Disappointing, but you did say 'roughly' so I'll give you a pass this time.
YouGov poll: what do you think a more appropriate verdict would be?
Guilty of murder 46% (male 51%, female 41%)
Not guilty by reason of insanity 21% (male 15% male, female 26%)
Not sure 33% (male 34%, female 33%)
So 79% of those polled weren't convinced by the insanity defense. There was a small bias of 10% toward male 'guilters', and a similar bias of 11% toward females who think she was insane.
Public opinion on the Lindsay Clancy case seems to split roughly along sex lines. Not all women will favor exonerating her, but on the other hand, some men certainly will. So I think as a rough estimate 50% will do for purposes of discussion.
Garbage in, garbage out.
If your positions on the moral, ethical, and policy questions regarding abortions of medical necessity will vary based on an accurate measure of the percentage of people who hold a particular position about Lindsay Clancy murdering her children, I'd like to learn more.
Now you know.
What are your positions? What percentage of shared viewpoint would change your positions?
My position is that insanity is a valid defense because the response should be different from 'normal' crimes.
Shared viewpoint means little to me. The important fact in this case was that Lindsay Clancy was suffering from
postpartum psychosis.
Problems can take the form of postpartum depression (“baby blues”) or the rarer postpartum psychosis. It affects, according to various sources, between 0.89 and 2.6 women for every 1000 births in the first 6 weeks after delivery.
Postpartum or puerperal psychosis is the most serious mental disorder associated with childbirth. It can affect women without a pre-established mental illness... women, both at-risk and healthy, were about 22 times more likely to be admitted to a psychiatric hospital 1 month after delivery than they were before pregnancy. In contrast, 20% of women with pre-existing bipolar disorder experienced severe postnatal mental illness, and one-third of women in the risk group experienced relapse.
Postpartum psychosis (or puerperal psychosis) is a psychiatric emergency with potentially serious consequences for mothers and children. Pregnant women with psychosis have an increased risk of obstetric and neonatal complications, and in extreme cases that disease can lead to suicide and/or infanticide
A serious medical condition with a known risk factor should be treated with the seriousness it deserves. It certainly shouldn't be ignored until someone attempts to take their own and/or other's lives, then prosecute them for murder as if they chose to do it of their own free will. Insane people aren't dissuaded by fear of legal repercussions, so treating them like criminals will not eliminate these occurrences.
Specifically, the issue of abortion due to the medical necessity to preserve the mental health of the mother. Do you think public policy should allow abortions for that reason? Up until which trimester? I assume you're already against extending mental health abortions to the fourth trimester and beyond, for obvious but rather arbitrary reasons. But what about the third trimester?
Yes, including the third trimester. In New Zealand there is no upper limit on abortion. 2 or 3 years is no problem legally.
If a pregnant woman gets a prognosis of PTSD, trauma, or the like if she carries the baby to term, but she's already in the third trimester, is it too late to save her sanity? Or do you think we should reform abortion policy to allow abortions of mental health necessity into the third trimester?
I'm not qualified to say. I understand there are treatments available, but I don't know anything about their efficacy. Therefore I think it would be best for medical professionals and/or the patient to make that determination. If a women was already suffering from psychosis I think it would be best to avoid having children, preferably with other measures but abortion should be an option. It's certainly better than suicide and/or infanticide.
The risk isn't so high that people shouldn't be given the opportunity to have children. However there should be sufficient support to monitor for and treat postpartum psychosis properly, like there should be for any life-threatening disease (even more so due to the legal hazard). IMO the best way to do that is with a well funded public health system. I don't mind having a small part my taxes going towards avoiding tragedies like this.