Lizards Undergo Rapid Evolution After Introduction To A New Home

Sounds like a simple controlable experiment.

take some lizard eggs, from the meat eaters, give them the vegitarian diet, and see how many of the first generation (maybe second generation) develop these structures.

If it is evolution and not adaptation, then only a small proportion should. If it were simply the expression of a latent trait, then most should...
The lizards on both islands feed on both insects and plants. The original ones feed mostly on insects. The ones on the second island feed mostly on plants.
Analysis of the stomach contents of lizards on Pod Mrcaru showed that their diet included up to two-thirds plants, depending on the season, a large increase over the population of Pod Kopiste.
Thus the lizards are omnivores.
 
FWIW, here are some comments from trying to read more about this topic. They aren't a complete reaction, and they aren't in very readable form, just notes.
(I added the quote code in response to skeptigirl's post.)

another quote from the paper:
This shift to a predominantly plant-based diet has resulted in
the dramatic evolution of intestinal morphology. Morphological
analysis of preserved specimens shows the presence of cecal
valves (Fig. 4) in all individuals, including a hatchling (26.4-mm
snout-vent length, umbilical scar present) and a very young
juvenile (33.11-mm snout-vent length) examined from Pod Mrc
ˇaru. These valves are similar in overall appearance and structure
to those found in herbivorous lacertid, agamid, and iguanid
lizards (13, 14) and are not found in other populations of P. sicula
(13) or in P. melisellensis. Cecal valves slow down food passage
and provide for fermenting chambers, allowing commensal
microorganisms to convert cellulose to volatile fatty acids (15,
16). Indeed, in the lizards from Pod Mrcˇaru, nematodes were
common in the hindgut but absent from individuals from Pod
Kopisˇte. The fact that 1% of all currently known species of
squamates have cecal valves (13, 14) illustrates the unusual
nature of these structures in this population. The evolution of
these structures has likely gone hand in hand with a novel
association between P. sicula on Pod Mrcˇaru and a set of
microorganisms assuring the digestion of cellulose as is suggested
by the presence of nematodes in the hindgut of individuals
from Pod Mrcˇaru.

It looks from their chart like the population of lizards on the other island (from which the lizards came initially) ate maybe 8% of plant matter. I don't know what that might mean - does it suggest that there is a baseline tendency for the lizards to eat plant matter that could be increased through natural selection?

There's another paper they cited which looked at some South American lizards, saying that herbivory had evolved a number of times in those lizards. I didn't read that paper. It would be interesting to know what kinds of anatomical or genetic changes go along with that kind of dietary change in other lizards.

I hope they can look at genetic changes in these lizards.

I predict Ken Ham etc. would just respond that they're STILL LIZARDS.

To really understand the issue, I'd want to know a lot more about normal variation in the different lizard species and populations.
There was another species of lizard on the island, Podarcis melisellensis, that disappeared during the 36 years. Is there any chance the two species could have hybridized? The mtDNA of the sampled lizards on the island all matched the P. sicula species, but I don't think that in itself rules out inbreeding initially.
(looking at another paper by Gorman from '75, it sounds like hybridization might be possible).

The Podarcis melisellensis lizard that was initially on the island, but disappeared, was also an insect eater. I wonder why it disappeared from that island. Was there a change in insect populations on the island (or not) during that time? Was it out-competed by the P. sicura? Before , during, or after the P. sicura adapted to eating more plant material?

This island doesn't sound that different from other habitats where P. sicura is found in that area. The new island looks like it's about 5 km from the previous habitat. In what ways was this a novel environment?

I looked at a paper from these researchers about the Podarcis melisellensis lizard species that has disappeared from that island during the 36 years. This study was based on another island nearby, Lastovo Island. There were three color morphs in the males, and they listed the dimensions of their heads. I've tried to list parts of the tables from the two papers to show the kind of variation in the P. sicula lizards after being put on the island, and the differences in head sizes of the other lizard species (measured on a different location). It seemed like it might help to see what the actual size differences were and what size differences you might see in a single species with different variations.

For comparison, here's the variation between head measurements from the current lizards Podarcis
sicula on the island and the Podarcis sicula lizards on the island from which the original pairs were taken (means +/- SD):
(from the paper referenced in my previous post, the one being discusssed in this topic). So there's an increase in the transplanted lizards, but it is not a huge change. How does it compare to variation in different populations of the lizard on other islands?


Pod Kopište (original island) Pod Mraru (new island)
Male Female *** Male Female
SVL, mm ( snout-vent length) M=63.06 +/- 4.68 F=56.80 +/- 5.30 ***M=69.54 +/- 2.86 F=64.08 +/- 2.93
Mass, g M=5.07 +/- 1.37 F=3.36 +/- 1.16 ***M=6.38 +/- 1.42 F=4.72 +/- 1.24
Head length, mm M=14.67 +/- 1.08 F=12.25 +/- 0.84 *** M=16.33 +/- 0.77 F=13.75 +/- 0.64
Head width, mm M=8.09 +/- 0.67 F=6.55 +/- 0.46 ***M=9.13 +/- 0.42 F=7.51 +/- 0.38
Head height, mm M=6.29 +/- 0.59 F=5.12 +/- 0.46 ***M=7.35 +/- 0.43 F=5.95 +/- 0.38
Lower jaw length, mm M=15.70 +/- 1.23 F=12.80 +/- 0.94 ***M=17.45 +/- 0.72 F=14.44 +/- 0.71

---------------------------------------------------

Variation between three color morphs of males of the species Podarcis melisellensis (the species no longer found on the Pod Mraru island in the above paper. This study was done on lizards on Lastovo Island, which looks like it's another 5 km away on amap, if I'm seeing the right island.):


Trait: White *** Yellow *** Orange
x SE n x SE N x SE n
SVL (mm) W=63.64 0.27 187 ***Y=63.02 0.46 78 ***O=64.67 0.23 148
Mass (g) W=5.41 0.21 69 ***Y=4.69 0.31 23 ***O=5.31 0.16 66
Head length (mm) W=14.84 0.07 168 *** Y=14.60 0.12 61 *** O=15.13 0.05 133
Head width (mm) W=8.75 0.07 97 8*** Y=8.43 0.12 45 *** O=9.04 0.07 91
Head height (mm) W=6.99 0.06 97 *** Y=6.74 0.09 45 *** O=7.20 0.05 91
Lower jaw length (mm) W=15.80 0.09 97 *** Y=15.48 0.15 45 *** O=16.19 0.07 91


From:
Morphology, performance, behavior and ecology of three color
morphs in males of the lizard Podarcis melisellensis
Katleen Huyghe,1,* Bieke Vanhooydonck,* Anthony Herrel,* Zoran Tadic´,†
and Raoul Van Damme†
Integrative and Comparative Biology, volume 47, number 2, pp. 211–220
http://webh01.ua.ac.be/funmorph/publications/Huyghe%20et%20al%202007%20ICB.pdf
 
Last edited:
So it does seem to sound like the result of (a single?) mutation.

Am I right in thinking that this implies that on the new island, all the lizards had common ancestor that was living on the new island, i.e. shared descent from one of the five breeding pairs?

I still think the article is crelessly written, if this is the case, as then the lizards are genetically distinct, but the difference is not identified.

If they are indistinguishable, then there is no genetic difference, and the "evolution" is something else.

Further (thought) experiment:

See what happens to the original island population if a "new" island lizard pair are introduced. How much do they compete, does one far outocompete the other...
 
Last edited:
I still think the article is crelessly written, if this is the case, as then the lizards are genetically distinct, but the difference is not identified.

How likely would it be, even, that the new lizards would be "genetically identical" to the 1st generation lizards?

I certainly am not "genetically identical" to my parents, and I suspect that going back just a few more generations would let me see drastically increased differences. Even assuming strong inbreeding with the lizards, the claim just doesn't seem to make much sense.
 
Not chance, but necessity. They suddenly moved from an environment with insects but few plants to one with plants but few insects.

Think about lions. They live where there's plenty of plant food. If plants provide a larger and more predictable food supply, why don't lions become herbivores?

Hmmmm.....? :)
Because adaptation within a genome differs by species. You offer a false argument that because species A doesn't do X, X must not occur in species B either. By your reasoning, environments should only have one species each or no species can adapt to variable environments without evolving. But evolving wouldn't include returning to the previous environment and returning to the previous state. The answer to whether this is evolution would include what happens when the old conditions are recreated.
 
Last edited:
Are the structures novel, or perhaps they were already present in the DNA and there was a mutation in a repressor gene that turned the genes for making it back on, like as if chickens suddenly regained the ability to grow teeth?:
 
What this interesting study is showing is that evolution is more than just genome change. What remains to be seen here is are the researchers missing more subtle genetic changes.

These more subtle changes might include turning genes on and/or off rather than more obvious changes to the gene itself. It might also be that very small genetic changes offer large differences in outcome. That is something we know occurs.

The third possibility which I think has also been demonstrated is that one's genetic makeup has a much broader potential to be different things in different environments than traditional evolution theory recognizes. This is part of the success story of evolution.

For example, if a genome can be expressed one way in island A's environment and a different way in island B's different environment, then species change has an intermediate step not previously recognized.

One of my aha moments came from this lecture:
Making Genetic Networks Operate Robustly: Unintelligent Non-design Suffices
Mathematical computer models of two ancient and famous genetic networks act early in embryos of many different species to determine the body plan. Models revealed these networks to be astonishingly robust, despite their 'unintelligent design.' This examines the use of mathematical models to shed light on how biological, pattern-forming gene networks operate and how thoughtless, haphazard, non-design produces networks whose robustness seems inspired, begging the question what else unintelligent non-design might be capable of.
It is an hour you can watch online or if you get UWTV, you can see when it is rerun at some point in the future. The basic discovery here was that it was hard to make a particular biological system fail because there was so much flexibility in the design. If you changed a single thing on a 'designed' transistor radio circuit board, chances are ~100% the thing would fail.
 
Last edited:
How likely would it be, even, that the new lizards would be "genetically identical" to the 1st generation lizards?

I certainly am not "genetically identical" to my parents, and I suspect that going back just a few more generations would let me see drastically increased differences. Even assuming strong inbreeding with the lizards, the claim just doesn't seem to make much sense.


I am not sure if you are agreeing with me or not.

My point is that if it is evolution, then there must be a genetic difference that is significant. A single gene switching something on perhaps.

If one knew where to look, one would then be able to identif the different populations by looking on that gene...
 
Are the structures novel, or perhaps they were already present in the DNA and there was a mutation in a repressor gene that turned the genes for making it back on, like as if chickens suddenly regained the ability to grow teeth?:
This was one of the things that came to mind for me as well. Studies in retro-engineering chicken embryos to produce dinosaur characteristics showed some of the genetics were still there, just turned off.

You must have seen the same program. :)
 
I am not sure if you are agreeing with me or not.

My point is that if it is evolution, then there must be a genetic difference that is significant. A single gene switching something on perhaps.

I am absolutely agreeing with you.

If there was no genetic change whatsoever, this wouldn't be "evolution".

It seems that posters have taken the claim of "genetically identical" to conclude that there are no changes. I would read it that way, too.

But I think the claim just doesn't make sense. If the lizards were genetically identical to the original generations that alone would be a spectacular discovery, wouldn't it?

(Later posts go way over my head, but as far as I understand the tests with the mitochondrial DNA these simply prove the linage of the new lizards.)
 
I am not sure if you are agreeing with me or not.

My point is that if it is evolution, then there must be a genetic difference that is significant. A single gene switching something on perhaps.

If one knew where to look, one would then be able to identif the different populations by looking on that gene...
In the chicken embryo studies they actually exposed the embryos to certain proteins which affected the gene expression. While the genes would control these proteins, I'm not sure they are only intrinsic. Could be extrinsic proteins at work in the environment. It certainly happens in birth defects.
 
...but as far as I understand the tests with the mitochondrial DNA these simply prove the linage of the new lizards.)
Right. In the paper, the only DNA comparison they made was to compare the sequence for a bit of mitochondrial DNA that codes for ribosomal RNA -not a gene that has anything to do with the adaptations, but just a gene used as what someone called a fingerprint. They didn't say anything at all about the comparing nuclear DNA, or about any genes that might be related to the changes in phenotype.
 
The article states:

I don't think that this means that the lizards on the second island were clones of the ones on the original island. It means that they were identical as in a genetic fingerprint sense, not as in every bit of the DNA was identical....
All individuals in a species except identical twins would have slightly different DNA. Because individuals continue to mingle their genes within the group, individual differences are not necessarily evolutionary changes in the classic sense of evolution.

To get evolution you need isolation and time. With a group no longer exchanging DNA with other members you start to get genetic drift between the two groups. If there is also a change in selection pressures, you can get rapid evolution. If not you get pretty slow drift.

So after 100,000 years, humans are quite different from humans of 100,000 years ago, but because selection pressures are similar and isolation not so perfect, humans remain a remarkably homogeneous species genetically. What appear to be large differences in outward appearance turn out to be pretty insignificant differences in terms of our genome.

Yet certain features can definitely be said to have evolved. For example skin pigment clearly is an evolutionary change. It took thousands of years, but dark skin evolved more than once as humans migrated to temperate zones and skin lightened and back down to equatorial zones where dark skin reappeared.

If you only consider evolution to have occurred when a new species appears, that would be contrary to evolution theory. OTOH, you need to distinguish between evolution and simple adaptation of the same species to a new environment which would be distinctly different from evolution. Fiona is right to question what this should be called. But we can look closer and answer the question.

Taking the example of Sun exposure, a light skinned person migrating to the equator adapts by using sunscreen and hats. A light skinned person who tans when exposed to the Sun would not be said to have evolved. Evolution would occur when dark skin developed in subsequent offspring.

But what makes that dark skin is not a simple genetic change that you can go out and find in every dark skinned person. Rather it is much more complex than any single identifiable genetic change. So were one only looking at the genome and one didn't know how the genes would be expressed in the individual, you cannot pick out dark skinned people as a distinct genetic group. There is a cluster of genetic markers more likely to be present in dark skinned people but it isn't any more unique than a cluster of genetic markers that identify blood type groups of individuals.

If you analyzed hundreds of human genomes, you could find any number of clusters of genes that you could use to arbitrarily categorize individuals as being in a group. But that could either be individual variation which is not considered an evolutionary change, or it could be an adaptive change such as skin color that was an evolutionary change.

In other words you need to look at more than just the genes and more than just the change to distinguish between adaptation and evolution in this sense.
 
Last edited:
FWIW, here are some comments from trying to read more about this topic. They aren't a complete reaction, and they aren't in very readable form, just notes.
While I envy people who cut and paste without my obsessive/compulsive editing that makes me waste so much time making perfect posts, it would help if you could just add a simple things like quote codes.

board formatting codes

Forum "How To..."

Another trick is to see how someone else did it by hitting the 'quote' box and just seeing what code they used.
 
How likely would it be, even, that the new lizards would be "genetically identical" to the 1st generation lizards?

I certainly am not "genetically identical" to my parents, and I suspect that going back just a few more generations would let me see drastically increased differences. Even assuming strong inbreeding with the lizards, the claim just doesn't seem to make much sense.
Depending on how many generations one is talking about and how large the current population is, whether the changes were the result of clusters of genetic changes or a single change each had to inherit to have, they could be exchanging enough genes within the group to evolve genetically as a group.

In other words, a single genetic mutation is unlikely to cause the group to evolve. It can happen, but evolutionary change is more likely to be a drifting of the group's genome, not the offspring of a single individual with a single genetic change. But if a single genetic change offered a significant survival advantage, it could end up dispersed within the group by mating and over time the individuals who failed to inherit it might die out.
 
Last edited:
What this interesting study is showing is that evolution is more than just genome change. What remains to be seen here is are the researchers missing more subtle genetic changes.

These more subtle changes might include turning genes on and/or off rather than more obvious changes to the gene itself. It might also be that very small genetic changes offer large differences in outcome. That is something we know occurs.

The third possibility which I think has also been demonstrated is that one's genetic makeup has a much broader potential to be different things in different environments than traditional evolution theory recognizes. This is part of the success story of evolution.

For example, if a genome can be expressed one way in island A's environment and a different way in island B's different environment, then species change has an intermediate step not previously recognized.

One of my aha moments came from this lecture:
Making Genetic Networks Operate Robustly: Unintelligent Non-design SufficesIt is an hour you can watch online or if you get UWTV, you can see when it is rerun at some point in the future. The basic discovery here was that it was hard to make a particular biological system fail because there was so much flexibility in the design. If you changed a single thing on a 'designed' transistor radio circuit board, chances are ~100% the thing would fail.

And this is what I was referring to earlier. In fact your "third" possibility and what you follow up with can be seen as the same thing, which can be explained in part by what is called "gene regulating DNA sequences", or switches.

That might be due to mutation which is perhaps easier to occur on certain sequences, but it might also be due to evolution having already tried that particular design in the past, but it becomes recessive when environmental circumstances don't give the advantage it once had; but it doesn't disappear from the genome and can reappear when it's beneficial.

That latter aspect might not be called "evolution" as such, but it is not hard to speculate that given enough time such dormant switches might indeed die off for good or become what is called "junk" sequences. It does however seem to give a plausible explanation for how new species can appear quite rapidly, given that all life may have the seeds of quite different functionality stored away in DNA, thanks to earlier experiments.
 
In case you hadn't heard, those 'junk sequences' are not likely junk. If they were, one would not expect to find them highly conserved.

It is a good point though, that a gene not subject to positive or negative selection pressure could eventually disappear. There is no reason necessarily for cave fish to go blind if resources are abundant, (the burden of a useless organ would matter more in some caves than in others), yet they eventually do.
 
Because adaptation within a genome differs by species.

You totally missed my point. Read post 17.

You offer a false argument that because species A doesn't do X, X must not occur in species B either. By your reasoning, environments should only have one species each or no species can adapt to variable environments without evolving.

Nonsense.

But evolving wouldn't include returning to the previous environment and returning to the previous state. The answer to whether this is evolution would include what happens when the old conditions are recreated.

Say again? Are you saying that if we moved the lizards back to their original island, they wouldn't change back to carnivores?
 
Okay, in response to skeptigirl's post about using quote codes, here's a section of the table from the paper using quote codes. (not worth doing the table from the other species.) Better than I expected. The ? diamonds are +/- characters. I didn't include the whole table.

Table 1. Phenotypic, performance, and ecological divergence for two populations of P. sicula 36 years after the introduction of 10 individuals in a new environment



 || |Pod Kopište | | Pod Mraru |
|Haldanes, m/f | Darwins, m/f | Male | Female |Male | Female |
SVL, mm |0.044/0.045 |2,713/3,350 |63.06 � 4.68 |56.80 � 5.30| 69.54 � 2.86 |64.08 � 2.93 |
Mass, g |0.028/0.034 |6,384/9,441 |5.07 � 1.37 |3.36 � 1.16 | 6.38 � 1.42 |4.72 � 1.24 |
Head length, mm |0.045/0.049 |2,978/3,209 |14.67 � 1.08 |12.25 � 0.84| 16.33 � 0.77 | 13.75 � 0.64 |
Head width, mm | 0.046/0.051| 3,359/3,799 | 8.09 � 0.67 |6.55 � 0.46| 9.13 � 0.42 | 7.51 � 0.38|
Head height, mm |0.048/0.048 |4,326/4,228 |6.29 � 0.59 |5.12 � 0.46 | 7.35 � 0.43 |5.95 � 0.38 |
Lower jaw length, mm |0.045/0.048 |2,936/3,349 |15.70 � 1.23 | 12.80 � 0.94| 17.45 � 0.72 |14.44 � 0.71 |
...
Lizards were transplanted from Pod Kopisˇte to Pod Mrcˇaru. Table entries are means  standard deviations. Divergence rates are indicated for males (m) and
females (f) separately. SVL, snout-vent length.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom