Lizards Undergo Rapid Evolution After Introduction To A New Home

You totally missed my point. Read post 17.
I didn't miss your point. I called you on your false analogy.



Say again? Are you saying that if we moved the lizards back to their original island, they wouldn't change back to carnivores?
If it is just diet and not evolution, change the diet back and see what happens.

Is the person just tan from the Sun or did they evolve darker skin? One is adaptation, one is evolution.

I agree this is evolution, Claus, you are fighting windmills again. I just also think Fiona had a good point that needed consideration.
 
In case you hadn't heard, those 'junk sequences' are not likely junk. If they were, one would not expect to find them highly conserved.

It is a good point though, that a gene not subject to positive or negative selection pressure could eventually disappear. There is no reason necessarily for cave fish to go blind if resources are abundant, (the burden of a useless organ would matter more in some caves than in others), yet they eventually do.

Of course I've heard, or I wouldn't have used the word.:cool: The relatively "new" concept is the one I mentioned about "switches" which may very well be within those previously, probably misnamed, junk sequences.

I don't think however, from your comment that you quite understood the point I was making; which is that "genes" can have a range of functions, as expressed through the chemicals they produce, by being appropriately switched by other controlling sequences.

An analogy would be a subroutine in a program that performs a definable function, but has multiple outputs within that function, depending on the data it is provided.

As a gut feel, it simply makes sense that there is much more to the 20,000 or so genomes that we are supposed to have, along with a lizards similar number. It is the interplay between them that multiplies the possible end results.

To quote from the article that I most recently read on this in Scientific American:

"When comparing mouse and human genomes, for example, biologists are able to identify a mouse counterpart for at least 99% of all our genes".

"In humans the protein coding stretches of DNA make up only about 1.5% of our genome, so genes are like little islands of information in a vast sea of DNA sequence. Much of the remaining noncoding DNA does nothing that we know of, but some of those sequences participate in the very important task of regulating gene expression. And these regulatory sequences are key to evolution."
 
Not chance, but necessity. They suddenly moved from an environment with insects but few plants to one with plants but few insects.
I am not clear on this point.

Nothing in the actual Herrel et al PNAS paper describes a difference in habitat or food sources between the two islands.

A quote from the source given in the OP suggests that Pod Mrcaru was richer in plants than Pod Kopiste (the original island):
According to Irschick, lizards on the barren island of Pod Kopiste were well-suited to catching mobile prey, feasting mainly on insects. Life on Pod Mrcaru, where they had never lived before, offered them an abundant supply of plant foods, including the leaves and stems from native shrubs.
This suggests that there was in fact a different vegetation on the two islands, and maybe a different array of insects.


But a description of the species from the Gorman '75 paper (Evolution, 29(1), pp 52-71) says this:
1) Lacerta sicula.-This species occurs in Italy and along the Adriatic coast of Yugoslavia. Its present distribution in northern Yugoslavia suggests that it has been a relatively recent invader, having come from north-eastern Italy around the Adriatic. Its occurrence on some southcentral
Adriatic islands, and its absence from the Yugoslav mainland at these latitudes suggests direct over-water colonization of these islands (Palagruza, Susac, Kopiste, Pod Kopiste) from Italy. L. sicula is also present in southern Yugoslavia, its presence there is presumably the result of another over-water colonization. About one-third of the described subspecies are on islands in the eastern Adriatic.
2) Lacerta melisellensis.-This is an autochthonous species to the coastal regions of Yugoslavia. Of the 18 named subspecies, one is on mainland Yugoslavia, the remainder are all insular isolates.
(note: genus name changed from Lacerta to Podarcis for these species.)

If P. sicula is that widespread, it seems unlikely that its first exposure to a richer plant life than found on a barren island was when the five pairs were placed on Pod Mrcaru.

Also, the article says that P. sicula lizards on Pod Kopiste (original island) did not have nematodes in their GI tracts while the ones on Pod Mrcaru (new island) did have nematodes, which the article connected to cellulose digestion.
But pubmed gives several links for articles about nematodes of different species in P. sicula lizards in other locations. (Perhaps those nematodes were not appropriate for plant digestion?) So the presence of nematodes in general is not unique to the Pod Mrcaru P. sicula lizards.

I'm not making an argument here, just trying to understand how the details fit together.
 
Last edited:
More info from this paper:
Differences in morphology, performance and behaviour between recently diverged populations of Podarcis sicula mirror differences in predation pressure
Bart Vervust, Irena Grbac and Raoul Van Damme
Oikos 116: 1343-1352, 2007

Both islands are tiny (Pod Mrcˇaru: 0.3 km2; Pod Kopisˇte: 0.9 km2), are highly similar in general physiognomy, exposure and elevation and only 4.5 km apart. Therefore, the two islands probably resemble each other closely in their abiotic environments. The only other ground-dwelling vertebrate on the islands is the lizard Lacerta oxycephala . This species occurs at very low densities on the outer reaches of the islands, where densities of P. sicula are low. Birds are probably the only significant predators in these populations. At first sight, the two islands do differ in vegetation structure. Both consist of an outer girdle of rocks with little or no vegetation, and a central part containing more lush vegetation. However, possibly due to the presence of a small number (<5) of sheep, the vegetation on Pod Kopisˇte is lower and less dense and may provide less cover from aerial attacks.
The islands resemble each other in general aspects. Both consist of organic limestone and have a central, vegetated zone (rising up to 20 m on Pod Mrcˇaru and 30 m on Pod Kopisˇte), encircled by more barren rocky belt. Plant cover on Pod Mrcˇaru (Fig. 2b) consists mainly of annuals: Lavatera arborea , Lotus edulis , Portulacea oleracea , Allium ampeloprasum and Cynodon dactylon in the centre, and Crithmum maritimum in the periphery. Pod Kopisˇte (Fig. 2a) has some low bushes of Pistacia lenticus and Juniperus
excelsa ; the central part is covered mainly by Chenopodium murale, Cynodon dactylon and Aspargus officinalis ; Crithmum maritimum is the dominant species on the rocky fringes. We noticed a few specimens of the sharpsnouted rock lizard, Lacerta oxycephala , climbing rocks in the outer fringes on both islands. Except for a small number of breeding yellow-legged seagulls (Larus michahellis ), no other vertebrates likely inhabit the
islands.
 
Of course I've heard, or I wouldn't have used the word.:cool: The relatively "new" concept is the one I mentioned about "switches" which may very well be within those previously, probably misnamed, junk sequences.

I don't think however, from your comment that you quite understood the point I was making; which is that "genes" can have a range of functions, as expressed through the chemicals they produce, by being appropriately switched by other controlling sequences....

Well from that comment, I don't think you read much of what I posted so I guess that makes us about even.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3636925#post3636925
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3636937#post3636937
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3636941#post3636941
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3637008#post3637008

Going back over your posts, to be clear here,
And this is what I was referring to earlier. In fact your "third" possibility and what you follow up with can be seen as the same thing, which can be explained in part by what is called "gene regulating DNA sequences", or switches.
The difference is that internal genetic changes can affect gene expression but so too can external non-gene based factors affect gene expression.

1) the gene changes result in new protein codons or other direct changes
2) genetic changes affect gene expression
3) other factors affect gene expression, for example stress might result in a changed hormone level that altered gene expression in either an adult or a developing fetus

For an example of the third option, just look at gender changes in reptiles and fish. Doesn't the incubation temperature change the sex of alligator embryos? And there is a fish species that has one male in a group. If the male dies, a single female will change into a male.

Fascinating stuff about the fish:
Temperature of egg incubation determines sex in Alligator mississippiensis

Gender change in fish
The gender change can be from male to female, or from female to male depending on species. Species that are born male and change to female are called Protandrous (proto = first, andros = male), and species that are born female and change to male are called Protogynous (proto = first,gyne = female). Gender change normally accompanies a change in size to a larger individual. Meaning that if the species is protandrous then the females are larger than the males, and if the species is protogynous then the males are larger than the females.

In Parrotfish and in some Wrasses the males and females have very different colouration, so much so that in some cases they were originally described as separate species. Such a species is called dichromatic. Thus in these species the change of gender involves not only an internal metamorphosis of the gonads and a rapid increase in size but also a change of colour.

In some groups the dominant male uses aggressive behaviour to keep his attendant females submissive, and therefore female. If the dominant male is removed the most aggressive female rapidly changes to male and takes over the dominant position.
 
Last edited:
You are missing the second part of the quote:

The article merely states that these cecal valves have never been reported before, not that they didn't exist before.

You still miss it: They went from primarily meat eaters to primarily plant eaters.
That's a huge step, evolutionary wise. And in only 36 years.

Not necessarily, as they appear to have been omnivores before the transferral as well.

Think about lions. They live where there's plenty of plant food. If plants provide a larger and more predictable food supply, why don't lions become herbivores?

That is a crap comparison. The lions are not omnivores before the change, as were the lizards. The lizards have not changed from one kind of nutrients to another, but merely changed the percentages of what they eat. To suggest that this is something astounding is ludicrous. Dunnocks do it every year, as do blackcaps and some other birds. This is not evolution, but changes in food preference depending on available sources.

So were the lizards in the beginning.

No:

article said:
Analysis of the stomach contents of lizards on Pod Mrcaru showed that their diet included up to two-thirds plants, depending on the season, a large increase over the population of Pod Kopiste.

"Two mitochondrial DNA fragments (12S rDNA and 16S rDNA) were
amplified by PCR...Sequences were edited and aligned with BioEdit software
(26). The MEGA v4 (27) was used to calculate pairwise Jukes–Cantor distances and to construct a neighbor-joining tree... "

Thanks! I'll read this later on. However: as they used 12S and 16S, it's not very strange that they find the lizards to be genetically identical, as these are slow genes, more commonly used on genus-level than on species-level. I'd have thought something more fast-evolving would be more suitable for this...

What this interesting study is showing is that evolution is more than just genome change. What remains to be seen here is are the researchers missing more subtle genetic changes.

This seems likely, as they didn't exactly chose the most suitable genes to study.

(note: genus name changed from Lacerta to Podarcis for these species.)

Let me just be overly pedantic, perhaps, and point out that scientific names should be in italics...^^
 
Last edited:
...

This[undetermined genetic differences] seems likely, as they didn't exactly chose the most suitable genes to study.
I don't agree. In fact, external factors affecting gene expression would account for rapid evolution where as genetic factors would take longer to manifest in a whole population. (Granted this colony started from only 5 initial pairs and a bottleneck could produce more rapid genetic changes in an entire population.) But consider the following:

External factors accelerate expression divergence between duplicate genes
We examined the evolution of expression of duplicate genes in Arabidopsis thaliana, by analyzing 512 data sets of gene expression microarrays and 2022 recent duplicate gene pairs. Expression divergence between gene duplicates is significantly greater in response to environmental stress than to developmental processes. A slow rate of expression divergence during development might offer dosage-dependent selective advantage, whereas rapid expression divergence in response to external changes might accelerate adaptation.

I think a paradigm shift (or rather adjustment) to evolution theory has been in the works for a while. In microorganisms it has been observed that stress can decrease DNA and RNA repair mechanisms resulting in increased rates of mutations in times of stress. That adds a little more to random mutation and selection pressures. We have a genetically based presumably selected process that affects mutation rates in a directed way.

In the case of these lizards, external stress might affect gene expression without genetic changes necessarily being needed to change the gene expression.
 
Last edited:
The DNA is identical to the original population: so it seems to me that big fat lizards are morphologically different from wee undernourished ones.

Where did you see that? The original article must, unless cloning is involved, refer to the general genome. No two individuals are generally alike unless they are identical twins, even eggs for egg-layers most often come about because of multiple fertilizations, and those will result in different genetic material.

They started with the same DNA, or something reasonably close, perhaps, but how can you assert their DNA is "identical to the original population"?

Given that sexual reproduction ensures that is never the case, what are you saying?

Please prove your assertion with testable, verifiable evidence. If you can't, you should retract your claim of identical DNA.

You are free to point out that the article quoted above has obvious flaws. It's interesting that you didn't note that immediately.
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure if this is the proper thread, but since sceptigirl mentioned something about a new paradigm, I just though this discussion between Richard Dawkins and Craig Venter might be of interest to some of you. Richard seemed sceptical about horizontal gene transfer, but admitted he’s very interested and ready to change his mind about molecular taxonomy.

Furthermore, chromosomal transplantation seemed really intriguing too. Venter made some vague point about how that could also have happened without human intervention, thus giving more ammunition against the slow random point mutation vs. complexity argument creationist seem to hang on to.

Highly recommended video (about 1h long) in the sense that I suppose much further discussion between Dawkins and Venter will come out of this. Just have to wait and see what happens.
 
Where did you see that? The original article must, unless cloning is involved, refer to the general genome. No two individuals are generally alike unless they are identical twins, even eggs for egg-layers most often come about because of multiple fertilizations, and those will result in different genetic material.

They started with the same DNA, or something reasonably close, perhaps, but how can you assert their DNA is "identical to the original population"?

Given that sexual reproduction ensures that is never the case, what are you saying?

Please prove your assertion with testable, verifiable evidence. If you can't, you should retract your claim of identical DNA.

You are free to point out that the article quoted above has obvious flaws. It's interesting that you didn't note that immediately.

What a brutish response! Both the original article and the one Claus links to in the OP claims that the two populations are genetically identical. Or, rather, the original article claims that they are "genetically indistinguishable from lizards from the source population". Unless lizards are vastly different from the animals I work with, this is to be expected when they chose to sequence 12S and 16S; I can't imagine anyone being surprised that these sequences are identical to the source population's after only 30 generations. That is certainly a potential flaw of the original paper, though I will agree that, for barcoding and identification purposes, these genes are somewhat sufficient.
 
I’m not sure if this is the proper thread, but since sceptigirl mentioned something about a new paradigm, I just though this discussion between Richard Dawkins and Craig Venter might be of interest to some of you. Richard seemed sceptical about horizontal gene transfer, but admitted he’s very interested and ready to change his mind about molecular taxonomy.

Furthermore, chromosomal transplantation seemed really intriguing too. Venter made some vague point about how that could also have happened without human intervention, thus giving more ammunition against the slow random point mutation vs. complexity argument creationist seem to hang on to.

Highly recommended video (about 1h long) in the sense that I suppose much further discussion between Dawkins and Venter will come out of this. Just have to wait and see what happens.

There are 4 well known mechanisms for horizontal gene transfer. I'd be surprised to learn Dawkins wasn't aware of that. I wonder if something was misunderstood?

I'll have to watch it later.
 
Last edited:
I don't agree. In fact, external factors affecting gene expression would account for rapid evolution where as genetic factors would take longer to manifest in a whole population. (Granted this colony started from only 5 initial pairs and a bottleneck could produce more rapid genetic changes in an entire population.) But consider the following:

I believe we are talking past each other. I meant that it is likely that the researchers have missed more subtle genetic differences, because they chose two very blunt genes to sequence. 12S and 16S evolve slowly, and it is not surprising that they seem to have remained constant over the last 30 generations. Had they instead chosen to study a more quickly evolving gene, they would be likely to have spotted larger differences, if there indeed are any. They are dragging a trawl net across a lawn and stating that there are few ladybugs there, where a finer net might have yielded many.

My comment was entirely on your "What remains to be seen here is are the researchers missing more subtle genetic changes" part. Perhaps I should have made that clearer.
 
My understanding of evolution is that there can be no claim to mutation in a species unless there is inheritance of that mutation - that is, a change in the chromosomal genetics of the individuals which display the change, so that it can be reflected in their offspring. The statement that the "genetic material is identical" must be false in detail if there is an evolutionary change. I think the problem is that the statement about the identical genetics means that they looked at some markers which differentiate this particular species from it's close mates, and there was no difference there, which verifies that the new lizards haven't crossed with any other species and thus inherited their changes from outside their pure line. It is flatly impossible that the chromosomes in a pair of individuals (even brothers, as long as they're not clones) are entirely identical in base pairs, and it's unlikely in the extreme that such a complete analysis has even occurred for any individual of the lizard species, involving the huge amount of labor required.

ed: I see that jj preceded me in this argument, so I yield it to him.
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure if this is the proper thread, but since sceptigirl mentioned something about a new paradigm, I just though this discussion between Richard Dawkins and Craig Venter might be of interest to some of you. Richard seemed sceptical about horizontal gene transfer, but admitted he’s very interested and ready to change his mind about molecular taxonomy.

Furthermore, chromosomal transplantation seemed really intriguing too. Venter made some vague point about how that could also have happened without human intervention, thus giving more ammunition against the slow random point mutation vs. complexity argument creationist seem to hang on to.

Highly recommended video (about 1h long) in the sense that I suppose much further discussion between Dawkins and Venter will come out of this. Just have to wait and see what happens.

I don't disagree with that. I thought you were saying undetected genetic changes were more likely to be the mechanism of change here. I think something in the environment, very likely stress of an abruptly changed food source, is more likely to have affected gene expression than some genetic change accounting for the observed physical changes.
 
Last edited:
You still miss it: They went from primarily meat eaters to primarily plant eaters.

That's a huge step, evolutionary wise. And in only 36 years.


Mind you, according to the creationists, T. Rex (and all the other carnivores) went from plant eaters to meat eaters overnight, after the Fall. ;)
 
My understanding of evolution is that there can be no claim to mutation in a species unless there is inheritance of that mutation - that is, a change in the chromosomal genetics of the individuals which display the change, so that it can be reflected in their offspring. The statement that the "genetic material is identical" must be false in detail if there is an evolutionary change. I think the problem is that the statement about the identical genetics means that they looked at some markers which differentiate this particular species from it's close mates, and there was no difference there, which verifies that the new lizards haven't crossed with any other species and thus inherited their changes from outside their pure line. It is flatly impossible that the chromosomes in a pair of individuals (even brothers, as long as they're not clones) are entirely identical in base pairs, and it's unlikely in the extreme that such a complete analysis has even occurred for any individual of the lizard species, involving the huge amount of labor required.

ed: I see that jj preceded me in this argument, so I yield it to him.
That is where a paradigm shift may be in order. Gene expression is turning out to play a larger role than would have been previously believed. The chicken embryo research revealed that a lot of genetic code remained in the chickens' genome from species the chicken evolved from. You wouldn't say the chickens were still dinosaurs and hadn't evolved because you can get the DNA instructions to work again. It is the characteristics of the species we define evolving as, not only the genes.

But just as my example with tanned skin vs a black person, there is still a difference between adapting to an environmental change and evolving an adaptation.

It may just be that we thought we understood that difference a little better before we recognized that we really may not have understood it as well as we had thought.
 
Last edited:
There are 4 well known mechanisms for horizontal gene transfer. I'd be surprised to learn Dawkins wasn't aware of that. I wonder if something was misunderstood?

I'll have to watch it later.

I should have been more specific: I think it was more about the role of viruses and bacteria in such processes. It became somewhat unclear what Venter actually meant, so Dawkins started to grill him a little bit on that issue. :p
 
They are not carnivores. Both sets of lizards are omnivores.

The new set definitely evolved to be able to handle the new diet.

I didn't miss your point. I called you on your false analogy.

Nonsense.

If it is just diet and not evolution, change the diet back and see what happens.

Is the person just tan from the Sun or did they evolve darker skin? One is adaptation, one is evolution.

False dilemma: People who tan never evolve darker skin?

I'm not making an argument here, just trying to understand how the details fit together.

Give it some time. It's a fairly new story.

The article merely states that these cecal valves have never been reported before, not that they didn't exist before.

Oh, come on. They wouldn't check the lizards from the old island?

Not necessarily, as they appear to have been omnivores before the transferral as well.

Being omnivorous does not mean that you eat equally from all groups. E.g., dogs are omnivorus (even turds! - yuck!), but that doesn't mean they feast on carrots.

That is a crap comparison.

I disagree.

The lions are not omnivores before the change, as were the lizards. The lizards have not changed from one kind of nutrients to another, but merely changed the percentages of what they eat. To suggest that this is something astounding is ludicrous. Dunnocks do it every year, as do blackcaps and some other birds. This is not evolution, but changes in food preference depending on available sources.

Not evolution? Where did the new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts come from? Magic?
 
...False dilemma: People who tan never evolve darker skin?
Do you ever actually think about what it is you are trying to discredit or is it just a compulsion you cannot control?

What dilemma? I gave an example of adaptation vs an example of evolution to illustrate the difference.

...Not evolution? Where did the new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts come from? Magic?
Protogynous and Protandrous fish develop new gonads, change color, and change size in response to environmental changes. Where do the new structures come from?

Adding specific proteins to chicken embryos can result in scales instead of feathers, teeth, and limbs instead of wings. Where did the structures come from? No evolution took place in these experiments. Gene expression was changed, but no genetic changes occurred.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom