Lindsay Clancy and Abortion

Post-partum depression and psychosis rarely lead to infanticide, and we usually don't punish people before they commit a crime. But if the mother wants to have an abortion - because she's afraid of what she might do, ir because she wants one for other reasons - then I think it's her right to have one.
 
Post-partum depression and psychosis rarely lead to infanticide,
But it is a risk. Why do you think the size of the risk matters?

and we usually don't punish people before they commit a crime.
Nobody was talking about punishment.=

But if the mother wants to have an abortion - because she's afraid of what she might do, ir because she wants one for other reasons - then I think it's her right to have one.
I started this thread specifically to talk about abortions of medical necessity - specifically mental health necessity.

Obviously the whole question of necessity becomes moot, if you're in favor of abortions on a whim.
 
Last edited:
Post-partum depression and psychosis rarely lead to infanticide, and we usually don't punish people before they commit a crime. But if the mother wants to have an abortion - because she's afraid of what she might do, ir because she wants one for other reasons - then I think it's her right to have one.
Abortions up to birth? Or do you favor some time limit like 24 weeks or something else?
 
To point out that the premise of this thread is idiotic and mockworthy.
Feel free to get started on that any time.

The premise of this thread is that abortions of mental health necessity are good policy, and that we should consider (a) whether we should extend that policy further into the lifetime of the child, out of an abundance of concern for the health of the mother, and (b) whether it makes sense to abort early in order to mitigate the risk of negative mental health impacts on the mother.

The question at issue in the Lindsay Clancy case is whether she had any choice in the matter. If she could have avoided post-partum depression by terminating the pregnancy pre-partum, would that have been a better outcome for everyone who survived?

We could also (c) just conclude that, as Helen has already implied, the question of abortions of medical necessity is entirely moot.



I get that the topic is upsetting to some people. A lot of people. I think a lot of people have never had to make a rational argument in favor of abortions of medical necessity. I think a lot of people have lived their entire lives with a vague sense of relief that all such arguments have already been made, proved, and accepted, and that they don't have to give it any thought of their own.

But lashing out at people who raise the question isn't the answer.
 
Last edited:
The premise of this thread is that abortions of mental health necessity are good policy, and that we should consider (a) whether we should extend that policy further into the lifetime of the child, out of an abundance of concern for the health of the mother, and (b) whether it makes sense to abort early in order to mitigate the risk of negative mental health impacts on the mother.
And that's dumb, disingenuous, and mockworthy.

We could also (c) just conclude that, as Helen has already implied, the question of abortions of medical necessity is entirely moot.
Abortion is not relevant because that debate crucially turns on medical autonomy and fetal personhood. Children at the ages these children were when they were killed are uncontroversially persons, and any concerns about medical autonomy dissolve after birth.

What you're left with is an agenda-driven attempt to shoehorn an irrelevant debate into a tragedy. It's contemptible.

But lashing out at people who raise the question isn't the answer.
Yes it is. Bad faith questions should be identified and the people who raise them should face social opprobrium.
 
Last edited:
But back before women became doctors, the arguments were the same as yours is now; it was against the nature of women. STEM is a good example, from 14% in 1970, to 35 now. And girls in science programs in high school; 54% here.

But I won't belabour this thread drift any further.
Men and women are different. It has nothing to do with competency. You can even see it reflected in the Clancy trial, where those wanting her to be acquitted are overwhelmingly female. They care more about Clancy's condition while men see premediated murder. Nurse vs. engineer. When we see behavioral sex differences is other animals, do we attribute that to society and culture?
 
Feel free to get started on that any time.

The premise of this thread is that abortions of mental health necessity are good policy, and that we should consider (a) whether we should extend that policy further into the lifetime of the child, out of an abundance of concern for the health of the mother, and (b) whether it makes sense to abort early in order to mitigate the risk of negative mental health impacts on the mother.

The question at issue in the Lindsay Clancy case is whether she had any choice in the matter. If she could have avoided post-partum depression by terminating the pregnancy pre-partum, would that have been a better outcome for everyone who survived?

We could also (c) just conclude that, as Helen has already implied, the question of abortions of medical necessity is entirely moot.



I get that the topic is upsetting to some people. A lot of people. I think a lot of people have never had to make a rational argument in favor of abortions of medical necessity. I think a lot of people have lived their entire lives with a vague sense of relief that all such arguments have already been made, proved, and accepted, and that they don't have to give it any thought of their own.

But lashing out at people who raise the question isn't the answer.
Is the idea that if abortion is good policy for the mental health of a pregnant woman, then allowing filicide for the same reason is the natural extension of that premise?
 
Last edited:
I made it up
Disappointing, but you did say 'roughly' so I'll give you a pass this time.

YouGov poll: what do you think a more appropriate verdict would be?
Guilty of murder 46% (male 51%, female 41%)
Not guilty by reason of insanity 21% (male 15% male, female 26%)
Not sure 33% (male 34%, female 33%)

So 79% of those polled weren't convinced by the insanity defense. There was a small bias of 10% toward male 'guilters', and a similar bias of 11% toward females who think she was insane.

Public opinion on the Lindsay Clancy case seems to split roughly along sex lines. Not all women will favor exonerating her, but on the other hand, some men certainly will. So I think as a rough estimate 50% will do for purposes of discussion.
Garbage in, garbage out.

If your positions on the moral, ethical, and policy questions regarding abortions of medical necessity will vary based on an accurate measure of the percentage of people who hold a particular position about Lindsay Clancy murdering her children, I'd like to learn more.
Now you know.

What are your positions? What percentage of shared viewpoint would change your positions?
My position is that insanity is a valid defense because the response should be different from 'normal' crimes.

Shared viewpoint means little to me. The important fact in this case was that Lindsay Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis.
Problems can take the form of postpartum depression (“baby blues”) or the rarer postpartum psychosis. It affects, according to various sources, between 0.89 and 2.6 women for every 1000 births in the first 6 weeks after delivery.
Postpartum or puerperal psychosis is the most serious mental disorder associated with childbirth. It can affect women without a pre-established mental illness... women, both at-risk and healthy, were about 22 times more likely to be admitted to a psychiatric hospital 1 month after delivery than they were before pregnancy. In contrast, 20% of women with pre-existing bipolar disorder experienced severe postnatal mental illness, and one-third of women in the risk group experienced relapse.
Postpartum psychosis (or puerperal psychosis) is a psychiatric emergency with potentially serious consequences for mothers and children. Pregnant women with psychosis have an increased risk of obstetric and neonatal complications, and in extreme cases that disease can lead to suicide and/or infanticide
A serious medical condition with a known risk factor should be treated with the seriousness it deserves. It certainly shouldn't be ignored until someone attempts to take their own and/or other's lives, then prosecute them for murder as if they chose to do it of their own free will. Insane people aren't dissuaded by fear of legal repercussions, so treating them like criminals will not eliminate these occurrences.

Specifically, the issue of abortion due to the medical necessity to preserve the mental health of the mother. Do you think public policy should allow abortions for that reason? Up until which trimester? I assume you're already against extending mental health abortions to the fourth trimester and beyond, for obvious but rather arbitrary reasons. But what about the third trimester?
Yes, including the third trimester. In New Zealand there is no upper limit on abortion. 2 or 3 years is no problem legally.

If a pregnant woman gets a prognosis of PTSD, trauma, or the like if she carries the baby to term, but she's already in the third trimester, is it too late to save her sanity? Or do you think we should reform abortion policy to allow abortions of mental health necessity into the third trimester?
I'm not qualified to say. I understand there are treatments available, but I don't know anything about their efficacy. Therefore I think it would be best for medical professionals and/or the patient to make that determination. If a women was already suffering from psychosis I think it would be best to avoid having children, preferably with other measures but abortion should be an option. It's certainly better than suicide and/or infanticide.

The risk isn't so high that people shouldn't be given the opportunity to have children. However there should be sufficient support to monitor for and treat postpartum psychosis properly, like there should be for any life-threatening disease (even more so due to the legal hazard). IMO the best way to do that is with a well funded public health system. I don't mind having a small part my taxes going towards avoiding tragedies like this.
 
Last edited:
I think a straightforward abortion thread would be more apt for this discussion. I understand the premise but the connection lacks the necessary combination at heart of that discussion.

I do find the overlap of pro choice and feminist voices on the pro insanity defense side to be descriptive. Another interesting topic with more substance to your position.

On the actual thread topic i dont see a strong connection. There is accountability avoidance, fingers pointing at both the medical and parental responsibilities, but not a straight line to culpability similarities between pregnancy termination and child murder for mental health concerns.
 
The idea is, we should question whether it should be as you say.
Why then was it necessary to falsely attribute a repugnant view to virtually all women, and ignore the fact that Lindsay Clancy tried to top herself after killing her children (which I think disposes of the idea that this could be medically indicated)? Why did you arrogantly assume that the reason people react badly to this nonsense is because they haven't thought through their position on medically indicated termination of a pregnancy (as if the moral calculus involved in deciding between a dead fetus or a dead fetus and a dead mother is particularly difficult)?

If all you wanted to do was ask whether or not it's morally permissible to strangle your kids to death, you could have just asked that. You didn't ask that, because there's no real controversy there, and it's transparently not what you wanted to do.
 
But back before women became doctors, the arguments were the same as yours is now; it was against the nature of women. STEM is a good example, from 14% in 1970, to 35 now. And girls in science programs in high school; 54% here.

But I won't belabour this thread drift any further.
In Ireland 56% of medical graduates are female. I'm sure that this says something......
 
Post-partum depression and psychosis rarely lead to infanticide, and we usually don't punish people before they commit a crime. But if the mother wants to have an abortion - because she's afraid of what she might do, ir because she wants one for other reasons - then I think it's her right to have one.
Agreed. Though I 'd offer psych counselling as well.
But to the Usual Suspects, abortion is always wrong, they're not interested in facts or nuances.
 
But to the Usual Suspects, abortion is always wrong,
Except when God does it. The Lord giveth and, 15% of the time, the Lord taketh away before the third trimester. 23 million miscarriages every year, translating to one every 1.4 seconds. God's so busy killing babies it's a wonder He has time left for anything else!
 
Agreed. Though I 'd offer psych counselling as well.
But to the Usual Suspects, abortion is always wrong, they're not interested in facts or nuances.
I for one am interested in facts and nuances.

I think a case could be made, from the facts, for abortions of medical necessity. I've just never seen it made. At this point I'm not sure such a case actually exists. But I stlill think it could exist, and I'd be receptive to it.

I also think there's some nuance to be considered, when it comes to abortions of moral outrage.

But let's start with some basic facts. Are you interested in providing basic facts? When are abortions medically necessew? What set of medical facts indicates to you that a pregnancy should be terminated to save the life of the mother, rather than doing everything modern medicine enables us to do, to try to save both lives if at all possible?
 
Yes, her case does make a strong point in favour of abortion. We wouldn't be here if she had been aborted :P
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom