexual organs. Then, suddenly, one generation develops them. Is this evolution of a new trait, or expression of a trait that was just dormant in the population? I would claim the latter. If we took some of these clitellates during the asexual stage and moved them to a novel environment where the conditions are such as to encourage sexual maturation, and we observe this, is this a significant finding from the viewpoint of the evolution of the two populations?

I would like to draw attention to the original article's Fig 2, which is a comparison of gut content between lizards of the two islands. 2a is from the spring, and 2b from the summers. While this is certainly not enough data points to draw any sweeping conclusions, we can note that while the lizards of Pod Mrcaru were indeed largely herbivorous during the summer (61% of the gut content being plant matter, with the rest being arthropods), the reverse is true during the spring (34% plant matter, with the rest being arthropods) (2). On Pod Kopiste, the proportion between plant and arthropod matter is largely constant over the year (7% plant in the spring and 4% in the summer, with the rest being arthropods).

I would like to ask any passing herpetologist if there is any chance that this change in diet over the year could cause the presence of the cecal valves to be seasonal, developed only when they are needed (i.e. during the summer, when the diet is predominantly vegetarian). If this is at all possible, then I suggest that the finding of these cecal valves, while of course interesting in some ways, do not necessarily represent a significant step in morphological evolution.

---
(1) I am talking from memory here, so if I am wrong, please point it out to me. Perhaps I am just reiterating skeptigirl's examples using other organisms.
(2) There is also something labelled "rest" in both diagrams, but this is seemingly constant over the year and between populations, and could include, for instance, the nematodes found in the gut of the Pod Mrcaru population, but I can't seem to find any mention of what this actually is, and it is largely irrelevant as well...
 
Last edited:
I have no idea. You posted the OP. This suggests that of the two of us, you are the one who would think there is a remarkable story in this.

Oh, it's hardly just me. It was carried by science magazines and major news media.

I will agree that some parts of this story are indeed very interesting, especially when it comes to the implications for plasticity in morphology and physiology even among "higher" vertebrates. The whole experiment as such seems very interesting as well. But the conclusions are not extremely extraordinary. However, as suggested by skeptigirl and others, we all seem to lack sufficient background knowledge on the group to be able to say anything more definite than that. I have downloaded some of their references, and will read them during the afternoon.

It isn't a question of evolution like this happening. The hubbub is that it happened so quickly.

Unless you have trained your cats to a vegetarian diet, in which case they are herbivores in the practical sense, my answer would be no. Cats are carnivores or, at best, omnivores.

My cats eat everything in sight. They sure like their normal cat food, but they would live on olives, raisins, sundried tomatoes, dust bunnies, socks and cotton, if they could.

So? A cow that eats a cricket doesn't become an omnivore, let alone a carnivore. It remains a herbivore.

I'm not talking about accidental chomping.
 
Oh, it's hardly just me. It was carried by science magazines and major news media.

Then I will amend my answer to "you and some science magazines and major news media are the ones who would think there is a remarkable story in this." I remain in my opinion that there is nothing necessarily spectacular about this, however.

It isn't a question of evolution like this happening. The hubbub is that it happened so quickly.

But what has actually happened "so quickly" that is so newsworthy? Can we rule out that the cecal valves are coded for, but not expressed, in the population of Pod Kopiste? If not, there s nothing remarkable in that. I will concede that it's interesting that the head size and shape have changed so rapidly, but that sort of thing is discovered all the time. It's hardly novel.

A guess could be that this group are good at marketing themselves. Mark Siddall got a lot of publicity last year for his paper on leach phylogenies, even though Trontelj and colleagues had published almost the same thing several years earlier. That a scientific paper is highlighted outside of the scientific journals, or in magazines and periodicals of a scientific or general-interest nature, does not necessarily mean that it's something extraordinary or novel. It can just be a case of good advertising in order to get more exposure to your research, and thus higher chances to get funding.

My cats eat everything in sight. They sure like their normal cat food, but they would live on olives, raisins, sundried tomatoes, dust bunnies, socks and cotton, if they could.

Then it appears your cats are neither carnivores nor herbivores, but omnivores. I fail to see where this part of the conversation is leading, however.

I'm not talking about accidental chomping.

Then please state your argument in clearer terms, as I am not sure what it is you are after. My claim is this: the example of a known omnivore changing the percentages of plant and animal matter in its diet is not significant enough a change to be usefully compared to a known carnivore changing its diet to herbivory. Especially not if, as in the present case, the omnivore still consumes a great deal of animal matter after the change.
 
Last edited:
Where did you see that? The original article must, unless cloning is involved, refer to the general genome. No two individuals are generally alike unless they are identical twins, even eggs for egg-layers most often come about because of multiple fertilizations, and those will result in different genetic material.

They started with the same DNA, or something reasonably close, perhaps, but how can you assert their DNA is "identical to the original population"?

Given that sexual reproduction ensures that is never the case, what are you saying?

Please prove your assertion with testable, verifiable evidence. If you can't, you should retract your claim of identical DNA.

You are free to point out that the article quoted above has obvious flaws. It's interesting that you didn't note that immediately.

You are going to dig me up for using the words in the article linked in the OP?

Tail clips taken for DNA analysis confirmed that the Pod Mrcaru lizards were genetically identical to the source population on Pod Kopiste.

I rather thought that it was obvious we were not talking about cloning, but it seems you need to have that spelled out for you. That is fine, but why the belligerence? Direct it at the journalist or the original researchers if you must. Though they, too, assume a basic level of knowledge which enables the general reader to distinguish between a clone and what is under discussion here. I think you are just making a rather silly pedantic point. Most people here do understand what I was getting at and the question of whether there is genetic mutation which has not been detected; or different expression of existing genes which have not mutated is the interesting one.
 
Last edited:
The source in the OP was unclear. The actual journal article was clear - they were not looking for mutations that would correspond to the phenotypic changes. They were only trying to tell if the current lizards on the island were descendents of the P. sicula lizards that had been deliberately transported to the island in 1971, rather than the lizards which had prevbiously inhabited the island.
 
The source in the OP was unclear. The actual journal article was clear - they were not looking for mutations that would correspond to the phenotypic changes. They were only trying to tell if the current lizards on the island were descendents of the P. sicula lizards that had been deliberately transported to the island in 1971, rather than the lizards which had prevbiously inhabited the island.
Yes, and from the OP link, Fiona had a very legitimate question about whether this was simple adaptation of a flexible species or true evolutionary change. And since the authors themselves said in the actual source paper
Although the presence of cecal valves and large heads in hatchlings and juveniles suggests a genetic basis for these differences, further studies investigating the potential role of phenotypic plasticity and/or maternal effects in the divergence between populations are needed.
it would appear Fiona's point was well worth bringing up in this discussion.

Is phenotypic plasticity an intermediary step in evolution, is it merely the flexibility of a species to survive in multiple environments or should we define it as actually being evolution?
 
Last edited:
Yes, and from the OP link, Fiona had a very legitimate question about whether this was simple adaptation of a flexible species or true evolutionary change. And since the authors themselves said in the actual source paperit would appear Fiona's point was well worth bringing up in this discussion.

Is phenotypic plasticity an intermediary step in evolution, is it merely the flexibility of a species to survive in multiple environments or should we define it as actually being evolution?
Yes, I agree that it's an important question.
(I just wanted to clarify that the authors published no genetic info in the article that addressed the question.)
 
This was one of the things that came to mind for me as well. Studies in retro-engineering chicken embryos to produce dinosaur characteristics showed some of the genetics were still there, just turned off.

You must have seen the same program. :)

That was what I was referring to when talking about "latent"...

The article was careless:

Examination of the lizard’s digestive tracts revealed something even more surprising. Eating more plants caused the development of new structures called cecal valves, designed to slow which slow the passage of food by creating fermentation chambers in the gut, where microbes can break down the difficult to digest portion of plants.

I know it is one of my hobbyhorses, but I am beginning to think that people sometimes think "evolution" itself has a directing influence, even if they do not agree with ID...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom